Land of Desire

Last updated

Land of Desire is a book by William Leach about the development of consumer capitalism in the United States from 1890 to 1932. It was a National Book Award Finalist for 1993.

Contents

The title of the book comes from the statement by store owner John Wanamaker that "everyone who starts a new thing has to stand where Columbus did when he set sail. Few had faith that he could ever reach the land of desire." [1]

Synopsis

Land of Desire opens with the premise that American democracy shifted fundamentally after the Civil War as land ownership became concentrated in fewer hands and the population moved to cities to become wage laborers. In the accompanying cultural transformation money gained importance as the good life came to be defined no longer by control over production but by the power to consume (pp. 3–8). [2] The emphasis shifted away from home, family, and self-reliance and towards standard of living, comfort, and luxury. This new mentality permeated all parts of society, including religious traditions, which adapted to the new mode of capitalism despite pockets of resistance. [3]

Economic change

The rise in consumption was preceded by a rise in mass production in which factory size increased dramatically and large corporations began to dominate the economic landscape. Suddenly overproduction became a real concern, and the corporations had to focus on finding new markets for their products (pp. 15–19).

Stores in the nineteenth century were generally small, with Alexander Turney Stewart's "marble palace" an exception. However, Tunney sold mostly dry goods, in wholesale quantities. Department stores appeared in the 1880s, first in New York and Chicago. Within a few decades these had become large and powerful, and had overcome some organized attempts to resist their dominance over local retail markets. The biggest names in the business were John Wanamaker (Wanamaker's), Marshall Field (Marshall Field's), "Department-Store Napoleon" Henry Siegel (Siegel-Cooper Company), [4] Edward and Lincoln Filene (Filene's), and the Straus family—Isidor, Nathan, Percy and Jesse—of Macy's (pp. 20–35). (Leach explores the personal life of some of these figures, especially John Wanamaker—, whose Protestant faith Leach juxtaposes with his business strategies—and his son Rodman Wanamaker; pp. 191–224.)

Interior of Wanamaker's in Philadelphia INTERIOR COURT - John Wanamaker Store, Thirteenth and Chestnut Streets, Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, PA HABS PA,51-PHILA,370-2.tif
Interior of Wanamaker's in Philadelphia

As retailing increased in scope, so did service economy, including not only the staff of retail stores but also workers in the hospitality industry and other sites of consumption. Ellsworth Statler and Lucius Boomer both developed the ideology of service in the hotel chains they owned. Tipping became institutionalized as an incentive to good service and a symbol of the status and power of the customer. Easy credit arose as a lubricant for consumption, sometimes enabling unsupportable spending binges. In cases such as Wanamaker v. Weaver (1903) department stores sued husbands to force them to pay their wives' spending debts (pp. 123–134).

By the 1920s, financiers (Goldman, Sachs, Lehman Brothers, Paul Mazur) turned the large stores into even larger chains and corporations though mergers and acquisitions. (pp. 263–292).

Marketing and display

The book devotes considerable attention to Wizard of Oz author L. Frank Baum, a display window designer and nationally known expert on decoration. It discusses other window designers including Elbert Hubbard, Arthur Fraser, and Walter F. Allert, commercial artists such as Maxfield Parrish, Louis Tiffany, Joseph Urban, Boardman Robinson, and promoters of advertising such as Robert Ogden (pp. 39–70 and passim).

Store interiors became increasingly ornate and carefully planned. Merchandisers also differentiated their stores, with high-end areas for "the classes" and bargain basements for "the masses". [5] Further differentiation brought cafeterias, tearooms, nurseries, concert halls, and theaters to draw shoppers and enhance their sense of well-being in the store. Architects incorporated elevators, escalators, and revolving doors for easy flow through the store. Designers used glass, mirrors, and lighting to increase the allure of goods and create feelings of depth. Decorators developed seasonally changing central themes based on holidays, mythology, orientalism, and other domains engaging the public imagination (pp. 71–84; 134–146).

The fashion industry helped to inspire desire for new clothing by promoting constantly-changing trends; fashion consulting and reporting became its own line of work (pp. 91–11; 308–317). Edward Bernays pioneered the public relations technique of generating news calculated to influence people's attitudes toward a show, product, or company (pp. 319–322). Commercial parades such as the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade drew on local traditions to create positive attention (pp. 323–328).

