Maksutov telescope

Last updated
A 150mm aperture Maksutov-Cassegrain telescope Maksutov 150mm.jpg
A 150mm aperture Maksutov–Cassegrain telescope

The Maksutov (also called a "Mak") [1] is a catadioptric telescope design that combines a spherical mirror with a weakly negative meniscus lens in a design that takes advantage of all the surfaces being nearly "spherically symmetrical". [2] The negative lens is usually full diameter and placed at the entrance pupil of the telescope (commonly called a "corrector plate" or "meniscus corrector shell"). The design corrects the problems of off-axis aberrations such as coma found in reflecting telescopes while also correcting chromatic aberration. It was patented in 1941 by Soviet optician Dmitri Dmitrievich Maksutov. [3] [4] Maksutov based his design on the idea behind the Schmidt camera of using the spherical errors of a negative lens to correct the opposite errors in a spherical primary mirror. The design is most commonly seen in a Cassegrain variation, with an integrated secondary, that can use all-spherical elements, thereby simplifying fabrication. Maksutov telescopes have been sold on the amateur market since the 1950s.

Contents

Invention

Dmitry Dmitrievich Maksutov Dmitri Maxutow Leutnant.jpg
Dmitry Dmitrievich Maksutov

Dmitri Maksutov may have been working with the idea of pairing a spherical primary mirror in conjunction with a negative meniscus lens as far back as 1936. His notes from that time on the function of Mangin mirrors, an early catadioptric spotlight reflector consisting of negative lens with silvering on the back side, include a sketch of a Mangin mirror with the mirror part and the negative lens separated into two elements. [5] Maksutov seems to have picked up the idea again in 1941 as a variation on an earlier design that paired a spherical mirror with a negative lens, Bernhard Schmidt's 1931 "Schmidt camera". [3] [4] Maksutov claimed to have come up with the idea of replacing the complex Schmidt corrector plate with an all-spherical "meniscus corrector plate" while riding in a train of refugees from Leningrad. [6] Maksutov is described as patenting his design in May, [6] August, or October 1941 [7] and building a "Maksutov–Gregorian"-style prototype in October 1941. [7] Maksutov came up with the unique idea using an "achromatic corrector", a corrector made of a single type of glass with a weak negative meniscus shape that departed from the pure concentric spherical symmetrical shape to correct chromatic aberration. [8]

Similar independent meniscus telescope designs were also patented in 1941: Albert Bouwers (his 1941 concentric meniscus telescope), K. Penning [9] and Dennis Gabor (a catadioptric non-monocentric design). [10] Wartime secrecy kept these inventors from knowing about each other's designs, leading to each being an independent invention.

Derivative designs

Maksutov's 1944 design was the first-published meniscus telescope design, and was published in the widely-read Journal of the Optical Society of America . [11] [12] [7] This led to professional and amateur designers almost immediately experimenting with variations, including Newtonian, Cassegrain, and wide-field camera designs.

Maksutov–Cassegrains

There are many Maksutov designs that use a Cassegrain configuration, mounting a convex secondary mirror near the focus of the primary mirror. Most types use full-aperture correctors and are therefore not very large, since the corrector plate rapidly becomes prohibitively large, heavy and expensive as the aperture increases, with very long cool-down times to reach optimal optical performance. Most commercial manufacturers usually stop at 180 mm (7 in).

Gregory or "spot" Maksutov–Cassegrains

Light path in a typical "Gregory" or "spot" Maksutov-Cassegrain. Maksutov spot cassegrain.png
Light path in a typical "Gregory" or "spot" Maksutov–Cassegrain.

