Election petition

Last updated

An election petition refers to the procedure for challenging the result of a Parliamentary election.

Contents

Outcomes

When a petition is lodged against an election return, there are 4 possible outcomes: [1]

  1. The election is declared void. The result is quashed and a writ is issued for a new election
  2. The election is held to have been undue: the original return is quashed, and another candidate is declared to have been elected.
  3. The election is upheld, and the member returned is found to have been duly elected.
  4. The petition is withdrawn. This may occur when the petitioner fails to attend a hearing, or when Parliament is dissolved before the petition process is complete

History

Controverted elections had been originally tried by select committees, afterwards by the Committee of Privileges and Elections, and ultimately by the whole House of Commons, with scandalous partiality, but under the Grenville Act of 1770 (10 Geo III. c. 16), and other later acts, by select committees, so constituted as to form a more judicial tribunal. The influence of party bias, however, too obviously prevailed until 1839, when Robert Peel introduced an improved system of nomination, which distinctly raised the character of election committees; but a tribunal constituted of political partisans, however chosen, was still open to jealousy and suspicion. At length the Parliamentary Elections Act 1868 transferred the trial of election petitions to judges of the superior courts, [2] to whose determination the House gives effect, by the issue of new writs or otherwise. The House, however, still retains and exercises its jurisdiction in all cases not relegated, by statute, to the judges.

Petitions, which resulted in the election in a constituency being held void used to be common after every general election, but are now rare.

When an election was held void the House of Commons could seat another candidate, order a new writ issued to fill the vacancy or leave the writ unissued for a time, thus suspending the representation of a constituency. As the tolerance of corrupt elections became less during the 18th and 19th centuries, boroughs found to be corrupt could be punished by either changing the area and the qualifications for voting or disenfranchising the constituency completely.

Such mechanism also exists in Hong Kong, [3] then a British colony, and in Australia, New Zealand or other (ex-)Commonwealth nations.

Cases

In 1961, Tony Benn was disqualified from taking up his seat after a by-election by an election court because he held a peerage.

In 1982, Seamus Mallon was disqualified from taking his seat in the Northern Ireland Assembly as he was a member of Seanad Éireann, the upper chamber of the parliament of the Republic of Ireland, at the time of his election. [4]

A recent example of an election being held void was when the 1997 election of Member of Parliament for Winchester, Mark Oaten, (Liberal Democrat) was contested by the Conservative Party candidate Gerry Malone. Oaten had won the seat by two votes, with 55 ballot papers had been rejected by the returning officer because they had not been stamped properly. Malone lodged an election petition in the High Court to contest the outcome. The petition was dealt with by special case in which Oaten joined. On 6 October 1997 Lord Justice Brooke ruled that the election was void: by a 1974 precedent the failure to stamp the ballots may have been the result of polling station staff forgetting, and had they been counted, Malone would have had a majority of two over Oaten.

Two election petitions were lodged after the General Election on 6 May 2010. The defeated Independent Rodney Connor, who lost in Fermanagh and South Tyrone by four votes has lodged a petition seeking a recount with scrutiny, [5] [6] and the case began on 13 September 2010. [7]

In the Oldham East and Saddleworth constituency, the defeated Liberal Democrat candidate Elwyn Watkins petitioned against the election of Phil Woolas, [8] a former Labour Minister, alleging that the result was affected by false statements of fact about his personal character. [9] The election court which heard the case ordered a re-run of the election in Woolas' constituency after finding him guilty of making false statements against his opponent during the original campaign. [10] [11] Phil Woolas sought a judicial review of the decision in the High Court, but was unsuccessful overall as that Court upheld the decision of the Election Court in relation to two statements, whilst quashing the decision in relation to a third. [12]

In the aftermath of the April 2021 Samoan general election, 28 election petitions were filed. [13] The country's Supreme Court ruled against it. [14]

Related Research Articles

Phil Woolas British environmental consultant, political lobbyist and former television producer and politician

Philip James Woolas is a British environmental consultant, political lobbyist and former television producer and politician who served as Minister of State for Borders and Immigration from 2008 to 2010. A member of the Labour Party, he was Member of Parliament (MP) for Oldham East and Saddleworth from 1997 to 2010.

