Interdisciplinary bedside rounds

Last updated

In the domain of hospital medicine, interdisciplinary bedside rounds are a collaborative approach to patient care that involves the participation of the bedside nurse, primary provider, and the patient. [1] They are often joined by family members and allied health professionals such as the patient's pharmacist and case manager.

Contents

During interdisciplinary bedside rounds, these participants visit the patient's bedside together — a type of short, interdisciplinary care team meeting. The rounds are typically conducted for all of a provider's patients on a hospital unit, one after another, with each patient's primary nurse joining for his or her patients.

Unlike conventional hospital care in which medical professionals treat patients independently and with minimal coordination, Interdisciplinary Bedside Rounds aim to foster real-time collaboration by having the whole care team converge at a patient's bedside to discuss their care and discharge plans.

This approach, by design, seeks to mitigate the risks associated with uncoordinated care, such as miscommunication, oversight, errors, and delays. Research on hospital teams show that teams make fewer mistakes than do individuals, and that team members know their responsibilities and those of their team members. [2] [3] [4]

Goals

Interdisciplinary bedside rounds aim to achieve several healthcare goals by embedding them into daily care routines:

Comparison with multidisciplinary rounds and medical rounds

Although IBRs, multidisciplinary rounds (MDRs), and medical rounds all aspire to enhance patient outcomes through collaboration, the three models diverge in their structure, focus, and execution. [9]

Multidisciplinary rounds (MDRs)

Definition: In MDRs, the healthcare team discusses patients outside the patient's presence, typically at a centralized location such as a nursing station or conference room.

Participants: MDRs are often brief "run the list" huddles between lead provider, case manager, and charge nurse, with a primary focus on discharge planning. Bedside nurses on the unit rarely attend MDRs, and if they do, they rarely have an active role.

Impact: Apart from these huddles, care providers in an MDR model largely function independently, leading to potential gaps in shared comprehension and decision-making, with different groups of health care professionals often working in isolation and with the illusion of teamwork. [10] [11]

Timing: MDRs can occur in the morning and/or afternoon

The actual execution of MDRs can vary from hospital to hospital and unit to unit. There is no official academic definition of multidisciplinary rounds.

Medical rounds

Definition: In medical rounds, also known as ward rounds, attending rounds, and safari rounds, [9] the lead provider rounds on his or her patient at the bedside. When conducted on a teaching unit with residents and interns, the focus is on medical education for the trainees.

Participants: Medical rounds can be conducted alone, or with a team of physicians, including junior doctors and medical students. If bedside nurses and other allied health professionals join, it is typically to observe and listen in.

Timing: Medical rounds typically occur in the morning

The actual execution of ward rounds can vary from hospital to hospital, unit to unit, physician to physician, and even day to day. Attending rounds have been called "The HumptyDumptification of Medical Discourse" because of the nonstandard nature of what is covered. [12]

Interdisciplinary bedside rounds (IBRs)

In contrast, interdisciplinary bedside rounds aim to foster an integrated and collaborative approach to patient care. These rounds take place at the patient's bedside and involve the lead provider, multiple other healthcare professionals, and the patient and their family.

During IBRs, the different professions engage in a collective dialogue, fostering a more comprehensive understanding of the patient's condition, needs, and care plan. The inclusion of the patient and their family in the conversation also ensures that the care plan is tailored to the patient's needs and preferences. Inputs shared forward from multiple stakeholders are readily synthesized together to form a cohesive plan of care.

Multiple studies have found that interdisciplinary teams consistently outperform multidisciplinary teams across most evaluated metrics. [13] However, implementing successful IBRs can be challenging, leading to mixed outcomes. [14] [13]

Comparison and consequences

MDRs, due to their absence of real-time, all-inclusive communication, can potentially result in missed cues, misinterpretations, and delays that negatively affect patient outcomes and satisfaction.

Conversely, IBRs aim to minimize these hazards by promoting shared decision-making, [15] enhancing interprofessional communication, [6] and placing the patient at the heart of their care. [5] These factors collectively contribute to improved care coordination, patient satisfaction, and overall care outcomes.

Implementation challenges and solutions

IBRs can be more challenging to implement than MDRs, and these challenges have been studied in detail. [16] [17] The IBR literature includes solutions that hospital units have seen work for them. [5] [6] [7] [18] [19] [20]

Structured interdisciplinary bedside rounds (SIBR rounds)

A well-known model of IBRs is structured interdisciplinary bedside rounds, abbreviated as SIBR rounds and pronounced "cyber."

SIBR follows a six-step process to create a shared mental model of who says what, when, and in what sequence when a care team enters the patient's room together. This structure is designed to ensure role clarity, consistency, efficiency, and sense-making.

