Frank Skuse

Last updated

Frank Skuse (born ca. 1934) [1] is a British former forensic scientist for the North West Forensic Laboratories based in Chorley, Lancashire. His flawed conclusions, eventually discredited, contributed to the convictions of Judith Ward and the Birmingham Six. [2]

Contents

Others who claimed they were wrongfully convicted on Skuse's evidence include Ann Gillespie, a native of Donegal, who served almost 10 years of a 15-year sentence for conspiracy and explosive charges after a bomb exploded in a home she and her sister were visiting in Manchester. [3]

Summerland

As an employee of the Home Office North-West forensic science laboratory, Skuse helped investigate the Summerland Fire. He concluded that the fire had started in a plastic mini-golf hut. [4]

Judith Ward

Skuse used the Griess test in which the presence of NO2− (nitrite ions) is detected in a sample by formation of a red azo dye. He used the extraction solvent ether. He analysed samples from Ward using thin layer chromatography in addition to the Griess test. [5]

Birmingham Six

Skuse used the results of the Griess test to claim that Patrick Hill and William Power had handled explosives. Gas chromatography-mass spectrometry tests at a later date were negative for Power and contradicted the initial results for Hill. [5]

Skuse's 99% certainty that Power and Hill had explosives traces on their hands was fundamentally opposed by defence expert Dr Hugh Kenneth Black FRIC (ex HM Chief Inspector of Explosives, Home Office). Skuse's evidence and testimony were preferred by The Hon. Mr Justice Bridge, the trial judge. [6]

Questions of competence

In 1981 and 1982 line managers at Chorley forensic science laboratory referred to a deterioration in the performance of Skuse and in January 1983 he was removed from reporting cases to court. [7]

In October 1985 a World in Action documentary In The Interests of Justice concluded the real Birmingham pub bombers had gone free. [8] Days after the TV programme, the Home Office retired Skuse, [9] aged 51, from the Civil Service on the grounds of "limited effectiveness". [1]

Throughout the following year 350 of Skuse's cases, dating back to 1966, were re-examined by the Laboratory Director. [7] On 1 December 1986, another "World in Action" documentary: A Surprise Witness made public the doubts about Skuse's methods. [7] [10] Skuse was subsequently portrayed by actor David Ryall in the 1990 docudrama Who Bombed Birmingham? [11]

Appeals

Birmingham Six appeal

In 1991 The Court of Appeal stated that the Griess test should only be used as a gateway or preliminary test and that:

Dr Skuse's conclusion was wrong, and demonstrably wrong, judged even by the state of forensic science in 1974. [12]

Caustic soda is used to break down the molecule of nitroglycerine to produce nitrite ions. The concentration is crucial to the test. If Skuse had used a dilute solution as he claimed, the test would react positive only on hands dripping with nitroglycerine, [13] which was an absurdity. [14] A stronger solution would react positive to any number of chemicals. Contaminants suggested included laboratory detergents used to wash the test containers and some soaps and lacquers, as well as the nitrocellulose polymer used on playing cards. [15]

Judith Ward appeal

In 1993 The Court of Appeal stated: [16]

there is...impressive...expert opinion...that Dr Skuse's tests...were of no value in establishing contact between the appellant and...explosives...

Scientific evidence showed that the samples taken by Skuse were 57 hours after the last bomb, and as such there could be no suggestion of explosives on Ward's hands. [5] Skuse relied on one TLC test spot which was not pink, causing the judges to question his handling of the Griess test as well.[ citation needed ]

Libel

The successful appeals ended sub judice issues. In March 1993, Skuse, wishing to prove he had not negligently misrepresented to the court, won an appeal allowing him to sue Granada TV for libel over the World in Action programmes. The action was partly funded by Sir James Goldsmith. [17] [18] he sued Granada using the defence that it was possible for someone to be wrong without being negligent. [19]

The libel action was dropped in October 1994 following attempts by scientists on both sides to reproduce the tests Skuse carried out. No damages or costs were awarded. Ian McBride, producer of the 1985 programme, stated "We stand by our programme". [17] His total legal bill was estimated at £290,000 [20] In May 1995 his solicitor, Peter Carter-Ruck, commenced proceedings for £130,000 in unpaid fees. [21]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Smiling Buddha</span> Indias first successful nuclear weapons test (1974)

