Last updated The cover of the first edition (1946)
Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and His Influence is a biography of Joseph Stalin, written by Leon Trotsky between 1938 and 1940. The book was never finished due to Trotsky's assassination in August 1940 although copious draft manuscripts for concluding chapters survived, allowing editors to complete the work.
The Russian manuscript was translated and edited by language professor and Trotskyist political sympathizer Charles Malamuth. Originally scheduled for publication in the second half of 1941, the book was printed but then abruptly withdrawn from distribution for political reasons due to American entry into World War II. The book finally was released in 1946 when the political relationship between the United States and Soviet Union became frosty. It was subsequently published in French and Spanish in 1948, and in Russian in 1985.
In 2016, an authorized revised second edition was published. British writer Alan Woods deconstructed the original manuscript and reassembled the pieces in as comprehensive a manner as possible, resulting in the addition of 100,000 words. An American edition of the lengthy tome was published in 2019.
Background
On February 15, 1938, New York publisher Harper & Brothers approached émigré communist political leader Leon Trotsky to write a biography of his arch-nemesis, General Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet UnionJoseph Stalin.[1] The proposal called for a payment of $5,000 for the book, with the advance to be paid to the author in installments.[1] Facing financial difficulties which could be obviated by a lucrative contract with a commercial publisher, Trotsky accepted the Harper proposal.[2]
Exposed to the Trotskyist movement through his experience as a foreign correspondent in 1931, Malamuth considered himself a convinced admirer of Trotsky and his disciples, although he was never himself a member of a Trotskyist political party.[1]
Trotsky began work on the manuscript in April 1938, with the first chapter completed and mailed to translator Malamuth on July 7.[2] The second chapter was completed and mailed on August 16 and a third on September 12.[2] However, Trotsky was interrupted by other tasks and the project hit a lull. Owing to the slow pace of writing, Harper & Brothers shut down payment of additional advances on the manuscript before the close of 1938.[4]
Trotsky also began to quarrel with the translator, taking issue with the quality of his translation, becoming angered by what he considered a breach of trust when Malamuth passed along copies of the manuscript to others, and finding Malamuth to be "tremendously pretentious" in his bearing.[4]
Work on the book continued through 1939, despite regular interruptions.[5] By May 1940 the work was finished through the revolutionary year of 1917, with the second half of the book remaining a patchwork of partially completed manuscripts.[5] A first assassination attempt by Soviet agents brought work to an abrupt halt, as Trotsky focused upon the ongoing legal investigation of the affair and fought off an avalanche of verbal attacks in the Mexican press.[5] A second assassination attempt on August 20, 1940, proved successful and Trotsky died with the manuscript uncompleted.[6]
Following Trotsky's death, publisher Harper & Brothers, who retained rights to the book, placed translator Malamuth in charge of rendering the fragmentary second half of the book fit for publication.[6] He gained possession of the manuscript and began making decisions on his sole authority as to what to include or exclude from the final publication.[7] Segue material was written in the form of commentaries.[7] Hundreds of lines were added from Malamuth's own pen, with one comparison of the original manuscript to the published version showing that an incredible 62% of chapter 11 originated with the erstwhile translator.[8]
Malamuth's commentary and silent insertions of content, some of which stood in contradiction to Trotsky's own views, drew a vehement rebuke from Natalia Sedova, Trotsky's widow. Sedova charged that "unheard-of violence" had been "committed by the translator on the author's rights" and declared that "everything written by the pen of Mr. Malamuth must be expunged from the book."[8] This was not to be, however, and the Malamuth commentaries remained in the published book despite a failed effort by Sedova to win an injunction against publication in court.[8]
Publication
Publication of Stalin was initially planned by Harper & Brothers for the second half of 1941.[8] Even as the book was being printed for distribution, however, the US government intervened with the publisher to halt publication, anxious to remain in good graces with Joseph Stalin in the aftermath of the Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union.[9] Already shipped to some distributors, the book was abruptly withdrawn from public sale.[10]
Full release was deferred until after the conclusion of World War II and the falling out of relations between the United States and its wartime Soviet ally.[10] The book's release in 1946 drew an enraged response from the pro-communist press, which took particular umbrage at Trotsky's unsubstantiated and outrageous charge that Stalin had poisoned Russian revolutionary leader V. I. Ulyanov (Lenin).[10]
An editor of the revised second edition of the book noted in 2016:
"Five years after it had been withdrawn to avoid embarrassment to Stalin, the book was now seen as a useful stick with which to beat him. Malamuth's insertions provided the necessary 'adjustments' to turn Trotsky's work into a weapon in the struggle not only against Stalinism but also against Bolshevism. For their part, Harper & Brothers were keen to make money from its delayed publication. The whole episode is characterized by the most blatant cynicism on all sides: the publishers, Malamuth, and the US government all conspired to use and abuse this book for their own ends. The one voice that was silenced was that of the author, Leon Trotsky."[11]
Summary
Trotsky controversially suggested that Stalin had poisoned V.I. Lenin, seen here with Stalin recuperating from a stroke in the city of Gorky.
