| Year | Winner | Runner-up | ref |
|---|
| 1845 | St George's Club, London | The Black Prince, First Trinity Boat Club | |
| 1846 | First Trinity Boat Club | Thames Club, London | |
| 1847 | Brasenose College, Oxford | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1848 | Christ Church, Oxford | Worcester College, Oxford | |
| 1849 | St John of Malta (Wadham & Oriel) | Second Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1850 | Lincoln College, Oxford | row over (no Cambridge crews entered) | |
| 1851 | Brasenose College, Oxford | Christ Church, Oxford | |
| 1852 | Pembroke College, Oxford | row over | |
| 1853 | First Trinity Boat Club | Pembroke College, Oxford | |
| 1854 | First Trinity Boat Club | Wadham College Boat Club | |
| 1855 | Balliol College, Oxford | Trinity College, Cambridge | |
| 1856 | Royal Chester Rowing Club | Lady Margaret Boat Club | [1] |
| 1857 | Exeter College, Oxford | Pembroke College, Oxford | |
| 1858 | Balliol College, Oxford | Exeter College, Oxford | [2] |
| 1859 | First Trinity Boat Club | Balliol College, Oxford | |
| 1860 | First Trinity Boat Club | | |
| 1861 | First Trinity Boat Club | Trinity College, Oxford | |
| 1862 | University College, Oxford | Eton College | |
| 1863 | University College, Oxford | Eton College | |
| 1864 | Eton College | | |
| 1865 | Third Trinity Boat Club | Eton College | |
| 1866 | Eton College | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1867 | Eton College | Radley College | |
| 1868 | Eton College | University College, Oxford | |
| 1869 | Eton College | Lady Margaret Boat Club | |
| 1870 | Eton College | Trinity College Dublin | |
| 1871 | Pembroke College, Oxford | Eton College | |
| 1872 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Pembroke College, Oxford | |
| 1873 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Trinity College Dublin | |
| 1874 | First Trinity Boat Club | Trinity College Dublin | |
| 1875 | Trinity College Dublin | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1876 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Caius College, Cambridge | |
| 1877 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Caius College, Cambridge | |
| 1878 | Jesus College, Cambridge | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1879 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Eton College | |
| 1880 | Trinity Hall, Cambridge | Eton College | |
| 1881 | First Trinity Boat Club | Eton College | |
| 1882 | Eton College | Radley College | |
| 1883 | Christ Church, Oxford | Eton College | |
| 1884 | Eton College | Radley College | |
| 1885 | Eton College | Corpus College, Oxford | |
| 1886 | Pembroke College, Cambridge | Eton College | |
| 1887 | Trinity Hall, Cambridge | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1888 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Pembroke College, Cambridge | |
| 1889 | Christ Church, Oxford | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1890 | Balliol College, Oxford | Trinity Hall, Cambridge | |
| 1891 | Balliol College, Oxford | Eton College | [3] |
| 1892 | First Trinity Boat Club | Third Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1893 | Eton College | Radley College | |
| 1894 | Eton College | Trinity College, Oxford | |
| 1895 | Eton College | St John's College, Oxford | |
| 1896 | Eton College | Balliol College, Oxford | |
| 1897 | Eton College | Emmanuel College, Cambridge | |
| 1898 | Eton College | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1899 | Eton College | Pembroke College, Cambridge | |
| 1900 | New College, Oxford | Eton College | |
| 1901 | University College, Oxford | Eton College | |
| 1902 | University College, Oxford | Eton College | |
| 1903 | Magdalen College, Oxford | Eton College | |