Operation Smiling Buddha or Operation Happy Krishna was the assigned code name of India's first successful nuclear bomb test on 18 May 1974. The bomb was detonated on the army base Pokhran Test Range (PTR), in Rajasthan, by the Indian Army under the supervision of several key Indian generals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trinity (nuclear test)</span> First detonation of a nuclear weapon

Trinity was the code name of the first detonation of a nuclear weapon, conducted by the United States Army at 5:29 a.m. MWT on July 16, 1945, as part of the Manhattan Project. The test was of an implosion-design plutonium bomb, nicknamed the "gadget", of the same design as the Fat Man bomb later detonated over Nagasaki, Japan, on August 9, 1945. Concerns about whether the complex Fat Man design would work led to a decision to conduct the first nuclear test. The code name "Trinity" was assigned by J. Robert Oppenheimer, the director of the Los Alamos Laboratory, inspired by the poetry of John Donne.

The defence of property is a common method of justification used by defendants who argue that they should not be held liable for any loss and injury that they have caused because they were acting to protect their property.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Birmingham Six</span> Irishmen falsely convicted for the Birmingham pub bombings

The Birmingham Six were six Irishmen who were each sentenced to life imprisonment in 1975 following their false convictions for the 1974 Birmingham pub bombings. Their convictions were declared unsafe and unsatisfactory and quashed by the Court of Appeal on 14 March 1991. The six men were later awarded financial compensation ranging from £840,000 to £1.2 million.

The nitrite ion has the chemical formula NO−
2. Nitrite is widely used throughout chemical and pharmaceutical industries. The nitrite anion is a pervasive intermediate in the nitrogen cycle in nature. The name nitrite also refers to organic compounds having the –ONO group, which are esters of nitrous acid.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Birmingham pub bombings</span> 1974 IRA attack in England

The Birmingham pub bombings were carried out on 21 November 1974, when bombs exploded in two public houses in Birmingham, England, killing 21 people and injuring 182 others.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gerry Conlon</span> Irishman wrongly convicted of terrorism

GerardPatrick "Gerry" Conlon was an Irish man known for being one of the Guildford Four who spent 15 years in prison after being wrongly convicted of being a Provisional IRA bomber.

The West Midlands Serious Crime Squad was a police unit in the English West Midlands which operated from 1974 to 1989. It was disbanded after an investigation into allegations of incompetence and abuse of power on the part of some of the squad's members. Some of this misconduct resulted in wrongful convictions, including the high-profile case of the Birmingham Six. The sister Regional Crime Squad based at Bilston was responsible for the investigation of the Bridgewater Four.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">M62 coach bombing</span> 1974 IRA attack in northern England

The M62 coach bombing, sometimes referred to as the M62 Massacre, occurred on 4 February 1974 on the M62 motorway in northern England, when a 25-pound (11 kg) Provisional Irish Republican Army (IRA) bomb hidden inside the luggage locker of a coach carrying off-duty British Armed Forces personnel and their family members exploded, killing twelve people and injuring thirty-eight others aboard the vehicle.

The Griess test is an analytical chemistry test which detects the presence of nitrite ion in solution. One of its most important uses is the determination of nitrite in drinking water. The Griess diazotization reaction, on which the Griess reagent relies, was first described in 1858 by Peter Griess. The test has also been widely used for the detection of nitrates, which are a common component of explosives, as they can be reduced to nitrites and detected with the Griess test.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Forensic Science Service</span> UK government agency

The Forensic Science Service (FSS) was a government-owned company in the United Kingdom which provided forensic science services to the police forces and government agencies of England and Wales, as well as other countries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gunshot residue</span> Particles expelled from the muzzle of a gun

Gunshot residue (GSR), also known as cartridge discharge residue (CDR), gunfire residue (GFR), or firearm discharge residue (FDR), consists of all of the particles that are expelled from the muzzle of a gun following the discharge of a bullet. It is principally composed of burnt and unburnt particles from the explosive primer, the propellant (gunpowder), and vaporized lead. The act of firing a bullet incites a very violent explosive reaction that is contained within the barrel of the gun, which can cause the bullet, the barrel, or the cartridge to become chipped. Meaning gunshot residue may also included metal fragments from the cartridge casing, the bullets jacket, as well as any other dirt or residue contained within the barrel that could have become dislodged.