Maksutov's design notes from 1941 explored the possibility of a 'folded' Cassegrain-type construction with a secondary silvered "spot" on the convex side of the meniscus facing the primary mirror. [7] He thought this would create a sealed and rugged optical system suitable for use in schools. [7] This design appeared commercially in Lawrence Braymer's 1954 Questar telescope and in PerkinElmer designer John Gregory's competing patent for a Maksutov–Cassegrain. Commercial use of Gregory's design was explicitly reserved for Perkin–Elmer but was published as an amateur telescope design in a 1957 issue of Sky and Telescope in f/15 and f/23 variations. Most Maksutovs manufactured today are this type of 'Cassegrain' design (called either a "Gregory–Maksutov" [13] or "Spot-Maksutov") that use all-spherical surfaces and have, as secondary, a small aluminized spot on the inner face of the corrector. This has the advantage of simplifying construction. It also has the advantage of fixing the alignment of the secondary and eliminates the need for a 'spider' that would cause diffraction spikes. The disadvantage is that, if all spherical surfaces are used, such systems have to have focal ratios above f/15 to avoid aberrations. [14] Also, a degree of freedom in correcting the optical system by changing the radius of curvature of the secondary is lost, since that radius is the same as that of the rear meniscus face. Gregory himself, in a second, faster (f/15) design, resorted to aspherization of the front corrector surface (or the primary mirror) in order to reduce aberrations. This has led to other designs with aspheric or additional elements to further reduce off-axis aberration. [15] This type of Maksutov-Cassegrain's high focal ratio and narrower field of view makes them more suitable for lunar and planetary imaging and any other type of observing where a narrow field high power view is a plus, such as resolving tightly packed globular clusters and double stars.

Meade ETX "spot" Maksutov-Cassegrain. Maksutov cassegrain comercial.png
Meade ETX "spot" Maksutov–Cassegrain.

The most notable early amateur astronomical type was the Questar 3-1/2 Maksutov Cassegrain introduced in 1954, a small-run, expensive model still available on the consumer market. The mid-1970s saw the introduction of mass-produced models by some of the major commercial manufacturers. More recently, low-cost Russian and, lately, Chinese mass-production has pushed the prices down even further. Many manufacturers currently produce Maksutov–Cassegrains, such as Explore Scientific, Intes, Intes-Micro, LOMO, Orion Optics, Telescope Engineering Company (TEC), Vixen, the Meade Instruments's ETX line, and the Synta Taiwan produced Celestron, Sky-Watcher and Orion Telescopes lines.

The spot Maksutov–Cassegrain design has been used extensively in military, industrial, and aerospace applications. Since all of the optical elements can be permanently fixed in alignment and the tube assembly can be environmentally sealed, the design is extremely rugged. That makes it ideal for tracking, remote viewing, and radar calibration / boresighting, where instruments are subjected to severe environments and high g-forces.

Rutten Maksutov–Cassegrains

Light path in a typical Rutten Maksutov-Cassegrain. Diagram Reflector RuttenMaksutov.svg
Light path in a typical Rutten Maksutov–Cassegrain.

The Rutten Maksutov–Cassegrain (also called a Rumak or Sigler Maksutov) [16] has a separate secondary mirror mounted on the inner surface of the meniscus corrector, sometimes similar to the corrector/mirror holder configurations found in commercial Schmidt–Cassegrains. This provides an extra degree of freedom in correcting aberration by changing the curvature of the corrector and the secondary independently. Specifically it allows the designer to aspherize the secondary to provide a much wider flat field than traditional spot Maksutovs, with less off-axis coma. Mounting the secondary on the corrector also limits diffraction spikes. This version is named after the work of Dutch optical designer Harrie Rutten.

Sub-aperture corrector Maksutov–Cassegrains

Light path in a typical sub-aperture Maksutov-Cassegrain. Diagram sub aperture maksutov cassegrain.svg
Light path in a typical sub-aperture Maksutov–Cassegrain.

