Crown prosecutor (Australia)

Last updated

Crown prosecutors are the public prosecutors in the legal system of Australia. [1] In Western Australia, they are referred to as State prosecutors. [2]

Contents

Crown prosecutors represent the Crown in right of the Commonwealth and in right of each state [3] or Territory in criminal proceedings. Crown prosecutors are appointed not elected [4] and are not public servants; they are private counsel briefed by the Director of Public Prosecutions for particular cases.

Both the Commonwealth of Australia and the states and territories can make criminal laws under the Constitution of Australia, so Crown prosecutors deal with both state and federal offences. The typical Crown prosecutor, often a Queen's Counsel or Senior Counsel, will have extensive experience as defence counsel as well as prosecuting counsel, across a full spectrum of legal disciplines.

History, role and function

The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) was derived from the United Kingdom in the 19th Century. Their role was created to further the separation of powers and remove prosecutorial decisions from the legislature and any political influence. [5] This was partly driven by the fact Attorney-General's are attached to the ministry and parliament. Thus to ensure integrity and fairness in the judicial process, [6] it was deemed prudent to develop an independent body to deal with, what can be, often controversial and politically damaging decisions. [5] Lastly, prosecutors main functions are statutorily derived from the Director of Public Prosecutors Act 1986 (NSW). [7] From a procedural perspective, the ODPP has also absorbed the International Association of Prosecutor’s Standards of Professional Responsibility and Statement of the Essential Duties and Rights of Prosecutors, [8] into their practices and guidelines.

Crown prosecutors are independent and perform a unique function. Their role is to represent the community [7] or 'the Crown' in criminal trials, and seek to assist the court and steer the jury toward the truth [9] as well as providing justice to the victim and the wider community. As their role is independent, they will always seek to provide the jury with all relevant and credible evidence that they have been presented with for an alleged crime, [10] without the intention of achieving victory or loss. This notion of not solely seeking to obtain a conviction was conveyed by the Canadian Supreme Court in Boucher v The Queen (1954) 110 CCC 263 at 270; “It cannot be over-emphasised that the purpose of a criminal prosecution is not to obtain a conviction; it is to lay before a jury what the Crown considers to be credible evidence relevant to what is alleged to be a crime. Counsel have a duty to see that all available legal  proof of the facts  is presented: it should be done firmly and pressed to its legitimate strength, but it must also be done fairly.”

To clarify, the ODPP is the main prosecutorial body responsible for representing the Crown in criminal trials. Crown prosecutors are barristers who are briefed, by the ODPP, to appear on behalf of the Crown and perform prosecutorial and other ancillary functions. Further, the ODPP and by extension crown prosecutors do not investigate crimes. The respective police force in each state or territory is responsible for the investigative aspect of an alleged criminal offence. The prosecutors role is to firstly, determine whether the evidence is strong enough and/or admissible in a court proceedings. And secondly, to then use that brief of evidence and act for the Crown in presenting that evidence to the jury to deliberate and make a decision.

A growing conflict with prosecutorial duties is becoming the duty of disclosure. [11] As aforementioned, a major component of the prosecutorial function is the exercise of procedural fairness [12] and absolute adherence to judicial principles and prosecutorial guidelines. Duties of disclosures relate to instances whereby the police and/or prosecutors do not disclose all available information to the opposing counsel in an attempt to disguise the true appearance of the facts. Recent Australian cases where this has been an issue include R v Easterday (2003) 143 A Crim R 154 and R v Sonnet [2010] VSCA 315.