Stalin begins with an unfinished introduction where Trotsky attempts to prove his objectivity in relation to the events in the rest of the book, however was never finished due to his assassination.[12] Trotsky spends the first chapter discussing Stalin's childhood, where he describes the young Stalin as a child who hates authority and whose "hostility was reserved, underhanded, watchful".[13]
Trotsky spends the next few chapters discussing Stalin's increasing role in revolutionary activities with the likes of Vladimir Lenin and Trotsky himself. Many of the revolutionary activities Stalin participated in during the early years of his life were against the Tsarist regime, who ruled Russia at the time.[14] Trotsky is quick to point out the difference between Lenin and Stalin, saying of Lenin, "The idea of making a fetish of the political machine was not only alien but repugnant to his nature."[15] Trotsky contrasts this sentiment of Lenin with a critique of Stalin, saying of him, "His thinking is too slow, his associations too single-tracked, his style too plodding and barren."[16]
After a couple of more chapters about Stalin's continued participation in anti-Tsarist movements and increasing popularity among revolutionaries, the section is left unfinished due to Trotsky's murder, only to resume during the period in which Lenin is approaching his death.[17]
Trotsky describes the years leading up to Lenin's death as being full of tension and internal conflict among those in the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.[18] Trotsky makes clear throughout the final chapter of the book that Lenin feared Stalin taking control of the Soviet Union after his death. Trotsky posits that Stalin may have been at fault for the poisoning of Lenin that ultimately led to his death and claims the events he outlines in the chapter "were known to no more than seven or eight persons" and that "of that number, besides myself, only Stalin and Molotov are still among the living."[19] With regard to Lenin's successor, Trotsky credits Lenin for saying, "I propose to the comrades to find a way to remove Stalin from that position and appoint to it another man," who would be, "more loyal, more courteous and more considerate to comrades, less capricious, etc.".[20]
Finally, Trotsky gives his account of the events surrounding Lenin's funeral, for which he was criticized for not being present:
According to a widely disseminated version, I lost power because I was not present at Lenin's funeral. This explanation can hardly be taken seriously. But the fact of my absence at the mourning ceremonies caused many of my friends serious misgivings. In the letter from my oldest son, who was then nearing eighteen, there was a note of youthful despair: I should have come at any price![21]
Trotsky accuses Stalin of scheduling the funeral in a way to prevent Trotsky from being able to attend:
Stalin maneuvered, deceiving not only me but, so it appears, also his allies of the triumvirate. Stalin was guided in his risky maneuvers by more tangible considerations. He might have feared that I would connect Lenin's death with last year's conversation about poison, would ask the doctors whether poisoning was involved, and demand a special autopsy. It was, therefore, safer in all respects to keep me away until after the body had been embalmed, the viscera cremated and a post mortem examination inspired by such suspicions no longer feasible.[22]
Trotsky's chronology ends with Stalin reading his "oath of fealty" over the bier of Lenin, which Trotsky describes as having "now superseded the Ten Commandments".[22]
Reception
Sketch featured in the New York Times article on Stalin by Trotsky. Vasiliev. Stalin and Lenin in 1917
On April 28, 1946, a New York Times article about the release of Trotsky's book was published. The article provides a thorough summary of the book and offers background information about Trotsky and his assassination. The article mentions the significance of the book during the time:
"It now is made available to the public at a moment when the man it attempts to appraise is at the height of his power and influence."[23]
The article also makes note of the editing that had to be done to the book as a result of Trotsky's death, resulting in the majority of the book to be about Stalin's youth rather than his time in power:
The rest was compiled by the editor from "largely raw material," with extensive interpolations of his own. The inevitable result is a certain lack of balance. Stalin's earlier years (up to 1917) have received a much fuller and more systematic treatment than his activities since the establishment of the Soviet regime in Russia. Admirable as Mr. Malamuth's editorial work has been, the later part of the book, dealing with the crucial problem of Stalin's rise to power, has remained rather sketchy and leaves some important points insufficiently developed.[23]
Later editions
In 1948 an edition of Stalin was published in French, edited by Jean van Heijenoort, a former secretary of Trotsky's, in conjunction with Trotsky's friend Alfred Rosmer.[24] Although believed by some to be a more authentic rendition of Trotsky's words, a subsequent comparison of the published French edition to Trotsky's original manuscript revealed the deletion of many pages of Trotsky's own writing, the addition of little of import, and a blurring of Malamuth's commentary with the words of Trotsky through the editorial removal of square brackets from the English edition.[24]
Alan Woods, editor of the second English edition of Stalin.
A Spanish edition also appeared in 1948, based upon the English edition but containing a warning to readers by Natalia Sedova about the editorial changes to the book's content and meaning made by Malamuth.[25] This Spanish edition was republished in Argentina in 1975.[25]
The first Russian edition, edited by Yuri Felshtinsky, was not published until 1985.[25] This two-volume version went back to the original Trotsky manuscript, now housed at Harvard University, and added substantial new content, while deleting a great deal of content previously published in the English edition of the book.[25] This Russian edition aggressively restructured the form of the book, changing the order of paragraphs to enhance readability.[25]
A new English edition saw print in 2016, edited by Alan Woods. This new version followed Felshtinsky's example of restructuring paragraph order, taking the manuscript to pieces and then reassembling it with the addition of all new material at the editor's disposal.[26] Declaring Malamuth's translation to have been "not at all bad," Woods removed all content originating from Malamuth's pen and replaced it, where necessary, with new bridging text of his own — segue material which did not attempt to impose the original ideas of the translator upon the manuscript, as had Malamuth.[27]
In this revised English translation, the decision was made not to interfere with the content of the first part of the book, Chapters 1 through 7, which had been translated for and approved by Trotsky during his life.[28] The second half of the book, however, was radically restructured, with old Chapters 8 through 12 becoming new Chapters 8 through 14 — a change which added 86,000 words to the 106,000 word length of the original.[28]
Editor Woods noted:
If Trotsky had lived, it is very clear that he would have produced an infinitely better work. He would have made a rigorous selection of the raw material. Like an accomplished sculptor he would have polished it and then polished it again, until it reached the dazzling heights of a work of art. We cannot hope to attain such heights. We do not know what material the great man would have selected or rejected. But we feel we are under a historic obligation at least to make available to the world all the material that is available to us."[28]
This revised second edition, approved by the estate of Leon Trotsky, was published in the United Kingdom by Wellred Books in 2016, with an American edition in hardcover and paperback published by Haymarket Books in 2019.[29]
Footnotes
1 2 3 Rob Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," [2016] Chicago: Haymarket Books, 2019, p. xix.
1 2 3 Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," p. xx.
↑ Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," pp. xviii–xix.
1 2 Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," p. xxi.
1 2 3 Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," p. xxii.
1 2 Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," p. xxi.
1 2 Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," p. xxv.
1 2 3 4 Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," p. xvi.
↑ Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," pp. xxvi–xxvii.
1 2 3 Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," p. xxvii.
↑ The words are those of Rob Sewell. See: Sewell, "Background to Trotsky's Stalin," p. xvii–xxviii.
↑ Trotsky, Leon (1941). Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. United States: Harper & Brothers. pp.xi–xv.
