First Monday in October (film)

Last updated
First Monday in October
First-monday-in-october-movie-poster-1981.jpg
Directed by Ronald Neame
Screenplay by Jerome Lawrence
Robert Edwin Lee
Based on First Monday in October
by Jerome Lawrence and Robert Edwin Lee
Produced byPaul M. Heller
Martha Scott
Starring Walter Matthau
Jill Clayburgh
Barnard Hughes
Music by Ian Fraser
Distributed by Paramount Pictures
Release date
  • August 21, 1981 (1981-08-21)
Running time
98 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Box office$12,480,249 [1]

First Monday in October is a 1981 American comedy-drama film from Paramount Pictures, produced by Paul M. Heller and Martha Scott, directed by Ronald Neame, that is based on the 1978 play of the same name by Jerome Lawrence and Robert Edwin Lee. The film stars Walter Matthau (for which he was nominated for a Golden Globe Award for Best Actor – Motion Picture Musical or Comedy) and Jill Clayburgh (for which she was nominated for a Golden Globe Award for Best Actress – Motion Picture Musical or Comedy). The cast also co-stars Jan Sterling in her final feature film role.

Contents

Paramount Pictures originally scheduled First Monday in October for release in February 1982, but President Ronald Reagan's nomination of Sandra Day O'Connor as the first female Supreme Court justice on July 7, 1981, forced the film's release a month after her nomination, in August 1981.

The film's title refers to the day that the Supreme Court commences its annual term, which continues until June or early July of the following year.

Plot

The death of Stanley Moorehead, Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court, has created a vacancy on the high court. The President's appointee turns out to be Ruth Loomis, a staunch conservative from Orange County, California, who is confirmed as the first female Associate Justice.

She and Associate Justice Daniel Snow, a committed liberal who is many years older than Loomis and with many years on the Supreme Court, clash intellectually on just about every judicial issue before them. One case involves a pornographic film and involves arguments about freedom of speech.

Another is a lawsuit, sent up from the lower court, brought by a company's stockholders regarding the suppression of a possibly revolutionary new power source, a momentum engine. The patent is controlled by the board of directors of Omnitech International, and its CEO Donald Richards, who has not been seen in public for a decade and is unavailable by subpoena.

Over time, the two judges begin to like and respect each other. While he and Loomis are debating the complexities of the momentum engine/Omnitech case after hours in the empty courthouse, Snow suffers a possible "heart episode" and goes to the hospital. Loomis, greatly worried, visits him while he recovers.

Based on something Snow intimated during their debate, Loomis returns to California overnight. There, in a records storage center, she discovers proof that her late husband and his law firm covered up the death of their client, Donald Richards. Because of her former association with the law firm, she concludes she has a serious conflict of interest on the Omnitech case, and must now resign her Associate Justice position. When Snow hears this, he leaves the hospital abruptly and after more debate, talks her out of resigning. They travel by taxi to the Supreme Court to announce her discovery and attend the next conference, one that will no doubt excite the Omnitech case and get it on the docket for the high court to review.

Cast

Critical response

New York Times critic Janet Maslin opened her review of the film with two questions: “What if the latest Supreme Court Justice were a woman? And what if that woman were a terrible pill?” concisely summarizing her problems with the film, which she felt clearly showed signs of having been rushed to market. She praised Matthau's performance and found fault with the character of Justice Ruth Loomis but pointed to the screenplay as “the main source of difficulty. The authors' idea is to confront a crotchety liberal Justice, Dan Snow, with the sprightly, more conservative Ruth Loomis, and let the sparks fly. However, Mr. Lawrence and Mr. Lee have a way of mistaking hectoring, nagging and all-out nastiness for the stuff of which sparks are made.” Director Ronald Neame came under fire for a variety of errors, including a scene set in August with snow and slush and the discordant casting of The Paper Chase star James Stephens in a role very similar to his character in the television series. [2] Gene Siskel of the Chicago Tribune believed that Matthau and Clayburgh were miscast and said that the film "says little about the law, and [...] even less about the high court. Unless you care that there may be spittoons under each justice's desk." [3] Bruce Blackader of The Toronto Star believed its box office could benefit from the timing, much like that of The China Syndrome , but said that "there’s nothing truly memorable about First Monday In October (the title refers to the day when the court opens its sessions); it's only serviceably directed by Ronald Neame; and the ending is curiously weak and anti-climactic." [4] Joe Pollock of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch wrote that "the comedy is light and entertaining, though it falls short of greatness for a number of reasons. Basically, Clayburgh is too young, Walter Matthau is too much of a comic and the plot line is too pat, too easy.- Even with those shortcoming, however, the film works pretty well and provides a good number of laugh lines." [5] Robert C. Trussell of The Kansas City Star called it "a hit-and-miss film that hangs its uneven mix of political commentary, romance, comedy and drama on the timely premise of the first appointment of a woman to the US Supreme Court." [6] Michael Blowen of The Boston Globe commented that "Walter Matihau spends the entire movie looking as if he's looking for Jack Lemmon, Jill Clayburgh spends the entire movie looking as if she's looking for Burt Reynolds, and the viewer spends the entire movie looking as if he's looking for the nearest exit." [7]