Maksutov noted in his designs that instead of using a full-aperture corrector, a small sub-aperture corrector could be placed in the converging light cone of the primary mirror and achieve the same effect. [17] In the 1980s Dave Shafer [17] and Ralph W. Field [18] came out with sub-aperture Cassegrain designs based on this idea. The design reduces the mass and "cool-down time" of a full-aperture corrector. It has the drawbacks of an open, unsealed tube and requires a spider assembly to hold the secondary mirror and corrector, which inevitably affects image quality through diffraction artifacts. Also since the light passes through the corrector twice, the number of surfaces involved is increased, making it difficult to achieve good aberration correction. [19] [20] Sub-aperture corrector Maksutovs are currently manufactured by Vixen telescopes, their VMC (Vixen Maksutov Cassegrain) models.

Maksutov–Newtonians

Maksutovs optics can be used in Newtonian configurations that have minimal aberration over a wide field of view, with one-fourth the coma of a similar standard Newtonian and one-half the coma of a Schmidt-Newtonian. [21] Diffraction can also be minimized by using a high focal ratio with a proportionally small diagonal mirror mounted on the corrector, allowing this design to achieve contrast and image quality approaching that of unobstructed high-end refractors (although with some vignetting when used photographically). [22] Like the Maksutov–Cassegrain, the overall diameter of the optical system is limited, due to the mass of the corrector plate. Synta Taiwan currently produces a 190 mm version under the Sky-Watcher brand as does Explore Scientific with a 152 mm version designed in collaboration with astronomer David Levy.

Maksutov cameras

The Maksutov system can be used in a (rare) type of prime-focus ultra-wide-field astronomical camera design similar to the Schmidt camera. Like the Schmidt camera, the Maksutov camera has a curved focal plane.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ritchey–Chrétien telescope</span> Specialized Cassegrain telescope

A Ritchey–Chrétien telescope is a specialized variant of the Cassegrain telescope that has a hyperbolic primary mirror and a hyperbolic secondary mirror designed to eliminate off-axis optical errors (coma). The RCT has a wider field of view free of optical errors compared to a more traditional reflecting telescope configuration. Since the mid 20th century, a majority of large professional research telescopes have been Ritchey–Chrétien configurations; some well-known examples are the Hubble Space Telescope, the Keck telescopes and the ESO Very Large Telescope.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Optical telescope</span> Telescope for observations with visible light

An optical telescope is a telescope that gathers and focuses light mainly from the visible part of the electromagnetic spectrum, to create a magnified image for direct visual inspection, to make a photograph, or to collect data through electronic image sensors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Reflecting telescope</span> Telescopes which utilize curved mirrors to form an image

A reflecting telescope is a telescope that uses a single or a combination of curved mirrors that reflect light and form an image. The reflecting telescope was invented in the 17th century by Isaac Newton as an alternative to the refracting telescope which, at that time, was a design that suffered from severe chromatic aberration. Although reflecting telescopes produce other types of optical aberrations, it is a design that allows for very large diameter objectives. Almost all of the major telescopes used in astronomy research are reflectors. Many variant forms are in use and some employ extra optical elements to improve image quality or place the image in a mechanically advantageous position. Since reflecting telescopes use mirrors, the design is sometimes referred to as a catoptric telescope.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Newtonian telescope</span> Type of reflecting telescope

The Newtonian telescope, also called the Newtonian reflector or just a Newtonian, is a type of reflecting telescope invented by the English scientist Sir Isaac Newton, using a concave primary mirror and a flat diagonal secondary mirror. Newton's first reflecting telescope was completed in 1668 and is the earliest known functional reflecting telescope. The Newtonian telescope's simple design has made it very popular with amateur telescope makers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Coma (optics)</span> Aberration inherent to certain optical designs or due to imperfection in the lens

In optics, the coma, or comatic aberration, in an optical system refers to aberration inherent to certain optical designs or due to imperfection in the lens or other components that results in off-axis point sources such as stars appearing distorted, appearing to have a tail (coma) like a comet. Specifically, coma is defined as a variation in magnification over the entrance pupil. In refractive or diffractive optical systems, especially those imaging a wide spectral range, coma can be a function of wavelength, in which case it is a form of chromatic aberration.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Schmidt camera</span> Astrophotographic telescope

