Hyde railway disaster

Last updated

Hyde railway disaster
Details
Date4 June 1943
13:45 NZST
Location Hyde, Otago, South Island
CountryNew Zealand
Line Otago Central Railway
Operator New Zealand Railways Department
Incident typeDerailment
CauseExcessive speed;
Driver intoxicated
Statistics
Trains1
Passengers113
Deaths21

The Hyde railway disaster occurred on 4 June 1943 near the small settlement of Hyde, Otago, New Zealand, on a bend of the Otago Central Railway. At the time, it was New Zealand's worst railway accident; of the 113 passengers on board, 21 were killed and a further 47 were injured. However, just over 10 years later, the Tangiwai disaster took 151 lives on 24 December 1953. The Hyde disaster remains as the second-worst railway accident in New Zealand's history.

Contents

Background

The Hyde disaster involved the daily passenger express train from Cromwell to Dunedin. In 1936, a year-round daily passenger express train was introduced, replacing a thrice weekly express that had been augmented by slow mixed trains. This service left Cromwell at 9 am and reached Dunedin at 5:20 pm; in 1937, the schedule was accelerated by half an hour and it was this timetable that was in force on 4 June 1943. The train was hauled by a steam locomotive, AB 782, and consisted of seven passenger carriages, a guard's van and two wagons of time-sensitive freight. [1] 4 June was a Friday and was to be followed by the King's Birthday long weekend, which boosted patronage to 113 as many passengers travelled to the Winter Show in Dunedin or horse races in Wingatui. [2]

Prior to the accident, some passengers became concerned about their safety. Regular commuters were aware that the train was travelling at excessive speed [3] and one who had moved from his seat to stand with friends in another carriage was forced to return to his seat as the movement of the train made it uncomfortable to stand. [4] In the minutes immediately preceding the accident, luggage and parcels fell from racks above the seats. [2]

Accident

"It is safe to say that no previous railway accident in this country
has resulted in such a mass of distorted and wrecked rolling stock."

Board of Inquiry [5]

The disaster occurred at 1:45 pm when the express failed to negotiate a 183 meter radius curve in a deep cutting known locally as Straw Cutting, shortly after crossing the Six Mile Creek between Hyde and the Rock and Pillar Range. The train derailed, with the locomotive coming to rest against the side of the cutting 60 meters from where it derailed; the boiler burst, extinguishing the fire in the firebox but severely scalding the fireman. The carriages piled up around the locomotive; all seven passenger carriages had left the tracks, with the second overturning and coming to rest in front of the locomotive while four of the other carriages telescoped together. The guards van and two goods wagons at the rear failed to derail. [2] [6]

The force of the crash was such that the undercarriage of one was twisted into the form of a letter "S" and one passenger who survived was thrown out of their carriage, struck the side of the cutting, and bounced back in through another window. Bits of the train were scattered throughout the surrounding farmland and the cutting contained a mass of splintered wood, bent steel, and broken seats; an attending doctor described it as resembling "the result of a bomb blast". [7]

Due to the remote location, it took approximately 90 minutes for rescuers to arrive. Reports reached Middlemarch of an accident where there "were possibly a few injuries" and medical personnel did not initially travel in a hurry to the disaster, but upon catching sight of the disaster from a rise in the road half a mile away, they proceeded swiftly. [7] In the intervening time, the injured were tended by the passengers from the relatively undamaged rear carriages [8] and by local farmer Pat Kinney, who owned the property through which the cutting ran; Kinney's son Frank had boarded the train at its last stop in Hyde and was one of the deceased. [9] Some passengers were trapped in the wreckage for several hours and medical personnel – with the assistance of railway maintenance staff – worked until it was too dark to see. [7]

Casualties

Those killed were:

Aftermath

The cairn memorial "dedicated 17th Feb. 1991 in memory of those who died". It is beside State Highway 87 and the Otago Central Rail Trail, 7 km south of Hyde. A nearby plaque states "accident site 540 m north of this cairn" Hyde railway disaster cairn.jpg
The cairn memorial "dedicated 17th Feb. 1991 in memory of those who died". It is beside State Highway 87 and the Otago Central Rail Trail, 7 km south of Hyde. A nearby plaque states "accident site 540 m north of this cairn"

The isolation of the disaster site was compounded by wartime conditions and little news was published of the accident. Relatives of the victims did not receive news of their loss until the next day. [10]

