Crop tolerance to seawater

Last updated

Crop tolerance to seawater is the ability of an agricultural crop to withstand the high salinity induced by irrigation with seawater , or a mixture of fresh water and seawater. There are crops that can grow on seawater and demonstration farms have shown the feasibility. [1] The government of the Netherlands reports a breakthrough in food security as specific varieties of potatoes, carrots, red onions, white cabbage and broccoli appear to thrive if they are irrigated with salt water. [2]

Contents

Salt Farm Texel

The Salt Farm Texel, a farm on the island of Texel, The Netherlands, is testing the salt tolerance of crops under controlled field conditions. There are 56 experimental plots of 160 m2 each that are treated in eight replicas with seven different salt concentrations. These concentrations are obtained with intensive daily drip irrigations of 10 or more mm (i.e. more than 10 liter per m2 per day) with water having a salt concentration expressed in electric conductivity (EC) of 2, 4, 8, 12, 16, 20 and 35 dS/m. [3] The range of EC values is obtained by mixing fresh water with the appropriate amount of seawater having a salinity corresponding to an EC value of about 50 dS/m. After planting, crops were allowed to germinate under fresh water conditions before the salt treatment started.

Soil salinity

The soil salinity is expressed in the electric conductivity of the extract of a saturated soil paste (ECe in dS/m). [4]

Author Schleiff presented a classification of salt tolerance of crops based on ECe in dS/m [5] that may be summarized as follows:

Salt tolerance
ECe (dS/m) ^)
Tolerance classification
   < 2very sensitive
   2 – 4sensitive
   4 – 6slightly sensitive
   6 – 8moderately tolerant
   8 – 10tolerant
   > 10very tolerant

^) The crop performs well (no yield reduction) up to the soil salinity level listed in the table. Beyond that level, the yield goes down.

The main difference with the classification published by Richards in the USDA Agriculture Handbook No. 60, 1954 [4] is that the classes are narrower with steps of 2 dS/m instead of 4.

Maas-Hoffman model fitted to a data set.
In this example the crop has a salt tolerance (threshold) of ECe=7 dS/m beyond which the yield declines. M-H model.png
Maas–Hoffman model fitted to a data set.
In this example the crop has a salt tolerance (threshold) of ECe=7 dS/m beyond which the yield declines.
Data from Salt Farm Brochure. Boundaries (yellow) and error ranges (light brown) have been added. The scatter is quite high. It is not known whether the yield percentages were computed year by year (A), or for all years combined (B). In case B the error ranges are still larger due to annual yield differences. No analysis of variance (Anova) was done to prove that the Maas-Hoffman model really is a statistically significant improvement over a simple, straightforward, downward sloping linear regression model. Mignonne+envelopes.png
Data from Salt Farm Brochure. Boundaries (yellow) and error ranges (light brown) have been added. The scatter is quite high. It is not known whether the yield percentages were computed year by year (A), or for all years combined (B). In case B the error ranges are still larger due to annual yield differences. No analysis of variance (Anova) was done to prove that the Maas-Hoffman model really is a statistically significant improvement over a simple, straightforward, downward sloping linear regression model.
The Salt Farm Texel also published a graph of the yield-salinity relation of white cabbage. Boundary lines were added separately in red color. The boundaries suggest that the slope of the ellipse encompassing the confidence area of the breakpoint should be upward to the right instead of to the left. However the Texel document does not give an explanation of the construction of the ellipse. White cabbage.png
The Salt Farm Texel also published a graph of the yield-salinity relation of white cabbage. Boundary lines were added separately in red color. The boundaries suggest that the slope of the ellipse encompassing the confidence area of the breakpoint should be upward to the right instead of to the left. However the Texel document does not give an explanation of the construction of the ellipse.

Modeling

The Salt Farm Texel uses the Maas–Hoffman model for crop response to soil salinity. [6] The model uses a response function starting with a horizontal line connected further on to a downward sloping line. The connection point is also called threshold or tolerance. Up to the threshold the crop is not affected by soil salinity while beyond it the yield starts declining. The model is fitted to the data by piecewise linear regression. [7]

Results

Crop Variety  ^)Threshold *)
(ECe in dS/m)
Class
Potato  x)Mignonne    #)4.1slightly sensitive
Achilles2.9sensitive
Foc2.1sensitive
Met1.9very sensitive
"927"3.4sensitive
CarrotCas4.5slightly sensitive
Ner3.6sensitive
Nat< 1very sensitive
Ben< 1very sensitive
"101"3.0sensitive
"102"5.0slightly sensitive
Pri2.1sensitive
OnionAlo2.4sensitive
Red5.9slightly sensitive
San3.2sensitive
Hyb3.4sensitive
LettuceBatavia H< 1very sensitive
Batavia S2.3sensitive
Butterhead L1.8very sensitive
Cabbage  White cabbage  #)  4.6slightly sensitive
Broccoli5.6slightly sensitive
BarleyQue 20143.3sensitive      +)
Que 20151.7very sensitive  +)

