Garrison mentality

Last updated

The theory of garrison mentality argues that early Canadian identity was characterised by fear of an empty and hostile national landscape. It suggests that the environment's impact on the national psyche has influenced themes within Canadian literature, cinema and television. The term was first coined by literary critic Northrop Frye in the Literary History of Canada (1965), who used the metaphorical image of a garrison to illustrate that Canadians are defensive and hiding from external forces. It was then expanded upon by various other critics, including authors and academics. The garrison mentality is apparent in both older and more contemporary Canadian literature and media. The theory has received criticism and praise for its overarching premise that the natural environment has determined the qualities of a population. [1]

Contents

Overview and characteristics

Painting by Edward Walsh from 1803 to 1807, depicting the upper Canadian wilderness closing off a small village from the rest of society. Edward Walsh - Queenstown, Upper Canada on the Niagara (a.k.a. Queenston, Ontario).jpg
Painting by Edward Walsh from 1803 to 1807, depicting the upper Canadian wilderness closing off a small village from the rest of society.

The garrison mentality posits that unaccommodating external environments in Canada, whether they be physical or political, have influenced the psyche of its inhabitants to make them introspective and defensive. For example, the unknown wilderness and cold emptiness of Canada's landscape during settlement is suggested to have caused such qualities, as isolating oneself from a dangerous environment is safer than attempting to tame it. [2]

The garrison mentality is suggested to entail various characteristics, such as: [3] [4] [5]

This garrison mentality typically manifests in characters of literature and media, who exhibit any of the above characteristics. Such characters may also be influenced by their environments to a great degree. Their personalities and behaviours may be moulded by the world they inhabit. Authors and artists themselves can also use these characteristics as thematic concerns for their work.

Development

The garrison mentality was first coined by literary critic Northrop Frye in his 'Conclusion' to the Literary History of Canada (1965). He suggested that this aspect of Canadian identity was formed through the population's history and experience with vast wilderness, early settlement and growth in multiculturalism. Frye stated that travellers and merchants who resided in early Canada developed these social traits because they lived in garrisons, or isolated military communities. [3] [6] He also claimed that this national identity of cowardly protectionism has stunted the growth of Canadian literature. [7]

The theory was later expanded upon by poet D. G. Jones in the book Butterfly on Rock (1970), arguing that the garrison mentality's defensive stance against nature has shifted into a more amicable relationship since colonisation. [1] Jones also expanded upon Frye's metaphor by considering the theory from a biblical perspective, asserting that significant Canadian writers have the salvational task to break down the garrison mentality. He believes that such authors are responsible for letting nature back into not only their own lives, but the lives of their audiences. [8]

Author Margaret Atwood in Survival: A Thematic Guide to Canadian Literature (1972) also added to the development of this theory by suggesting that the Canadian insecurity surrounding survival was also a product of cultural domination from the US, not just the physical landscape. [1] These ideas were also corroborated by articles, such as from The New York Times, which implicitly acknowledged and signalled a change from Atwood's model of the garrison mentality by stating: "After decades of meekly accepting cultural domination by Americans, the people of Canada are suddenly moving on several fronts to protect and revitalize their national culture." [9] She also theorised that characters were very commonly in positions of 'victimhood' within Canadian texts. [6] Atwood agreed with Frye's evaluation that Canadian literature lacked growth and grounding, finding that this level of preoccupation with survival was unique to Canadian texts. [7]

Examples in literature

Examples in media

A worn down garage from Schitt's Creek. Its unappealing design reflects the garrison mentality, as characters are forced to spend time in and around this environment. Schitt's Creek, Bob's Garage.jpg
A worn down garage from Schitt's Creek. Its unappealing design reflects the garrison mentality, as characters are forced to spend time in and around this environment.