Appointment process

This section will focus on the appointment and eligibility requirements to become or be eligible to be appointed as a crown prosecutor. Each state has different legislation that is responsible for the appointment process. All prosecutors generally have the same requirements. Using NSW as a case study, appointments are made pursuant to the 'Crown Prosecutors Act 1986 (NSW). They firstly must be a qualified Australian legal practitioner. Secondly, crown prosecutors must also be members of the private bar, in NSW known as the New South Wales Bar Association. To be appointed at the bar as a barrister, one must receive the required standard of 75% in the NSW Bar Examination along with other administrative components. [13] Once a member of the private bar, barristers can be appointed by the Governor to serve as Crown Prosecutors. The main condition of their appointment is viewed below:

Section 4(2A) [14] – 'A Crown Prosecutor is to be appointed by the Governor for a term of 7 years or for such shorter term as may be necessary to ensure that the person's term of office extends to (but not beyond) the date on which the person reaches the age of 72 years. A Crown Prosecutor is eligible (if otherwise qualified) for reappointment.'

At the moment, there are currently 124 crown prosecutors in NSW.

Another role that exists within this, is that of a Senior Crown Prosecutor. This follows a similar process of appointment to that of the Crown Prosecutors, outlined in section 4A. [14] Senior Crown Prosecutors have the same roles and responsibilities; however, they represent the Crown in the most serious and complex matters. Their remuneration and tenure is fixed, yet the remuneration is slightly higher to reflect the added seniority and complexity of the job. [15]

Controversies

There have been recent instances where Crown and Senior Crown Prosecutors have found themselves under the microscope of investigations and been charged or publicly reprimanded. Particularly, Margaret Cunneen being summoned before ICAC and Mark Tedeschi's numerous misconduct allegations and complaints.

Mark Tedeschi, AM, QC MarkTedeschi.jpg
Mark Tedeschi, AM, QC

In October 2014, ICAC established ‘Operation Hale’ [16] to investigate allegations that in May 2014, Margaret Cunneen had advised her eldest son's girlfriend to fake chest pains to avoid a roadside breath test at the scene of a car crash. and also whether she lied about aspects of the accident to the insurance agency and DPP. [17] Cunneen sought an injunction against ICAC in the NSW Supreme Court [18] on two grounds: (1) a declaration ICAC was exceeding its jurisdictional scope; and (2) a declaration that the ICAC's decision to hold a public inquiry was invalid. [19] Cunneen appealed the initial decision of the Supreme Court, which went in ICAC's favor, to the NSW Court of Appeal. In Cunneen v ICAC, [20] a 2:1 majority of the NSW Court of Appeal held, inter alia, that the impugned conduct was not corrupt conduct as stipulated in s 8(2) of the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act 1988 (NSW) (‘ICAC Act’). In addition, the Court also ruled that ICAC's decision to hold such a public inquiry was unreasonable. [19] ICAC appealed the Supreme Court's decision to the High Court, given the significance of this decision on future investigations. [19] On 15 April 2015, via a 4:1 majority the High Court held in favor of the respondent (Cunneen), that the conduct was not corrupt within the meaning of the ‘ICAC Act’. [21] Subsequently, amendments were made to the ICAC Act, resulting in the Independent Commission Against Corruption Amendment Act 2015 (NSW) (‘ICAC Act’).

Mark Tedeschi AM QC is another high-profile Senior Crown Prosecutor who has faced accusations and allegations for misconduct and malicious prosecution. [22] Tedeschi was a regarded Crown Prosecutor, securing convictions in high-profile trials of Ivan Milat, the political assassin Phuong Ngo and the infamous case of the baby killer Keli Lane. Nevertheless, during the appeal of Gordon Wood's murder conviction, the appeal judges issued scathing commentary [23] on the conduct of Tedeschi during the trial as they threw out Mr. Wood's murder conviction. The judges accused Tedeschi of failing his core obligation as a prosecutor, which is to portray the case fairly to the jury. They alleged Mr. Tedeschi tried to artificially inflate the strength of the Crown case by employing fiction, inadmissible reasoning and ambiguity that suggested Wood had been in a relationship with the deceased to delineate and convince the jury Caroline Byrne could not have committed suicide. [23] Other instances of complaints have also come from former Ananda Marga member, Tim Anderson who sought action against Mark Tedeschi after a 1991 Appeal Court dismissed Anderson's conviction for the murder of three people in the Hilton Hotel Bombing. He claimed Legal Aid have laid almost fifty complaints to the NSW Bar Council against Tedeschi. [23] In addition, former NSW Drug Squad undercover detective Paul Kenny states he was a victim of Tedeschi's prosecutorial tactics. [22] Kenny was charged by internal affairs police with conspiring to pervert the course of justice and demanding bribes from a heroin dealer. Tedeschi led the prosecution; however ultimately withdrew the charges. Tedeschi's handling of the case came under scrutiny by a judicial inquiry with Justice Nader noting, “[he found it] frightening that [Tedeschi] didn’t even concede the possibility that Kenny was innocent”. [23] The inquiry found no evidence that suggested Tedeschi had acted improperly.