^) Many variety names are uncommon as they consist of 3 letters only
*) It is not known what the results would have been if the planting was not done under fresh water conditions but in saline conditions.
#) Graphs with scatter plots are shown in the report for these two varieties only. They show considerable variation both in Y (Yield) and X (ECe) direction.
x) For potato only one comparable value is known in literature, namely for the very sensitive variety white rose having a threshold of 1.7 dS/m [8]
+) For barley, in contrast, the U.S. Salinity Laboratory mentions a threshold value of ECe = 8 dS/m, which makes it a tolerant crop [9]

Summary

The highest tolerance is found for the onion variety "Red" which classifies as slightly sensitive. All crops classify in the range from very sensitive over sensitive to slightly sensitive. There is no crop classified as tolerant, not even moderately tolerant.

S-curve model

In the Texel report, also the Van Genuchten-Gupta model (giving an S-curve) was used to find the soil salinity at the 90% yield point. The rationale for this was not given.

Lentils

Lentils 3 types of lentil.jpg
Lentils

The Mediterranean Agronomic Institute, Valenzano, Bari, Italy South coast grew 5 cultivars of lentil irrigated with sea water of different salinity levels. Saline water was prepared by mixing fresh water (EC = 0.9 dS/m) with sea water (EC = 48 dS/m) to achieve salinity levels of 3.0, 6.0, 9.0 and 12.0 dS/m.[ citation needed ] Some of the results are shown in the following table:

Salinity
(dS/m)
Relative seedling length in % (control = 100%)
by cultivar
ILL4400ILL5582ILL5845ILL5883ILL8006
    3   98   83   82   98   96
    6   70   43   78   90   83
    9   57   48   63   52   62
   12   36   40   38   30   43

Halophytes

Turtleweed Batis maritima male.jpg
Turtleweed

Halophytes, or salt-loving plants, can be irrigated with pure seawater with the aim to grow fodder crops. A trial was made by Glenn et al. to use halophytes for feeding of sheep and it was concluded that the animals thrived well. [10]

Setting the yield of an alfalfa (lucerne) fodder crop irrigated with fresh water (2 kg/m2) at 100%, the following results were obtained for the yield of halophytic crops irrigated with seawater:

CropRelative yield (%)
Atriplex lentiformis , quailbush90
Pickleweed, turtleweed89
Suaeda sp., sea blite88
Dwarf glasswort, Salicornia bigelovii 87
Sesuvium portulacastrum , sea purslane85
Distichlis palmeri , Palmers grass65
Atriplex cinerea , coast salt bush45
Barley (Hordeum vulgare) Barley (Hordeum vulgare) - United States National Arboretum - 24 May 2009.jpg
Barley (Hordeum vulgare)

Barley

After selecting the most salt tolerant cultivar, the University of California at Davis has grown barley irrigated with pure seawater and obtained half the normal yield per acre, i.e. half of the average yield per acre at national level. [11] The experiment was conducted at Bodega Bay, North of San Francisco, in a laboratory on the Pacific Ocean.

Rice

Liu Shiping's team at Yangzhou University created rice varieties that can be grown in salt water, and achieve yields of 6.5 to 9.3 tons per hectare. [12] [13] As of 2021, seawater rice had been planted on 400,000 ha (990,000 acres) in soils with up to 4 grams of salt per kilogram, with yields averaging 8.8 tons per hectare, according to Qingdao Saline-Alkali Tolerant Rice Research and Development Center. [14]

Lettuce, chard and chicory

In a recent trial comparing three seawater and freshwater blends (i.e. 5%–10%–15% of seawater), some scientists found that lettuce productivity was negatively affected by 10% and 15% blends of seawater, whereas chard and chicory’s growth was not affected by any blend. Interestingly, water consumption dropped and WUE significantly increased in every tested crop accordingly with increased seawater concentrations. They concluded that certain amounts of seawater can be practically used in hydroponics, allowing freshwater savings and increasing concentrations of certain mineral nutrients. [15]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Salinity</span> Proportion of salt dissolved in water

Salinity is the saltiness or amount of salt dissolved in a body of water, called saline water. It is usually measured in g/L or g/kg.

Biosalinity is the study and practice of using saline (salty) water for irrigating agricultural crops.