Jack Mathews of the Detroit Free Press observed:

"First Monday in October" was scheduled to open somewhere around the first Monday of October, but since Ronald Reagan beat Paramount Pictures to the punch by nominating Sandra Day O'Connor as the country's first female Supreme Court justice, the studio figured it had better trot out its nominee—Jill Clayburgh—as soon as possible.

The movie does not seem to benefit from the marketing decision, and certainly not from current events. Seeing Clayburgh in the role so soon after the introduction of O'Connor merely underscores the absurdity of casting a young leading lady in the role of a person who,' by all that is judicial necessity, would be well into middle age.

Even Walter Matthau, as the ascorbic, liberal Justice Dan Snow, who is at odds with conservative Justice Ruth Loomis ("Tim Mother Superior of Orange County," he calls her), looks too young for a part that was played onstage by Melvyn Douglas and then by Henry Fonda. That may be taking too seriously a movie intended as repartee comedy and not social drama, but the humor's success is dependent entirely on the believability of the dueling justices. [8]

Edwin Howard of the Memphis Press-Scimitar criticized Matthau's performance and the script dynamics while noting that it "seems certain to split the court of public opinion". [9] Thomas Fox of The Commercial Appeal called the film "very lightweight stuff considering the potential of its subject". [10]

One positive review, however, came from Nancy Scott of the San Francisco Examiner , who gave the film a full four-star rating and said "here we have a case of reality catching up with art—a movie about the first woman to be appointed to the US Supreme Court. Would that the real world could be as witty, as literate and as delightful as Clayburgh and Matthau. Barring a couple of lapses of taste and intention, it's a fine, civilized comedy." [11] Sue Eisenhuth of The Sun-Herald also liked the film, giving it three stars and commended "the witty script" and Matthau and Clayburgh's chemistry. [12]

Home video

First Monday in October was first released on DVD by Paramount Home Video on July 6, 2004. No Blu ray release has been announced.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jack Lemmon</span> American actor (1925–2001)

John Uhler Lemmon III was an American actor, musician, producer, director and comedian. Considered equally proficient in both dramatic and comic roles, Lemmon was known for his anxious, middle-class everyman screen persona in dramedy pictures, leading The Guardian to label him as "the most successful tragi-comedian of his age."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sandra Day O'Connor</span> American lawyer, politician and judge (1930–2023)

Sandra Day O'Connor was an American attorney, politician, and jurist who served as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1981 to 2006. O'Connor was the first woman to serve as a U.S. Supreme Court justice. A moderate conservative, O'Connor was known for her precisely researched opinions. Nominated by President Ronald Reagan, she was considered a swing vote for the Rehnquist Court and the first four months of the Roberts Court. Before O'Connor's tenure on the Court, she was an Arizona state judge and earlier an elected legislator in Arizona, serving as the first female majority leader of a state senate as the Republican leader in the Arizona Senate. Upon her nomination to the Court, O'Connor was confirmed unanimously by the United States Senate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Walter Matthau</span> American actor (1920–2000)

Walter Matthau was an American actor, comedian and film director. He won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor for his performance in the Billy Wilder film The Fortune Cookie (1966).

