Leon Trotsky on China

Last updated

Leon Trotsky on China
Author Leon Trotsky
Original titleLeon Trotsky on China
TranslatorLes Evans, Ruseel Block and Peng Shuzhi
Language Russian
Genre Nonfiction
Publisher Pathfinder Press (America), Monad Press
Publication date
1976
Publication place Soviet Union
Media typePrint

Trotsky on China is a compilation of letters and articles by Russian revolutionary Leon Trotsky, from 1925 until 1940. [1] These writings documented his views on the nature of the Chinese revolution, his warnings of Joseph Stalin's policies in relation to the Kuomintang alliance which precipitated the repression campaign against the Chinese Communists in 1927 and the Sino-Japanese war. [1] [2]

Contents

Writing background

Trotsky and members of the Left Opposition in 1927, prior to their expulsion from the Soviet Union Trotskigroup640.jpg
Trotsky and members of the Left Opposition in 1927, prior to their expulsion from the Soviet Union

The Bolsheviks had viewed anti-imperialist movements in the colonised regions as a major reserve for proletarian revolution alongside continental Europe. [3] Vladimir Lenin and Trotsky had postulated that Western capitalism would be considerably weakened with the eruption of anti-colonial rebellions which in turn could suspend the supply of cheap labour, raw materials and investment inflows. [3] In 1920, the Comintern had proclaimed the alliance between Western communists and liberation movements in the East although the exact nature of this relationship remained imprecise at this stage. [3] From the perspective of early Chinese onlookers, Trotsky had been presented as the formal second-in command in the Soviet Union and had a significant role in the founding of the Sun Yat-sen University. [4]

The schism between Stalin and the Trotskyist Left Opposition had ruptured in the Soviet Union in 1923 over issues related to democratisation, industrialization and foreign affairs such as relations with trade unions in Britain and the foreign Communist parties. [5] Stalin and his faction in the CPSU and Comintern believed that the incipient Chinese revolution would follow a bourgeois-democratic model of revolution which would necessitate an alliance with bourgeois leaders. [5]

Stain also perceived the Kuomintang as a revolutionary, progressive force because it was anti-imperialist albeit with nationalist and bourgeois composition. [2] In his interpretation, the Kuomintang consisted of a "bloc of four classes" which included the national bourgeoisie, the petty bourgeoisie, the peasants and workers which could be directed to serve the interests of socialist revolution. [3] Chiang Kai-Shek had been appointed an honorary member of the Executive of the Comintern prior to the Shanghai massacre, Stalin had commended his military forces as "revolutionary armies" and rejected any attempts to form soviets in China. [3]

As early as 1924, Trotsky had strongly criticised the position of the Politburo that the Chinese Communists should subordinate their independent role to the needs of a political alliance with the Kuomintang. [3] Rather, Trotsky insisted that the Chinese Communists form Workers and Peasants Councils with the peasantry in Southern China in opposition to Chiang Kai-shek. [3] Stalin alongside the Politburo had censured the criticism presented by the Left Opposition with disciplinary methods and prevented the factional controversy from receiving public attention in the Soviet Union. [3] This matter concerning the Chinese Revolution remained a central issue of contention during the inner-party struggle before the final dissolution of the United Opposition. [3]

Content

Trotsky's writings on China situated the revolutionary period from 1925-1927 in the wider context of world revolution. He had made a number of warnings about the dangers associated with the Comintern policy pursued under the direction of Stalin. [2] Trotsky rejected the view that the Kuomintang was hostile to foreign capital and instead argued that the party had allied itself with old feudal elements which had established linkages with urban capital. [2]

In his view, Stalin's policy of bourgeois-democratic revolution imposed a mechanistic conception of revolution reminiscent of the Menshevik theory of preconceived stages. Trotsky believed this would inadvertently support the status quo and would postpone socialist revolution for an undetermined future. [2] Contrastingly, Trotsky argued for the formation of an independent worker's party in alignment with the peasantry.