The 1997 Winchester by-election was a by-election to the UK House of Commons in the constituency of Winchester, Hampshire. Winchester was initially declared to have been won by Mark Oaten with a majority of two votes at the general election on 1 May 1997, but following a legal challenge, a new election was allowed by the High Court. The by-election, held on 20 November, was won by Oaten with a majority of 21,556.

Fermanagh and South Tyrone (UK Parliament constituency)

Fermanagh and South Tyrone is a parliamentary constituency in the British House of Commons. The current MP is Michelle Gildernew of Sinn Féin.

Canterbury (UK Parliament constituency) UK Parliament constituency since 1295

Canterbury is a constituency represented in the House of Commons of the UK Parliament since 2017 by Rosie Duffield of the Labour Party.

Taunton (UK Parliament constituency) Parliamentary constituency in the United Kingdom, 1885–2010

Taunton was a constituency represented in the House of Commons of the Parliament of the United Kingdom and its predecessors from 1295 to 2010, taking its name from the town of Taunton in Somerset. Until 1918, it was a parliamentary borough, electing two Member of Parliaments (MPs) between 1295 and 1885 and one from 1885 to 1918; the name was then transferred to a county constituency, electing one MP.

Oldham East and Saddleworth (UK Parliament constituency) Parliamentary constituency in the United Kingdom, 1997 onwards

Oldham East and Saddleworth is a constituency in outer Greater Manchester represented in the House of Commons of the UK Parliament since January 2011 by Debbie Abrahams of the Labour Party.

Stafford (UK Parliament constituency) Parliamentary constituency in the United Kingdom, 1983 onwards

Stafford is a constituency represented in the House of Commons of the UK Parliament since 2019 by Theodora Clarke, a Conservative.

Colchester (UK Parliament constituency) UK Parliament constituency since 1997

Colchester is a constituency represented in the House of Commons of the UK Parliament since 2015 by Will Quince, a Conservative.

Winchester (UK Parliament constituency) Parliamentary constituency in the United Kingdom, 1885 onwards

Winchester is a constituency represented in the House of Commons of the UK Parliament since 2010 by Steve Brine, a Conservative.

Gloucester (UK Parliament constituency) Parliamentary constituency in the United Kingdom, 1885 onwards

Gloucester is a constituency centred on the cathedral city and county town of the same name, represented in the House of Commons of the UK Parliament by Richard Graham of the Conservative Party.

2010 United Kingdom general election General election held in the United Kingdom

The 2010 United Kingdom general election was held on Thursday 6 May 2010, with 45,597,461 registered voters entitled to vote to elect members to the House of Commons. The election took place in 650 constituencies across the United Kingdom under the first-past-the-post system.

Peter Gerald "Gerry" Malone is a British Conservative Party politician who served as a member of Parliament (MP) from 1983 to 1987 and again from 1992 to 1997.

Representation of the People Act 1983 United Kingdom legislation

The Representation of the People Act 1983 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. It changed the British electoral process in the following ways:

Beverley (UK Parliament constituency) Parliamentary constituency in the United Kingdom, 1983–1997

Beverley has been the name of a parliamentary constituency in the East Riding of Yorkshire for three periods. From medieval times until 1869 it was a parliamentary borough consisting of a limited electorate of property owners of its early designated borders within the market town of Beverley, which returned (elected) two Members of Parliament to the House of Commons of the English and Welsh-turned-UK Parliament during that period.

In United Kingdom election law, election court is a special court convened to hear a petition against the result of a local government or parliamentary election. The court is created to hear the individual case, and ceases to exist when it has made its decision.

