Freshman's dream

Last updated April 12, 2024

The freshman's dream is a name given to the erroneous equation $(x+y)^{n}=x^{n}+y^{n}$ , where $n$ is a real number (usually a positive integer greater than 1) and $x,y$ are non-zero real numbers. Beginning students commonly make this error in computing the power of a sum of real numbers, falsely assuming powers distribute over sums.^[1]^[2] When n = 2, it is easy to see why this is incorrect: (x + y)² can be correctly computed as x² + 2xy + y² using distributivity (commonly known by students in the United States as the FOIL method). For larger positive integer values of n, the correct result is given by the binomial theorem.

The name "freshman's dream" also sometimes refers to the theorem that says that for a prime number p, if x and y are members of a commutative ring of characteristic p, then (x + y)^p = x^p + y^p. In this more exotic type of arithmetic, the "mistake" actually gives the correct result, since p divides all the binomial coefficients apart from the first and the last, making all the intermediate terms equal to zero.

The identity is also actually true in the context of tropical geometry, where multiplication is replaced with addition, and addition is replaced with minimum.^[3]

Examples

$(1+4)^{2}=5^{2}=25$ , but $1^{2}+4^{2}=17$ .
${\sqrt {x^{2}+y^{2}}}$ does not equal ${\sqrt {x^{2}}}+{\sqrt {y^{2}}}=|x|+|y|$ . For example, ${\sqrt {9+16}}={\sqrt {25}}=5$ , which does not equal 3 + 4 = 7. In this example, the error is being committed with the exponent n = 1/2.

Prime characteristic

When $p$ is a prime number and $x$ and $y$ are members of a commutative ring of characteristic $p$ , then $(x+y)^{p}=x^{p}+y^{p}$ . This can be seen by examining the prime factors of the binomial coefficients: the nth binomial coefficient is

{\binom {p}{n}}={\frac {p!}{n!(p-n)!}}.

The numerator is p factorial(!), which is divisible by p. However, when 0 < n < p, both n! and (p−n)! are coprime with p since all the factors are less than p and p is prime. Since a binomial coefficient is always an integer, the nth binomial coefficient is divisible by p and hence equal to 0 in the ring. We are left with the zeroth and pth coefficients, which both equal 1, yielding the desired equation.

Thus in characteristic p the freshman's dream is a valid identity. This result demonstrates that exponentiation by p produces an endomorphism, known as the Frobenius endomorphism of the ring.

The demand that the characteristic p be a prime number is central to the truth of the freshman's dream. A related theorem states that if p is prime then (x + 1)^p ≡ x^p + 1 in the polynomial ring $\mathbb {Z} _{p}[x]$ . This theorem is a key fact in modern primality testing.^[4]

History and alternate names

The history of the term "freshman's dream" is somewhat unclear. In a 1940 article on modular fields, Saunders Mac Lane quotes Stephen Kleene's remark that a knowledge of (a + b)² = a² + b² in a field of characteristic 2 would corrupt freshman students of algebra. This may be the first connection between "freshman" and binomial expansion in fields of positive characteristic.^[5] Since then, authors of undergraduate algebra texts took note of the common error. The first actual attestation of the phrase "freshman's dream" seems to be in Hungerford's graduate algebra textbook (1974), where he quotes McBrien.^[6] Alternative terms include "freshman exponentiation", used in Fraleigh (1998).^[7] The term "freshman's dream" itself, in non-mathematical contexts, is recorded since the 19th century.^[8]

Since the expansion of (x + y)ⁿ is correctly given by the binomial theorem, the freshman's dream is also known as the "child's binomial theorem"^[4] or "schoolboy binomial theorem".

Related Research Articles

In elementary algebra, the binomial theorem (or binomial expansion) describes the algebraic expansion of powers of a binomial. According to the theorem, it is possible to expand the polynomial $(x + y) n$ into a sum involving terms of the form $ax b y c$ , where the exponents $b$ and $c$ are nonnegative integers with $b + c = n$ , and the coefficient $a$ of each term is a specific positive integer depending on $n$ and $b$ . For example, for $n = 4$ ,

In mathematics, a finite field or Galois field is a field that contains a finite number of elements. As with any field, a finite field is a set on which the operations of multiplication, addition, subtraction and division are defined and satisfy certain basic rules. The most common examples of finite fields are given by the integers mod $p$ when $p$ is a prime number.

