First International Statistical Congress

Last updated
Portrait of Adolphe Quetelet, Belgian astronomer and statistician who aided in the founding of the Congress. Adolphe Quetelet by Joseph-Arnold Demannez.jpg
Portrait of Adolphe Quetelet, Belgian astronomer and statistician who aided in the founding of the Congress.

The First International Statistical Congress was held on September 19th, 1853 in Brussels, Belgium, with twenty-six countries in attendance. [1] It was principally organised by Belgian astronomer and statistician Adolphe Quetelet, who envisioned a standardisation of European units of measurement to allow for collaborative research to be done between nations. The International Statistical Congress was therefore designed to create tentative guidelines for the process of unifying measurement in statistical research, and it was also aimed to establish leadership and regulations for future congresses. [2] Although the First Congress was followed by seven further sessions across Europe between 1853 and 1876, it was unsuccessful in its initial goals to standardise all measurements across nations, as it occurred at a time when international conferences failed to overcome national interests. [3]

Contents

Congress development

Prince Albert, husband to Queen Victoria, another instrumental figure in the founding of the Congress. (Photograph by J. J. E. Mayall, 1860) Albert, Prince Consort by JJE Mayall, 1860 crop.png
Prince Albert, husband to Queen Victoria, another instrumental figure in the founding of the Congress. (Photograph by J. J. E. Mayall, 1860)
A map of Europe's states in 1850, three years before the Congress was assembled. 1850 Mitchell Map of Europe - Geographicus - Europe-mitchell-1850.jpg
A map of Europe's states in 1850, three years before the Congress was assembled.

In 1851, Queen Victoria’s husband, Prince Albert, organised the first World’s Fair held at the Great Exhibition of London. As the World’s Fair attracted scholars from different parts of Europe, Prince Albert began the task of influencing public opinion favourably towards the standardisation of international statistics. [4] One of these scholars was the Belgian astronomer and statistician Adolphe Quetelet, who became convinced of the necessity for an international congress to unify the various methods of statistical measurement across different nations. Upon his return to Brussels, Quetelet wrote to Prince Albert expressing his desire to collaborate in the creation of an international statistical congress. Aided by members of the Belgian Statistical Commission, Quetelet and Prince Albert agreed to work together to create the First International Statistical Congress in Brussels. [5]

The purpose of the International Statistical Congress went beyond simply standardising units of measurement throughout Europe. The founders believed that a common means of measuring, to use the same units to represent the same results, was necessary. It would allow for easier transfer of data between nations so that officials could interpret other states’ findings without previously converting them. [6] In doing so, this would not only create a sense of unity amongst European nations, but it would also greatly increase the efficacy of statistical-based research, allowing for bigger scientific initiatives to be taken in the hopes of improving living conditions across Europe. [7]

Attendance and roles

States in attendance

A total of twenty-six states and their leading statisticians participated in the Congress. Officially, the states represented were:

CountryFlag
Austria
Flag of the Habsburg Monarchy.svg
Baden
Flag of the Grand Duchy of Baden (1871-1891).svg
Bavaria
Flag of Bavaria (striped).svg
Belgium
Flag of Belgium.svg
Denmark
Flag of Denmark.svg
Ottoman Egypt
Flag of Egypt (1844-1867).svg
France
Flag of France.svg
Frankfurt-am-Main
Flag of the Free City of Frankfurt.svg
Great Britain
Flag of the United Kingdom.svg
Hamburg
Flag of Hamburg.svg
Hanover
Flag of Hanover 1837-1866.svg
Hesse-Kassel
Flag of Hesse.svg
Grand Duchy of Hesse
Flagge Grossherzogtum Hessen ohne Wappen.svg
Lübeck
Flag of the Free City of Lubeck.svg
The Netherlands
Flag of the Netherlands.svg
Norway
Flag of Norway.svg
Portugal
Flag of Portugal (1830).svg
Prussia
Flag of the Kingdom of Prussia (1803-1892).svg
Sardinia
Civil Flag and Civil Ensign of the Kingdom of Sardinia (1816-1848).svg
Saxony
State flag of the Saxony (1815-1952).gif
Spain
Flag of Spain (1785-1873, 1875-1931).svg
Switzerland
Flag of Switzerland.svg
Grand Duchy of Tuscany
Flag of the Grand Duchy of Tuscany (1840).svg
The Two Sicilies
Flag of the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies (1816).svg
The United States of America
Flag of the United States (1851-1858).svg
Württemberg
Flagge Konigreich Wurttemberg.svg

Administrative roles

Portrait of Ramon de la Sagra, Spanish delegate to the Congress, who was also one of its Vice-Presidents. Ramon de la sagra.jpg
Portrait of Ramón de la Sagra, Spanish delegate to the Congress, who was also one of its Vice-Presidents.

