English Phonotypic Alphabet

Last updated

Street sign of Kingston Buildings in Bath, once seat of The Phonetic Society KiNGston BildiNGz, near Bath Abbey - geograph.org.uk - 717317.jpg
Street sign of Kingston Buildings in Bath, once seat of The Phonetic Society
Letters of the English phonotypic Alphabet (1847) English Phonotypic Alphabet - 1847.png
Letters of the English phonotypic Alphabet (1847)
Additional letters for other languages in 1845. English Phonotypic Alphabet - Additional Symbols for Foreign Sounds - 1845.png
Additional letters for other languages in 1845.
The American version of the alphabet of 1855, as reprinted in a medical dictionary in 1871 American Phonetic Alphabet.png
The American version of the alphabet of 1855, as reprinted in a medical dictionary in 1871
An early version of the alphabet, 1843 Phonotypic Alphabet No. 10 (October 1843).png
An early version of the alphabet, 1843

The English Phonotypic Alphabet is a phonetic alphabet developed by Sir Isaac Pitman and Alexander John Ellis originally as an English language spelling reform. [2] Although never gaining wide acceptance, elements of it were incorporated into the modern International Phonetic Alphabet. [3]

Contents

It was originally published in June 1845. [4] Subsequently, adaptations were published which extended the alphabet to the German, Arabic, Spanish, Tuscan, French, Welsh, Italian, Dutch, Polish, Portuguese and Sanskrit languages. [5]

Etymology

The English Phonotypic Alphabet was a phonotype, which is a phonetic form of printing derived from the Greek root "phon-" for voice and "-typ" for type. [6] [7] As such, Pitman and Ellis gave their alphabet the alternative name of Phonotypy or, even more phonetically, Fonotypy. It was designed to be the print form extension of Pitman Shorthand, a form of abbreviated phonetic handwriting. [8] It is closely associated with Phonetic Longhand, which is the handwritten, or script, form of Phonotypy. [9]

Purpose

The philosophical case for the English Phonotypic Alphabet was made by Alexander John Ellis, who conducted an extensive study of the problems with English orthography, which he published in his treatise Plea for Phonetic Spelling, or the Necessity of Orthographic Reform, in 1848. [10] Learned societies such as the London Philological Society and education journals such as The Massachusetts Teacher debated the arguments for reform and the utility of the English Phonotypic Alphabet. [11] [12]

Unexpectedly, when the English Phonotypic Alphabet was trialled to teach literacy, it was discovered that after learning to read & write, students effortlessly transitioned their literacy skills to traditional English orthography. This also gave purpose to the English Phonotypic Alphabet being used as a transitional mechanism to improve the teaching of literacy. [13] [14]

Letters

The letters are as follows (with some approximations to accommodate Unicode)

Late 1843 (English)

At this stage, long vowels had a cross-bar, and short vowels did not

Long vowels

Ɨ /iː/, E /eɪ/, A /ɑː/, Ɵ /ɔː/, Ʉ /oʊ/?, ᗻ (for some fonts ᗼ) /uː/

Short vowels

I /ɪ/, ⵎ /ɛ/, Ʌ /æ/, O /ɒ/, U /ʌ/, ᗯ /ʊ/

(the letter for /ʊ/ was like Ɯ but with the middle stem not so tall as the others, and did not have a serif at the bottom right)

Diphthongs

Ɯ /juː/ (like Iᗯ), ⅄ /aɪ/ (like ɅI), Ȣ /aʊ/ (like Oᗯ)?

Reduced ('obscure') vowels

Ǝ /ə/, /ᵊ/

Consonants

P B, T D, Є J /tʃ dʒ/, K G

F V, Θ Δ /θ ð/, S Z, Σ Σ /ʃ ʒ/,

L R, M N, И /ŋ/, Y W H.