Halotolerance is the adaptation of living organisms to conditions of high salinity. Halotolerant species tend to live in areas such as hypersaline lakes, coastal dunes, saline deserts, salt marshes, and inland salt seas and springs. Halophiles are organisms that live in highly saline environments, and require the salinity to survive, while halotolerant organisms can grow under saline conditions, but do not require elevated concentrations of salt for growth. Halophytes are salt-tolerant higher plants. Halotolerant microorganisms are of considerable biotechnological interest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Halophyte</span> Salt-tolerant plant

A halophyte is a salt-tolerant plant that grows in soil or waters of high salinity, coming into contact with saline water through its roots or by salt spray, such as in saline semi-deserts, mangrove swamps, marshes and sloughs, and seashores. The word derives from Ancient Greek ἅλας (halas) 'salt' and φυτόν (phyton) 'plant'. Halophytes have different anatomy, physiology and biochemistry than glycophytes. An example of a halophyte is the salt marsh grass Spartina alterniflora. Relatively few plant species are halophytes—perhaps only 2% of all plant species. Information about many of the earth's halophytes can be found in the halophyte database.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Soil salinity</span> Salt content in the soil

Soil salinity is the salt content in the soil; the process of increasing the salt content is known as salinization. Salts occur naturally within soils and water. Salination can be caused by natural processes such as mineral weathering or by the gradual withdrawal of an ocean. It can also come about through artificial processes such as irrigation and road salt.

<i>Soda inermis</i> Species of plant

Soda inermis, the opposite-leaved saltwort, oppositeleaf Russian thistle, or barilla plant, is a small, annual, succulent shrub that is native to the Mediterranean Basin. It is a halophyte that typically grows in coastal regions and can be irrigated with salt water. The plant was previously classified as Salsola soda, and many of the sources for this article used that designation.

<i>Distichlis palmeri</i> Species of flowering plant

Distichlis palmeri is an obligate emergent perennial rhizomatous dioecious halophytic C4 grass in the Poaceae (Gramineae) family. D. palmeri is a saltwater marsh grass endemic to the tidal marshes of the northern part of the Gulf of California and Islands section of the Sonoran Desert. D.palmeri is not drought tolerant. It does withstand surface drying between supra tidal events because roots extend downward to more than 1 meter where coastal substrata is still moist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Soil salinity control</span> Controlling the problem of soil salinity

Soil salinity control refers to controlling the process and progress of soil salinity to prevent soil degradation by salination and reclamation of already salty (saline) soils. Soil reclamation is also known as soil improvement, rehabilitation, remediation, recuperation, or amelioration.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">SahysMod</span>

SahysMod is a computer program for the prediction of the salinity of soil moisture, groundwater and drainage water, the depth of the watertable, and the drain discharge in irrigated agricultural lands, using different hydrogeologic and aquifer conditions, varying water management options, including the use of ground water for irrigation, and several crop rotation schedules, whereby the spatial variations are accounted for through a network of polygons.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">SaltMod</span> Salinity modelling software

SaltMod is computer program for the prediction of the salinity of soil moisture, groundwater and drainage water, the depth of the watertable, and the drain discharge (hydrology) in irrigated agricultural lands, using different (geo)hydrologic conditions, varying water management options, including the use of ground water for irrigation, and several cropping rotation schedules. The water management options include irrigation, drainage, and the use of subsurface drainage water from pipe drains, ditches or wells for irrigation.

<i>Chloris gayana</i> Species of grass

Chloris gayana is a species of grass known by the common name Rhodes grass. It is native to Africa but it can be found throughout the tropical and subtropical world as a naturalized species.

A leaching model is a hydrological model by which the leaching with irrigation water of dissolved substances, notably salt, in the soil is described depending on the hydrological regime and the soil's properties.

Deficit irrigation (DI) is a watering strategy that can be applied by different types of irrigation application methods. The correct application of DI requires thorough understanding of the yield response to water and of the economic impact of reductions in harvest. In regions where water resources are restrictive it can be more profitable for a farmer to maximize crop water productivity instead of maximizing the harvest per unit land. The saved water can be used for other purposes or to irrigate extra units of land. DI is sometimes referred to as incomplete supplemental irrigation or regulated DI.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Genetically modified rice</span>

Genetically modified rice are rice strains that have been genetically modified. Rice plants have been modified to increase micronutrients such as vitamin A, accelerate photosynthesis, tolerate herbicides, resist pests, increase grain size, generate nutrients, flavors or produce human proteins.

Saltwater aquaponics is a combination of plant cultivation and fish rearing, systems with similarities to standard aquaponics, except that it uses saltwater instead of the more commonly used freshwater. In some instances, this may be diluted saltwater. The concept is being researched as a sustainable way to eliminate the stresses that are put on local environments by conventional fish farming practices who expel wastewater into the coastal zones, all while creating complementary crops.