The first order of business for the Congress was to establish administrative roles. Ferdinand Piercot, Belgium's Minister of the Interior, was elected as President of the Congress; William Farr of England, Louis-René Villermé of France, Karl Friedrich Wilhelm Dieterici of then-Prussia, Carl Mittermaier of then-Baden, Jan Akersdyck of the Netherlands, Ramón de la Sagra of Spain, Karl von Czoernig of Austria, and Bertini of Sardinia were named Vice-Presidents. [8] A system of publications and operations, along with an official and regular correspondence scheme between members and nations, was devised for implementation in the Congress. The Congress proceeded to appoint one person by nation responsible for receiving and reporting new national scientific developments, and lastly, created the Bulletin of the Central Statistical Commission to publish an annual newsletter of statistical communications and documents relevant to the committee. [9]

National interests

Despite the Congress's emphasis on international collaboration, a great portion of the conference was first spent highlighting domestic statistics and measurement processes to gain a better understanding of how best to begin standardisation. Delegates in attendance spoke of the methods in which their nations compiled statistical information. [10] However, this was not without ulterior motives. Often, participating nations exerted their own interests to influence the agenda to varying degrees. For example, the Belgian commission expressed the need to focus on economic statistics for workers. [11] Vienna introduced ethnographic statistics concerning demographics and populations at the encouragement of Karl von Czoernig, the director of the Habsburg’s statistical service, who believed in the viability of international demographic analysis. [12] Furthermore, national interests directly conflicted with the gathering of statistical information. In France, statisticians were prompted to present misleading demographic statistics that would underestimate the population growth of the country as not to raise concerns among their European neighbours regarding the balance of power. [13]

Congress accomplishments

Organisations for standard measurement

The Congress first decided that if a united system of information was needed in international statistics, they would have to establish a standard template for officials across nations to follow when informing the public of various statistics. As a result, the members of the Congress concluded that it was necessary to create a certain manner of tables and statements to be implemented across Europe. Likewise, they recommended that each national government establish a Central Statistical Commission, which would be uniform throughout the continent, and ensure that the standardisation of statistics by these officials would be done according to the new measures. In addition to these Central Commissions, the Congress advised that local Commissions also be established for the purpose of overcoming any local irregularities concerning the measurement process of statistics previously overlooked. [14]

Industry and agriculture

Collaboratively, the First International Statistical Congress took into account the nature of industries throughout European nations, including agriculture, mining, manufacturing, and commercial enterprises which consisted of import and export statistics. For agriculture specifically, censuses were designed to measure what and how much was produced, what farm equipment was used, and how many workers and animals were present; these took place once every ten years in the winter, after the annual harvests to ensure availability of farmers. [15] Industrial censuses measured what kind of mechanical forces were prevalent in specific industries, such as hydraulics or steam power, as well as demographics like the number of workers, their salaries, and the quantity of goods produced. For example, mines would need to report the size and depth of the mine, as well as the methods of extraction, the good extracted, and how much was produced. The Congress agreed that in order to record the most precise information possible using these agricultural censuses, it was necessary to conduct surveys simultaneously and collect the results through local Commissions, at which point a final table could be created and used for comparison against other states. [16]

Urbanisation and education

The Congress sought to standardise certain measurements for cities and their inhabitants. In terms of demographics and population, metrics like emigration and immigration were analysed based on origin, health condition, and number of people departing from and arriving at certain nations. As well, the cause of the immigration was considered, such as political or religious reasonings. Originally, the Congress advocated that any censuses regarding immigration and emigration consist of personal details including the motive for emigration, as well as the capital which the migrant would carry with them. However, this led to conflicting discussion on the merits of asking questions that seemed to be too inquisitive, and thus the final proposed censuses avoided questions seen as overtly personal. [17] The working class was also examined from an economic angle, through their savings and expenses from food, rent, and clothing. Here, data was gathered from one family or household every ten years in the month of December. Additionally, personal information such as Indigenous status, language spoken, religion, place of birth, education level and profession, number of rooms in one’s house, and illnesses were also included in the census.