<i>An Unmarried Woman</i> 1978 film by Paul Mazursky

An Unmarried Woman is a 1978 American romantic comedy-drama film written and directed by Paul Mazursky and starring Jill Clayburgh, Alan Bates, Michael Murphy, and Cliff Gorman. The film was nominated for three Academy Awards: Best Picture, Best Original Screenplay, and Best Actress (Clayburgh).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ruth Bader Ginsburg</span> US Supreme Court justice from 1993 to 2020

Joan Ruth Bader Ginsburg was an American lawyer and jurist who served as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1993 until her death in 2020. She was nominated by President Bill Clinton to replace retiring justice Byron White, and at the time was viewed as a moderate consensus-builder. Ginsburg was the first Jewish woman and the second woman to serve on the Court, after Sandra Day O'Connor. During her tenure, Ginsburg authored the majority opinions in cases such as United States v. Virginia (1996), Olmstead v. L.C. (1999), Friends of the Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Environmental Services, Inc. (2000), and City of Sherrill v. Oneida Indian Nation of New York (2005). Later in her tenure, Ginsburg received attention for passionate dissents that reflected liberal views of the law. She was popularly dubbed "the Notorious R.B.G.", a moniker she later embraced.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jill Clayburgh</span> American actress (1944–2010)

Jill Clayburgh was an American actress known for her work in theater, television, and cinema. She received the Cannes Film Festival Award for Best Actress and was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Actress for her breakthrough role in Paul Mazursky's comedy drama An Unmarried Woman (1978). She also received a second consecutive Academy Award nomination for Starting Over (1979) as well as four Golden Globe nominations for her film performances.

<i>Hopscotch</i> (film) 1980 American comedy spy film

Hopscotch is a 1980 American comedy spy film, produced by Edie Landau and Ely A. Landau, directed by Ronald Neame, that stars Walter Matthau, Glenda Jackson, Sam Waterston, Ned Beatty, and Herbert Lom. The screenplay was written by Bryan Forbes and Brian Garfield, based on Garfield's 1975 novel of the same name.

<i>Silver Streak</i> (film) 1976 film directed by Arthur Hiller

Silver Streak is a 1976 American thriller comedy film, about a murder on a Los Angeles-to-Chicago train journey. It was directed by Arthur Hiller and stars Gene Wilder, Jill Clayburgh, and Richard Pryor, with Patrick McGoohan, Ned Beatty, Clifton James, Ray Walston, Scatman Crothers, and Richard Kiel in supporting roles. The film score is by Henry Mancini. This film marked the first pairing of Wilder and Pryor, who were later paired in three other films.

United States v. Paramount Pictures, Inc., 334 U.S. 131 (1948), was a landmark United States Supreme Court antitrust case that decided the fate of film studios owning their own theatres and holding exclusivity rights on which theatres would show their movies. It would also change the way Hollywood movies were produced, distributed, and exhibited. It also opened the door for more foreign and independent films to be shown in U.S. theaters. The Supreme Court affirmed the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York's ruling that the existing distribution scheme was in violation of United States antitrust law, which prohibits certain exclusive dealing arrangements.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ronald Neame</span> English film producer, director, cinematographer and screenwriter (1911–2010)

Ronald Neame CBE, BSC was an English film producer, director, cinematographer, and screenwriter. Beginning his career as a cinematographer, for his work on the British war film One of Our Aircraft Is Missing (1943) he received an Academy Award nomination for Best Special Effects. During a partnership with director David Lean, he produced Brief Encounter (1945), Great Expectations (1946), and Oliver Twist (1948), receiving two Academy Award nominations for writing.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jill Ireland</span> British actress (1936–1990)

Jill Dorothy Ireland was an English actress and singer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nina Totenberg</span> American journalist (born 1944)

Nina Totenberg is an American legal affairs correspondent for National Public Radio (NPR) focusing primarily on the activities and politics of the Supreme Court of the United States. Her reports air regularly on NPR's news magazines All Things Considered, Morning Edition, and Weekend Edition. From 1992 to 2013, she was also a panelist on the syndicated TV political commentary show Inside Washington.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jill Eikenberry</span> American actress (born 1947)