In his later writings at the end of the 1930s, he wrote on the possibilities of greater industrialization in China which would reaffirm the political principality of the Chinese working class. [2] He would intervene in the rehabilitation of Chen Duxiu after criticisms of his ideological development and leadership from Oppositionist circles. [6] Trotsky sought to develop a more comprehensive understanding of the Chinese economy and language through written correspondence. [7] The wider relations between the two figures would change and subsidy over the course of the interwar period. [8] Trotsky would also detail his views on the prospect of guerrilla warfare in the region [2] [1] and expressed support for the tactic of revolutionary defeatism in the Sino-Japanese War. [9] [1]

Reception

Chen Duxiu, co-founder of the Chinese Communist Party and member of the Left Opposition Chen Duxiu.jpg
Chen Duxiu, co-founder of the Chinese Communist Party and member of the Left Opposition

His writings on China have been credited for their prescience in predicting the outcome of the Comintern's policies and criticised for transposing the historical experience of the Russian Revolution onto China. [2] [3] In particular, his presumption on the primacy of the Chinese industrial proletariat over the rural peasantry in the course of social revolution. [10]

Political scientist Baruch Knei-Paz insisted that the Chinese experience confirmed elements of Trotsky's theory of permanent revolution in the sense that a backward nation could undergo a socialist revolution before an advanced nation. [2] Yet, he also noted that the Chinese context had demonstrated certain limitations in the applicability of his theory such as the occurrence of peasant leadership. [2]

Chinese Left Opposition leader and academic, Chen Duxiu, viewed Trotsky's writings on China approvingly along with the latter’s publication of Lenin's testament. [11] Specifically, Dixiu regarded these commentaries as his exoneration for the initial failure of the Chinese revolution, providing the basis for compatible theoretical formulations and serving to legitimise an ideological break with Stalin. [12]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leon Trotsky</span> Soviet politician and revolutionary (1879–1940)

Lev Davidovich Bronstein, better known as "Leon Trotsky", was a Russian revolutionary, politician, and political theorist. He was a central figure in the 1905 Revolution, October Revolution, Russian Civil War, and establishment of the Soviet Union. Trotsky and Vladimir Lenin were widely considered the two most prominent Soviet figures, and Trotsky was "de facto" second-in-command during the early years of the Russian Soviet Republic. Ideologically a Marxist and Leninist, his thought and writings inspired a school of Marxism known as Trotskyism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trotskyism</span> Variety of Marxism developed by Leon Trotsky

Trotskyism is the political ideology and branch of Marxism developed by Russian revolutionary and intellectual Leon Trotsky along with some other members of the Left Opposition and the Fourth International. Trotsky described himself as an orthodox Marxist, a revolutionary Marxist, and a Bolshevik–Leninist as well as a follower of Karl Marx, Frederick Engels, Vladimir Lenin, Karl Liebknecht, and Rosa Luxemburg. His relations with Lenin have been a source of intense historical debate. However, on balance, scholarly opinion among a range of prominent historians and political scientists such as E.H. Carr, Isaac Deutscher, Moshe Lewin, Ronald Suny, Richard B. Day and W. Bruce Lincoln was that Lenin’s desired “heir” would have been a collective responsibility in which Trotsky was placed in "an important role and within which Stalin would be dramatically demoted ".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chen Duxiu</span> Chinese politician and co-founder of the Chinese Communist Party (1879–1942)

Chen Duxiu was a Chinese revolutionary socialist, educator, philosopher and author, who co-founded the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) with Li Dazhao in 1921. From 1921 to 1927, he served as the Communist Party's first general secretary. Chen was a leading figure in both the Xinhai Revolution that overthrew the Qing dynasty and the May Fourth Movement for scientific and democratic developments in the early Republic of China. After his expulsion from the CCP in 1929, Chen was for a time the leader of China's Trotskyist movement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Communist International</span> Political organization (1919–1943)

The Communist International (Comintern), also known as the Third International, was an international organization founded in 1919 that advocated world communism, and which was led and controlled by the Communist Party of the Soviet Union. The Comintern resolved at its Second Congress in 1920 to "struggle by all available means, including armed force, for the overthrow of the international bourgeoisie and the creation of an international soviet republic as a transition stage to the complete abolition of the state". The Comintern was preceded by the dissolution of the Second International in 1916. Vladimir Lenin, Leon Trotsky, and Joseph Stalin were all honorary presidents of the Communist International.