↑ Trotsky, Leon (1941). Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. U.S.: Harper & Brothers. p.23.
↑ Trotsky, Leon (1941). Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. U.S.: Harper & Brothers. pp.55–84.
↑ Trotsky, Leon. Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. p.62.
↑ Trotsky, Leon. Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. p.66.
↑ Trotsky, Leon. Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence.
↑ Trotsky, Leon. Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. pp.372–383.
↑ Trotsky, Leon. Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. p.373.
↑ Trotsky, Leon. Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. p.375.
↑ Trotsky, Leon. Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. p.381.
1 2 Trotsky, Leon. Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and his Influence. p.382.
1 2 Karpovich, Michael (April 28, 1946). "Stalin by Trotsky". New York Times.
1 2 Alan Woods, "Editor's Note" [2016], in Leon Trotsky, Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and His Influence. Chicago: Haymarket Books, 2019; p. xxxi.
Lev Davidovich Bronstein, better known as Leon Trotsky, was a Russian-born revolutionary, Soviet politician, and political theorist. Along with Vladimir Lenin, he was a central figure in the October Revolution and establishment of the Soviet Union. Ideologically a Marxist and a Leninist, Trotsky's thought and writings inspired a school of Marxism known as Trotskyism.
Henri Barbusse was a French novelist, short story writer, journalist, poet and political activist. He began his literary career in the 1890s as a Symbolist poet and continued as a neo-Naturalist novelist; in 1916, he published Under Fire, a novel about the World War I based on his experience which is described as one of the earliest works of the Lost Generation movement or as the work which started it; the novel had a major impact on the later writers of the movement, namely on Ernest Hemingway and Erich Maria Remarque. Barbusse is considered as one of the important French writers of 1910–1939 who mingled the war memories with moral and political meditations.
Max Shachtman was an American Marxist theorist. He went from being an associate of Leon Trotsky to a social democrat and mentor of senior assistants to AFL–CIO President George Meany.
Lenin's Testament is a document dictated by Vladimir Lenin in late 1922 and early 1923. In the testament, Lenin proposed changes to the structure of the Soviet governing bodies. Sensing his impending death, he also gave criticism of Bolshevik leaders Zinoviev, Kamenev, Trotsky, Bukharin, Pyatakov and Stalin. He warned of the possibility of a split developing in the party leadership between Trotsky and Stalin if proper measures were not taken to prevent it. In a post-script he also suggested Joseph Stalin be removed from his position as General Secretary of the Russian Communist Party's Central Committee. Although there are some historical questions regarding the document’s origins, the majority view is that the document was authored by Lenin.
Victor Serge, born Victor Lvovich Kibalchich, was a Russian revolutionary Marxist, novelist, poet and historian. Originally an anarchist, he joined the Bolsheviks five months after arriving in Petrograd in January 1919 and later worked for the Comintern as a journalist, editor and translator. He was critical of the Stalinist regime and remained a revolutionary Marxist until his death. He is best remembered for his Memoirs of a Revolutionary and series of seven "witness-novels" chronicling the lives of Soviet people and revolutionaries and of the first half of the 20th century.
Dmitri Antonovich Volkogonov was a Soviet and Russian historian and colonel general who was head of the Soviet military's psychological warfare department. After research in secret Soviet archives, he published a biography of Joseph Stalin and Vladimir Lenin, among others such as Leon Trotsky. Despite being a committed Stalinist and Marxist–Leninist ideologue for most of his career, Volkogonov came to repudiate communism and the Soviet system within the last decade of his life before his death from cancer in 1995.
Zinaida Lvovna Volkova was a Russian Marxist. She was Leon Trotsky's first daughter by his first wife, Aleksandra Sokolovskaya, a Marxist from Nikolaev (Ukraine). She was raised by her aunt Yelizaveta, sister of Trotsky, after their parents divorced. Her younger sister, Nina, stayed with her mother.
Censorship of images was widespread in the Soviet Union. Visual censorship was exploited in a political context, particularly during the political purges of Joseph Stalin, where the Soviet government attempted to erase some of the purged figures from Soviet history, and took measures which included altering images and destroying film. The USSR curtailed access to pornography, which was specifically prohibited by Soviet law.