History and development of SIBR

The concept of SIBR was developed by hospitalist and quality expert Dr. Jason Stein and colleagues at Emory University Hospital in the early 2010s. [26]

The SIBR model and its inventors have won several US national awards from the Society of Hospital Medicine and attracted international attention. [27] [28] [29] The insights were recognized by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Innovation Center.

Numerous studies of various SIBR units have shown substantial improvements for clinical, [7] [21] [23] [30] throughput, [5] [15] [20] [26] [31] cost [7] and patient/staff experience and engagement outcomes, [6] [20] [32] with some having failed to achieve desired outcomes. [33] [34]

References

  1. Gonzalo JD, Kuperman E, Lehman E, Haidet P (August 2014). "Bedside interprofessional rounds: Perceptions of benefits and barriers by internal medicine nursing staff, attending physicians, and housestaff physicians". J Hosp Med. 9 (10): 646–651. doi:10.1002/jhm.2245. PMID   25130404.
  2. Smith-Jentsch KA, Salas E, Baker DP (December 1996). "Training team performance-related assertiveness". Pers Psychol. 49 (4): 909–936. doi:10.1111/j.1744-6570.1996.tb02454.x.
  3. Volpe CE, Cannon-Bowers JA, Salas E, Spector PE (March 1996). "The impact of cross-training on team functioning: An empirical investigation". Hum. Factors. 38 (1): 87–100. doi:10.1518/001872096778940741. PMID   8682521. S2CID   43030853.
  4. Salas E, Sims DE, Burke CS (October 2005). "Is there a "Big Five" in Teamwork?". Small Group Research. 36 (5): 555–599. doi:10.1177/1046496405277134. S2CID   143395088.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Cao, Victor; Tan, Laren D.; Horn, Femke; Bland, David; Giri, Paresh; Maken, Kanwaljeet; Cho, Nam; Scott, Loreen; Dinh, Vi A.; Hidalgo, Derrek; Nguyen, H. Bryant (January 2018). "Patient-Centered Structured Interdisciplinary Bedside Rounds in the Medical ICU" . Critical Care Medicine. 46 (1): 85–92. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000002807. ISSN   0090-3493. PMID   29088002. S2CID   42618135.
  6. 1 2 3 4 Schwartz, Jeremy I; Gonzalez-Colaso, Rosana; Gan, Geliang; Deng, Yanhong; Kaplan, Michael H; Vakos, Patricia-Ann; Kenyon, Kathleen; Ashman, Amy; Sofair, Andre N; Huot, Stephen J; Chaudhry, Sarwat I (2021-01-12). "Structured interdisciplinary bedside rounds improve interprofessional communication and workplace efficiency among residents and nurses on an inpatient internal medicine unit" . Journal of Interprofessional Care: 1–8. doi:10.1080/13561820.2020.1863932. ISSN   1356-1820. PMID   33433262. S2CID   231584694.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Clay-Williams, Robyn; Plumb, Jennifer; Luscombe, Georgina M.; Hawke, Catherine; Dalton, Hazel; Shannon, Gabriel; Johnson, Julie (May 2018). "Improving Teamwork and Patient Outcomes with Daily Structured Interdisciplinary Bedside Rounds: A Multimethod Evaluation". Journal of Hospital Medicine. 13 (5): 311–317. doi: 10.12788/jhm.2850 . ISSN   1553-5592. PMID   29698537. S2CID   13862109.
  8. Cox, Elizabeth D.; Jacobsohn, Gwen C.; Rajamanickam, Victoria P.; Carayon, Pascale; Kelly, Michelle M.; Wetterneck, Tosha B.; Rathouz, Paul J.; Brown, Roger L. (2017-05-01). "A Family-Centered Rounds Checklist, Family Engagement, and Patient Safety: A Randomized Trial". Pediatrics. 139 (5). doi:10.1542/peds.2016-1688. ISSN   0031-4005. PMC   5404725 . PMID   28557720.
  9. 1 2 3 O'Hare, James A. (July 2008). "Anatomy of the ward round" . European Journal of Internal Medicine. 19 (5): 309–313. doi:10.1016/j.ejim.2007.09.016. PMID   18549930.
  10. Körner, Mirjam; Lippenberger, Corinna; Becker, Sonja; Reichler, Lars; Müller, Christian; Zimmermann, Linda; Rundel, Manfred; Baumeister, Harald (April 2014). McDermott, Aoife M (ed.). "Knowledge integration, teamwork and performance in health care" . Journal of Health Organization and Management. 30 (2): 227–243. doi:10.1108/JHOM-12-2014-0217. ISSN   1477-7266. PMID   27052623.