Commonwealth prosecutors

Whilst the majority of crown prosecutors belong to one of the independent state agencies, such as the ODPP NSW or the OPP VIC, an independent prosecutorial body exists that is responsible for the prosecution of crimes against the Commonwealth [24] as well as the provision of advice to agencies. This prosecution agency is called the Office of the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions or, colloquially, the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP). Established by parliament under the Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1983 (the DPP Act), the service seeks to prosecute alleged offences against Commonwealth Law. This originally pertained to acts committed under the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) and the Commonwealth Criminal Code. In more recent times, Commonwealth crown prosecutors have overseen and covered areas such as commercial and financial crimes, human exploitation and border protection, illegal trade, organised crime and counter terrorism along with revenue and benefits fraud. [25] Previous Commonwealth Directors of the CDPP and established senior crown prosecutors include Ian Temby AO, QC, Christopher Craigie SC, Michael Rozenes QC and the current director – Sarah McNaughton SC.

In the media

Two prominent Australian television shows have been made that depict the role of crown prosecutors. These are Crownies and its subsequent spin-off series Janet King.

Crownies

Crownies depicts the life of five recently graduated solicitors as they navigate the fast-paced and morally challenging workplace [26] that is the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, whilst working alongside crown prosecutors. There was twenty two episodes run which were broadcast on ABC1 from 14 July until 1 December 2011. Crownies was written by Greg Haddrick and produced by Karl Zwicky. The main cast included: Todd Lasance as Ben McMahon, Hamish Michael as Richard Sterling, Marta Dusseldorp as Janet King and Jerome Ehlers as Rhys Kowalski. The character of Janet King was later spun-off into its own show. In critical analysis, a Craig Mathieson article in the Sydney Morning Herald [27] drew correlations to the US hit show, Greys Anatomy. This pertained to the “overlap of professional stress and personal relationships, the overt melodrama, the comic diversions.” Crownies was nominated for an Equity Award for Most Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series in March 2012.

Janet King

Marta Dusseldorp, lead actress who played Janet King in Crownies and the subsequent spin-off series Marta Dusseldorp 2015.jpg
Marta Dusseldorp, lead actress who played Janet King in Crownies and the subsequent spin-off series

Janet King was first aired on ABC1 on the 27th February 2014 as a spin-off from the 2011 legal drama Crownies . The show was 'spun-off' due to modest reviews in the original Crownies 22-part season and wanting to focus on certain positive aspects of the original show. [28] The show was starred by Marta Dusseldorp who played Janet King in the original show, and featured many of her other supporting actors including; Hamish Michael (Richard Sterling), Ella Scott Lynch (Erin O’Shaughnessy), Andrea Demetriades (Lina Badir), Peter Kowitz (Tony Gillies), Christopher Morris (Andy Campbell) and Indiana Evans (Tatum Novak). The show was split into three seasons, focusing on her involvement in the Department of Public Prosecutions (Season 1), her leading role in the Royal Commission into Serious Firearm Crime (Series 2), and culminating with her lead role in a National Crime Commission investigation into organised crime in sport (Season 3). The show was well-received with Ben Pobjie commenting that it was a “high-class act” that managed to overcome the “inherent staleness of legal drama”. [29] The show received accolades and nominations with Marta Dusseldorp winning the Best Lead Actress in a Television Drama in the 2014 AACTA Awards. The show Janet King was also nominated for Best Television Drama Series in the same awards. Marta was also subsequently nominated for Most Outstanding Actress in the 2015 Logie Awards.

