List of Indy Eleven records and statistics

Last updated

Indy Eleven are an American professional soccer team based in Indianapolis.

Contents

This list encompasses the major records set by the club and their players in both the North American Soccer League (2014–2017) and USL Championship (2018–present).

Player records

Appearances

Ayoze Garcia is the club's record holder for games played (126), started (106) and assists (22). CINvIND 2018-09-29 - Ayoze (44459868104) (cropped).jpg
Ayoze Garcia is the club's record holder for games played (126), started (106) and assists (22).
As of August 25, 2025.

Competitive matches only, includes appearances as substitute. Numbers in parentheses indicate goals scored.

NameYearsSigned fromLeaguePlayoffsU.S. Open CupUSL CupTotal
1 Flag of Spain.svg Ayoze Garcia 2018–2022 New York Cosmos 120 (13)4 (0)2 (0)126 (13)
2 Flag of the United States.svg Brad Ring 2014–2018 Portland Timbers 109 (4)2 (0)4 (0)115 (4)
3 Flag of Canada (Pantone).svg Karl Ouimette 2018–2022 San Francisco Deltas 100 (7)4 (1)4 (0)108 (8)
4 Flag of the United States.svg Cameron Lindley 2020, 2023–present Orlando City SC, Colorado Springs Switchbacks 90 (2)1 (0)8 (0)5 (0)104 (2)
5 Flag of Jamaica.svg Don Smart 2014–2017 RVA FC 95 (10)2 (0)4 (0)101 (10)
6 Flag of Trinidad and Tobago.svg Neveal Hackshaw 2019–2022 Charleston Battery 88 (7)3 (0)2 (0)93 (7)
7 Flag of the United States.svg Dylan Mares 2014–2016,
2018
Indiana Hoosiers,
Miami FC 2
85 (12)2 (0)5 (1)92 (13)
8 Flag of Scotland.svg Jack Blake 2023–present San Diego Loyal 76 (20)1 (0)7 (1)5 (1)89 (22)
9 Flag of the United States.svg Marco Franco 2014,
2015–2017
Chicago Fire 82 (0)2 (0)4 (0)88 (0)
10 Flag of the United States.svg Tyler Gibson 2019–2020,
2024
FC Cincinnati,
Louisville City
71 (2)3 (0)5 (0)79 (2)

Bold denotes players still playing for the club.

Goals

Eamon Zayed scored 27 goals in 63 games during his two years with the club. Eamon Zayed.jpg
Éamon Zayed scored 27 goals in 63 games during his two years with the club.
As of August 25, 2025.

Competitive matches only. Numbers in parentheses indicate appearances made.

NameYearsSigned fromLeaguePlayoffsU.S. Open CupUSL CupTotal
1 Flag of Libya.svg Éamon Zayed 2016–2017 Sabah 26 (59)0 (2)1 (2)27 (63)
2 Flag of Canada (Pantone).svg Tyler Pasher 2018–2020 Sporting Kansas City 22 (57)2 (3)0 (2)24 (62)
3 Flag of Scotland.svg Jack Blake 2023–present San Diego Loyal 20 (76)0 (1)1 (7)1 (5)22 (89)
4 Flag of the United States.svg Justin Braun 2016–2018 Sacramento Republic 18 (60)0 (3)1 (4)19 (67)
5 Flag of Uruguay.svg Sebastián Guenzatti 2023–2024 Tampa Bay Rowdies 16 (62)0 (1)0 (6)16 (69)
6 Flag of Venezuela.svg Manuel Arteaga 2021–2022 Zamora 15 (53)0 (0)0 (0)15 (53)
7 Flag of the United States.svg Aodhan Quinn 2023–present Phoenix Rising 12 (59)1 (1)0 (4)1 (5)14 (69)
8 Flag of Sierra Leone.svg Augustine Williams 2024 Charleston Battery 10 (32)0 (1)3 (5)13 (38)
Flag of Brazil.svg Stéfano Pinho 2022–2023 Austin Bold 13 (50)0 (1)0 (1)13 (52)
Flag of Spain.svg Ayoze García 2018–2022 New York Cosmos 13 (120)0 (4)0 (2)13 (126)
Flag of the United States.svg Dylan Mares 2014–2016,
2018
Indiana Hoosiers,
Miami FC 2
12 (85)0 (2)1 (5)13 (92)

Bold denotes players still playing for the club.

