Countersteering

For the technique with a similar name used in automobiles, see Countersteering (Automobile).

Countersteering is used by single-track vehicle operators, such as cyclists and motorcyclists, to initiate a turn toward a given direction by momentarily steering counter to the desired direction ("steer left to turn right"). To negotiate a turn successfully, the combined center of mass of the rider and the single-track vehicle must first be leaned in the direction of the turn, and steering briefly in the opposite direction causes that lean. ^[1] The rider's action of countersteering is sometimes referred to as "giving a steering command". ^{[2] [3] : 15}

The scientific literature does not provide a clear and comprehensive definition of countersteering. In fact, "a proper distinction between steer torque and steer angle ... is not always made." ^[4]

A hypothetical curve on dry asphalt

How it works

Image montage showing different stages of countersteering. Here, a scooter is countersteered to turn left.

When countersteering to turn right, the following is performed: ^{[5] [6]}

• A torque on the handlebars to the left is applied.
• The front wheel will then rotate about the steering axis to the left and the tire will generate forces in the contact patch to the left.
• The machine as a whole steers to the left.
• Because the forces in the contact patch are at ground level, this pulls the wheels "out from under" the bike to the left and causes it to lean to the right.
• The rider, or in most cases the inherent stability of the bike, provides the steering torque necessary to rotate the front wheel back to the right and in the direction of the desired turn.
• The bike begins a turn to the right.

While this appears to be a complex sequence of motions, it is performed by every child who rides a bicycle. The entire sequence goes largely unnoticed by most riders, which is why some assert that they do not do it. ^[6]

It is also important to distinguish the steering torque necessary to initiate the lean required for a given turn from the sustained steering torque and steering angle necessary to maintain a constant radius and lean angle until it is time to exit the turn.

• The initial steer torque and angle are both opposite the desired turn direction.
• The sustained steer angle is in the same direction as the turn.
• The sustained steer torque required to maintain that steer angle is either with or opposite the turn ^[7] direction depending on forward speed, bike geometry, and combined bike and rider mass distribution.

Need to lean to turn

A bike can negotiate a curve only when the combined center of mass of bike and rider leans toward the inside of the turn at an angle appropriate for the velocity and the radius of the turn:

${\displaystyle \theta =\arctan \left({\frac {v^{2}}{gr}}\right)}$

where ${\displaystyle v}$ is the forward speed, ${\displaystyle r}$ is the radius of the turn and ${\displaystyle g}$ is the acceleration of gravity. ^[8]

Higher speeds and tighter turns require greater lean angles. If the mass is not first leaned into the turn, the inertia of the rider and bike will cause them to continue in a straight line as the tires track out from under them along the curve. The transition of riding in a straight line to negotiating a turn is a process of leaning the bike into the turn, and the most practical way to cause that lean (of the combined center of mass of bike and rider) is to move the support points in the opposite direction first. ^[9]

Stable lean

Graphs showing the lean and steer angle response of an otherwise uncontrolled simplified model of a typical bike, traveling at a forward speed in its stable range (in this case 6 m/s), to a positive steer torque (to the right) that begins as an impulse and then remains constant. It causes an initial steer angle to the right, a lean to the left, and eventually a steady-state lean to the left, steer angle to the left, and thus a turn to the left.

As the desired angle is approached, the front wheel must usually be steered into the turn to maintain that angle or the bike will continue to lean with gravity, increasing in rate, until the side contacts the ground. This process often requires little or no physical effort, because the geometry of the steering system of most bikes is designed in such a way that the front wheel has a strong tendency to steer in the direction of a lean.

The actual torque the rider must apply to the handlebars to maintain a steady-state turn is a complex function of bike geometry, mass distribution, rider position, tire properties, turn radius, and forward speed. At low speeds, the steering torque necessary from the rider is usually negative, that is opposite the direction of the turn, even when the steering angle is in the direction of the turn. At higher speeds, the direction of the necessary input torque often becomes positive, that is in the same direction as the turn. ^{[7] [10]}

At low speeds

At low speeds countersteering is equally necessary, but the countersteering is then so subtle that it is hidden by the continuous corrections that are made in balancing the bike, often falling below a just noticeable difference or threshold of perception of the rider. Countersteering at low speed may be further concealed by the ensuing much larger steering angle possible in the direction of the turn.^{[ citation needed ]}

Gyroscopic effects

One effect of turning the front wheel is a roll moment caused by gyroscopic precession. The magnitude of this moment is proportional to the moment of inertia of the front wheel, its spin rate (forward motion), the rate that the rider turns the front wheel by applying a torque to the handlebars, and the cosine of the angle between the steering axis and the vertical. ^[10]