The 5th Congress of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party was held in London between May 13 and June 1, 1907. The 5th Congress had the largest attendance of the Congresses of the unified RSDLP. Thirty-five sessions of the Congress were held in the Brotherhood Church in Hackney, during which stormy debates took place.
The History of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks): Short Course, translated to English under the title History of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks): Short Course, is a textbook on the history of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks), first published in 1938. Colloquially known as the Short Course, it became the most widely disseminated book during the time that Joseph Stalin served as the General Secretary of the Central Committee of the AUCP (B) and one of the most important works elucidating Marxism–Leninism.
David King was a British graphic designer, design historian, and writer, who assembled one of the largest collections of Soviet graphics and photographs. From this collection, he created a series of books covering the history of the Russian Revolution and its associated art and propaganda. In addition to Soviet-era photographs, posters, and other materials, his collection included items related to the Spanish Civil War, Maoist China, the Weimar Republic, and American labour organizations. King, a "leftist with Trotskyist leanings", in particular collected photographs and ephemera related to Leon Trotsky, who was extensively doctored out of revolutionary photographs and records under Josef Stalin's regime.
Max Forrester Eastman was an American writer on literature, philosophy and society, a poet and a prominent political activist. Moving to New York City for graduate school, Eastman became involved with radical circles in Greenwich Village. He supported socialism and became a leading patron of the Harlem Renaissance and an activist for a number of liberal and radical causes. For several years, he edited The Masses. With his sister Crystal Eastman, he co-founded in 1917 The Liberator, a radical magazine of politics and the arts.
Marxism and the National Question is a short work of Marxist theory written by Joseph Stalin in January 1913 while living in Vienna. First published as a pamphlet and frequently reprinted, the essay by the ethnic Georgian Stalin was regarded as a seminal contribution to Marxist analysis of the nature of nationality and helped to establish his reputation as an expert on the topic. Stalin would later become the first People's Commissar of Nationalities following the victory of the Bolshevik Party in the October Revolution of 1917.
Grigory Yevseyevich Zinoviev was a Russian revolutionary and Soviet politician. An Old Bolshevik, Zinoviev was a prominent figure in the leadership of the early Soviet Union, and served as chairman of the Communist International (Comintern) from 1919 to 1926.
Lev Borisovich Kamenev was a Bolshevik revolutionary and a prominent Soviet politician.
The Revolution Betrayed: What Is the Soviet Union and Where Is It Going? is a book published in 1936 by the exiled Soviet Bolshevik leader Leon Trotsky. This work analyzed and criticized the course of historical development in the Soviet Union following the death of Vladimir Lenin in 1924 and is regarded as Trotsky's primary work dealing with the nature of Stalinism. The book was written by Trotsky during his exile in Norway and was originally translated into Spanish by Victor Serge. The most widely available English translation is by Max Eastman.
Socialism in one country was a Soviet state policy to strengthen socialism within the country rather than socialism globally. Given the defeats of the 1917–1923 European communist revolutions, Joseph Stalin encouraged the theory of the possibility of constructing socialism in the Soviet Union. The theory was eventually adopted as Soviet state policy.
The following is a chronological list of books by Leon Trotsky, a Marxist theoretician, including hardcover and paperback books and pamphlets published during his life and posthumously during the years immediately following his assassination in the summer of 1940. Included are the original Russian or German language titles and publication information, as well as the name and publication information of the first English language edition.
Charles Malamuth was an American journalist, writer, and translator known as an "expert in Slavic languages," "Russian expert," and anticommunist. His best known over the years as translator of Stalin: An Appraisal of the Man and His Influence by Leon Trotsky (1941) for which Soviet communists attacked him as a Trotskyite in the 1940s and Trotskyites attacked him as an anticommunist in the 2010s.
Foundations of Leninism was a 1924 collection made by Joseph Stalin that consisted of nine lectures he delivered at Sverdlov University that year. It was published by the Soviet newspaper, Pravda.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