1845

Vowels
Monophthongs
Front Back
Close Ɛɛ••ᗯɯ
Near-close Ii••Ꞷꞷ
Open-mid Ee•Uu•Oo
Near-open Aɑ•Āᶐ•Ɵɵ
Diphthongs beginning with an unrounded vowel
Back
Close •Աᶙ
Diphthongs ending with an unrounded vowel
Front Back
Close-mid ᗩa•
Near-open •ⵚơ
Open ┼ᶖ•
Diphthongs ending with a rounded vowel
Front Back
Close-mid •𐐗ɷ
Open రȣ•
Consonants
Pulmonic section
Labial Coronal Dorsal Laryngeal
Bilabial Labiodental Dental Alveolar Postalveolar Palatal Velar Glottal
Nasal •Mm•Nn•И̡ŋ
Plosive Pp•BbTt•DdCc•Gg
Sibilant affricate Єꞔ•Jj
Sibilant fricative Ss•ZzΣʃ•𐅠ʒ
Non-sibilant fricativeFf•Vv⅂ҽ•ƋꞛHh•
Approximant •Rr•Yy
Lateral approximant•Ll
Co-articulated section
Labial-velar•Ww

Teaching Literacy

The first page of the Longley Primer, shows children the letters of the Phonotypic alphabet so they can learn the associated sounds. First Phonetic Reader by Elias Longley.png
The first page of the Longley Primer, shows children the letters of the Phonotypic alphabet so they can learn the associated sounds.

The ultimate objective of the English Phonotypic Alphabet was to improve literacy levels; as such, to demonstrate its efficacy, it was trialled for teaching literacy in many different settings. It was mainly tried in schools with children but also illiterate inmates of workhouses, reformatories and jails and by missionaries in Africa, China & India. In 1849, its potential was shown when 1,300 Mancunian illiterates were taught to read and write in only a few months. [15]

These trials culminated in the adoption of the English Phonotypic Alphabet in two public school districts in the United States: - Waltham, Massachusetts, between 1852 & 1860 and Syracuse, New York, between 1850 & 1866. Both districts used a variant of the English Phonotypic Alphabet known as the Cincinnati Phonotypy or the American Phonetic Alphabet. [16] This type was used by Longley Brothers to publish a set of reading-books: - a first phonetic reader, a second phonetic reader, and a transition reader. [17] [18] [19]

Waltham

Cover of the Second Phonetic Reader in Phonotypy Second Phonetic Reader - Cover.png
Cover of the Second Phonetic Reader in Phonotypy

In the 1852-53 annual report of Waltham's school committee, the chairman, Reverend Thomas Hill, reported the effect of Phonotypy on the 800 pupils within the ten schools: – [20]

"It has been proved in repeated experiment that if a child upon his first learning his letters, is taught the Phonetic Alphabet, and is confined to Phonetic books for the first six to eight months of schooling, he will at the end of the first year's schooling read common print and spell in common spelling better than children will ordinarily do at the end of four or five year's instruction." [21]

Syracuse

Since a child learns literacy in Phonotypy, this page of the Transition Reader explains to the child why they need to change alphabet. Transition Reader.png
Since a child learns literacy in Phonotypy, this page of the Transition Reader explains to the child why they need to change alphabet.

Bothe's analysis of the course of study for the Syracuse school district measured the improvement from using Phonotypy: -

In 1855, before the introduction of the transitional alphabet, the student was expected to finish reading Webb's Second Reader by the end of the third grade. In 1858, the first year in which phonetic texts appeared in the course of study, Webb's Second Reader was entirely completed two-thirds through the second grade (four trimesters gained). [22]

Successor

Elias Longley, author of The Phonetic Readers in Phonotypy. Elias Longley (1823-1899).png
Elias Longley, author of The Phonetic Readers in Phonotypy.