A Schmidt camera, also referred to as the Schmidt telescope, is a catadioptric astrophotographic telescope designed to provide wide fields of view with limited aberrations. The design was invented by Bernhard Schmidt in 1930.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dmitry Dmitrievich Maksutov</span>

Dmitry Dmitrievich Maksutov was a Soviet optical engineer and amateur astronomer. He is best known as the inventor of the Maksutov telescope.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Catadioptric system</span> Optical system where refraction and reflection are combined

A catadioptric optical system is one where refraction and reflection are combined in an optical system, usually via lenses (dioptrics) and curved mirrors (catoptrics). Catadioptric combinations are used in focusing systems such as searchlights, headlamps, early lighthouse focusing systems, optical telescopes, microscopes, and telephoto lenses. Other optical systems that use lenses and mirrors are also referred to as "catadioptric", such as surveillance catadioptric sensors.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Schmidt–Cassegrain telescope</span> Type of catadioptric telescope

The Schmidt–Cassegrain is a catadioptric telescope that combines a Cassegrain reflector's optical path with a Schmidt corrector plate to make a compact astronomical instrument that uses simple spherical surfaces.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vixen (telescopes)</span> Japanese company

Vixen is a Japanese company that makes telescopes, binoculars, spotting scopes and accessories for their products.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cassegrain reflector</span> Combination of concave and convex mirrors

The Cassegrain reflector is a combination of a primary concave mirror and a secondary convex mirror, often used in optical telescopes and radio antennas, the main characteristic being that the optical path folds back onto itself, relative to the optical system's primary mirror entrance aperture. This design puts the focal point at a convenient location behind the primary mirror and the convex secondary adds a telephoto effect creating a much longer focal length in a mechanically short system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Schmidt–Newtonian telescope</span> Type of catadioptric telescope

A Schmidt–Newtonian telescope or Schmidt–Newton telescope is a catadioptric telescope that combines elements from both the Schmidt camera and the Newtonian telescope. In this telescope design, a spherical primary mirror is combined with a Schmidt corrector plate, which corrects the spherical aberration and holds the secondary mirror. The resulting system has less coma and diffraction effects than a Newtonian telescope with a parabolic mirror and a "spider" secondary mirror support. The design uses a 45° flat secondary mirror to view the image, as in a standard Newtonian telescope.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Argunov–Cassegrain telescope</span> Catadioptric telescope design

The Argunov–Cassegrain telescope is a catadioptric telescope design first introduced in 1972 by P. P. Argunov. All optics are spherical, and the classical Cassegrain secondary mirror is replaced by a sub-aperture secondary corrector group consisting of three air-spaced elements, two lenses and a Mangin mirror.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lurie–Houghton telescope</span>

The Houghton telescope or Lurie–Houghton telescope is a catadioptric telescope. Houghton's original design uses a two-lens corrector at the front of the telescope and a spherical mirror at the back; it was patented in 1944. Instead of the hard to make intricately shaped compound curve Schmidt corrector plate, or the heavy Maksutov-type meniscus corrector lens, the Houghton double-lens corrector is relatively easy to make.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mangin mirror</span> Catadioptric reflector for search lights

In optics, a Mangin mirror is a negative meniscus lens with the reflective surface on the rear side of the glass forming a curved mirror that reflects light without spherical aberration if certain conditions are met. This reflector was invented in 1874 by a French officer Alphonse Mangin as an improved catadioptric reflector for search lights and is also used in other optical devices.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sky-Watcher</span>

Sky-Watcher is a commercial distribution company established in 1999 by the Synta Technology Corporation of Taiwan that markets telescopes and astronomical equipment, like mounts and eyepieces, aimed at the amateur astronomical market. The products are manufactured at Synta Taiwan's Suzhou Synta Optical Technology Co., Ltd. in Suzhou (Jiangsu), China. The brand is distributed in Canada and Europe and, in the late 2000s, was extended to the USA market.