  11. West, Michael A.; Lyubovnikova, Joanne (2013-03-15). "Illusions of team working in health care". Journal of Health Organization and Management. 27 (1): 134–142. doi:10.1108/14777261311311843. ISSN   1477-7266. PMID   23734481.
  12. Körner, Mirjam (August 2018). "Interprofessional teamwork in medical rehabilitation: a comparison of multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary team approach" . Clinical Rehabilitation. 24 (8): 745–755. doi:10.1177/0269215510367538. ISSN   0269-2155. PMID   20530646. S2CID   4150666.
  13. 1 2 Ratelle, John T; Sawatsky, Adam P; Kashiwagi, Deanne T; Schouten, Will M; Erwin, Patricia J; Gonzalo, Jed D; Beckman, Thomas J; West, Colin P (April 2019). "Implementing bedside rounds to improve patient-centred outcomes: a systematic review" . BMJ Quality & Safety. 28 (4): 317–326. doi:10.1136/bmjqs-2017-007778. ISSN   2044-5415. PMID   30224407. S2CID   52286940.
  14. Heip, Tine; Van Hecke, Ann; Malfait, Simon; Van Biesen, Wim; Eeckloo, Kristof (January 2022). "The Effects of Interdisciplinary Bedside Rounds on Patient Centeredness, Quality of Care, and Team Collaboration: A Systematic Review". Journal of Patient Safety. 18 (1): e40 –e44. doi:10.1097/PTS.0000000000000695. ISSN   1549-8425. PMC   8719516 . PMID   32398542.
  15. 1 2 Basic, David; Huynh, Elizabeth; Gonzales, Rinaldo; Shanley, Chris (2018-11-08). "Structured interdisciplinary bedside rounds, in-hospital deaths, and new nursing home placements among older inpatients". Clinical Interventions in Aging. 13: 2289–2294. doi: 10.2147/CIA.S171508 . PMC   6233858 . PMID   30519010.
  16. O'Leary, Kevin J; Killarney, Audrey; Hansen, Luke O; Jones, Sasha; Malladi, Megan; Marks, Kelly; M Shah, Hiren (December 2016). "Effect of patient-centred bedside rounds on hospitalised patients' decision control, activation and satisfaction with care" . BMJ Quality & Safety. 25 (12): 921–928. doi:10.1136/bmjqs-2015-004561. ISSN   2044-5415. PMID   26628552. S2CID   46595605.
  17. Walton, Victoria; Hogden, Anne; Long, Janet C.; Johnson, Julie K.; Greenfield, David (2019-12-11). "How Do Interprofessional Healthcare Teams Perceive the Benefits and Challenges of Interdisciplinary Ward Rounds". Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare. 12: 1023–1032. doi: 10.2147/JMDH.S226330 . PMC   6912018 . PMID   31849478.
  18. Pannick, Samuel; Wachter, Robert M; Vincent, Charles; Sevdalis, Nick (2016-10-18). "Rethinking medical ward quality". BMJ. 355: i5417. doi:10.1136/bmj.i5417. hdl: 10044/1/41514 . ISSN   1756-1833. PMID   27756729. S2CID   32871706.
  19. Martin, Graham P.; Finn, Rachael (November 2011). "Patients as team members: opportunities, challenges and paradoxes of including patients in multi-professional healthcare teams: Patients as team members". Sociology of Health & Illness. 33 (7): 1050–1065. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9566.2011.01356.x . hdl: 2381/10028 . PMID   21668454.
  20. 1 2 3 Lopez, Merrick; Vaks, Yana; Wilson, Michele; Mitchell, Kenneth; Lee, Christina; Ejike, Janeth; Oei, Grace; Kaufman, Danny; Hambly, Jamie; Tinsley, Cynthia; Bahk, Thomas; Samayoa, Carlos; Pappas, James; Abd-Allah, Shamel (May 2019). "Impacting Satisfaction, Learning, and Efficiency Through Structured Interdisciplinary Rounding in a Pediatric Intensive Care Unit: A Quality Improvement Project". Pediatric Quality & Safety. 4 (3): e176. doi:10.1097/pq9.0000000000000176. ISSN   2472-0054. PMC   6594789 . PMID   31579875.
  21. 1 2 Grogean, Thomas S; DeMarco, William (April 2023). "More data, fewer problems: Reducing variability of structured interdisciplinary rounds" . Journal of Hospital Medicine. 18 (S1). doi:10.1002/jhm.13090. ISSN   1553-5592.
  22. Bryson, Christine; Boynton, Greta; Stepczynski, Anna; Garb, Jane; Kleppel, Reva; Irani, Farzan; Natanasabapathy, Siva; Stefan, Mihaela S (2017-08-08). "Geographical assignment of hospitalists in an urban teaching hospital: feasibility and impact on efficiency and provider satisfaction". Hospital Practice. 45 (4): 135–142. doi:10.1080/21548331.2017.1353884. ISSN   2154-8331. PMC   6954492 . PMID   28707548.
