Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam

Last updated
Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam
MeccanTradeAndTheRiseOfIslam.jpg
Cover
Author Patricia Crone
LanguageEnglish
Subject Islam
Published1987 (Gorgias Press)
Media typePrint
ISBN 1-59333-102-9
OCLC 57718221

Meccan Trade And The Rise Of Islam is a 1987 book written by scholar and historiographer of early Islam Patricia Crone. The book argues that Islam did not originate in Mecca, located in western Saudi Arabia, but in northern Arabia. Her views are hugely different from those of historians and orientalist scholars like W. Montgomery Watt and Fred Donner, who have publications detailing trade activities and the struggles between competing Meccan tribes for control over trade routes. [1] [ page needed ] [2] [ page needed ] [3] [ page needed ] [4] [ page needed ] [5] [ page needed ]

Contents

Content

Crone found no evidence of Mecca being an important trading center in late antiquity of 6th and 7th century CE:

If it is obvious that if the Meccans had been middlemen in a long-distance trade of the kind described in traditional Islamic literature, there ought to have been some mention of it in the writings of their customers who wrote extensively about the south Arabians who supplied them with aromatics. Despite the considerable attention paid to Arabian affairs there is no mention at all of Quraysh (the tribe of Mohammed) and their trading center Mecca, be it in the Greek, Latin, Syriac, Aramaic, Coptic, or other literature composed outside Arabia. [10]

She concludes that "Meccans did not trade outside of Mecca on the eve of Islam". [11] That there was no continuous transmission of historical fact through the three generations or so that separated the early first/seventh century from the mid-second/eight century" and that the lines of transmission of the accounts were "pure fabrications". [12]

Crone also found Islamic "traditions" to be unreliable, conflicting "with each other so often and so regularly `that one could were one so inclined, rewrite most of Montgomery Watt's biography of Muhammad in the reverse.'" [13]

An examination of all available evidence and sources leads Crone to conclude that Mohammed's career took place not in Mecca and Medina or in southwest Arabia at all, but in northwest Arabia.

Reception

Robert Bertram Serjeant described the book as a "confused, irrational and illogical polemic, further complicated by her misunderstanding of Arabic texts, her lack of comprehension of the social structure of Arabia, and twisting of the clear sense of other writings, ancient and modern, to suit her contentions." [14]

Abdullah al-Andalusi of the Muslim Debate Initiative contended Crone's placing Islamic events not in Mecca, but closer to the Mediterranean Sea, stating: "If there was a proto-Islamic sect pre-dating Meccan Islam existing at Abdat or elsewhere in Nabatean borderland between Arabia and the Roman Empire, an advanced and literate society with extensive trade links with the rest of the Roman world, it is surely utterly implausible that no sect, nor text of a sect, nor witness to the sect would have survived." [15]

Fred Donner, on the other hand, stated that "[the] assumption that Mecca was the linchpin of international luxury trade [has] been decisively challenged in recent years – notably in Patricia Crone, Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam.", [16] although Patricia Crone's theory has been challenged by Robert Bertram Serjeant who favored the Meccan trade theory. [17]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Religion in pre-Islamic Arabia</span>

Religion in pre-Islamic Arabia included indigenous Arabian polytheism, ancient Semitic religions, Christianity, Judaism, Mandaeism, and Zoroastrianism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mecca</span> Holiest city in Islam, Saudi Arabias provincial capital

Mecca is the capital of Mecca Province in the Hejaz region of western Saudi Arabia and is considered the holiest city in Islam. It is 70 km (43 mi) inland from Jeddah on the Red Sea, in a narrow valley 277 m (909 ft) above sea level. Its last recorded population was 1,578,722 in 2015. Its estimated metro population in 2020 is 2.042 million, making it the third-most populated city in Saudi Arabia after Riyadh and Jeddah. Pilgrims more than triple this number every year during the Ḥajj pilgrimage, observed in the twelfth Hijri month of Dhūl-Ḥijjah.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Badr</span> First major battle in early Islam (624)

The Battle of Badr, also referred to as The Day of the Criterion in the Qur'an and by Muslims, took place on 15 March 624 CE, near the present-day city of Badr, Al Madinah Province in Saudi Arabia. Muhammad, commanding an army of his Sahaba, defeated an army of the Quraysh led by Amr ibn Hishām, better known among Muslims as Abu Jahl. The battle marked the beginning of the six-year war between Muhammad and his tribe. Before the battle, the Muslims and the Meccans had fought several smaller skirmishes in late 623 and early 624.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quraysh</span> Arab tribal confederation of Mecca, Arabia

The Quraysh were a grouping of Arab clans that historically inhabited and controlled the city of Mecca and its Kaaba. The Islamic prophet Muhammad was born into the Hashim clan of the tribe. By 600 CE, the tribe were affluent merchants who dominated commerce between the Indian Ocean and East Africa on one side and the Mediterranean on the other. They organized caravans that traveled to Gaza and Damascus in the summer and to Yemen in the winter. On those routes, they were also engaged in mining and other enterprises. They were known for their hilm, or "absence of hotheadedness," because, despite their rivalries, they put commercial interests and unity first.