Dr Edwin Leigh extensively practised using Phonotypy to teach literacy. He became persuaded of its efficacy and a passionate advocate but failed to convince his own St. Louis school district to adopt it. He concluded that Phonotypy was not widely accepted because parents, teachers, and district officials could not understand the orthography themselves. [23]

2nd Phonetic Reader - The teacher's notes explain the importance of comprehension as children learn to read more quickly with Phonotypy. Second Phonetic Reader - Teachers Notes.png
2nd Phonetic Reader - The teacher's notes explain the importance of comprehension as children learn to read more quickly with Phonotypy.

Phonotypy had never been designed as a transitionary mechanism to attain literacy in standard English; instead, people had only realised it could be used this way after it was launched. Subsequently, Leigh designed a successor, Pronouncing Orthography, which was explicitly designed for this purpose, and to this end, it superseded Phonotypy as a transitory orthography toward literacy. [24]

Citations

  1. Mason, Cai (25 January 2019). "Bath Abbey: Revelations from Abbey Chambers, Kingston Buildings and the 4th Fonetik Institut". Wessex Archaeology. Retrieved 26 October 2024.
  2. Daniels, Peter T.; Bright, William, eds. (1996). The World's Writing Systems. Oxford University Press. p. 831. ISBN   0-19-507993-0.
  3. Coulmas, Florian (12 March 1999). "English Phonotypic Alphabet". The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Writing Systems. Wiley. ISBN   0-631-21481-X.
  4. "Completion of the Phonotypic Alphabet". The Phonotypic Journal. 4 (42). Bath: Phonographic Institution: 105–106. June 1845.
  5. "Extension of the Phonotypic Alphabet". The Phonotypic Journal. 4 (43). Bath: Phonographic Institution: 121–123. June 1845.
  6. "Word Root: typ (Root)". Membean. Retrieved 13 January 2024.
  7. "Word Root: phon (Root)". Membean. Retrieved 13 January 2024.
  8. Pitman & St. John 1969, pp. 79–80, Chapter 6 - Four Centuries of Spelling and Alphabet Reform.
  9. Longley, Elias [Secretary of the American Phonetic Association] (1878). The Phonetic Educator: Devoted to Phonography and the Spelling Reform. Vol. I. Cincinnati, Ohio: Phonetic Publishing Company (published 1 December 1878). p. 61.
  10. Ellis 1848, pp. 1–195.
  11. Blake, F.N. (1 March 1850). "Spelling Reform". The Massachusetts Teacher. III (3): 83–85 via Internet Archive.
  12. Marshall 2020, p. 2"...Britain's greatest nineteenth century phoneticians, Alexander John Ellis (1814-1890) and Henry Sweet (1845-1912), were frequent contributors to the journal. Hailed as the man 'responsible for laying the foundations of phonetic studies in Britain', Ellis was an excellent speaker and consecutively delivered the first three annual presidential addresses to the Society, the first of which was in 1872."
  13. Hill, Thomas (3 July 1856). "Phonotypy as a Reading Reform". The Four Ways of Teaching to Read: An Address Delivered Before the Ohio Teachers' Association, July 3rd, 1856. Cincinnati: Longley Brothers. pp. 14–15.
  14. Withers 2023, pp. 59–76, SECTION (4) English Spelled as Pronounced, a Means of Attaining the Present Reading and Spelling more easily. Experiments in Teaching.
  15. Pitman & St. John 1969, p. 85, Chapter 6 - Four Centuries of Spelling and Alphabetic Reform.
  16. Bothe 1967, p. 38.
  17. Longley 1855.
  18. Longley & 1851 1st Reader.
  19. Longley & 1851 2nd Reader.
  20. Hill 1889, p. 186, cited Reverend Thomas Hill (1st June 1853) as Chairman in the annual report of the Waltham School Committee"..We tested it thoroughly for six or seven years in the town of Waltham, Massachusetts, which then had about 800 children in the public schools. The effect on the school life of the town was very marked...experience has demonstrated that there is no means so efficient as the use of simple reading-books printed in a truly phonetic manner...when the pupil can read fluently phonetic English, he requires but a few weeks to learn to read the ordinary spelling."
  21. Pitman & St. John 1969, p. 85, Chapter 6; - Four Centuries of Spelling and Alphabetic Reform...cited the Waltham School District annual school report of 1852-1853 of the school committee where Reverend Hill was Chairman.
  22. Bothe 1967, pp. 55–56, Section (4) - Syracuse, New York.
  23. Leigh 1864, p. 3, Reasons why Phonotypy Failed..The causes of this ill success are many and obvious. Among them may be mentioned........ Fonotypy's departure from common orthography; changing the forms and outlines and spellings of English words, thus offending the eye and arousing the prejudices of the unlettered and the literary; apparently compelling the learner to master two languages, the phonetic and the English; requiring him to become familiar with the wrong spellings in order to learn the right, and to acquire an entirely new language in order to learn the common print. It was hard for men to believe that two languages (as it seemed to them) could be learned more easily than one, and the best way to learn to spell was first to spell wrong..."
  24. Leigh 1864, p. 6, Leigh's Plan for an Alternative to Orthography.