Clean Sheets

Jon Busch kept a record 19 clean sheets over two seasons with the club. Jon Busch 2 (cropped).jpg
Jon Busch kept a record 19 clean sheets over two seasons with the club.
As of August 25, 2025.

Competitive matches only. Numbers in parentheses indicate appearances made.

NameYearsSigned fromLeaguePlayoffsU.S. Open CupUSL CupTotal
1 Flag of the United States.svg Jon Busch 2016–2017 Chicago Fire 17 (59)2 (2)0 (1)19 (62)
2 Flag of the United States.svg Hunter Sulte 2024–present Portland Timbers 13 (44)0 (1)2 (5)1 (4)16 (54)
3 Flag of the United States.svg Evan Newton 2019–2020 FC Cincinnati 13 (42)0 (0)1 (1)14 (43)
4 Flag of the United States.svg Jordan Farr 2018–2021 Portland Timbers U23 9 (31)2 (3)1 (2)12 (36)
5 Flag of Wales (1959-present).svg Owain Fôn Williams 2018 Inverness CT 11 (34)0 (1)0 (1)11 (36)
6 Flag of the United States.svg Tim Trilk 2022–2023 Chattanooga Red Wolves 9 (30)0 (1)0 (1)9 (32)
7 Flag of Germany.svg Yannik Oettl 2023–2024 New England Revolution II 6 (28)0 (0)1 (3)7 (31)
8 Flag of Germany.svg Kristian Nicht 2014–2015 Rochester Rhinos 7 (47)0 (0)0 (3)7 (50)
9 Flag of the United States.svg Elliot Panicco 2022 Nashville SC 2 (10)0 (0)0 (0)2 (10)
Flag of Grenada.svg Reice Charles-Cook 2025–present Welling United FC 0 (2)0 (0)1 (2)1 (1)2 (5)
11 Flag of the United States.svg Eric Dick 2021 Columbus Crew 1 (4)0 (0)0 (0)1 (4)

Bold denotes players still playing for the club.

Managerial records

As of August 4, 2025.

Includes USL Regular Season, USL Playoffs, U.S. Open Cup & USL Cup. Excludes friendlies.

NameFromToPWDLGSGA%WHonors
Flag of the United States.svg Juergen Sommer June 11, 2013June 2, 2015 [1] 38813174963021.05
Flag of the United States.svg Tim Regan (interim)June 2, 2015 [1] December 2, 2015 [2] 2275102637031.82
Flag of the United States.svg Tim Hankinson December 2, 2015 [2] November 28, 2017 [3] 692424219489034.78(1) NASL Spring Season
Flag of Scotland.svg Martin Rennie January 16, 2018 [4] June 16, 2021 [5] 99453519126108045.45
Flag of England.svg Mark Lowry November 16, 2021 [6] November 28, 2023 [7] 7226153190102036.11
Flag of England.svg Sean McAuley January 8, 2024 [8] Present622816189587045.16

P – Total of played matches W – Won matches D – Drawn matches L – Lost matches GS – Goals scored GA – Goals against
%W – Percentage of matches won

References

  1. 1 2 "REGAN IN AS INTERIM HEAD COACH". indyeleven.com. Indy Eleven. June 2, 2015. Archived from the original on July 7, 2015. Retrieved May 13, 2016.
  2. 1 2 "Tim Hankinson Takes Over Indy Eleven Head Coaching Position". nasl.com. Retrieved December 11, 2015.
  3. Kennedy, Paul. "Tim Hankinson won't return as Indy Eleven's head coach". SoccerAmerica. Retrieved November 29, 2017.
  4. "RENNIE TO LEAD INDY ELEVEN AS HEAD COACH". indyeleven.com. Indy Eleven Communications. January 16, 2018. Retrieved January 16, 2018.
  5. "INDY ELEVEN AND HEAD COACH MARTIN RENNIE MUTUALLY AGREE TO PART WAYS". indyeleven.com. Indy Eleven Communications. June 16, 2021. Retrieved June 16, 2021.
  6. Indy Eleven Communications. "INDY ELEVEN INSTALLS MARK LOWRY AS HEAD COACH". Indy Eleven Press Release. Retrieved November 16, 2021.
  7. "Indy Eleven, Head Coach Mark Lowry Part Ways". Indy Eleven. Retrieved November 4, 2024.
  8. "Indy Eleven Announces Sean McAuley as Head Coach". Indy Eleven. Retrieved November 4, 2024.