| Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Site | MVP | Reference |
|---|
| 1992 | Iona (1) | 0–0†
(3–2 pen.) | Loyola (MD) | | Cindy Waldman, Iona | |
| 1993 | Fairfield (1) | 0–0†
(2–0 pen.) | Loyola (MD) | | Christen Veach, Fairfield | |
| 1994 | Loyola (MD) (1) | 2–1 | Canisius | | Betsy Given, Loyola (MD) | |
| 1995 | Fairfield (2) | 0–0†
(3–0 pen.) | Loyola (MD) | | Christen Veach, Fairfield | |
| 1996 | Loyola (MD) (2) | 2–0 | Siena | | Cara Mooney, Loyola (MD) | |
| 1997 | Fairfield (3) | 1–0*(OT) | Loyola (MD) | | Anne Lyons, Fairfield | |
| 1998 | Fairfield (4) | 1–0*(OT) | Loyola (MD) | | Pam Cluff, Fairfield | |
| 1999 | Fairfield (5) | 1–1†
(4–3 pen.) | Loyola (MD) | | Patrice Bourke, Fairfield | |
| 2000 | Loyola (MD) (3) | 2–1 | Fairfield | | Kathleen Shields, Loyola (MD) | |
| 2001 | Loyola (MD) (4) | 1–0 | Marist | | Katie Elliot, Loyola (MD) | |
| 2002 | Loyola (MD) (5) | 3–0 | Rider | | Audra Garuccio, Loyola (MD) | |
| 2003 | Loyola (MD) (6) | 2–0 | Niagara | | Carolyn Kennington, Loyola (MD) | |
| 2004 | Loyola (MD) (7) | 2–0 | Rider | | Lindsey Tracey, Loyola (MD) | |
| 2005 | Fairfield (6) | 2–1 | Niagara | | Alex Caram, Fairfield | |
| 2006 | Niagara (1) | 2–1 | Siena | | Brittany Bisnott, Niagara | |
| 2007 | Loyola (MD) (8) | 2–0 | Marist | Tenney Stadium • Poughkeepsie, New York | Brittany Henderson, Loyola (MD) | [3] |
| 2008 | Fairfield (7) | 3–0 | Loyola (MD) | Siena Field • Loudonville, New York | Ahna Johnson, Fairfield | [4] |
| 2009 | Loyola (MD) (9) | 3–2 | Niagara | ESPN Wide World of Sports Complex • Lake Buena Vista, Florida | Gianna Mangione, Loyola (MD) | [5] |
| 2010 | Siena (1) | 1–0*(OT) | Canisius | Demske Sports Complex • Buffalo, New York | Tabitha Tice, Siena | [6] |
| 2011 | Marist(1) | 1–0 | Loyola (MD) | Ridley Athletic Complex • Baltimore, Maryland | Amanda Epstein, Marist | [7] |
| 2012 | Loyola (MD) (10) | 2–1 | Marist | Tenney Stadium • Poughkeepsie, New York | Gigi Mangione, Loyola (MD) | [8] |
| 2013 | Monmouth (1) | 2–0 | Fairfield | ESPN Wide World of Sports Complex • Lake Buena Vista, Florida | Ashley Lewis, Monmouth | [9] |
| 2014 | Rider (1) | 1–1†
(5–4 pen.) | Fairfield | Hesse Field • West Long Branch, New Jersey | Bethany-May Howard, Rider | [10] |
| 2015 | Siena (2) | 5–2 | Manhattan | Allison Clark, Siena | [11] |
| 2016 | Monmouth(2) | 5–2 | Quinnipiac | Miranda Konstantinides, Monmouth | [12] |
| 2017 | Monmouth(3) | 5–1 | Manhattan | ESPN Wide World of Sports Complex • Lake Buena Vista, Florida | Allie Girardi, Monmouth | [13] |
| 2018 | Monmouth(4) | 7–1 | Siena | Hesse Field • West Long Branch, New Jersey | Madie Gibson, Monmouth | [14] |
| 2019 | Monmouth(5) | 6–0 | Fairfield | Sarina Jones, Monmouth | [15] |
| 2020 | Siena(3) | 0–0†
(4–2 pen.) | Monmouth | Tenney Stadium • Poughkeepsie, New York | Emily McNelis, Siena | [16] |
| 2021 | Monmouth(6) | 4–0 | Quinnipiac | Hesse Field • West Long Branch, New Jersey | Lauren Karabin, Monmouth | [17] |
| 2022 | Quinnipiac(1) | 4–0 | Niagara | Quinnipiac Soccer Stadium • Hamden, Connecticut | Rebecca Cooke, Quinnipiac | [18] |
| 2023 | Quinnipiac(2) | 1–0 | Fairfield | Courtney Chochol, Quinnipiac | [19] [20] |
| 2024 | Fairfield(8) | 1–0 | Quinnipiac | Lessing Field • Fairfield, CT | Maddy Theriault, Fairfield | [21] [22] |