Child consumers

Marketing children's products and advertising them to children became a significant part of department store strategy. Thus, new fancifully-decorated "Children's Departments" were created to attract families and inspire desire for the commodities displayed therein (pp. 85–90). Sidonie Gruenberg and Joseph Jastrow spoke on the need of children to have 'their own things' in order to better develop their individual personalities, and allowances to learn how to spend; Gruenberg was made head of the Society for the Study of Child Nature and funded by the Rockefeller Foundation to promote these ideas, but recanted in 1934 with her book Parents, Children, and Money (pp. 328–330, 380)

Significant government apparatus also formed around children's issues, especially the U.S. Children's Bureau which engaged in collaborations with department stores (pp. 180–185).

Institutional coalitions

Part II of the book focuses on public–private partnerships and other institutional connections which helped to promote the culture of consumerism. These include the sponsorship of educational programs to produce advertising and decoration specialists (New York School of Fine and Applied Art) and retail specialists (New York University School of Retailing), as well as academic research institutes devoted to studying problems interesting to business (Harvard Bureau of Business Research, led by Edwin Francis Gay and Arch Wilkinson Shaw) (pp. 153–163). The book also discusses other professors who provided intellectual support of the consumerist movement and sometimes collaborated directly with the corporations involved. These include Emily Fogg Mead (mother of Margaret Mead), an early advocate of using advertising to stimulate mass desire (pp. 37, 48).

Museum curators Morris D'Camp Crawford (American Museum of Natural History), Stewart Culin (Brooklyn Museum), John Cotton Dana (Newark Museum), and Richard F. Bach (Metropolitan Museum of Art) formed partnerships with business to develop designs based on museum artifacts and to use museum spaces for exhibitions of marketable contemporary work (pp. 164–173; 324–326).

Leach discusses the "mind cure" philosophy (including New Thought, Unity Church, Christian Science, and theosophy) as an auxiliary to consumerism. He focuses on economics professor Simon Patten, whose philosophy of limitless desires he places within this movement (225–260).

He cites a performance associated with the 1913 Paterson silk strike, organized by John Reed and Robert Edmond Jones as a paradoxical example of labor radicalism coopted by the emerging aesthetic of spectacle (pp. 185–190).

Government

Leach argues that the creation of the massive Department of Commerce building in 1927 reflected the government's commitment to serve the growing corporate sector. Historical night view, main entrance Commerce Department Building, 14th and Constitution.jpg
Leach argues that the creation of the massive Department of Commerce building in 1927 reflected the government's commitment to serve the growing corporate sector.

New federal agencies, especially the Department of Commerce and Department of Labor (at first together as United States Department of Commerce and Labor) reflected new economic needs (pp. 176–180). Herbert Hoover promoted advertising and the expansion of consumer desire in his eight years as Secretary of Commerce (during which he created the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce) and then as President (pp. 349–378).

Department stores cultivated great influence with local governments and typically succeeded in their plans for urban renewal or redesign (pp. 173–176). Fifth Avenue and Seventh Avenue in New York were redesigned to serve specific commercial purposes, with minimized interference of garment workers with the comfortable shopping environment (pp. 292–294). Times Square with its billboards and electric lighting exemplified the new consumer ideology (pp. 338–348).

Reception

Richard Bushman wrote that Leach's "gloomy picture could have been made darker still if the nineteenth-century origins of consumer culture figured more in the book", describing how consumption of goods such as furniture was motivated by the desire to project gentility and emulate higher classes. Bushman suggests also that Leach may have overemphasized the statements of advertisers and department store owners, without scrutinizing how completely the ambition to manage desire had been realized among the masses. [1]

Elliott J. Gorn wrote that "Leach is at his best when he focuses on particular details" such as the use of glass in store displays and urban design. Gorn found the book's tone overly critical, "ponderous" and "heavy-handed" at times "because the author is at such pains to debunk the culture of consumption". [2] Thomas D. Beal, however, felt that "unlike many recent studies, Leach's work neither praises nor condemns this secular culture, but provides new insights into the ways it gradually became a way of seeing and organizing American society." [6]

Alan Trachtenberg also praised the book for its details, writing "Leach has gathered material and biographical evidence from virtually every realm of public life in these years (roughly 1890 to 1930) to document a cultural shift of monumental proportions. In no other recent work on the rise of commercial culture do we find anything like the array of data regarding how the change came about, how it looked, and how it felt to its advocates and critics alike." He wrote that if the book has any flaw, it is its failure to further investigate the failure of existing American cultural traditions to respond critically to consumer culture. [3]

Bibliographic information

William Leach. Land of Desire: Merchants: Power and the Rise of a New American Culture. New York: Vintage Books (Random House), 1993. ISBN   0-394-54350-5.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shopping</span> Buying goods