See also

Related Research Articles

The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) is the office or official charged with the prosecution of criminal offences in several criminal jurisdictions around the world. The title is used mainly in jurisdictions that are or have been members of the Commonwealth of Nations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">District attorney</span> U.S. government representative in the prosecution of criminal offenses

In the United States, a district attorney (DA), county attorney, state's attorney, prosecuting attorney, commonwealth's attorney, state attorney or solicitor is the chief prosecutor and/or chief law enforcement officer representing a U.S. state in a local government area, typically a county or a group of counties. The exact name and scope of the office varies by state. Alternative titles for the office include county attorney, solicitor, or county prosecutor. Generally the prosecutor represents the people of the jurisdiction and in many states their authority stems from the state constitution. Unlike similar roles in other common law judicial systems, these are appointed through partisan political processes, and their holders usually have an allegiance to a political party or faction, rather than being held by a career civil servant appointed on merit in an independent process.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prosecutor</span> Legal profession

A prosecutor is a legal representative of the prosecution in states with either the common law adversarial system or the civil law inquisitorial system. The prosecution is the legal party responsible for presenting the case in a criminal trial against an individual accused of breaking the law. Typically, the prosecutor represents the state or the government in the case brought against the accused person.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Independent Commission Against Corruption (New South Wales)</span> Anti-corruption agency in New South Wales, Australia

The Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) is an agency of the Government of New South Wales responsible for eliminating and investigating corrupt activities and enhancing the integrity of the state's public administration. The Commission was established in 1989, pursuant to the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act, 1988 (NSW), modeled after the ICAC in Hong Kong.

Ian Michael Macdonald is a former Australian politician and currently undergoing court proceedings and was a member of the New South Wales Legislative Council from 1988 to 2010 representing the Labor Party. Between 2003 and 2010, Macdonald held a range of ministerial responsibilities in the Carr, Iemma, Rees, and Keneally ministries. Macdonald, who joined the Labor Party in 1972, had his membership of the party terminated in 2013 for bringing the party into disrepute.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prosecutions Division (Hong Kong)</span>

The Prosecutions Division (刑事檢控科) of the Department of Justice, is the public prosecution office in Hong Kong led by the Director of Public Prosecutions. The Prosecutions Division is the largest in the Department, with about 125 lawyers, known as 'Public Prosecutors', and about 115 lay prosecutors, known as 'Court Prosecutors'. The role of the Division is to prosecute trials and appeals on behalf of Hong Kong, to provide legal advice to law enforcement agencies upon their investigations, and generally to exercise on behalf of the Secretary for Justice the discretion of whether or not to bring criminal proceedings in Hong Kong. In addition, counsel in the Division provide advice and assistance to Government bureaux and departments in relation to any criminal law aspects of proposed legislation.

Margaret Mary Cunneen is an Australian barrister, prosecutor and commissioner of a government inquiry.

Leanne Clare is a Judge of the District Court of Queensland and a former Queensland Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). On 2 April 2008 she was appointed to the District Court after eight years as DPP. Between 1999 and 2000 she served as an acting judge at Ipswich District Court.