2011 Oldham East and Saddleworth by-election

The 2011 by-election in Oldham East and Saddleworth was a by-election for the Parliament of the United Kingdom's House of Commons constituency of Oldham East and Saddleworth held on 13 January 2011. Labour Party candidate Debbie Abrahams held the seat for her party with an increased majority over the Liberal Democrats, succeeding Phil Woolas, whose victory in the 2010 general election had been declared void because he had knowingly made false statements attacking his Liberal Democrat opponent's personal character.

Robert Elwyn James Watkins, is a British Liberal Democrat politician. He narrowly lost to Labour Party candidate Phil Woolas for the Oldham East and Saddleworth seat in the 2010 general election, but the result was overturned by an election court, which found that Woolas had knowingly lied about Watkins' personal character. Watkins had stood down as a councillor representing Healey Ward on Rochdale Council in order to contest the general election. He was selected as the Liberal Democrat candidate for the constituency in late 2007.

2021 Samoan general election General election held in Samoa

General elections were held in Samoa on 9 April 2021 to determine the composition of the 17th Parliament. In March 2021, Fiamē Naomi Mataʻafa, a former member of the ruling Human Rights Protection Party (HRPP) and a former Deputy Prime Minister, was elected to lead the main opposition party, Faʻatuatua i le Atua Samoa ua Tasi (FAST). Prime minister Tuila'epa Sa'ilele Malielegaoi led the HRPP into the election.

Next Samoan general election General election held in Samoa

General elections were due to be held in Samoa on 21 May 2021. They were called by O le Ao o le Malo Tuimalealiʻifano Vaʻaletoʻa Sualauvi II following the inconclusive results of the April 2021 election, but before the new parliament had even been convened or numerous electoral court petitions settled.

References

  1. Rallings, Colin; Tharsher, Michael (2006). British Electoral Facts. London: Total Politics. p. 246. ISBN   978-1-907278-03-7.
  2. Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). "Election"  . Encyclopædia Britannica . Vol. 7 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 170.
  3. "Cap 542F Legislative Council (Election Petition) Rules; Legislative Council Ordinance". Archived from the original on 20 August 2016. Retrieved 13 September 2016.
  4. "Key players". The Daily Telegraph . 25 October 2001. Retrieved 29 May 2010.
  5. Saunderson, Sarah (3 June 2010). "Connor asks High Court for election recount". The Impartial Reporter.
  6. "Election petition submitted to the High Court of Northern Ireland" (PDF). Electoral Office for Northern Ireland. Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 July 2011. Retrieved 15 September 2010.
  7. "Notice of Election Court" (PDF). Electoral Office for Northern Ireland. Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 July 2011. Retrieved 15 September 2010.
  8. "Losing candidate challenges Oldham election result". BBC. 28 May 2010. Retrieved 28 May 2010.
  9. Election Petition submitted to the High Court - Part 1 Archived 18 January 2012 at the Wayback Machine , Part 2 Archived 18 January 2012 at the Wayback Machine and Part 3 Archived 18 January 2012 at the Wayback Machine . Parts 2 and 3 includes copies of the election literature challenged. (Oldham Council website, Retrieved 30 June 2010)
  10. "Judges order election re-run in ex-minister's seat". BBC News. 5 November 2010. Retrieved 5 November 2010.
  11. "Watkins v Woolas 2010 EWHC 2702 (QB)". British and Irish Legal Information Institute. 5 November 2010. Retrieved 5 November 2010.
  12. "R on the application of Woolas v The Parliamentary Election Court and others (2010) EWHC 3169 (Admin)". British and Irish Legal Information Institute. 3 December 2010. Retrieved 3 December 2010.
  13. "Court challenges to Samoa election begin". RNZ. 4 May 2021. Retrieved 4 May 2021.
  14. "Samoa's Head of State sets a date for parliament to meet". PMN. 21 May 2021. Retrieved 21 May 2021.