In criminal law and in the law of tort, recklessness may be defined as the state of mind where a person deliberately and unjustifiably pursues a course of action while consciously disregarding any risks flowing from such action. Recklessness is less culpable than malice, but is more blameworthy than carelessness.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fort Halstead</span>

Fort Halstead was a research site of the Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl), an executive agency of the UK Ministry of Defence. It is situated on the crest of the Kentish North Downs, overlooking the town of Sevenoaks, southeast of London. Originally constructed in 1892 as part of a ring of fortresses around London, Fort Halstead was to be staffed by volunteers in the event of a crisis.

Frederick Salem Zain was an American forensic laboratory technician in West Virginia and Bexar County, Texas, who falsified serology results to obtain convictions.

Godfrey Alexander Oldfield, known as George Oldfield, was a British police detective who finished his career as an Assistant Chief Constable with West Yorkshire Police. He is known for leading inquiries by the force into major crimes, including the M62 coach bombing and the 'Yorkshire Ripper' series of murders; the latter inquiry put great strain on his health. In recent years Oldfield's reputation has come under scrutiny, particularly concerning his two major cases, and has resulted in allegations of corruption and incompetence.

Rape is a statutory offence in England and Wales. The offence is created by section 1 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003:

(1) A person (A) commits an offence if—

(2) Whether a belief is reasonable is to be determined having regard to all the circumstances, including any steps A has taken to ascertain whether B consents.
(3) Sections 75 and 76 apply to an offence under this section.

(4) A person guilty of an offence under this section is liable, on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for life.

The Liebermann reagent named after Hungarian chemist Leo Liebermann (1852-1926) is used as a simple spot-test to presumptively identify alkaloids as well as other compounds. It is composed of a mixture of potassium nitrite and concentrated sulfuric acid. 1 g of potassium nitrite is used for every 10 mL of sulfuric acid. Potassium nitrite may also be substituted by sodium nitrite. It is used to test for cocaine, morphine, PMA and PMMA.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lorne Elias</span> Canadian chemist, inventor

Lorne Elias is a Canadian chemist, inventor, and a pioneer in explosives detection technology. He invented the explosives vapour detector, EVD-1, a portable bomb detection instrument deployed at international airports in Canada in the 1980s. He contributed to the field of explosives detection for over three decades, and is called the father of vapour and trace explosives detection technology.

References

  1. 1 2 HC Deb 12 June 1990 vol 174 cc261-70, api.parliament.uk, 12 June 1990.
  2. ↑ The Birmingham Framework – Six Innocent Men Framed for the Birmingham Bombings by Fr Denis Faul and Fr Raymond Murray (1976).
  3. ↑ "I don't want English pardon", The Sunday Times , 27 November 2005.
  4. ↑ The Guardian, Clear advice on Oroglas from America, 21 November 1973.
  5. 1 2 3 Schurr, Beverley (1993). "Expert Witnesses And The Duties Of Disclosure & Impartiality: The Lessons Of The IRA Cases In England" (PDF). NetK.net.au. NSW Legal Aid Commission. Retrieved 2019-07-05.
  6. ↑ R v McIlkenney (1991) 93 Cr.App.R. 287.
  7. 1 2 3 HC Deb 17 March 1988 vol 129 cc1209-10, api.parliament.uk; accessed 6 April 2017.
  8. ↑ World in Action: In The Interests of Justice (1985), bfi.org.uk; accessed 6 April 2017.
  9. ↑ New Scientist , 16 February 1991.
  10. ↑ University of Hull Catalog] DMU/1 Birmingham Six Case Papers; accessed 28 August 2017.
  11. ↑ ITN Source Archived 19 October 2013 at the Wayback Machine
  12. ↑ R v McIlkenney (1991) 93 Cr.App.R. 53-54.
  13. ↑ R v McIlkenney (1991) 93 Cr.App.R. 297.
  14. ↑ R v McIlkenney (1991) 93 Cr.App.R. 298.
  15. ↑ Mullin, Chris (1990). Error of Judgement (3rd ed.). Poolbeg. pp. 168–169. ISBN   1-85371-090-3.
  16. ↑ R v Ward (1993) 96 Cr.App.R. 1.
  17. 1 2 "Pub blasts scientist drops libel action", The Independent; 18 October 1994.
  18. ↑ "Skuse wins right to sue", The Times, 31 March 1993.
  19. ↑ "Birmingham Six scientist says he has new evidence", The Times, 5 October 1994.
  20. ↑ It could be you: a sure-fire way to lose a million, Times Higher Education, 24 March 2000.
  21. ↑ "Scientist sued", The Independent, 27 May 1995.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.