Regarding cities themselves, studies were conducted in an attempt to compare countries’ standards of public health, criminal behaviour, and property partitioning. For property, the Congress examined different states’ measurements of who inherited property and how much was inherited after death. [18]

Geography and navigation

To standardise physical terrain across nations to create uniformity, the Congress proposed a system of triangulation to measure distance for each country’s map if states were able to provide an adequate, acceptable one. If not, the accepted solution was to begin with the largest possible approximation of triangulation, and gain closer results by subdividing each triangle until the resulting map was satisfactory. This process was done immediately after following surveys of land, and was subsequently followed up by closer examinations of each nation’s soil and flora. [19]

Navigation was also a component that the Congress looked at; the participating countries agreed to keep a measure of the number of boats entering and exiting each sea, as well as the number of people and cargo aboard. It was required to do so in a manner that differentiated between classical sailboats and newer steam-powered boats. [20]

Spread of information

Traditionally, methods to transmit information at the time of the Congress included introductory letters, scientific correspondence, and face-to-face visits. However, the Congress coincided with growth of more modern methods of communication, such as telegrams. This allowed for a shift in the means of transmitting knowledge and further collaboration between nations. It was the hope that nations would use telegrams to produce quicker and more efficient communications between each other, but national interests prevailed over international cooperation, which adversely impacted the effect that telegrams had on statistical standardisation overall. [21]

Aftermath

Despite many of the major areas talked about during the First International Statistical Congress, no major progress was achieved in standardising measurement across Europe. This was partly attributed to an overall lack of cohesive communication, an inability for the Congress to gather and verify data, and a growing tension in nationalist beliefs in states. In particular, France and Germany were culprits of misrepresentation of population demographics. [22] Moreover, nationalism played a large role in the failure of standardising statistical information across Europe; domestic governments' desire to push individual agendas overcame the desire to develop international uniformity. [23]

The First Congress would give way to seven more International Statistical Congresses, which took place across Europe from 1855 to 1876.

These include:

In addition, after the eighth Congress, the Permanent Commission of the International Statistical Congress was created in 1872 to guide and facilitate cooperation on developing international statistics. They would assemble four times in the following eight years. [24] The backlash to all of these iterations of the International Statistical Congress, however, mainly centred on how all states involved were ultimately unable to accomplish anything of note. In each Congress, the agenda would often be populated with topics that were desirable to certain nations and undesirable to others. As a result, collaboration could not be achieved and the Congresses failed to progress further. [25]

See also

Further reading

The Permanent Commission of the International Statistical Congress (1872).

Second International Statistical Congress, Paris (1855)

Third International Statistical Congress, Vienna (1857)

Fourth International Statistical Congress, London (1860)

Fifth International Statistical Congress, Berlin (1863)

Sixth International Statistical Congress, Florence (1867)

Seventh International Statistical Congress, The Hague (1869)

Eighth International Statistical Congress, St. Petersburg (1872)

Bibliography

Related Research Articles

Batavi (Germanic tribe) Germanic tribe

The Batavi were an ancient Germanic tribe that lived around the modern Dutch Rhine delta in the area that the Romans called Batavia, from the second half of the first century BC to the third century AD. The name is also applied to several military units employed by the Romans that were originally raised among the Batavi. The tribal name, probably a derivation from batawjō, refers to the region's fertility, today known as the fruitbasket of the Netherlands.

Adolphe Quetelet Belgian astronomer, mathematician, and sociologist

Lambert Adolphe Jacques Quetelet FRSF or FRSE was a Belgian astronomer, mathematician, statistician and sociologist who founded and directed the Brussels Observatory and was influential in introducing statistical methods to the social sciences. His name is sometimes spelled with an accent as Quételet.

Social statistics is the use of statistical measurement systems to study human behavior in a social environment. This can be accomplished through polling a group of people, evaluating a subset of data obtained about a group of people, or by observation and statistical analysis of a set of data that relates to people and their behaviors.

Norman Ravitch is a professor emeritus of history at University of California, Riverside. He has written books, as well as occasional pieces for the Rockwell Foundation and other libertarian think-tanks.

José Peirats Spanish newspaper editor (1908-1989)

José Peirats Valls (1908–1989) was a Spanish anarchist, activist, journalist and historian.

