| Year | Champion | Site | Most Valuable Player |
|---|
| 1987 | Detroit Mercy | Indianapolis, IN | N/A |
| 1988 | Detroit Mercy | Indianapolis, IN |
| 1989 | Detroit Mercy | Indianapolis, IN |
| 1990 | Notre Dame | Dayton, OH |
| 1991 | Notre Dame | Indianapolis, IN |
| 1992 | Detroit Mercy | Indianapolis, IN | Denice Tackett, Detroit Mercy |
| 1993 | Notre Dame | Indianapolis, IN | Terri Kobata, Notre Dame |
| 1994 | Notre Dame | Indianapolis, IN | Terri Kobata, Notre Dame |
| 1995 | Notre Dame | Cleveland, OH | Sara Hayes, Notre Dame |
| 1996 | Northern Illinois | DeKalb, IL | Missy Kaczor, Northern Illinois |
| 1997 | Cleveland State | Detroit, MI | Amy Kyler, Cleveland State |
| 1998 | UIC | Green Bay, WI | Samantha Iuli, UIC |
| 1999 | UIC | Chicago, IL | Samantha Iuli, UIC |
| 2000 | UIC | Indianapolis, IN | Samantha Iuli, UIC |
| 2001 | UIC | Chicago, IL | Stefanie Christoferson, UIC |
| 2002 | UIC | Dayton, OH | Amanda Rivera, UIC |
| 2003 | Wright State | Cleveland, OH | Stephanie Salas, Wright State |
| 2004 | UIC | Chicago, IL | Amanda Rivera, UIC |
| 2005 | Green Bay | Green Bay, WI | Stephanie Hansen, Green Bay |
| 2006 | Youngstown State | Canfield, OH | McKenzie Bedra, Youngstown State |
| 2007 | Wright State | Cleveland, OH | Jamie Perkins, Wright State |
| 2008 | Wright State | Chicago, IL | Sharon Palma, Wright State |
| 2009 | Cleveland State | Pendleton, IN | |
| 2010 | Wright State | Cleveland, OH | |
| 2011 | UIC | Chicago, IL | Ashley Hewitt, UIC |
| 2012 | Valparaiso | Valparaiso, IN | Angie Doerffler, Valparaiso |
| 2013 | Valparaiso | Chicago, IL | Janelle Bouchard, Valparaiso |
| 2014 | Green Bay | Dayton, OH | Ashley Nannemann, Green Bay |
| 2015 | Oakland | Oakland Softball Stadium • Rochester, MI | Sara Cupp, Oakland |
| 2016 | Valparaiso | Chicago, IL | Sam Stewart, Valparaiso |
| 2017 | UIC | Chicago, IL | Tianna Mack-Miller, UIC |
| 2018 | UIC | Chicago, IL | Tianna Mack-Miller, UIC |
| 2019 | Detroit Mercy | Chicago, IL | Liz Murphy, Detroit Mercy |
| 2020 | Championship canceled due to COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2021 | UIC | YSU Softball Complex • Youngstown, OH | Marley Hanlon, UIC |
| 2022 | Oakland | YSU Softball Complex | Madison Jones, Oakland |
| 2023 | Northern Kentucky | Green Bay, WI | Lauryn Hicks, Northern Kentucky |
| 2024 | Cleveland State | YSU Softball Complex | Melissa Holzopfel, Cleveland State |