For a sample motorcycle moving at 22 m/s (50 mph) that has a front wheel with a moment of inertia of 0.6 kgm², turning the front wheel one degree in half a second generates a roll moment of 3.5 Nm. In comparison, the lateral force on the front tire as it tracks out from under the motorcycle reaches a maximum of 50 N. This, acting on the 0.6 m (2 ft) height of the center of mass, generates a roll moment of 30 Nm. ^[10]

While the moment from gyroscopic forces is only 12% of this, it can play a significant part because it begins to act as soon as the rider applies the torque, instead of building up more slowly as the wheel out-tracks. This can be especially helpful in motorcycle racing. ^[10]

Motorcycles

Deliberately countersteering is essential for safe motorcycle riding, and as a result is generally a part of safe riding courses run by organisations like the Motorcycle Safety Foundation, the Canada Safety Council, or Australian Q-Ride providers. Deliberately countersteering a motorcycle is a much more efficient way to steer than to just lean. ^{[3] : 15} At higher speeds the self-balancing property of the bike gets stiffer, and a given input force applied to the handlebars produces smaller changes in lean angle. ^{[3] : 16}

Training

Much of the art of motorcycle cornering is learning how to effectively push the grips into corners and how to maintain proper lean angles through the turn. When the need for a quick swerve to one side suddenly arises in an emergency, it is essential to know, through prior practice, that countersteering is the most efficient way to change the motorcycle's course. ^{[3] : 16} Many accidents result when otherwise experienced riders who have never carefully developed this skill encounter an unexpected obstacle.

To encourage an understanding of the phenomena around countersteering, the phrase positive steering is sometimes used. ^{[11] [12]} Other phrases are "PRESS – To turn, the motorcycle must lean", "To lean the motorcycle, press on the handgrip in the direction of the turn" or "Press left – lean left – go left". ^[13]

The Motorcycle Safety Foundation teaches countersteering to all students in all of its schools, as do all motorcycle racing schools. Countersteering is included in United States state motorcycle operator manuals and tests, such as Washington, ^[14] New Jersey, ^[15] California, ^[16] and Missouri. ^[17]

Safety

According to the Hurt Report, most motorcycle riders in the United States would over-brake and skid the rear wheel and under-brake the front when trying hard to avoid a collision. The ability to countersteer and swerve was essentially absent with many motorcycle operators. ^[18] The often small amount of initial countersteering input required to get the bike to lean, which may be as little as 0.125 seconds, keeps many riders unaware of the concept. ^[19]

Multi-track vehicles

Sidecar on Vespa scooter

Tripendo recumbent tricycle, a tilting three-wheeler

Three wheeled motorcycles without the ability to lean have no need to be countersteered, and an initial steer torque in one direction does not automatically result in a turn in the other direction. This includes sidecar rigs where the car is rigidly mounted on the bike. The three wheeled BRP Can-Am Spyder Roadster uses two front wheels which do not lean, and so it steers like a car. ^[20]

Some sidecars allow the motorcycle to lean independent of the sidecar, and in some cases, the sidecar even leans in parallel with the motorcycle. These vehicles must be countersteered the same way as a solo motorcycle. ^[21] The three wheel Piaggio MP3 uses mechanical linkages to lean the two front wheels in parallel with the rear frame, and so that it is countersteered in the same manner as a two-wheeled motorcycle. ^[20]

Free-leaning multi-track vehicles must be balanced by countersteering before turning. Multi-track leaning vehicles that are forced-tilted, such as the Carver, are tilted without countersteering the control and are not balanced by the operator. Later versions of the Carver introduced automatic countersteer to increase tilt speed and reduce the force required to tilt the vehicle. Other forced-tilted vehicles may incorporate automatic countersteering. ^[22] A prototype tilting multi-track free leaning vehicle was developed in 1984 that employs automatic countersteering and does not require any balancing skills. ^[23]

Countersteering by weight shifting

With a sufficiently light bike (especially a bicycle), the rider can initiate a lean and turn without using the handlebars by shifting body weight, called counter lean by some authors. ^{[8] [24] [25] [26]} Documented physical experimentation shows that on heavy bikes (many motorcycles) shifting body weight is less effective at initiating leans. ^[27]

The following is done when countersteering using weight shifting to turn left:

• The rider applies a momentary torque, either at the seat via the legs or in the torso that causes the bike itself to lean to the right.
• The combined center of mass of the bike and rider is only lowered and not moved out, but if the front of the bike is free to swivel about its steering axis, the lean to the right will cause it to steer to the right by some combination of gyroscopic precession, ground reaction forces, gravitational force on an off-axis center of mass or simply the inertia of an off-axis center of mass depending on the exact geometry and mass distribution of the particular bike and the amount of torque and the speed at which it is applied. ^{[8] [28]}
• This countersteering to the right causes the ground contact to move to the right of the center of mass, as the bike moves forward, thus generating a leftward lean. Finally the front end steers to the left and the bike enters the left turn.