Jill Susan Eikenberry is an American film, stage, and television actress. She is known for her role as lawyer Ann Kelsey on the NBC drama L.A. Law (1986–94), for which she is a five-time Emmy Award and four-time Golden Globe Award nominee, winning the Golden Globe for Best Actress in a Drama Series in 1989. She received an Obie Award in 1986 for the Off-Broadway plays Lemon Sky and Life Under Water, and was nominated for a 2011 Drama Desk Award for the Off-Broadway musical The Kid. Her film appearances include Hide in Plain Sight (1980), Arthur (1981) and The Manhattan Project (1986).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Supreme Court of the United States in fiction</span>

Like many institutions that draw public interest, the Supreme Court of the United States has frequently been depicted in fiction, often in the form of legal drama. While early depictions of the Supreme Court in fiction tended to be reverential, over time depictions became more critical and melodramatic. In some instances, real decisions rendered by real courts are dramatized, as in Gideon's Trumpet and the seminal trial in The People vs. Larry Flynt. Other depictions are purely fictional, but center on realistic issues that come before the court. Despite the comparative dearth of material on the Supreme Court in popular culture as compared to other branches of government, such depictions are "the primary source of the public's knowledge about the legal system as a whole, including the Supreme Court".

<i>Shy People</i> 1987 film by Andrei Konchalovsky

Shy People is a 1987 American drama film directed by Andrei Konchalovsky, from a script by Konchalovsky, Marjorie David and Gérard Brach. It stars Barbara Hershey, Jill Clayburgh, and Martha Plimpton, and features music by the German electronic music group Tangerine Dream. The film is about the culture clash that takes place between Diana, a Manhattan writer, her wayward teenage daughter Grace, and their long-distant relatives in the bayous of Louisiana.

<i>First Monday in October</i> Play by Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee

First Monday in October is a 1978 play by Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee. The title refers to the day on which the United States Supreme Court traditionally convenes following its summer recess.

Dear Ruth is a successful 1944 Broadway play written by Norman Krasna. It ran for 680 performances.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Heller</span> American film producer (1927–2020)

Paul Heller was an American film producer residing in Southern California. His best known movies include Enter the Dragon, Withnail and I, My Left Foot, The Annihilation of Fish, Skin Game, Hot Potato, The Promise, The Barony, Black Belt Jones, and David and Lisa.

<i>On the Basis of Sex</i> 2018 film by Mimi Leder

On the Basis of Sex is a 2018 American biographical legal drama film based on the life and early cases of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who was the second woman to serve as an Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court. Directed by Mimi Leder and written by Daniel Stiepleman, it stars Felicity Jones as Ginsburg. Armie Hammer, Justin Theroux, Jack Reynor, Cailee Spaeny, Sam Waterston, and Kathy Bates feature in supporting roles.

Jill McKee Pohlman is an American lawyer from Utah who serves as the as a justice of the Utah Supreme Court. From 2016 to 2022, she was an associate presiding judge of the Utah Court of Appeals.

References

  1. "First Monday in October".
  2. Janet Maslin (21 August 1981). "Movie Review: First Monday in October". New York Times. Retrieved 2009-01-10.
  3. Siskel, Gene (August 21, 1981). "Matthau, Clayburgh casting doesn't do justice to 'October'". Chicago Tribune . Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  4. Blackader, Bruce (August 21, 1981). "Timing on the side of First Monday". Toronto Star . Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  5. Pollock, Joe (August 21, 1981). "The New Movies". St. Louis Post-Dispatch . Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  6. Trussell, Robert C. (August 23, 1981). "'Monday' timely but uneven". The Kansas City Star . Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  7. Blowen, Michael (August 21, 1981). "First Monday is a last resort". The Boston Globe . Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  8. Mathews, Jack (August 21, 1981). "Reagan upstages Paramount". Detroit Free Press . Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  9. Howard, Edwin (August 21, 1981). "The Front Row: 'First Monday in October' Results in a Split Court". Memphis Press-Scimitar . Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  10. Fox, Thomas (August 21, 1981). "Reality crosses 'First Monday' as benchmark". The Commercial Appeal . Memphis, Tennessee. Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  11. Scott, Nancy (August 21, 1981). "An affirmative ruling on 'First Monday'". San Francisco Examiner . Retrieved October 28, 2023.
  12. Eisenhuth, Sue (February 21, 1982). "Good laughs in a spoof of the law". The Sun-Herald . Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. Retrieved October 28, 2023.