Reception
"Flicker" was watched by 2.64 million people during its original broadcast, and gained a 1.4 ratings share among adults aged 18–49. [1] It also ranked second in the Nielsen Social ratings, with 115,000 tweets seen by over 1.12 million people. [2]
The episode received critical acclaim. It has earned a 100% approval rating based on 12 reviews, with an average score of 8.53/10, on review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes. The critical consensus reads: ""Flicker" is an especially enjoyable and tightly scripted episode of Hotel, presenting an intriguing backstory for Lady Gaga's Countess character." [3] Alex Stedman from Variety complimented "Flicker" for revealing more backstory about Gaga's character, as well as secrets hidden in the titular hotel. He added, "Most importantly, though, we learn even more about the Countess' backstory and, for the first time, see her pre-ancient blood virus. And, in a rare occasion, we see her genuinely, truly scared." [4] Another positive review came from Matt Fowler of IGN who rated the episode 7.6 on 10, and believed that the "strongest" plots of Hotel were surrounding those of Evan Peters' James March character. He also complimented that the Countess' storyline was expanded and the connections were established. However, Fowler believed Gaga's acting needed improvement with her dialogue delivery. [5]
Michael Calia from The Wall Street Journal described the episode as "[conjuring] a version of Hollywood history soaked in blood, sex and treachery. You know, like actual Hollywood history, except involving the undead". [6] Emily L. Stephens from The A.V. Club gave it a rating of A−, giving positive review for the plotline, the time utilization and the "tight narrative", complimenting Gaga, Bates and Peters' acting. She ended the review with her observation saying, "The characters of "Flicker" are seduced by the allure of immortality. They strive to become gods, if not through the flicker of film and the adoration of the masses, then by sacrificing their humanity." [7]
Writing for Entertainment Weekly , Darren Franch complimented one line spoken by Bates, "I couldn't pick my butthole out of a lineup", in reference to the character Will Drake getting his anus waxed, and wrote, "What a line! I would take a whole episode of American Horror Story that was just every member of the cast stepping into the spotlight on a darkened stage, clearing their throat, and intoning." [8] The line was also commended by Lacy Baugher from The Baltimore Sun. However, Baugher felt that Denis O'Hare and Angela Bassett were underutilized. [9] Ryan Sandoval from TV.com commended the backstory of the characters in the episode, adding that the "episode was essentially showing us the bare-bones theme of the whole season like a corpse dunked in an acid bath: the cost of fame". [10] Danielle Henderson from Cosmopolitan gave a positive review to the portrayal of Valentino and the fan reactions surrounding his death in the episode, as well as his fictional portrayal as a vampire. However, Henderson criticized Gaga's emotionless delivery and her makeup in the scene with Peters. [11]