A board of inquiry was established to investigate the accident. Based on the state of the wreckage, it found that the train had to be travelling in excess of 70 miles per hour (110 km/h) on a curve with a speed limit of 30 miles per hour (48 km/h) and had thus derailed due to the operation of centrifugal force. It found that the judgement of the driver, 55-year-old John Corcoran, was markedly impaired as he had been drunk, and thus charged him with serious dereliction of duty. Corcoran was tried in the Dunedin Supreme Court with manslaughter, found guilty, and sentenced to three years' jail. The train's guard was reprimanded for not taking action when he became aware of the train's excessive speed, but he was not criminally prosecuted. [8] [9]

In the years after the disaster, it had little legacy as it was overshadowed by World War II. When a memorial was established to victims of the Tangiwai disaster decades later, relatives of Hyde disaster victims began to work for their own memorial, led by Molly Winter and Elizabeth Coleman. [10] In August 1990, a committee was formed to erect a monument, a 2.5 m high cairn, at an easily accessible site near the location of the derailment. [11] The cutting of the disaster itself can also be walked, as the Otago Central Railway closed on 30 April 1990 and has been converted into the Otago Central Rail Trail.

The disaster was the only significant accident involving passengers that occurred on the Otago Central Railway between the start of construction in 1877 and closure. [12]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Granville rail disaster</span> 1977 train derailment in Australia

The Granville rail/train disaster occurred on Tuesday 18 January 1977 at Granville, a western suburb of Sydney, New South Wales, Australia, when a crowded commuter train derailed, running into the supports of a road bridge that collapsed onto two of the train's passenger carriages. The official enquiry found the primary cause of the crash to be poor fastening of the track.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tangiwai disaster</span> 1953 railway accident in New Zealand

The Tangiwai disaster occurred at 10:21 p.m. on 24 December 1953 when a railway bridge over the Whangaehu River collapsed beneath an express passenger train at Tangiwai, North Island, New Zealand. The locomotive and the first six carriages derailed into the river, killing 151 people. The subsequent board of inquiry found that the accident was caused by the collapse of the tephra dam holding back nearby Mount Ruapehu's crater lake, creating a rapid mudflow (lahar) in the Whangaehu River, which destroyed one of the bridge piers at Tangiwai only minutes before the train reached the bridge. The volcano itself was not otherwise erupting at the time. The disaster remains New Zealand's worst rail accident.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rail transport in New Zealand</span> Conveyance of passengers and goods by way of wheeled vehicles running on rail tracks in New Zealand

Rail transport in New Zealand is an integral part of New Zealand's transport network, with a nationwide network of 4,375.5 km (2,718.8 mi) of track linking most major cities in the North and South Islands, connected by inter-island rail and road ferries. Rail transport in New Zealand has a particular focus on bulk freight exports and imports, with 19 million net tonnes moved by rail annually, with 99.5% of New Zealand's exports and imports being transported through the country's seaports.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dunedin Railways</span>

Dunedin Railways is the trading name of Dunedin Railways Limited, an operator of a railway line and tourist trains based at Dunedin Railway Station in the South Island of New Zealand. The company is a council-controlled trading organisation wholly owned by Dunedin City Council through its holding company Dunedin City Holdings Limited.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ocean Beach Railway</span>

The Ocean Beach Railway (OBR) is a heritage railway that operates in Dunedin, New Zealand. It is located between John Wilson Drive in the suburb of Saint Kilda and sports grounds near Forbury Park Raceway, and runs parallel with the city's main beach, Ocean Beach. This is near where the Ocean Beach Branch once ran, but not on the same formation.

The Southerner was a passenger express train in New Zealand's South Island between Christchurch and Invercargill along the South Island Main Trunk, that ran from 1970 to 2002. It was one of the premier passenger trains in New Zealand and its existence made Invercargill the southernmost passenger station in the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Polmont rail accident</span> 1984 Scotland train disaster

The Polmont rail accident, also known as the Polmont rail disaster, occurred on 30 July 1984 to the west of Polmont, near Falkirk, in Scotland. A westbound push-pull express train travelling from Edinburgh to Glasgow struck a cow, which had gained access to the track through a damaged fence from a field near Polmont railway station. The collision caused all six carriages and the locomotive of the train to derail, killing 13 people and injuring 61 others. The accident led to a debate about the safety of push-pull trains on British Rail.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Staplehurst rail crash</span> Railway accident in Kent, England, in 1865

The Staplehurst rail crash was a derailment at Staplehurst, Kent, on 9 June 1865 at 3:13 pm. The South Eastern Railway Folkestone to London boat train derailed while crossing a viaduct where a length of track had been removed during engineering works, killing ten passengers and injuring forty. In the Board of Trade report it was found that a man had been placed with a red flag 554 yards (507 m) away but the regulations required him to be 1,000 yards (910 m) away and the train had insufficient time to stop.