Shopping is an activity in which a customer browses the available goods or services presented by one or more retailers with the potential intent to purchase a suitable selection of them. A typology of shopper types has been developed by scholars which identifies one group of shoppers as recreational shoppers, that is, those who enjoy shopping and view it as a leisure activity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The May Department Stores Company</span> Defunct retail company acquired by Federated Department Stores in 2006

The May Department Stores Company was an American department store holding company, formerly headquartered in downtown St. Louis, Missouri. It was founded in Leadville, Colorado, by David May in 1877, moving to St. Louis in 1905. After many changes in the retail industry, the company merged with Federated Department Stores in 2005.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Wanamaker</span> US Postmaster General and merchant (1838–1922)

John Wanamaker was an American merchant and religious, civic and political figure, considered by some to be a proponent of advertising and a "pioneer in marketing". He was born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and served as U.S. Postmaster General during the term of U.S. President Benjamin Harrison from 1889 to 1893.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Department store</span> Retail establishment; building which offers a wide range of consumer goods

A department store is a retail establishment offering a wide range of consumer goods in different areas of the store, each area ("department") specializing in a product category. In modern major cities, the department store made a dramatic appearance in the middle of the 19th century, and permanently reshaped shopping habits, and the definition of service and luxury. Similar developments were under way in London, in Paris and in New York (Stewart's).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Macy's, Inc.</span> American department store holding company

Macy's, Inc. is an American holding company of department stores. Upon its establishment, Federated held ownership of the regional department store chains Abraham & Straus, Lazarus, Filene's, and Shillito's. Bloomingdale's joined Federated Department Stores the following year. Throughout its early history, frequent acquisitions and divestitures saw the company operate a number of nameplates. In 1994, Federated took over the department store chain Macy's. Despite a long history of preserving regional nameplates, with the acquisition of The May Department Stores Company in 2005, they were retired and replaced by the Macy's and Bloomingdale's brands nationwide by 2006. Ultimately, Federated itself was renamed Macy's, Inc. in 2007.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Consumer behaviour</span> Study of individuals, groups, or organisations and all the activities associated with consuming

Consumer behaviour is the study of individuals, groups, or organisations and all the activities associated with the purchase, use and disposal of goods and services. Consumer behaviour consists of how the consumer's emotions, attitudes, and preferences affect buying behaviour. Consumer behaviour emerged in the 1940–1950s as a distinct sub-discipline of marketing, but has become an interdisciplinary social science that blends elements from psychology, sociology, social anthropology, anthropology, ethnography, ethnology, marketing, and economics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wanamaker's</span> United States historic place

John Wanamaker Department Store was one of the first department stores in the United States. Founded by John Wanamaker in Philadelphia, it was influential in the development of the retail industry including as the first store to use price tags. At its zenith in the early 20th century, Wanamaker's also had a store in New York City at Broadway and Ninth Street. Both employed extremely large staffs. By the end of the 20th century, there were 16 Wanamaker's outlets, but after years of change, the chain was bought by A. Alfred Taubman in late 1986, and added to his previous purchase of Woodward & Lothrop, the Washington, D.C., department store. In 1994, Woodies, as it was known, filed for bankruptcy. The assets of Woodies were purchased by the May Company Department Stores and JCPenney. In 1995, Wanamaker's transitioned to Hecht's, one of the May Company brands. In 2006, Macy's opened in the former Philadelphia Wanamaker's Department Store, now called Macy's Center City. The building is a National Historic Landmark.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Downtown Crossing</span> Shopping district in Boston, Massachusetts, United States

Strawbridge's, formerly Strawbridge & Clothier, was a department store in the northeastern United States, with stores in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware. The Center City Philadelphia flagship store was, in its day, a gracious urban emporium. The retailer started adding branch stores starting in the 1930s and, by their zenith in the 1980s, enjoyed annual sales of over a billion dollars By the 1990s, Strawbridge's became part of the May Department Stores conglomerate until May's acquisition by Federated Department Stores on August 30, 2005.

Woodward & Lothrop was a department store chain headquartered in Washington, D.C. that began as the capital's first department store in 1887. Woodies, as it was often nicknamed, maintained stores in the Mid-Atlantic United States. Its flagship store was a fixture of Washington, D.C.'s downtown shopping district, competing with Garfinckel's and acquiring Palais Royal. The chain filed for bankruptcy in January 1994 and completed liquidation in November 1995, with most locations sold to either J. C. Penney or May Department Stores Company. The flagship building is a D.C. historic landmark that became the center of controversy over competing visions for DC's urban renewal after the chain's demise, and the former service warehouse in the city's northeast is also listed as a landmark.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Filene's</span> Defunct department store chain in the northeastern US

Filene's was an American department store chain; it was founded by William Filene in 1881. The success of the original full-line store in Boston, Massachusetts, was supplemented by the foundation of its off-price sister store Filene's Basement in 1908. Filene's, in partnership with Abraham & Straus, Lazarus, and Shillito's, was an original member of the holding company Federated Department Stores upon its establishment in 1929.