Kevin Paul Zervos is a Justice of Appeal of the Court of Appeal of Hong Kong. He previously served as Director of Public Prosecutions of the Department of Justice of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region from March 2011 to September 2013.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mark Tedeschi</span>

Mark Tedeschi, is an Australian barrister, law professor, photographer and author. He is in private practice at Wardell Chambers in Sydney. He was formerly the Senior Crown prosecutor for New South Wales and the Head of Chambers of the 100 or so Crown prosecutors. He was the founder and president of the Australian Association of Crown Prosecutors and is a visiting professor at the University of Wollongong. As a prosecutor, Tedeschi was best known for the prosecution of numerous high-profile cases in Australia, including the backpacker murders committed by Ivan Milat in the 1990s. He has won numerous awards for his photography and has been featured in galleries throughout the world, including in the State Library of New South Wales, the New South Wales Art Gallery, the Center for Fine Art Photography in Colorado, and the National Library in Canberra.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Director of Public Prosecutions of Kenya</span>

The Constitution itself anchors the role of the Director of Public Prosecutions in Kenya. The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) is the National Prosecuting Authority in Kenya. The Constitution mandates it to prosecute all criminal cases in the country.

Crown advocate is a title used in some former British colonies for a government prosecutor. In former British Colonies and certain British extraterritorial courts the title is used by the senior government advocate. Until recently, in Britain the title is used for entry-level prosecution counsel employed by the Crown Prosecution Service.

The Office of the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions or, informally, the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP) is an independent prosecuting service and government agency within the portfolio of the Attorney-General of Australia, as a part of the Attorney-General's Department. It was established by the Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1983 (Cth) and began its operations in 1984.

The New South Wales Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) is an independent prosecuting service and government agency within the portfolio of the Attorney General of New South Wales. Of all prosecuting services in Australia, the ODPP has the largest caseload, staff, and budget.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Janet King (character)</span> Fictional character

Janet King is a fictional character from the Australian ABC1 legal dramas Crownies and Janet King, played by Marta Dusseldorp. She debuted on-screen in the first episode of Crownies broadcast on 14 July 2011. To prepare, Dusseldorp researched legal cases and observed prosecutors in court. She also visited the NSW Director of Public Prosecutions Nicholas Cowdery and shadowed Margaret Cunneen SC, a Senior Crown Prosecutor and model for the character Janet King. Janet is characterised as a "tough and tenacious" Senior Crown Prosecutor who has worked in the DPP office for ten years. The character is in a same-sex relationship and has children via IVF. When Crownies finished airing plans were made to create a spin-off show centric to the character. Janet King was produced in 2013 with Dusseldorp returning to the titular role. The actress has stated that she made deliberate changes to ensure Janet listened to others more often.

The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions is the principal public agency for conducting criminal prosecutions in the Republic of Ireland. It is led by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP).

Elizabeth Lillian Fullerton is an Australian lawyer, specialising in criminal law, who has been a judge of the Supreme Court of New South Wales since February 2007.

Sarah McNaughton is an Australian judge and former barrister who has served as a judge of the Supreme Court of New South Wales since 10 October 2022. Prior to her appointment to the judiciary, she served as the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions from 16 May 2016 to 2 September 2022.

The Director of Public Prosecutions of Hong Kong (DPP) is a law officer and head of the Prosecutions Division of the Department of Justice; the director is responsible for directing the conduct of trials and appeals on behalf of Hong Kong, providing legal advice to law enforcement agencies, exercising the discretion of whether to institute criminal proceedings, and providing advice to others in government on proposed changes to the criminal law.

Sally Dowling is an Australian lawyer who has been Director of Public Prosecutions for New South Wales since August 2021.

