Plot
 | This episode's plot summary may be too long or excessively detailed.(January 2019) |
2012
Johnny Morgan breaks into the boarded-up asylum, listening to an audiobook called Tales from Briarcliff, written and read by Lana. He imagines her telling him she could not wait to give him up and that he should never have been born. As she relates via audio that Oliver Thredson was an "unspeakable monster", Johnny imagines Thredson telling him that he loved him and that Lana kept them apart.
Then, Leo and Teresa enter the asylum as seen in "Welcome to Briarcliff". They end up at the cell where Johnny waits inside. He puts on the Bloody Face mask, pulls out a machete, and chops off Leo's arm holding the camera-phone.
1971
Lana has become a television investigative reporter. She and her camera crew sneak into the asylum via the tunnel to film Briarcliff Exposed. She plans on rescuing Sister Jude after learning she was still alive. They film in the former kitchen, where an attendant catches them. Lana asks about Jude and imagines rescuing her, when, in reality, Jude had already been released. Lana goes to the office, searching through files scattered on the floor, to find Jude's file. She then goes to Kit Walker's residence after learning he was the one who got Jude out of Briarcliff. He relates to her what happened to Jude after he brought her home.
Kit helped Jude through detox of the asylum medication. She then relapsed into an insane authoritarian and chased his children, Thomas and Julia, with a broom. He tried to send the kids out of the room to protect them, but instead they both led Jude by hand out to the nearby woods. Later, with her mind inexplicably healed, Jude bonds with the family, becoming a surrogate grandmother to the children. Jude is truly happy for the first time in her life. Six months later, Jude suddenly dies due to a kiss from the Angel of Death, which she is finally ready for.
2013
Lana is getting ready for a television interview about her career. The interview is held in her spacious New York City apartment where she lives with her new life-partner, Marian, a famous opera singer who leaves for work. The young interviewer, April Mayfield, wishes to begin by discussing Oliver Thredson, but Lana refuses by saying he has become a "household name" and is undeserving of further mention. They instead discuss Lana's career change from print to television and her exposé of Briarcliff. April praises her for shutting down the asylum, but Lana wished for a different ending to the piece by finding Jude there. Lana momentarily stops the interview and asks for water, which is delivered by a member of the crew – Johnny.
The interview resumes with Lana's exposure of Timothy Howard in the 1970s (he had since been anointed as the Cardinal of New York), with his knowledge of Dr. Arden's experiments and the general mistreatment of the asylum patients. Howard denied the allegations on camera but later kills himself at home by slashing his wrists in a bathtub. April listens as Lana admits to lying in her book about her baby's death as well as certain details about her life and sexual orientation. Lana mentions saving Johnny as a boy from a bully in the 1970s. She chose not to stay in touch with him but often thought about him.
Lana also mentions Kit developing pancreatic cancer in the 1980s, and that one day he just disappeared, never to be seen again. It is shown that Kit was in fact taken from his home by aliens. April ends the interview for the day and she and her crew leave Lana alone in the apartment, but Lana pours two drinks. She knows someone has stayed behind – Johnny. She knew who he was after the police previously showed his picture to her. They were investigating someone breaking into Thredson's former house in Massachusetts, killing the occupants, and living in it. Johnny tells her that he knew she was his mother after she approached him that day on the playground when he was a boy.
His hatred and resentment towards his mother began when he purchased Thredson's taped confession to her online, and Thredson begged Lana not to abort the pregnancy. He puts a gun to her head, but she convinces him that he is not a killer like his father. Feeling the guilt of his crimes, Johnny finally snaps as he lowers the gun and breaks down in tears, admitting that he's hurt everyone in his way. Lana tells him that it's not his fault before turning the gun on him, insisting that it's her fault, and proceeds to shoot him in the head, killing him.
1964
Flashing back to the events of the season premiere, shortly after Lana visited Briarcliff, Sister Jude cautions Lana about her desire to question a killer coming into the asylum. Prior to both of them leaving, Jude states, "If you look in the face of evil, evil's going to look right back at you." Lana simply looks at Jude and smiles. The Virgin Mary statue is seen while Sister Jude smiles and "Dominique" begins playing.