Criticism and praise

Criticism

One major critique of Frye and Atwood's presentation of the garrison mentality is that the theory's scope seems heavily Eurocentric. Professor William Beard from the University of Alberta has stated that “the Frye-Atwood model [of the garrison mentality is viewed] with contempt if not outright hostility” in film studies. This criticism contends that the theory is confined “to an Anglo-colonial way of thinking that puts white British conquerors in charge of everything, so blind to the regionalism and multiculturalism of the refigured national conversation”. [14] Because it centralises the experience of colonists trying to manage and navigate a foreign land, the theory has been labelled as biased to Western civilizations.

Another criticism levelled against the theory is for its foundational assumption that the environment will influence authors and artists. Literary academic Eli Mandel has argued that Frye's claim of natural land determining qualities in literature is false. Mandel conversely presented the idea that authors ‘invent’ the land themselves, using their writing to represent the Canadian landscape. [1] This critique thus attempts to undermine the theory as a whole, as the assumption that one's environment can influence their qualities is a central tenet of the garrison mentality.

It has also been critiqued for being reductive, and has been accused of simplifying complex characteristics of Canadian culture and identity. Academic Sherrie Malisch suggested that the garrison mentality is used too freely as a "shorthand for deficiencies in the Canadian national spirit... [it] appears in everything from a political rant against 'Laurentian elites' to an institutional critique of the CBC". This critique represents the garrison mentality as a popular buzzword in Canadian discourse, and calls for a refocusing of what the term was originally referring to.

Additionally, the theory has been overlooked on the grounds of being too narrow-minded, ultimately not accounting for the vast amount of creative material that Canadian writers produce. This has been argued by Canadian authors such as J. M. Frey, who wrote that the Frye-Atwood model is "hardly representative of what all of us are writing". [15]

Praise

Despite criticism, the longevity of Frye's original theory has given it "the power of a biblical authority", as academic Helen M. Buss wrote. [8] Thus, the garrison mentality has attained a privileged status of credibility because of how influential it was and still is in Canadian cultural discourse.

Similarly, it has received praise for how inextricably connected it has become with the study and consideration of Canadian culture. Canadian literary critic David Staines stated that the term 'garrison mentality' has become “part of our [the Canadian people's] critical vocabulary, indeed of our very language”. [16] By emphasising how integrated the terminology has become with Canadian vernacular, Staines esteems the concept and its accessibility.

The theory has also been heralded for its ongoing relevance to human nature and the environment, especially in regards to climate change. When viewed from the perspective of contemporary eco-criticism, the thesis can be reinterpreted to suggest that fear and retreat from climate change is both prevalent and useful in the 21st century. [16]

See also

Related Research Articles

Psychoanalytic literary criticism is literary criticism or literary theory that, in method, concept, or form, is influenced by the tradition of psychoanalysis begun by Sigmund Freud.

Feminist literary criticism is literary criticism informed by feminist theory, or more broadly, by the politics of feminism. It uses the principles and ideology of feminism to critique the language of literature. This school of thought seeks to analyze and describe the ways in which literature portrays the narrative of male domination by exploring the economic, social, political, and psychological forces embedded within literature. This way of thinking and criticizing works can be said to have changed the way literary texts are viewed and studied, as well as changing and expanding the canon of what is commonly taught. It is used a lot in Greek myths.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Literary theory</span> Systematic study of the nature of literature

Literary theory is the systematic study of the nature of literature and of the methods for literary analysis. Since the 19th century, literary scholarship includes literary theory and considerations of intellectual history, moral philosophy, social philosophy, and interdisciplinary themes relevant to how people interpret meaning. In the humanities in modern academia, the latter style of literary scholarship is an offshoot of post-structuralism. Consequently, the word theory became an umbrella term for scholarly approaches to reading texts, some of which are informed by strands of semiotics, cultural studies, philosophy of language, and continental philosophy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Literary criticism</span> Study, evaluation, and interpretation of literature

Literary criticism is the study, a genre of arts criticism, evaluation, and interpretation of literature. Modern literary criticism is often influenced by literary theory, which is the philosophical discussion of literature's goals and methods. Although the two activities are closely related, literary critics are not always, and have not always been, theorists.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Margaret Atwood</span> Canadian writer (born 1939)