The amount of leftward steering necessary to balance the leftward lean appropriate for the forward speed and radius of the turn is controlled by the torque generated by the rider, again either at the seat or in the torso.

To straighten back out of the turn, the rider simply reverses the procedure for entering it: cause the bike to lean farther to the left; this causes it to steer farther to the left, which moves the wheel contact patches farther to the left, eventually reducing the leftward lean and exiting the turn.

A National Highway Traffic Safety Administration study showed that rider lean has a larger influence on a lighter motorcycle than a heavier one, ^[29] which helps explain why no-hands steering is less effective on heavy motorcycles. Leaning the torso with respect to the bike does not cause the bike to lean far enough to generate anything but the shallowest turns. No-hands riders may be able to keep a heavy bike centered in a lane and negotiate shallow highway turns, but not much else.

Complex maneuvers are not possible using weight shifting alone because even for a light machine there is insufficient control authority. ^[24] Although on a sufficiently light bike (especially a bicycle), the rider can initiate a lean and turn by shifting body weight, ^[8] there is no evidence that complex maneuvers can be performed by bodyweight alone. ^[27]

Other uses

Motorcycle speedway racing

The term countersteering is also used by some authors to refer to the need on bikes to steer in the opposite direction of the turn (negative steering angle) to maintain control in response to significant rear wheel slippage. ^[10] Motorcycle speedway racing takes place on an oval track with a loose surface of dirt, cinders or shale. Riders slide their machines sideways, powersliding or broadsiding into the turns, using an extreme form of this type of countersteering that is maintained throughout the turn. This also works, without power, for bicycles on loose or slippery surfaces, although it is an advanced technique.

The term is also used in the discussion of the automobile driving technique called drifting.

The Wright Brothers

Wilbur Wright explained countersteering this way:

I have asked dozens of bicycle riders how they turn to the left. I have never found a single person who stated all the facts correctly when first asked. They almost invariably said that to turn to the left, they turned the handlebar to the left and as a result made a turn to the left. But on further questioning them, some would agree that they first turned the handlebar a little to the right, and then as the machine inclined to the left, they turned the handlebar to the left and as a result made the circle, inclining inward. ^{[30] [31]}