  23. 1 2 Loertscher, Laura; Wang, Lian; Sanders, Shelley Schoepflin (2021-07-04). "The impact of an accountable care unit on mortality: an observational study". Journal of Community Hospital Internal Medicine Perspectives. 11 (4): 554–557. doi:10.1080/20009666.2021.1918945. ISSN   2000-9666. PMC   8221162 . PMID   34211668.
  24. Radhakrishnan, Nila S; Lukose, Kiran; Cartwright, Richard; Sleiman, Andressa; Matey, Nicholas; Lim, Duke; LeGault, Tiffany; Pollard, Sapheria; Gravina, Nicole; Southwick, Frederick S (December 2022). "Prospective application of the interdisciplinary bedside rounding checklist 'TEMP' is associated with reduced infections and length of hospital stay". BMJ Open Quality. 11 (4): e002045. doi:10.1136/bmjoq-2022-002045. ISSN   2399-6641. PMC   9723909 . PMID   36588303.
  25. Al Halabi, Anas; Habas, Elmukhtar; Farfar, Khalifa L; Ghazouani, Hafedh; Alfitori, Gamal; Abdulla, Moza A; Borham, Abdelsalam M; Khan, Fahmi Y (2023-04-21). "Time Spent on Medical Round Activities, Distance Walked, and Time-Motion in the General Medicine Department at Hamad General Hospital in Qatar". Cureus. 15 (4): e37935. doi: 10.7759/cureus.37935 . ISSN   2168-8184. PMC   10200253 . PMID   37220459.
  26. 1 2 3 Stein, Jason; Payne, Christina; Methvin, Amanda; Bonsall, Joanna M.; Chadwick, Liam; Clark, Diaz; Castle, Bryan W.; Tong, David; Dressler, Daniel D. (January 2015). "Reorganizing a hospital ward as an accountable care unit: Reorganizing a Hospital Ward" . Journal of Hospital Medicine. 10 (1): 36–40. doi:10.1002/jhm.2284. PMID   25399928.
  27. Shank, Brendon (May 5, 2015). "Society of Hospital Medicine Names 2015 Excellence Award Winners". The Hospitalist. Retrieved June 8, 2023.
  28. Caldwell, Gordon (June 23, 2022). "Dr Gordon Caldwell - Tweet". Twitter. Retrieved June 8, 2023.
  29. Clinical Excellence Commission, 2014, Clinical Excellence Commission Year in Review 2013-14, pp. 36. Sydney: Clinical Excellence Commission
  30. Basic, David; Huynh, Elizabeth T.; Gonzales, Rinaldo; Shanley, Christopher G. (March 2021). "Twice-Weekly Structured Interdisciplinary Bedside Rounds and Falls among Older Adult Inpatients" . Journal of the American Geriatrics Society. 69 (3): 779–784. doi:10.1111/jgs.17007. ISSN   0002-8614. PMID   33395498. S2CID   230666210.
  31. Sunkara, Padageshwar R; Islam, Tareq; Bose, Abhishek; Rosenthal, Gary E; Chevli, Parag; Jogu, Hanumantha; Tk, Luqman Arafath; Huang, Chi-Cheng; Chaudhary, Dipendra; Beekman, Daniel; Dutta, Abhishek; Menon, Suma; Speiser, Jaime L (July 2020). "Impact of structured interdisciplinary bedside rounding on patient outcomes at a large academic health centre". BMJ Quality & Safety. 29 (7): 569–575. doi:10.1136/bmjqs-2019-009936. ISSN   2044-5415. PMC   10189805 . PMID   31810994.
  32. Gausvik, Christian; Lautar, Ashley; Miller, Lisa; Pallerla, Harini; Schlaudecker, Jeffrey (January 2015). "Structured nursing communication on interdisciplinary acute care teams improves perceptions of safety, efficiency, understanding of care plan and teamwork as well as job satisfaction". Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare. 8: 33–37. doi: 10.2147/JMDH.S72623 . ISSN   1178-2390. PMC   4298312 . PMID   25609978.
  33. Huynh, Elizabeth; Basic, David; Gonzales, Rinaldo; Shanley, Chris (2017). "Structured interdisciplinary bedside rounds do not reduce length of hospital stay and 28-day re-admission rate among older people hospitalised with acute illness: an Australian study". Australian Health Review. 41 (6): 599–605. doi: 10.1071/AH16019 . ISSN   0156-5788. PMID   27883874.
  34. Jala, Sheila; Giaccari, Sarah; Passer, Melissa; Bertmar, Carin; Day, Susan; Griffith, Dayna; Krause, Martin (January 2019). ""In Safe Hands" – A costly integrated care program with limited benefits in stroke unit care" . Journal of Clinical Neuroscience. 59: 84–88. doi:10.1016/j.jocn.2018.10.135. PMID   30409533. S2CID   53217177.