Margaret Eleanor Atwood is a Canadian poet, novelist, literary critic, essayist, teacher, environmental activist, and inventor. Since 1961, she has published eighteen books of poetry, eighteen novels, eleven books of non-fiction, nine collections of short fiction, eight children's books, two graphic novels, and a number of small press editions of both poetry and fiction. Atwood has won numerous awards and honors for her writing, including two Booker Prizes, the Arthur C. Clarke Award, the Governor General's Award, the Franz Kafka Prize, Princess of Asturias Awards, and the National Book Critics and PEN Center USA Lifetime Achievement Awards. A number of her works have been adapted for film and television.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Canadian literature</span> Field of literature from Canada

Canadian literature is the literature of a multicultural country, written in languages including Canadian English, Canadian French, Indigenous languages, and many others such as Canadian Gaelic. Influences on Canadian writers are broad both geographically and historically, representing Canada's diversity in culture and region.

Herman Northrop Frye was a Canadian literary critic and literary theorist, considered one of the most influential of the 20th century.

Frankland Wilmot Davey, FRSC is a Canadian poet and scholar.

<i>Anatomy of Criticism</i> Literary criticism book by Northrop Frye

Anatomy of Criticism: Four Essays is a book by Canadian literary critic and theorist Northrop Frye that attempts to formulate an overall view of the scope, theory, principles, and techniques of literary criticism derived exclusively from literature. Frye consciously omits all specific and practical criticism, instead offering classically inspired theories of modes, symbols, myths and genres, in what he termed "an interconnected group of suggestions." The literary approach proposed by Frye in Anatomy was highly influential in the decades before deconstructivist criticism and other expressions of postmodernism came to prominence in American academia circa 1980s.

Southern Ontario Gothic is a subgenre of the Gothic novel genre and a feature of Canadian literature that comes from Southern Ontario. This region includes Toronto, Southern Ontario's major industrial cities, and the surrounding countryside. While the genre may also feature other areas of Ontario, Canada, and the world as narrative locales, this region provides the core settings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">House of Anansi Press</span> Canadian publishing company

House of Anansi Press is a Canadian publishing company, founded in 1967 by writers Dennis Lee and Dave Godfrey. The company specializes in finding and developing new Canadian writers of literary fiction, poetry, and non-fiction.

Ecocriticism is the study of literature and ecology from an interdisciplinary point of view, where literature scholars analyze texts that illustrate environmental concerns and examine the various ways literature treats the subject of nature. It was first originated by Joseph Meeker as an idea called "literary ecology" in his The Comedy of Survival: Studies in Literary Ecology (1972).

Robin Daniel Mathews was a Canadian poet, academic, and political activist against United States foreign policy.

Archetypal literary criticism is a type of analytical theory that interprets a text by focusing on recurring myths and archetypes in the narrative, symbols, images, and character types in literary works. As an acknowledged form of literary criticism, it dates back to 1934 when Classical scholar Maud Bodkin published Archetypal Patterns in Poetry.

The Garrison State is a concept first introduced in a seminal, highly influential and cited 1941 article originally published in the American Journal of Sociology by political scientist and sociologist Harold Lasswell. It was a "developmental construct" that outlined the possibility of a political-military elite composed of "specialists in violence" in a modern state. Lasswell was particularly influenced by the development of aerial warfare, especially as employed during the Second Sino-Japanese War, which he believed would lead to a "socialization of danger" throughout. His writings preceded and anticipated criminal fire-bombing campaigns in the era of the Vietnam War, including the use of Agent Orange, and beyond, as well as firebombings of Dresden, Tokyo, London, Hamburg and use of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki during World War II.

<i>Survival: A Thematic Guide to Canadian Literature</i>

Survival: A Thematic Guide to Canadian Literature is a survey of Canadian literature by Margaret Atwood, one of the best-known Canadian authors. It was first published by House of Anansi in 1972.