See also

Related Research Articles

The Deseret alphabet is a phonemic English-language spelling reform developed between 1847 and 1854 by the board of regents of the University of Deseret under the leadership of Brigham Young, the second president of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. George D. Watt is reported to have been the most actively involved in the development of the script's novel characters, which were used to replace those of Isaac Pitman's English phonotypic alphabet. He was also the "New Alphabet's" first serious user. The script gets its name from the word deseret, a hapax legomenon in the Book of Mormon, which is said to mean "honeybee" in the only verse it is used in.

English orthography comprises the set of rules used when writing the English language, allowing readers and writers to associate written graphemes with the sounds of spoken English, as well as other features of the language. English's orthography includes norms for spelling, hyphenation, capitalisation, word breaks, emphasis, and punctuation.

An orthography is a set of conventions for writing a language, including norms of spelling, punctuation, word boundaries, capitalization, hyphenation, and emphasis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shavian alphabet</span> Phonemic alphabet proposed for English spelling

The Shavian alphabet is a constructed alphabet conceived as a way to provide simple, phonemic orthography for the English language to replace the inefficiencies and difficulties of conventional spelling using the Latin alphabet. It was posthumously funded by and named after Irish playwright George Bernard Shaw and designed by Ronald Kingsley Read.

A spelling reform is a deliberate, often authoritatively sanctioned or mandated change to spelling rules. Proposals for such reform are fairly common, and over the years, many languages have undergone such reforms. Recent high-profile examples are the German orthography reform of 1996 and the on-off Portuguese spelling reform of 1990, which is still being ratified.

The Initial Teaching Alphabet is a variant of the Latin alphabet developed by Sir James Pitman in the early 1960s. It was not intended to be a strictly phonetic transcription of English sounds, or a spelling reform for English as such, but instead a practical simplified writing system which could be used to teach English-speaking children to read more easily than can be done with traditional orthography. After children had learned to read using I.T.A., they would then eventually move on to learn standard English spelling. Although it achieved a certain degree of popularity in the 1960s, it has fallen out of use since the 1970s.

Spelling is a set of conventions for written language regarding how graphemes should correspond to the sounds of spoken language. Spelling is one of the elements of orthography, and highly standardized spelling is a prescriptive element.

Phonetic transcription is the visual representation of speech sounds by means of symbols. The most common type of phonetic transcription uses a phonetic alphabet, such as the International Phonetic Alphabet.