The Third Period is an ideological concept adopted by the Communist International (Comintern) at its Sixth World Congress, held in Moscow in the summer of 1928. It set policy until reversed when the Nazis took over Germany in 1933.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mikhail Borodin</span> Comintern agent known for his role as advisor to the Kuomintang in China during the 1920s

Mikhail Markovich Gruzenberg, known by the alias Borodin, was a Bolshevik revolutionary and Communist International (Comintern) agent. He was an advisor to Sun Yat-sen and the Kuomintang (KMT) in China during the 1920s.

In political ideology, a deviationist is a person who expresses a deviation: an abnormality or departure. In Stalinist ideology and practice, deviationism is an expressed belief which does not accord with official party doctrine for the time and area. Accusations of deviationism often led to purges. Forms of deviationism included revisionism, dogmatism, and bourgeois nationalism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shanghai Commune of 1927</span>

The Provisional Municipal Government of the Special City of Shanghai, also known as the Shanghai Civil Government or Shanghai Commune, was a provisional administration that briefly governed the city of Shanghai during the Northern Expedition. Established by people's committees with the assistance of Chen Duxiu, Zhou Enlai, and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), the commune briefly administered the city of Shanghai before its forceful dissolution by order of Chiang Kai-shek. The dissolution of the Shanghai Commune would lead to the 1927 Shanghai massacre, and the onset of the Chinese Civil War.

Moscow Sun Yat-sen University, officially the Sun Yat-sen Communist University of the Toilers of China, was a Comintern school which operated from 1925 to 1930 in the city of Moscow, Russia, then the Soviet Union. It was a training camp for Chinese revolutionaries from both the Kuomintang (KMT) and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) that was split off from the Communist University of the Toilers of the East. Its relationship to the Comintern's International Liaison Department remains unclear.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shanghai massacre</span> 1927 killings of Chinese Communist Party members and alleged sympathizers by the Kuomintang

The Shanghai massacre of 12 April 1927, the April 12 Purge or the April 12 Incident as it is commonly known in China, was the violent suppression of Chinese Communist Party (CCP) organizations and leftist elements in Shanghai by forces supporting General Chiang Kai-shek and conservative factions in the Kuomintang. Following the incident, conservative KMT elements carried out a full-scale purge of communists in all areas under their control, and violent suppression occurred in Guangzhou and Changsha. The purge led to an open split between left-wing and right-wing factions in the KMT, with Chiang Kai-shek establishing himself as the leader of the right-wing faction based in Nanjing, in opposition to the original left-wing KMT government based in Wuhan, which was led by Wang Jingwei. By 15 July 1927, the Wuhan regime had expelled the Communists in its ranks, effectively ending the First United Front, a working alliance of both the KMT and CCP under the tutelage of Comintern agents. For the rest of 1927, the CCP would fight to regain power, beginning the Autumn Harvest Uprising. With the failure and the crushing of the Guangzhou Uprising at Guangzhou however, the power of the Communists was largely diminished, unable to launch another major urban offensive.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph Stalin's rise to power</span> Events leading to his dictatorship of the Soviet Union

Joseph Stalin started his career as a robber, gangster as well as an influential member and eventually the leader of the Bolshevik faction of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party. He served as the General Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union from April 3, 1922 until the official abolition of the office during the 19th Party Congress in October 1952 and absolute leader of the USSR from January 21, 1924 until his death on March 5, 1953.

Vissarion Vissarionovich "Beso" Lominadze, was a Georgian revolutionary and Soviet politician. The head of the Transcaucasian Oblast organization of the All-Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks) [VKP(b)], Lominadze is best remembered as a participant in the Syrtsov-Lominadze affair of 1930, a failed attempt to rein in the growing power of Soviet Communist Party General Secretary Joseph Stalin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Karl Radek</span> Polish revolutionary (1885–1939)

Karl Berngardovich Radek was a revolutionary and writer active in the Polish and German social democratic movements before World War I and a Communist International leader in the Soviet Union after the Russian Revolution.