Linda Hutcheon, FRSC, O.C. is a Canadian academic working in the fields of literary theory and criticism, opera, and Canadian studies. She is a University Professor Emeritus in the Department of English and of the Centre for Comparative Literature at the University of Toronto, where she has taught since 1988. In 2000 she was elected the 117th President of the Modern Language Association, the third Canadian to hold this position, and the first Canadian woman. She is particularly known for her influential theories of postmodernism.

Wacousta is a novel by John Richardson. It was first published in December 1832 by Thomas Cadell in London and William Blackwood in Edinburgh. Wacousta is sometimes claimed as the first Canadian novel, although in fact it is preceded by Julia Catherine Beckwith's St. Ursula's Convent; or, The Nun of Canada. Wacousta is better categorized as the first attempt by a Canadian-born author at historical fiction.

<i>The Bush Garden</i>

The Bush Garden: Essays on the Canadian Imagination is a collection of essays by Canadian literary critic Northrop Frye (1912–1991). The collection was originally published in 1971; it was republished, with an introduction by Canadian postmodern theorist Linda Hutcheon, in 1995. The Bush Garden features analyses of Canadian poetry, prose fiction and painting. According to Frye's introduction, the essays were selected to provide a composite view of the Canadian imagination, an understanding of the human imagination's reaction to and development in response to the Canadian environment.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 "Literature in English: Theory and Criticism | The Canadian Encyclopedia". www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca. Retrieved 2022-03-21.
  2. The Reception of Northrop Frye. University of Toronto Press. 2021. doi:10.3138/j.ctv1x6778z. ISBN   978-1-4875-0820-3.
  3. 1 2 3 Haripriya, R (2020). "An Overview of Garrison Mentality and Applicability of Theme In Literature" (PDF). Journal of Interdisciplinary Cycle Research. 1: 879–884.
  4. Noel-Bentley, Peter C. (1970). "Our Garrison Mentality". Mosaic: A Journal for the Interdisciplinary Study of Literature. 4 (1): 127–133. ISSN   0027-1276.
  5. 1 2 Lieblein, Josh (2018-11-12). "The Garrison Mentality: More Than Meets The Eye". Liberty Island. Retrieved 2022-04-29.
  6. 1 2 3 Templin, Charlotte (2011-01-01). "Americans Read Margaret Atwood's Surfacing:Literary Criticism and Cultural Differences". Reception: Texts, Readers, Audiences, History. 3 (3): 102–135. doi:10.5325/reception.3.3.0102. ISSN   2168-0604.
  7. 1 2 3 4 The Canadian Horror Film: Terror of the Soul. University of Toronto Press. 2015. doi:10.3138/j.ctvg25364. ISBN   978-1-4426-2850-2.
  8. 1 2 McMullen, Lorraine (2010). Re(dis)covering our foremothers : nineteenth-century Canadian women writers. University of Ottawa Press. ISBN   978-0-7766-1681-0. OCLC   1077739364.
  9. Borders, William (1975-01-11). "Canada Is Seeking to Reduce U.S. Cultural Influence". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved 2022-05-12.
  10. Atwood, Margaret (1972). Surfacing. Simon & Schuster.
  11. 1 2 Ondaatje, Michael (1987). In the Skin of a Lion. Picador Classic. p. 56.
  12. McDonald, Bruce; Reilly, Georgina; Alianak, Hrant; Houle, Lisa; Roberts, Rick; McHattie, Stephen, Pontypool, OCLC   1129223958 , retrieved 2022-04-29
  13. 1 2 Marche, Stephen (2021). "The funniest places: Why Canadian comedy is obsessed with geography".
  14. Beard, William. "Aesthetic Nationalism in English-Canadian Cinema – Senses of Cinema" . Retrieved 2022-04-29.
  15. "AEscifi.ca The Canadian Science Fiction Review". aescifi.ca. Retrieved 2022-05-12.
  16. 1 2 Malisch, Sherrie (2014). "In Praise of the Garrison Mentality: Why Fear and Retreat May be Useful Responses in an Era of Climate Change". Studies in Canadian Literature / Études en littérature canadienne. 39 (1). doi: 10.7202/1062361ar . ISSN   0380-6995.

Sources