F&R Lazarus & Company was a regional department store with its retail chain operating primarily in the U.S. Midwest, and based in Columbus, Ohio. For over 150 years, Lazarus was influential in the American retail industry, particularly during the early 20th century as a founding partner in Federated Department Stores, and continued until the nameplate was retired on March 6, 2005, in favor of Macy's.

Consumer capitalism is a theoretical economic and social political condition in which consumer demand is manipulated in a deliberate and coordinated way on a very large scale through mass-marketing techniques, to the advantage of sellers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edward Filene</span> American businessman and philanthropist

Edward Albert Filene was an American businessman and philanthropist. He is best known for building the Filene's department store chain and for his decisive role in pioneering credit unions across the United States.

Ernest Dichter was an American psychologist and marketing expert known as the "father of motivational research." Dichter pioneered the application of Freudian psychoanalytic concepts and techniques to business — in particular to the study of consumer behavior in the marketplace. Ideas he established were a significant influence on the practices of the advertising industry in the twentieth century. Dichter promised the "mobilisation and manipulation of human needs as they exist in the consumer". As America entered the 1950s, the decade of heightened commodity fetishism, Dichter offered consumers moral permission to embrace sex and consumption, and forged a philosophy of corporate hedonism, which he thought would make people immune to dangerous totalitarian ideas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">One South Broad</span> A 28-story 472-foot (144 m) office tower in Center City, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States

One South Broad, also known as the Lincoln-Liberty Building or PNB Building, is a 28-story 472-foot (144 m) office tower in Center City, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States. The art deco tower, designed by architect John Torrey Windrim as an annex for Wanamaker's department store, was completed in 1932. Wanamaker's Men's Store opened in the first seven floors of the building, which is located a block from Wanamaker's main store, and was intended to rival European department stores with its size and selection. In 1952, the Philadelphia National Bank (PNB) bought the building and converted it into offices and banking space. Until 2014, the building's bell tower was decorated on all four sides with PNB's initials in stainless steel 16 feet (4.9 m) tall. Wells Fargo is the main tenant, occupying almost half the building. The former banking space at street level was converted to retail and restaurant space in 2000.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Nystrom</span> American economist

Paul Henry Nystrom was an American economist, and professor of marketing at Columbia University. He is most known as pioneer in marketing, and for his The Economics of Retailing (1915) and his Economics of Fashion (1928).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Window shopping</span> Examining a shops stock without intent to purchase

Window shopping, sometimes called browsing, refers to an activity in which a consumer browses through or examines a store's merchandise as a form of leisure or external search behaviour without a current intent to buy. Depending on the individual, window shopping can be a pastime or be used to obtain information about a product's development, brand differences, or sale prices.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of retail</span> Historical development of sales to consumers

The history of retail encompasses the sale of goods and services to consumers across all cultures and time periods from ancient history to the present.The first form of commerce was bargaining between early human civilizations. Beginning with Middle Eastern towns in the 7th millennium BCE, retail markets emerged when civilizations created money to allow commerce more easily. Open-air markets were created by numerous ancient Middle Eastern and European civilizations to enable merchants and other producers to sell goods to consumers. The earliest known permanent retail centers, the forums, were created in ancient Rome. Similar shopping centers are thought to have been created in China, but this information has been lost. Chinese retail was extensive by the first millennium BCE, and this included branding and packaging.

Department stores are an established retail format globally. The format has origins in France, the United Kingdom and United States, among many others.

References

  1. 1 2 Richard L. Bushman, book review in Contemporary Sociology 23(6), November 1994 (JSTOR).
  2. 1 2 Elliott J. Gorn, "Selling Urban Dreams" (book review essay), Journal of Urban History 24(4), May 1998.
  3. 1 2 Alan Trachtenberg, book review in American Historical Review, February 1995 (JSTOR).
  4. Christopher Gray, "Streetscapes / Henry Siegel and the 14th Street Store; The Rise and Fall of the Department-Store Napoleon", New York Times, 16 May 1999.
  5. Margo Jefferson, "The Department Store and the Culture It Created", New York Times, 1 December 1993.
  6. Thomas D. Beal, book review in Business History Review 68(1), Spring 1994.