In mathematics, particularly in algebra, a field extension is a pair of fields $such that the operations of K are those of L restricted to K . In this case, L is an extension field of K and K is a subfield of L . For example, under the usual notions of addition and multiplication, the complex numbers are an extension field of the real numbers; the real numbers are a subfield of the complex numbers.$

In mathematics, an integral domain is a nonzero commutative ring in which the product of any two nonzero elements is nonzero. Integral domains are generalizations of the ring of integers and provide a natural setting for studying divisibility. In an integral domain, every nonzero element a has the cancellation property, that is, if a ≠ 0, an equality ab = ac implies b = c.

In mathematics, a polynomial is a mathematical expression consisting of indeterminates and coefficients, that involves only the operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication, and positive-integer powers of variables. An example of a polynomial of a single indeterminate $x$ is $x 2 - 4 x + 7$ . An example with three indeterminates is $x 3 + 2 xyz 2 - yz + 1$ .

In algebra, a prime ideal is a subset of a ring that shares many important properties of a prime number in the ring of integers. The prime ideals for the integers are the sets that contain all the multiples of a given prime number, together with the zero ideal.

In mathematics, a principal ideal domain, or PID, is an integral domain in which every ideal is principal, i.e., can be generated by a single element. More generally, a principal ideal ring is a nonzero commutative ring whose ideals are principal, although some authors refer to PIDs as principal rings. The distinction is that a principal ideal ring may have zero divisors whereas a principal ideal domain cannot.

In mathematics, a unique factorization domain (UFD) is a ring in which a statement analogous to the fundamental theorem of arithmetic holds. Specifically, a UFD is an integral domain in which every non-zero non-unit element can be written as a product of irreducible elements, uniquely up to order and units.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Factorization</span> (Mathematical) decomposition into a product

In mathematics, factorization (or factorisation, see English spelling differences) or factoring consists of writing a number or another mathematical object as a product of several factors, usually smaller or simpler objects of the same kind. For example, $3 \times 5$ is an integer factorization of $15$ , and $(x - 2)(x + 2)$ is a polynomial factorization of $x 2 - 4$ .

In algebraic number theory, an algebraic integer is a complex number that is integral over the integers. That is, an algebraic integer is a complex root of some monic polynomial whose coefficients are integers. The set of all algebraic integers $A$ is closed under addition, subtraction and multiplication and therefore is a commutative subring of the complex numbers.

In mathematics, an irreducible polynomial is, roughly speaking, a polynomial that cannot be factored into the product of two non-constant polynomials. The property of irreducibility depends on the nature of the coefficients that are accepted for the possible factors, that is, the field to which the coefficients of the polynomial and its possible factors are supposed to belong. For example, the polynomial $x 2 - 2$ is a polynomial with integer coefficients, but, as every integer is also a real number, it is also a polynomial with real coefficients. It is irreducible if it is considered as a polynomial with integer coefficients, but it factors as $if it is considered as a polynomial with real coefficients. One says that the polynomial x 2 - 2 is irreducible over the integers but not over the reals.$

In algebra, a monic polynomial is a non-zero univariate polynomial in which the leading coefficient is equal to 1. That is to say, a monic polynomial is one that can be written as

In mathematics, especially in the field of algebra, a polynomial ring or polynomial algebra is a ring formed from the set of polynomials in one or more indeterminates with coefficients in another ring, often a field.

In mathematics, a formal group law is a formal power series behaving as if it were the product of a Lie group. They were introduced by S. Bochner. The term formal group sometimes means the same as formal group law, and sometimes means one of several generalizations. Formal groups are intermediate between Lie groups and Lie algebras. They are used in algebraic number theory and algebraic topology.

In commutative algebra and field theory, the Frobenius endomorphism is a special endomorphism of commutative rings with prime characteristic $p$ , an important class that includes finite fields. The endomorphism maps every element to its $p$ -th power. In certain contexts it is an automorphism, but this is not true in general.