Banu Abd Shams refers to a clan within the Meccan tribe of Quraysh.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Treaty of Hudaybiyyah</span> Treaty between Muhammad, representing the state of Medina, and the Quraish tribe of Mecca

The Treaty of Hudaybiyyah was an event that took place during the lifetime of the Islamic prophet Muhammad. It was a pivotal treaty between Muhammad, representing the state of Medina, and the tribe of the Quraysh in Mecca in January 628. The treaty helped to decrease tension between the two cities, affirmed peace for a period of 10 years, and authorised Muhammad's followers to return the following year in a peaceful pilgrimage, which was later known as The First Pilgrimage.

In Islam, a ḥanīf, meaning "renunciate", is someone who maintains the pure monotheism of the patriarch Abraham. More specifically, in Islamic thought, renunciates were the people who, during the pre-Islamic period or Jahiliyyah, were seen to have renounced idolatry and retained some or all of the tenets of the religion of Abraham, which was submission to God in its purest form. The word is found twelve times in the Quran and Islamic tradition tells of a number of individuals who were ḥanīfs. According to Muslim tradition, Muhammad himself was a ḥanīf and a descendant of Ishmael, son of Abraham.

The historiography of early Islam is the scholarly literature on the early history of Islam during the 7th century, from Muhammad's first purported revelations in 610 until the disintegration of the Rashidun Caliphate in 661, and arguably throughout the 8th century and the duration of the Umayyad Caliphate, terminating in the incipient Islamic Golden Age around the beginning of the 9th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Patricia Crone</span> Danish Orientalist and historian (1945–2015)

Patricia Crone was a Danish historian specialised in early Islamic history. Crone was a member of the Revisionist school of Islamic studies and questioned the historicity of the Islamic traditions about the beginnings of Islam.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">W. Montgomery Watt</span> Scottish historian and Orientalist (1909–2006)

William Montgomery Watt was a Scottish Orientalist, historian, academic, and Anglican priest. From 1964 to 1979, he was Professor of Arabic and Islamic studies at the University of Edinburgh.

Muhammad at Mecca is a book about the Islamic prophet Muhammad, specifically about the first phase of his public mission, which concern his years in Mecca until the hijra to Medina. It was written by the non-Muslim Islamic scholar W. Montgomery Watt and published by Oxford University Press in 1953.

Muhammad at Medina is a book about early Islam written by the non-Muslim Islamic scholar W. Montgomery Watt. Published at 418 pages by Oxford University Press in 1956, it is the sequel to Watt's 1953 volume, Muhammad at Mecca.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Muhammad in Medina</span> Overview of Muhammads stay in Medina

The Islamic State of Medina was a theocratic sovereign state on the Arabian Peninsula from 622 when the Islamic prophet Muhammad came to the city of Medina following the migration of his followers in what is known as the Hijrah till his death in the year 632. The State of Medina is considered to be the first Islamic State and the precursor to the Rashidun Caliphate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Muhammad in Mecca</span> First 52 years of his life before migrating to Medina

Muhammad, the final Islamic prophet, was born and lived in Mecca for the first 53 years of his life until the Hijra. This period of his life is characterized by his proclamation of prophethood. Muhammad's father, Abdullah ibn Abd al-Muttalib, died before he was born. His mother would raise him until he was six years old, before her death around 577 CE at Abwa'. Subsequently raised by his grandfather, Abd al-Muttalib, and then his uncle, Abu Talib ibn ‘Abd al-Muttalib, Muhammad's early career involved being a shepherd and merchant. Muhammad married Khadija bint Khuwaylid after a successful trading endeavour in Syria. After the death of Khadija and Abu Talib in the Year of Sorrow, Muhammad married Sawda bint Zam'a and Aisha.