David Hand (statistician) British statistician

David John Hand is a British statistician. His research interests include multivariate statistics, classification methods, pattern recognition, computational statistics and the foundations of statistics. He has written technical books on statistics, data mining, finance, classification methods, and measuring wellbeing, as well as science popularisation books including The Improbability Principle: Why Coincidences, Miracles, and Rare Events Happen Every Day; Dark Data: Why What You Don’t Know Matters; and Statistics: A Very Short Introduction. In 1991 he launched the journal Statistics and Computing, which is now celebrating its third decade.

Thomas Graham Balfour Scottish physician

Thomas Graham Balfour was a Scottish physician noted for his work with medical statistics, and a member of Florence Nightingale's inner circle.

Édouard Ducpétiaux Belgian journalist and social reformer

Antoine Édouard Ducpétiaux was a Belgian journalist and social reformer.

The Social Bases of Nazism, 1919–1933 is a 2003 non-fiction book written by Detlef Muehlberger.

Hitler's Prisons: Legal Terror in Nazi Germany is a 2004 book by Nikolaus Wachsmann. Wachsmann is a modern European history professor. In his book, he argues how the Nazi judiciary played a key role in Nazi terror. There were harsh punishments that came with prison systems by enforcing Nazi racial policies of Jews, homosexuals and Jehovah's Witnesses. Wachsmann visualized how law enforcements created an unhealthy obsession with the Nazi and terror acts in Germany before and during World War II. Each chapter is dedicated towards a specific topic relating to political and prisoner terror. The author operated his book by aluminizing the bureaucratic and institutional history of prisons and the history of inmates themselves.

Cinema and the Swastika: The International Expansion of Third Reich Cinema is a 2007 book published by Palgrave Macmillan and edited by Roel Vande Winkel and David Welch.

<i>Demanding the Impossible</i>

Demanding the Impossible is a book on the history of anarchism by Peter Marshall.

International Congress of Orientalists Series of academic conferences on orientalism

The International Congress of Orientalists, initiated in Paris in 1873, was an international conference of Orientalists. The first thirteen meetings were held in Europe; the fourteenth congress was held in Algiers in 1905 and some of the subsequent conferences were also held outside Europe. Papers were primarily about philology and archaeology. The Proceedings of the Congresses were published. The work of the International Congress of Orientalists is carried on by the International Congress of Asian and North African Studies.

<i>Living Anarchism</i> 2015 biography of José Peirats by Chris Ealham

Living Anarchism: José Peirats and the Spanish Anarcho-Syndicalist Movement is a biography of Spanish anarcho-syndicalist and historian of anarchism José Peirats written by Chris Ealham and published by AK Press in 2015. It was subsequently published in Spanish as Vivir la anarquía, vivir la utopía (2016).

Sulphur Crisis of 1840 Conflict between Sicily and the United Kingdom

The Sulphur Crisis of 1840 was a conflict between the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies and the United Kingdom. In the 19th century, the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies maintained a large sulphur mining industry and was responsible for most of the world's production. In industrialising, British demand for sulphur increased considerably. The nation had a very favourable treaty with the Two Sicilies, negotiated in 1816. The Sulphur Crisis of 1840 occurred when King Ferdinand II gave a monopoly of the sulphur industry to a French firm. The British argued it violated the 1816 trade agreement. A peaceful solution was eventually negotiated by France.

Daniel Uziel is an Israeli historian and head of photographic collections at Yad Vashem. His doctoral thesis was on the Wehrmacht propaganda corps and was accepted in 2001 by Hebrew University in Jerusalem.

Andreas Wimmer is a Swiss sociologist who is the Lieber Professor of Sociology and Political Philosophy at Columbia University. He has a PhD in social anthropology from the University of Zurich.

Free Women of Spain: Anarchism and the Struggle for the Emancipation of Women is a 1991 book by Martha Ackelsberg on feminist practices in the Spanish anarchist movement. It is supplemented by interviews the author performed with surviving members of Mujeres Libres.

Elisa Camiscioli is an American historian specialized in immigration to and from France, sex trafficking, and race and sexual politics in modern France and its empire. In 2008, she became an associate professor of history at Binghamton University. She authored Reproducing the French Race: Immigration, Intimacy, and Embodiment in the Early Twentieth Century. Duke University Press. 2009. ISBN 978-0-8223-4565-7. Camiscioli was co-editor of the Journal of Women's History from 2015 to 2020.

Lorelle Denise Semley is an American historian of Africa specialized in modern West Africa, French imperialism, gender, and the Atlantic World. She is a professor of history at the College of the Holy Cross.