| 1904 | Eton College | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1905 | Eton College | Christ's College, Cambridge | |
| 1906 | First Trinity Boat Club | Christ Church, Oxford | |
| 1907 | Trinity Hall, Cambridge | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1908 | Jesus College, Cambridge | New College, Oxford | |
| 1909 | St John's College, Oxford | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1910 | Eton College | Balliol College, Oxford | |
| 1911 | Eton College | First Trinity, Cambridge | |
| 1912 | Eton College | Radley College | |
| 1913 | First Trinity Boat Club | Trinity College, Oxford | |
| 1914 | Pembroke College, Cambridge | First Trinity, Cambridge | [4] |
| 1920 | Christ Church, Oxford | Merton College, Oxford | |
| 1921 | Eton College | Lady Margaret Boat Club | |
| 1922 | Brasenose College, Oxford | Magdalen College, Oxford | |
| 1923 | Trinity College, Oxford | Jesus College, Cambridge | |
| 1924 | Shrewsbury School | Jesus College, Cambridge | |
| 1925 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Radley College | |
| 1926 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Pembroke College, Cambridge | [5] |
| 1927 | First Trinity Boat Club | Third Trinity, Cambridge | [6] |
| 1928 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Selwyn College, Cambridge | [7] |
| 1929 | First Trinity Boat Club | University College, Oxford | [8] |
| 1930 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Pembroke College, Cambridge | [9] |
| 1931 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Shrewsbury School | [10] |
| 1932 | Shrewsbury School | Oriel College, Oxford | [11] |
| 1933 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Magdalen College, Oxford | [12] |
| 1934 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Trinity College Dublin | [13] |
| 1935 | Trinity Hall, Cambridge | Eton College | [14] |
| 1936 | First Trinity Boat Club | Clare College, Cambridge | [15] |
| 1937 | Clare College, Cambridge | First Trinity, Cambridge | [16] |
| 1938 | Radley College | Pembroke College, Cambridge | [17] |
| 1939 | Clare College, Cambridge | Corpus Christi College, Cambridge | [18] |
| 1946 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Trinity College Dublin | [19] |
| 1947 | First and Third Trinity Boat Club | Eton College | [20] [21] |
| 1948 | Eton College | Bryanston School | [22] |
| 1949 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Pembroke College, Cambridge | [23] |
| 1950 | New College, Oxford | Trinity College Dublin | [24] |
| 1951 | Pembroke College, Cambridge | Jesus College, Cambridge | [25] |
| 1952 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Trinity Hall, Cambridge | |
| 1953 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Radley College | [26] |
| 1954 | First and Third Trinity Boat Club | Trinity Hall, Cambridge | [27] |
| 1955 | Queens' College, Cambridge | Lady Margaret Boat Club | [28] |
| 1956 | Peterhouse, Cambridge | Magdalene College, Cambridge | [29] |
| 1957 | Pembroke College, Cambridge | Christ Church, Oxford | [30] |
| 1958 | Jesus College, Cambridge | Christ Church, Oxford | [31] |
| 1959 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Emmanuel College, Cambridge | [32] |
| 1960 | Eton College | Jesus College, Cambridge | [33] |
| 1961 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Eton College | [34] |
| 1962 | Queens' College, Cambridge | First & Third Trinity, Cambridge | [35] |
| 1963 | Royal Military Academy, Sandhurst | St Edmund Hall, Oxford | [36] |
| 1964 | Pembroke College, Cambridge | Royal Military Academy, Sandhurst | [37] |
| 1965 | St Edmund Hall, Oxford | Jesus College, Cambridge | [38] |
| 1966 | Lady Margaret Boat Club | Jesus College, Cambridge | [39] |
| 1967 | First and Third Trinity Boat Club | Emanuel School | [40] |