The Najdat were the sub-sect of the Kharijite movement that followed Najda ibn 'Amir al-Hanafi, and in 682 launched a revolt against the Umayyad Caliphate in the historical provinces of Yamama and Bahrain, in central and eastern Arabia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kaaba</span> Building at the center of Islams most important mosque, the Masjid al-Haram

The Kaaba, also spelled Ka'ba, Ka'bah or Kabah, sometimes referred to as al-Ka'ba al-Musharrafa, is a stone building at the center of Islam's most important mosque and holiest site, the Masjid al-Haram in Mecca, Saudi Arabia. It is considered by Muslims to be the Bayt Allah and is the qibla for Muslims around the world. The current structure was built after the original building was damaged by fire during the siege of Mecca by Umayyads in 683.

Sakhr ibn Harb ibn Umayya, commonly known by his kunyaAbu Sufyan, was a prominent opponent turned companion of the Islamic prophet Muhammad. He was the father of the first Umayyad caliph Mu'awiya I and namesake of the Sufyanid line of Umayyad caliphs which ruled from 661 to 684. He was a first-cousin-once-removed of the third Rashidun caliph Uthman; Abu Sufyan's uncle Abu al-As ibn Umayya was the grandfather of Uthman. Abu Sufyan was also a third-cousin of Prophet Muhammad; both men being great-great-grandsons of Abd Manaf ibn Qusai. One of his daughters, Ramla, was married to Muhammad, but this occurred before Abu Sufyan's own conversion and without his consent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Allah as a lunar deity</span> Fringe historical claim related to the origins of Islam

Allah as a Lunar deity refers to a historical postulation that 'Allah' originated as a moon god. The claim first arose in 1901 in the scholarship of archeologist Hugo Winckler, who identified the name Allah with a pre-Islamic Arabian deity known as Lah or Hubal, which he called a lunar deity.

The Revisionist school of Islamic studies, is a movement in Islamic studies that questions traditional Muslim narratives of Islam's origins.

The Muslim–Quraysh War was a six-year military and religious war in the Arabian Peninsula between the early Muslims led by Muhammad on one side and the Arab pagan Quraysh tribe on the other. The war started in March 624 with the Battle of Badr, and concluded with the Conquest of Mecca.

References

  1. Watt, W. Montgomery (William Montgomery) (1990). Early Islam : collected articles. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. ISBN   978-1-4744-7345-3. OCLC   1145654394.
  2. Watt, W. Montgomery. (1993). Muhammad at Mecca (2. impr ed.). Karachi: Oxford Univ. Press. ISBN   0-19-577278-4. OCLC   258364402.
  3. Watt, W. Montgomery (William Montgomery) (1965). A history of Islamic Spain. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. ISBN   0-85224-332-4. OCLC   391773.
  4. Watt, William Montgomery (1999). Islam : a short history. Oxford, England: Oneworld. ISBN   1-85168-205-8. OCLC   43697146.
  5. Donner, Fred McGraw, 1945- (1998). Narratives of Islamic origins : the beginnings of Islamic historical writing. Princeton, N.J.: Darwin Press. ISBN   0-87850-127-4. OCLC   37594489.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  6. 1 2 Neva & Koren, "Methodological Approaches to Islamic Studies", 2000: p.431
  7. Crone, Patricia (1987). "2". Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam. Princeton University Press.
  8. Crone, Patricia (1987). "4". Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam. Princeton University Press.
  9. Crone, Patricia (1987). "5". Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam. Princeton University Press.
  10. Patricia Crone, Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam (Princeton, U.S.A: Princeton University Press, 1987), p.134
  11. Crone, Patricia (1987). Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam . Princeton University Press. p.  114. ISBN   9780691054803.
  12. Neva & Koren, "Methodological Approaches to Islamic Studies", 2000: p.432
  13. Crone, Patricia (1987). Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam . Princeton University Press. p.  111. ISBN   9780691054803.
  14. Serjeant, R. B.; Crone, Patricia (1990). "Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam: Misconceptions and Flawed Polemics". Journal of the American Oriental Society . 110 (3): 472. doi:10.2307/603188. JSTOR   603188.
  15. Al Andalusi, Abdullah (20 October 2012). "Tom Holland's Obsession with Islam's Origins: A Critical response". Muslim Debate Initiative.
  16. Donner, Fred M. (2010). Muhammad and the Believers . Cambridge, Massachusetts: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. p.  241. ISBN   978-0-674-05097-6.
  17. D. Bukharin, Mikhail (January 2009). Mecca On The Caravan Routes In Pre-Islamic Antiquity. Brill. ISBN   9789047430322 . Retrieved 20 February 2020.

Bibliography