The Valigonda rail disaster occurred on 29 October 2005 near the town of Valigonda, south of Hyderabad in the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh. A flash flood swept away a small rail bridge, and a "Delta Fast Passenger" train traveling on it derailed at the broken section of the line, killing at least 114 people and injuring over 200.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Otago Central Railway</span> Branch railway line in Otago, New Zealand

The Otago Central Railway (OCR) or in later years Otago Central Branch Railway, now often referred to as the Taieri Gorge Railway, was a secondary railway line in Central Otago, in the South Island of New Zealand.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hyde, New Zealand</span>

Hyde is a locality in Otago, New Zealand, located in the Strath-Taieri. It is close to the northern end of the Rock and Pillar Range on State Highway 87 between Middlemarch and Ranfurly. Hyde is best known as the site of the Hyde railway disaster of 4 June 1943, in which 21 people were killed when an express train on the Otago Central Railway derailed at high speed in a cutting near the town. At the time, it was the worst railway accident in New Zealand's history; it has only been passed by the Tangiwai disaster of 24 December 1953, which claimed the lives of 151 people. The site of the Hyde disaster can now be walked as part of the Otago Central Rail Trail and a monument, a 2.5 m high cairn, stands as a memorial to the victims.

There have been a number of train accidents on the railway network of Victoria, Australia. Some of these are listed below.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Versailles rail accident</span> 1842 train wreck in France

On 8 May 1842, a train crashed in the cutting between Meudon and Bellevue stations on the railway between Versailles and Paris, France. The train was travelling to Paris when it derailed after the leading locomotive broke an axle, and the carriages behind piled into it and caught fire. It was the first French railway accident and the deadliest in the world at the time, causing between 52 and 200 deaths, including that of explorer Jules Dumont d'Urville. The accident led the French to abandon the practice of locking passengers in their carriages.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Great Western Railway accidents</span>

Great Western Railway accidents include several notable incidents that influenced rail safety in the United Kingdom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rakaia railway accident</span>

The Rakaia railway accident at Rakaia, Canterbury, New Zealand on the evening of Saturday, 11 March 1899 occurred when the second of two excursion trains returning from Ashburton to Christchurch ran into the rear of the first at the Rakaia Railway Station, killing four passengers. While due to excessive speed, the accident resulted in overdue improvements by New Zealand Railways to signalling and braking.

The Rimutaka incline railway line suffered from strong cross winds. On two occasions passenger trains were derailed by them. The first in 1880 resulting in four deaths, and the second in 1936 resulting in only injuries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ongarue railway disaster</span>

The Ongarue railway disaster occurred on 6 July 1923 near the small settlement of Ongarue, near Taumarunui, North Island, New Zealand, when an overnight express ran into a landslip. Of the 200 passengers on board, 17 died and 28 were injured. The disaster marked the first major loss of life in New Zealand railway history; the Christchurch Press noted that each of the previous fatal railway accidents had resulted in no greater loss of life than that resulting from an overturned motor car.

References

  1. ↑ J. A. Dangerfield and G. W. Emerson, Over the Garden Wall: Story of the Otago Central Railway, third edition (Dunedin: Otago Railway and Locomotive Society, 1995), 42–3.
  2. 1 2 3 Geoff Conly and Graham Stewart, New Zealand Tragedies on the Track: Tangiwai and Other Railway Accidents, revised edition (Wellington: Grantham House, 1991 [1986]), 103.
  3. ↑ Emily Toxward, "Service Recalls Hyde Disaster", Otago Daily Times (5 June 1993).
  4. ↑ Mike Crean, "Premonition of Doom", Star Sunday (16 December 1990), Section 3: 1.
  5. ↑ Cited in Conly and Stewart, New Zealand Tragedies on the Track, 103.
  6. ↑ Dangerfield and Emerson, Over the Garden Wall, 43.
  7. 1 2 3 Adrian Webb, "Doctor Recalls Horrific Scene", Star Sunday (16 December 1990), Section 3: 2.
  8. 1 2 Conly and Stewart, New Zealand Tragedies on the Track, 104.
  9. 1 2 Mike Crean, "Tragedy for District, Hell for Driver", Star Sunday (16 December 1990), Section 3: 2.
  10. 1 2 Mike Crean, "Waiting for the Worst", Star Sunday (16 December 1990), Section 3: 2.
  11. ↑ Mike Crean, "Memorial to Forgotten Rail Crash Victims", Star Sunday (16 December 1990), Section 3: 1.
  12. ↑ Dangerfield and Emerson, Over the Garden Wall, 44.

Coordinates: 45°21′06″S170°14′15″E / 45.3517°S 170.2376°E / -45.3517; 170.2376

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.