| 1968 | Cherwell Boat Club | First & Third Trinity, Cambridge | [41] |
| 1969 | ASR Nereus, Netherlands | Trinity College, USA | [42] |
| 1970 | G.S.R. Aegir, Netherlands | University of London | [43] |
| 1971 | University of London | Trinity College, USA | [44] |
| 1972 | DSRV Laga, Netherlands | G.S.R. Aegir, Netherlands | [45] |
| 1973 | Harvard University, USA | DSR Laga, Netherlands | [46] |
| 1974 | University College Dublin, Ireland | University of London | [47] |
| 1975 | University of London | Isis Boat Club | [48] |
| 1976 | Trinity College, Hartford, USA | Queen's University, Belfast | [49] |
| 1977 | Trinity College Dublin | Pembroke College, Cambridge | [50] |
| 1978 | Imperial College, London | Yale University | [51] |
| 1979 | Yale University, USA | Downing College, Cambridge | |
| 1980 | Yale University, USA | Witwatersrand University, South Africa | [52] |
| 1981 | University of Washington, USA | Yale University | [53] |
| 1982 | University of London | Isis Boat Club | [54] |
| 1983 | Harvard University, USA | Isis Boat Club | |
| 1984 | Brown University, USA | Temple University, USA | |
| 1985 | Leander Club | Garda Siochana Boat Club, Ireland | |
| 1986 | Neptune Rowing Club, Ireland | Harvard University, USA | |
| 1987 | University of London | Tideway Scullers School | |
| 1988 | Mercantile Rowing Club, Australia | Leander Club | |
| 1989 | NCRA | Harvard University, USA | [55] |
| 1990 | Harvard University, USA | University of London | |
| 1991 | Leander Club & Molesey Boat Club | University of London & Oxford University | |
| 1992 | Imperial College, London | ASR Nereus, Netherlands | |
| 1993 | Brown University, USA | NCRA | |
| 1994 | College Boat Club, Pennsylvania, USA | London & NCRA | |
| 1995 | NCRA | Princeton University, USA | |
| 1996 | Goldie Boat Club | Leander Club | [56] |
| 1997 | NCRA & Oxford Brookes | University of Washington, USA | |
| 1998 | Harvard University, USA | Cambridge University & Star Club | [57] |
| 1999 | Cambridge University & Queen's Tower Boat Club | University of California-Berkeley, USA | |
| 2000 | Brown University, USA | ORC Rostock & Heidelberger Rg, Germany | |
| 2001 | Dartmouth Rowing Club, USA | Princeton University, USA | |
| 2002 | Harvard University, USA | Molesey Boat Club | |
| 2003 | University of Washington, USA | Rutgers University, USA | |
| 2004 | Leander Club | Harvard University, USA | |
| 2005 | Cambridge University Boat Club | Leander Club | |
| 2006 | Princeton University, USA | Leander Club & Molesey Boat Club | |
| 2007 | Harvard University, USA | Molesey Boat Club & New York Athletic, USA | |
| 2008 | Leander Club | RSVU Okeanos & DSR Laga, Netherlands | |
| 2009 | Brown University, USA | Leander Club & Molesey Boat Club | |
| 2010 | Harvard University, USA | Oxford Brookes & Oxford University Boat Club | |
| 2011 | Berliner Ruderclub and Olympische Ruder Club Rostock, Germany | Leander Club | |
| 2012 | Harvard University, USA | Leander Club | |
| 2013 | Leander Club & Molesey Boat Club | Northeastern University, USA | |
| 2014 | University of California, Berkeley, USA | Leander Club | |
| 2015 | Yale University USA | University of Washington, USA | |
| 2016 | Leander Club | Following disqualification of ASR Nereus | |
| 2017 | Oxford Brookes & Taurus | Molesey Boat Club & London Rowing Club | |
| 2018 | Oxford Brookes | Oxford Brookes & Edinburgh University Boat Club | |
| 2019 | Oxford Brookes | Hollandia Roeiclub | |
| 2020 | No competition due to COVID-19 pandemic | [58] |
| 2021 | Oxford Brookes | Molesey Boat Club & Twickenham Rowing Club | [59] |
| 2022 | Leander Club | University of California, Berkeley, USA | [60] |
| 2023 | Oxford Brookes | Leander Club | [61] |
| 2024 | Princeton University, USA | Cambridge University Boat Club | [62] |
| 2025 | Leander Club | Oxford Brookes | [63] |