In mathematics, the Lasker–Noether theorem states that every Noetherian ring is a Lasker ring, which means that every ideal can be decomposed as an intersection, called primary decomposition, of finitely many primary ideals. The theorem was first proven by Emanuel Lasker for the special case of polynomial rings and convergent power series rings, and was proven in its full generality by Emmy Noether.

In additive number theory, Fermat's theorem on sums of two squares states that an odd prime p can be expressed as:

In algebraic geometry, supersingular elliptic curves form a certain class of elliptic curves over a field of characteristic p > 0 with unusually large endomorphism rings. Elliptic curves over such fields which are not supersingular are called ordinary and these two classes of elliptic curves behave fundamentally differently in many aspects. Hasse (1936) discovered supersingular elliptic curves during his work on the Riemann hypothesis for elliptic curves by observing that positive characteristic elliptic curves could have endomorphism rings of unusually large rank 4, and Deuring (1941) developed their basic theory.

In mathematics, the degree of a polynomial is the highest of the degrees of the polynomial's monomials with non-zero coefficients. The degree of a term is the sum of the exponents of the variables that appear in it, and thus is a non-negative integer. For a univariate polynomial, the degree of the polynomial is simply the highest exponent occurring in the polynomial. The term order has been used as a synonym of degree but, nowadays, may refer to several other concepts.

In commutative algebra, an integrally closed domainA is an integral domain whose integral closure in its field of fractions is A itself. Spelled out, this means that if x is an element of the field of fractions of A that is a root of a monic polynomial with coefficients in A, then x is itself an element of A. Many well-studied domains are integrally closed, as shown by the following chain of class inclusions:

References

↑ Julio R. Bastida, Field Extensions and Galois Theory, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1984, p.8.
↑ Fraleigh, John B., A First Course in Abstract Algebra, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1993, p.453, ISBN 0-201-53467-3.
↑ Difusión DM (2018-02-23), Introduction to Tropical Algebraic Geometry (1 of 5) , retrieved 2019-06-11
1 2 A. Granville, It Is Easy To Determine Whether A Given Integer Is Prime , Bull. of the AMS, Volume 42, Number 1 (Sep. 2004), Pages 3–38.
↑ Colin R. Fletcher, Review of Selected papers on algebra, edited by Susan Montgomery, Elizabeth W. Ralston and others. Pp xv, 537. 1977. ISBN 0-88385-203-9 (Mathematical Association of America), The Mathematical Gazette, Vol. 62, No. 421 (Oct., 1978), The Mathematical Association. p. 221.
↑ Thomas W. Hungerford, Algebra, Springer, 1974, p. 121; also in Abstract Algebra: An Introduction, 2nd edition. Brooks Cole, July 12, 1996, p. 366.
↑ John B. Fraleigh, A First Course In Abstract Algebra, 6th edition, Addison-Wesley, 1998. pp. 262 and 438.
↑ Google books 1800–1900 search for "freshman's dream": Bentley's miscellany, Volume 26, p. 176, 1849

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[1] Julio R. Bastida, Field Extensions and Galois Theory, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1984, p.8.

[2] Fraleigh, John B., A First Course in Abstract Algebra, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1993, p.453, ISBN 0-201-53467-3.

[3] Difusión DM (2018-02-23), Introduction to Tropical Algebraic Geometry (1 of 5) , retrieved 2019-06-11

[Granville-4] 1 2 A. Granville, It Is Easy To Determine Whether A Given Integer Is Prime , Bull. of the AMS, Volume 42, Number 1 (Sep. 2004), Pages 3–38.

[5] Colin R. Fletcher, Review of Selected papers on algebra, edited by Susan Montgomery, Elizabeth W. Ralston and others. Pp xv, 537. 1977. ISBN 0-88385-203-9 (Mathematical Association of America), The Mathematical Gazette, Vol. 62, No. 421 (Oct., 1978), The Mathematical Association. p. 221.

[6] Thomas W. Hungerford, Algebra, Springer, 1974, p. 121; also in Abstract Algebra: An Introduction, 2nd edition. Brooks Cole, July 12, 1996, p. 366.

[7] John B. Fraleigh, A First Course In Abstract Algebra, 6th edition, Addison-Wesley, 1998. pp. 262 and 438.

[8] Google books 1800–1900 search for "freshman's dream": Bentley's miscellany, Volume 26, p. 176, 1849

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]