References

  1. ↑ "Glossary of Legal Terms". Attending Court. Federal Court of Australia. 28 October 2012. Retrieved 17 April 2015.
  2. ↑ "Statement of Prosecution Policy and Guidelines 2018" (PDF). Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions. p. 3.
  3. ↑ "The role of the prosecutor". Department of Justice and Attorney-General. Queensland Government. 27 June 2012. Retrieved 17 April 2015.
  4. ↑ "Silbert appointed chief Crown prosecutor". The Sydney Morning Herald . 4 March 2008. Retrieved 17 April 2015.
  5. 1 2 Corporate=, ACT Director of Public Prosecutions; PositionTitle=Web Manager; SectionName= (1 August 2019). "History". www.dpp.act.gov.au. Retrieved 15 December 2021.
  6. ↑ Préfontaine, Q.C, Daniel (9 December 1998). "The Rule of Law and the Independence of the Judiciary". World Conference on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
  7. 1 2 Director of Public Prosecutions Act 1986 (NSW)
  8. ↑ "International Association of Prosecutors – IAP Standards: IAP". www.iap-association.org. Retrieved 15 December 2021.
  9. ↑ Cunneen, Margaret (Winter 2011). "Practising as a Crown Prosecutor". The Journal of the New South Wales Bar Association. 86– via Austlii.
  10. ↑ "Crown Prosecutors | ODPP". www.odpp.nsw.gov.au. Retrieved 13 December 2021.
  11. ↑ Plater, David; de Vreeze, Lucy A. (22 November 2012). "Is the 'Golden Rule' of Full Prosecution Disclosure a Modern 'Mission Impossible'?". Rochester, NY. doi:10.2139/ssrn.2358308. SSRN   2358308.{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  12. ↑ Johns, Rowena (2001). "Independence and Accountability of the Director of Public Prosecutions: A Comparative Survey". Briefing Paper. No 9.
  13. ↑ "How to Become a Barrister in NSW". beyondlaw.com.au. Retrieved 15 December 2021.
  14. 1 2 Crown Prosecutors Act 1986 (NSW) s 4(2A)
  15. ↑ Association, The New South Wales Bar. "Senior Crown Prosecutor Role – NSW ODPP". www.nswbar.asn.au. Retrieved 15 December 2021.
  16. ↑ Press, Australian Associated (4 December 2015). "Report on Icac: pursuit of Margaret Cunneen was 'unreasonable and unjust'". the Guardian. Retrieved 15 December 2021.
  17. ↑ Whitbourn, Michaela (4 December 2015). "ICAC 'acted illegally' in Margaret Cunneen inquiry, Inspector says". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 15 December 2021.
  18. ↑ Cunneen v Independent Commission Against Corruption [2014] NSWSC 1571
  19. 1 2 3 Dobinson, Ian; Houston, Leanne (2017). "ICAC's Operation 'Hale': A Low Point in the History of the Agency". Current Issues in Criminal Justice. 29: 57–75. doi:10.1080/10345329.2017.12036085. S2CID   149027558.
  20. ↑ Cunneen v Independent Commission Against Corruption [2014] NSWCA 421
  21. ↑ Whitbourn, Michaela (4 December 2015). "ICAC 'acted illegally' in Margaret Cunneen inquiry, Inspector says". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 4 January 2022.
  22. 1 2 High profile prosecutor faces accusations, Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 12 March 2012, retrieved 4 January 2022
  23. 1 2 3 4 "Wood appeal puts prosecutor on the spot". ABC News. 12 March 2012. Retrieved 4 January 2022.
  24. ↑ Prosecutions, Commonwealth Director of Public (5 August 2015). "About Us". www.cdpp.gov.au. Retrieved 4 January 2022.
  25. ↑ Prosecutions, Commonwealth Director of Public (11 August 2015). "Case Reports". www.cdpp.gov.au. Retrieved 4 January 2022.
  26. ↑ Crownies (TV Series 2011) – IMDb , retrieved 4 January 2022
  27. ↑ Mathieson, Craig (31 August 2011). "A damning verdict". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 4 January 2022.
  28. ↑ "ABC considers Crownies spin-off | TV Tonight". tvtonight.com.au/. Retrieved 4 January 2022.
  29. ↑ Pobjie, Ben (26 March 2014). "The Mora the murkier for Janet King". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 4 January 2022.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.