References

  1. Levi, Leone (1854). "Resume of the Statistical Congress, held at Brussels, September 11th, 1853, for the Purpose of Introducing Unity in the Statistical Documents of all Countries". Journal of the Statistical Society of London. 17 (1): 1–14. doi:10.2307/2338350. ISSN   0959-5341. JSTOR   2338350.
  2. Hayes, M. (1855). Compte rendu des travaux du congrès général de statistique. Bruxelles. hdl:2027/mdp.39015058579163.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: date and year (link)
  3. Randeraad, Nico (2011-01-01). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.
  4. Willcox, Walter F. (1949). "Development of International Statistics". The Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly. 27 (2): 143–153. doi:10.2307/3348163. ISSN   0026-3745. JSTOR   3348163. PMID   18127264.
  5. Willcox, Walter F. (1949). "Development of International Statistics". The Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly. 27 (2): 143–153. doi:10.2307/3348163. ISSN   0026-3745. JSTOR   3348163. PMID   18127264.
  6. Hayes, M. (1855). Compte rendu des travaux du congrès général de statistique. Bruxelles. hdl:2027/mdp.39015058579163.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: date and year (link)
  7. Randeraad, Nico (2011-01-01). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.
  8. Brown, Samuel (1855). "Report of the Proceedings at the Statistical Congress, held at Brussels, 19th to 22nd September, 1853 (Concluded)". The Assurance Magazine, and Journal of the Institute of Actuaries. 5 (1): 25–45. doi:10.1017/S204616580005019X. JSTOR   41134642.
  9. Quetelet, Adolphe (1873). Congrès International de Statistique: sessions de Bruxelles (1853), Paris (1855), Vienne (1857), Londres (1860), Berlin (1863), Florence (1867), La Haye (1869) et St. Pétersbourg (1872) (in French). Hayez.
  10. Brown, Samuel (1855). "Report of the Proceedings at the Statistical Congress, held at Brussels, 19th to 22nd September, 1853 (Concluded)". The Assurance Magazine, and Journal of the Institute of Actuaries. 5 (1): 25–45. doi:10.1017/S204616580005019X. JSTOR   41134642.
  11. Randeraad, Nico (2011). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.
  12. Randeraad, Nico (2011). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.
  13. Randeraad, Nico (2011-01-01). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.
  14. Brown, Samuel (1855). "Report of the Proceedings at the Statistical Congress, held at Brussels, 19th to 22nd September, 1853 (Concluded)". The Assurance Magazine, and Journal of the Institute of Actuaries. 5 (1): 39. JSTOR   41134642.
  15. Brown, Samuel (1855). "Report of the Proceedings at the Statistical Congress, held at Brussels, 19th to 22nd September, 1853 (Concluded)". The Assurance Magazine, and Journal of the Institute of Actuaries. 5 (1): 25–45. doi:10.1017/S204616580005019X. ISSN   2046-1658. JSTOR   41134642.
  16. Brown, Samuel (1855). "Report of the Proceedings at the Statistical Congress, held at Brussels, 19th to 22nd September, 1853 (Concluded)". The Assurance Magazine, and Journal of the Institute of Actuaries. 5 (1): 41–42. JSTOR   41134642.
  17. Brown, Samuel (1855). "Report of the Proceedings at the Statistical Congress, held at Brussels, 19th to 22nd September, 1853 (Concluded)". The Assurance Magazine, and Journal of the Institute of Actuaries. 5 (1): 41. JSTOR   41134642.
  18. Hayes, M. (1855). Compte rendu des travaux du Congrès général de statistique.
  19. Quetelet, Adolphe (1873). Congrès International de Statistique: sessions de Bruxelles (1853), Paris (1855), Vienne (1857), Londres (1860), Berlin (1863), Florence (1867), La Haye (1869) et St. Pétersbourg (1872) (in French).
  20. Hayes, M. (1855). Compte rendu des travaux du Congrès général de statistique.
  21. Randeraad, Nico (2011-01-01). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.
  22. Randeraad, Nico (2011-01-01). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.
  23. Randeraad, Nico (2011-01-01). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.
  24. Willcox, Walter F. (1949). "Development of International Statistics". The Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly. 27 (2): 143–153. doi:10.2307/3348163. JSTOR   3348163. PMID   18127264.
  25. Randeraad, Nico (2011). "The International Statistical Congress (1853—1876): Knowledge Transfers and their Limits" (PDF). European History Quarterly. 41 (1): 50–65. doi:10.1177/0265691410385759. ISSN   0265-6914. S2CID   143541643.