The Central Soil Salinity Research Institute (CSSRI) is an autonomous institute of higher learning, established under the umbrella of Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR) by the Ministry of Agriculture, Government of India for advanced research in the field of soil sciences. The institute is located on Kachawa Road in Karnal, in the state of Haryana, 125 km (78 mi) from the Indian capital of New Delhi.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Salt tolerance of crops</span>

Salt tolerance of crops is the maximum salt level a crop tolerates without losing its productivity while it is affected negatively at higher levels. The salt level is often taken as the soil salinity or the salinity of the irrigation water.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">U.S. Salinity Laboratory</span> National Laboratory for research on salt-affected soil

The U.S. Salinity Laboratory is a National Laboratory for research on salt-affected soil-plant-water systems. It resorts under the Agricultural Research Service (ARS) of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) and is located in Riverside, California, U.S.A.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Biosaline agriculture</span> Production of crops in salt-rich conditions

Biosaline agriculture is the production and growth of plants in saline rich groundwater and/or soil. In water scarce locations, salinity poses a serious threat to agriculture due to its toxicity to most plants. Abiotic stressors such as salinity, extreme temperatures, and drought make plant growth difficult in many climate regions. Integration of biosaline solutions is becoming necessary in arid and semiarid climates where freshwater abundance is low and seawater is ample. Salt-tolerant plants that flourish in high-salinity conditions are called halophytes. Halophyte implementation has the potential to restore salt-rich environments, provide for global food demands, produce medicine and biofuels, and conserve fresh water.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Freshwater salinization</span> Salty runoff contaminating freshwater ecosystems

Freshwater salinization is the process of salty runoff contaminating freshwater ecosystems, which can harm aquatic species in certain quantities and contaminate drinking water. It is often measured by the increased amount of dissolved minerals than what is considered usual for the area being observed. Naturally occurring salinization is referred to as primary salinization; this includes rainfall, rock weathering, seawater intrusion, and aerosol deposits. Human-induced salinization is termed as secondary salinization, with the use of de-icing road salts as the most common form of runoff. Approximately 37% of the drainage in the United States has been affected by salinization in the past century. The EPA has defined two thresholds for healthy salinity levels in freshwater ecosystems: 230 mg/L Cl for average salinity levels and 860 mg/L Cl for acute inputs.

References

  1. Monica Nicks, 2014. Consider The Salt-Tolerant Potato. In: Modern Farmer. On line:
  2. Government of The Netherlands, 2017. Dutch saline agricultural knowledge brings breakthrough in food security. News item | 23-02-2017 | 12:13. On line:
  3. Salt Farm Texel, 2017. Crop salt tolerance brochure. On line
  4. 1 2 L. A. Richards, Editor, 1954, Diagnosis and Improvement of saline and alkali soil, Agriculture Handbook No. 60, USDA.
  5. Uwe Schleiff, Research for crop salt tolerance under brackish irrigation. On line:
  6. Maas EV, Hoffman GJ, 1977. Crop salt tolerance-current assessment. Journal of the Irrigation and Drainage Division, American Society of Civil Engineers 103: 115–134.
  7. PennState Eberly College of Science. Piecewise Linear Regression Models. On line:
  8. Bernstein, L., Ayers, A.D. & Wadleigh, C.H. 1951. The salt tolerance of white rose potatoes. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci., 57: 231–236.
  9. U.S. Salinity Laboratory, United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Salt Tolerance of Fiber, Grain and Special Crops. On line:
  10. Edward P. Glenn, J. Jed Brown and James W. O’Leary, 1998, Irrigating Crops with Seawater. In: Scientific American, August 1998. On line:
  11. A. Rossiter, 1977. Scientists grow barley with seawater irrigation.. The Washington post. On line:
  12. Beach, Greg (October 25, 2017). "Chinese scientists created a type of rice that can grow in saltwater". inhabitat.com.
  13. Kentish, Benjamin (October 24, 2017). "Chinese scientists may have just found a new way to feed 200 million people". The Independent.
  14. Micu, Alexandru (2022-10-14). "A significant rice in productivity: China's output of GMO "seawater rice" doubled over the last 2 years". ZME Science. Retrieved 2022-10-31.
  15. Atzori, G., Guidi Nissim W., Caparrotta S., Vignolini P., Masi E., Azzarello E.,Pandolfi C., Gonnelli C., Mancuso S. (2016). “Potential and constraints of different seawater and freshwater blends as growing media for three vegetable crops”, Agricultural Water Management, 176: 255-262 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2016.06.016