A phonemic orthography is an orthography in which the graphemes correspond consistently to the language's phonemes, or more generally to the language's diaphonemes. Natural languages rarely have perfectly phonemic orthographies; a high degree of grapheme–phoneme correspondence can be expected in orthographies based on alphabetic writing systems, but they differ in how complete this correspondence is. English orthography, for example, is alphabetic but highly nonphonemic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alexander John Ellis</span> English mathematician, philologist and phonetician (1814–1890)

Alexander John Ellis was an English mathematician, philologist and early phonetician who also influenced the field of musicology. He changed his name from his father's name, Sharpe, to his mother's maiden name, Ellis, in 1825 as a condition of receiving significant financial support from a relative on his mother's side. He is buried in Kensal Green Cemetery, London.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Russian orthography</span>

Russian orthography is an orthographic tradition formally considered to encompass spelling and punctuation. Russian spelling, which is mostly phonemic in practice, is a mix of morphological and phonetic principles, with a few etymological or historic forms, and occasional grammatical differentiation. The punctuation, originally based on Byzantine Greek, was in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries reformulated on the models of French and German orthography.

For centuries, there have been movements to reform the spelling of the English language. Such spelling reform seeks to change English orthography so that it is more consistent, matches pronunciation better, and follows the alphabetic principle. Common motives for spelling reform include making learning quicker, making learning cheaper, and making English more useful as an international auxiliary language.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Pitman</span> British businessman, civil servant, publisher, politician & spelling reformer

Sir Isaac James Pitman (known as James), KBE (14 August 1901 – 1 September 1985) was a publisher, senior civil servant, politician, and prominent educationalist with a lifelong passion for etymology, orthography, and pedagogy. He is best known for his attempt to improve children's literacy in the English-speaking world by means of an interim teaching orthography, known as the initial teaching alphabet or i.t.a. He was honoured with a knighthood in 1961 for his life accomplishments.

Inventive spelling is the use of unconventional spellings of words.

A pronunciation respelling for English is a notation used to convey the pronunciation of words in the English language, which do not have a phonemic orthography.

Interspel, or International English Spelling, is a set of principles introduced by Valerie Yule that aims to address the unpredictability and inconsistency of present English spelling, while preserving its heritage of print through minimal changes in appearance.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">SoundSpel</span> English spelling reform proposal

SoundSpel is a regular and mostly phonemic English-language spelling reform proposal. It uses a 26-letter alphabet that is fully compatible with QWERTY keyboards. Though SoundSpel was originally based on American English, it can represent dialectal pronunciation, including British English. With roots extending as far back as 1910 but largely complete by 1986, SoundSpel was developed "in response to the widely held conviction that English spelling is more complex than it needs to be." The American Literacy Council has endorsed the reform because anglophones can easily read it. Additionally, according to its proponents, "[SoundSpel] is fully compatible with traditional spelling and can be mixed with it in any proportion desired."

<i>The Phonetic Journal</i>

The Phonetic Journal was the official journal of The Phonetic Society based at the Kingston Buildings in Bath, Somerset, England and is the first ever journal about phonetics. It was published subtitled as Published Weekly, Devoted to the Propagation of Phonetic Shorthand, and Phonetic Reading, Writing and Printing.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Downing (educational psychologist)</span> British Educational Psychologist practiced from 1960 until 1987

John Downing (1922–1987) was a British educational psychologist who started his career as a teacher then worked as an academic from 1960 until his death in 1987. He published over 300 academic papers in his 27-year academic career, specialising in both how children read and how they learn to read. His three main fields of study were the initial teaching alphabet, the psychology of reading and the comparison of reading methods across different languages and cultures. His principle works in each of these fields were Evaluating the Initial Teaching Alphabet, Reading & Reasoning and Comparative Reading. Fundamentally, Downing was an educational psychologist and his main lifetime achievement was the formulation of the cognitive clarity theory of learning to read.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pronouncing Orthography</span>

In 1864, Pronouncing Orthography was released as a simplified version of traditional English orthography to help children learn to read more quickly and easily; it became widely adopted by the United States public school system and incorporated into most basal reading schemes of the time. It aimed to improve literacy education by eliminating the irregularities of conventional English orthography and adhering to the alphabetic principle, wherein every letter represented a specific sound. This allowed children to read words by combining elementary sounds using phonics.

References