The Left Opposition was a faction within the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks) from 1923 to 1927 headed de facto by Leon Trotsky. The Left Opposition was formed by Trotsky to mount a struggle against the bureaucratic degeneration that began within the party leadership headed by Stalin during the serious illness of the Bolshevik founder Vladimir Lenin. The degeneration intensified after Lenin's death in January 1924. The Left Opposition advocated for a programme of rapid industrialization, voluntary collectivisation of agriculture, and the expansion of a worker's democracy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">World revolution</span> Marxist concept of overthrowing capitalism

World revolution is the Marxist concept of overthrowing capitalism in all countries through the conscious revolutionary action of the organized working class. For theorists, these revolutions will not necessarily occur simultaneously, but where and when local conditions allow a revolutionary party to successfully replace bourgeois ownership and rule, and install a workers' state based on social ownership of the means of production. In many Marxist schools, such as Trotskyism and Communist Left, the essentially international character of the class struggle and the necessity of global scope are critical elements and a chief explanation of the failure of socialism in one country.

Permanent revolution is the strategy of a revolutionary class pursuing its own interests independently and without compromise or alliance with opposing sections of society. As a term within Marxist theory, it was first coined by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels as early as 1850. Since then different theorists, most notably Leon Trotsky (1879–1940), have used the phrase to refer to different concepts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wuhan Nationalist government</span> 1927 political split between leftist KMT government in Wuhan and KMT rightist government in Nanjing

The Wuhan Nationalist government, also known as the Wuhan government, Wuhan regime, or Hankow government, was a government dominated by the left-wing of the Nationalist or Kuomintang (KMT) Party of China that was based in Wuhan from 5 December 1926 to 21 September 1927, led first by Eugene Chen, and later by Wang Jingwei.

Chen Bilan was a Chinese communist. Chen was one of the founders of the Chinese Trotskyist movement and was exiled in 1948. For the rest of her life, she was a leader of the exiled Chinese Trotskyists and a member of the Fourth International.

The Spanish Revolution, 1931–1939 is a collection of Leon Trotsky's writings about the Spanish Civil War.

The Struggle Against Fascism in Germany is a 1971 compilation book based on the writings of Russian revolutionary, Leon Trotsky on the origin of fascism; his early warnings on Nazi Germany, his views on the Comintern, and his tactical support for a united front.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Trotsky, Leon (1976). Leon Trotsky on China. Pathfinder Press. pp. 1–30, 666–721. ISBN   978-0-87348-835-8.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Knei-Paz, Baruch (1978). The social and political thought of Leon Trotsky. Oxford [Eng.] : Clarendon Press. pp. 358–366. ISBN   978-0-19-827233-5.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Deutscher, Isaac (January 5, 2015). The Prophet: The Life of Leon Trotsky. Verso Books. p. 866-890. ISBN   978-1-78168-721-5.
  4. Kuhfus, Peter (1985). "Chen Duxiu and Leon Trotsky: New Light on Their Relationship". The China Quarterly (102): 253–276. ISSN   0305-7410.
  5. 1 2 Chattopadhyay, Kunal (2004). Trotskyism in China: The Formative Years. pp. 971–983.
  6. Kuhfus, Peter (1985). "Chen Duxiu and Leon Trotsky: New Light on Their Relationship". The China Quarterly (102): 253–276. ISSN   0305-7410.
  7. Kuhfus, Peter (1985). "Chen Duxiu and Leon Trotsky: New Light on Their Relationship". The China Quarterly (102): 253–276. ISSN   0305-7410.
  8. Kuhfus, Peter (1985). "Chen Duxiu and Leon Trotsky: New Light on Their Relationship". The China Quarterly (102): 253–276. ISSN   0305-7410.
  9. "Leon Trotsky: On the Sino-Japanese War (Septemnber 1937)". www.marxists.org.
  10. Ballis, William B. (1953). "Review of The Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution; Russia and Asia". The Far Eastern Quarterly. 12 (3): 359–361. doi:10.2307/2942161. ISSN   0363-6917.
  11. Kuhfus, Peter (1985). "Chen Duxiu and Leon Trotsky: New Light on Their Relationship". The China Quarterly (102): 253–276. ISSN   0305-7410.
  12. Kuhfus, Peter (1985). "Chen Duxiu and Leon Trotsky: New Light on Their Relationship". The China Quarterly (102): 253–276. ISSN   0305-7410.