Albert A. Bouwers (1893–1972) was a Dutch optical engineer. He is known for developing and working with X-rays and various optical technologies as a high-level researcher at Philips research labs. He is lesser known for patenting in 1941 a catadioptric meniscus telescope design similar to but slightly predating the Maksutov telescope.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Klevtsov–Cassegrain telescope</span> Type of catadioptric telescope

The Klevtsov–Cassegrain telescope is a type of catadioptric Cassegrain telescope that uses a spherical primary mirror and a sub-aperture secondary corrector group composed of a small lens and a Mangin mirror.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Meniscus corrector</span>

A meniscus corrector is a negative meniscus lens that is used to correct spherical aberration in image-forming optical systems such as catadioptric telescopes. It works by having the equal but opposite spherical aberration of the objective it is designed to correct.

References

  1. Paul E. Kinzer, Stargazing Basics: Getting Started in Recreational Astronomy, Cambridge University Press - 2015, page 43
  2. John J. G. Savard, "Miscellaneous Musings"
  3. 1 2 John Woodruff (2003). Firefly Astronomy Dictionary . Firefly Books. p.  135. ISBN   978-1-55297-837-5.
  4. 1 2 Evolution of the Maksutov design
  5. Dmitri Maksutov: The Man and His Telescope
  6. 1 2 Armstrong, E. B., "Geometrical Optics and the Schmidt Camera", Irish Astronomical Journal, vol. 1(2), p. 48
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 "Dmitri Maksutov: The Man and His Telescopes By Eduard Trigubov and Yuri Petrunin". Archived from the original on 2012-02-22. Retrieved 2009-03-24.
  8. Daniel J. Schroeder (2000). Astronomical Optics. Elsevier Science. p. 202. ISBN   978-0-12-629810-9.
  9. Fritz Blechinger; Bertram Achtner (2005). Handbook of Optical Systems, Volume 4: Survey of Optical Instruments. Wiley. p. 806. ISBN   978-3-527-40380-6.
  10. Rudolf Kingslake (1978). Lens Design Fundamentals. Academic Press. p. 313. ISBN   978-0-12-408650-0.
  11. "History of the Mak-Newt". company7.
  12. Maksutov, Dmitri Dmitrievich (May 1944). "New catadioptric meniscus systems". Journal of the Optical Society of America . 34 (5): 270. doi:10.1364/JOSA.34.000270.
  13. Mullaney, James (26 May 2007). A Buyer's and User's Guide to Astronomical Telescopes & Binoculars. p. 46. ISBN   9781846287077.
  14. Baril, Marc René. "A photovisual Maksutov Cassegrain telescope". Although convenient, this design is limited to focal ratios above f/15 unless an aspheric correction is applied to some element in the optical system.
  15. Rutten, Harrie; van Venrooij, Martin (1988). Telescope Optics: Evaluation and Design. Richmond, VA: Willman–Bell. ISBN   0-943396-18-2.
  16. Baril, Marc René. "A photovisual Maksutov Cassegrain telescope". Archived from the original on 2006-10-29. Retrieved 2007-04-08.
  17. 1 2 Moore, Patrick (26 June 2002). More Small Astronomical Observatories. p. 229. ISBN   9781852335724.
  18. Sinnott, Roger W., ed. (August 1981). "Maksutovs with subaperture correctors". Sky & Telescope. pp. 166–168. Archived from the original on 20 September 2009.
  19. Sacek, Vladimir. "Catadioptric telescopes". telescope-optics.net. Notes on amateur telescope optics. 10.2.1.
  20. Mollise, Rod (28 February 2009). Choosing and using a new CAT: Getting the Most from your Schmidt Cassegrain or any catadioptric telescope. p. 103. ISBN   9780387097725.
  21. Rutten, Harrie G. J.; van Venrooij, Martin A.M. (1988). Telescope Optics: Evaluation and design. ISBN   9780943396187.
  22. Mollise, Rod (28 February 2009). Choosing and Using a New CAT. p. 101. ISBN   9780387097725.