See also

• Bicycle and motorcycle dynamics
• Motorcycle safety
• Non-minimum phase system

Notes

1. Sheldon Brown. "Countersteering" . Retrieved 9 November 2012. "Countersteering" refers to the momentary motion of the handlebars in the opposite direction of the desired turn.
2. "Curriculum for driving licenses A1, A2 and A"/"Læreplan Førerkortklasse A1, A2 and A" (PDF). Norwegian Public Roads Administration. 2013. p. 55.
3. Leif Klyve; Henry Enoksen; Gunnar Kubberød. Full Kontroll (PDF). Norwegian Motorcycle Union. p. 15. ISBN   82-92276-00-9. Archived from the original (PDF) on 8 October 2008.
4. Sharp, R. S. (2008). "On the stability and control of the bicycle". Applied Mechanics Reviews. 61 (6): 1–24. Bibcode:2008ApMRv..61f0803S. doi:10.1115/1.2983014. A positive right-hand torque leads to negative steer and roll angles, corresponding to a left turn. This behavior is often called countersteering, and it appears that it was known in the very early days of cycling, although a proper distinction between steer torque and steer angle forcing is not always made.
5. Jones, David (1970). "The Stability of the Bicycle" (PDF). Retrieved 31 March 2009.
6. "More on countersteering", Cycle World: 71, October 1985, [A] motorcycle has to lean to turn, and countersteering to the left steers the front wheel out from under the motorcycle, causing the motorcycle to lean to the right. So the basic sequence for the right turn is this: turn the bars to the left to start the turn, and then let them swing back to the right as you settle into a steady cornering attitude. Many (if not most) motorcyclists are not consciously aware of this sequence, and find it slightly incredible... [but] it is the only way to make a motorcycle turn quickly.
7. V. Cossalter pp. 1343–1356: "Correlations with the subjective opinions of expert test riders have shown that a low torque effort should be applied to the handlebar in order to have a good feeling, and preferably in a sense opposite to the turning direction."
8. Fajans, Joel (July 2000). "Steering in bicycles and motorcycles" (PDF). American Journal of Physics. 68 (7): 654–659. Bibcode:2000AmJPh..68..654F. doi:10.1119/1.19504 . Retrieved 4 August 2006.
9. Wilson, David Gordon; Jim Papadopoulos (2004). Bicycling Science (Third ed.). The MIT Press. pp.  270–272. ISBN   0-262-73154-1.
10. V. Cossalter pp. 241–342
11. Jon Taylor & Stefan Bartlett (2009). How to be a Better Rider. Institute of Advanced Motorists. ISBN   978-0-9562239-1-3.
12. "Novice Motorcycle Riders to Learn Positive Steering". Biker 24/7 News. 29 June 2009. Archived from the original on 10 September 2011. Retrieved 31 December 2009.
13. "Motorcycle Operator Manual" (PDF). Motorcycle Safety Foundation (MSF-USA). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2 November 2012. Retrieved 28 August 2014.
14. "Department of Licensing Motorcycle Operator Manual" (PDF). Washington State Department of Licensing.
15. "Motorcycle Manual" (PDF). New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission.
16. "California Motorcycle Operators Handbook" (PDF). California DMV. Archived from the original (PDF) on 11 June 2014. Retrieved 28 August 2014.
17. "DOR-2332 (3-2008) Motorcycle Operator" (PDF). Missouri Department of Revenue. Archived from the original (PDF) on 6 August 2009. Retrieved 28 August 2014.
18. Hugh H. Hurt; Ouellet, J.V.; Thom, D.R. (January 1981). Motorcycle Accident Cause Factors and Identification of Countermeasures, Volume 1: Technical Report (PDF) (Technical report). Washington DC: US Department of Transportation. Archived from the original (PDF) on 23 August 2014.
19. National Public Services Research Institute, "Photographic Analysis of Motorcycle Operator Control Responses", 1976
20. 1 2 Motorcyclist Magazine; Stein, John L. (2011). The Complete Idiot's Guide to Motorcycles (5 ed.). Penguin. p. 339. ISBN   978-1-61564-070-6 . Retrieved 15 January 2011.
21. H. A. Kendall (2003). Sidecar Operator Manual (PDF). p. 98.
22. Poelgeest, A.; Edge, K. A.; Darling, J. (November 2007). Development of a Steer Tilt Controller for a Three Wheeled Tilting Vehicle.
23. Mike McCarthy (January 1987). "Bankable future for leaning car". Wheels Magazine. pp. 12–13. Retrieved 18 November 2014.
24. Evangelou, S, 2004 "The Control and Stability Analysis of Two-Wheeled Road Vehicles", PhD Thesis, Imperial College London
25. Cocco, Gaetano (2004). Motorcycle Design and Technology. Motorbooks. p. 25. ISBN   978-0-7603-1990-1.
26. Foale, Tony (2006). Motorcycle Handling and Chassis Design, the Art and Science (2nd ed.). Tony Foale Designs. pp. 4–7. ISBN   978-84-933286-3-4.
27. Gromer, Cliff (1 February 2001). "STEER GEAR So how do you actually turn a motorcycle?". Popular Mechanics. Archived from the original on 26 January 2010. Retrieved 7 August 2006.
28. Brandt, Jobst (16 September 1997). "What keeps the bicycle upright?". sheldonbrown.com. Retrieved 17 October 2007.
29. Anil V. Khadilkar; R. Nichols; R. Schwarz (1977), "Analytical results: influence of rider lean angle", Motorcycle Safety Improvement, vol. 2, United States Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, p. 4-24
30. Crouch, Tom D. (1989). The Bishop's Boys. New York: W. W. Norton. p. 170. ISBN   0-393-30695-X.
31. Kelly, Fred C. (1989). The Wright Brothers . Courier Dover Publications. pp.  297–299. ISBN   978-0-486-26056-3.

References

• Vittore Cossalter; R. Lot; M. Peretto (2007). "Steady turning of motorcycles". Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering. 221 (11): 1343–1356. doi:10.1243/09544070jauto322. ISBN   978-1-4303-0861-4. S2CID   109274283.(subscription required)
• Leif Klyve; Henry Enoksen; Gunnar Kubberød (2006). "Full Control"/"Full Kontroll" (PDF). Norwegian Motorcycle Union. ISBN   82-92276-00-9. Archived from the original (PDF) on 8 October 2008.

External links

• Balance and Steering, by Tony Foale
• Full Control (English version), by Norwegian Motorcycle Union
• "No B.S. Machine" physical experimentation
• "The Physics of Unicycling" 5 minutes, explains countersteering from fundamental physics principles, requires Adobe Flash