| Name | Electorate | Years in office |
|---|
| Alexander, Maurice Maurice Alexander [d] | Goulburn | 1861–1872 |
| Allen, William Bell William Allen | Williams | 1860–1864 |
| Arnold, William Munnings William Arnold | Paterson | 1856–1875 |
| Atkinson, James James Atkinson [w] | Central Cumberland | 1859–1863 |
| Bell, David David Bell [i] | Camden | 1861–1865 |
| Blake, Isidore Isidore Blake [h] | Hunter | 1860–1861 |
| Buchanan, David David Buchanan [p] [ab] | Morpeth, East Macquarie | 1860–1862, 1864–1867, 1869–1877, 1879–1885, 1888–1889 |
| Buchanan, James James Buchanan [v] | Goldfields North | 1863–1864 |
| Burdekin, Marshall Marshall Burdekin [u] | Liverpool Plains | 1863–1866, 1867–1869 |
| Burns, Marshall John Burns [h] | Hunter | 1861–1869, 1872–1891 |
| Byrnes, James James Byrnes [a] | Parramatta | 1857–1872 |
| Caldwell, John John Caldwell | East Sydney | 1860–1866 |
| Close, Edward Edward Close [p] | Morpeth | 1859–1860, 1862–1864 |
| Cowper, Charles Charles Cowper | East Sydney | 1856–1859, 1860–1870 |
| Cowper, Charles Jr Charles Cowper Jr. [y] | Tumut, Orange | 1860–1866 |
| Cummings, William William Cummings | East Macquarie | 1859–1874 |
| Cunneen, James James Cunneen | Hawkesbury | 1860–1869, 1872–1877 |
| Dalgleish, Daniel Daniel Dalgleish | West Sydney | 1860–1864 |
| Dalley, William Bede William Dalley [q] | Carcoar | 1856–1860, 1862–1864 |
| Dangar, Thomas Thomas Dangar [b] | Upper Hunter | 1861–1864 |
| Daniel, Silvanus Silvanus Daniel [m] | Wellington | 1860–1862 |
| Darvall, John John Darvall [x] | East Maitland | 1856–1857, 1859–1860, 1863–1865 |
| Dick, Alexander Alexander Dick [u] | Liverpool Plains | 1860–1862 |
| Dickson, James James Dickson [x] | East Maitland | 1857–1859, 1859–1863 |
| Douglas, John John Douglas [i] | Camden | 1859–1859, 1860–1861 |
| Driver, Richard Richard Driver | West Macquarie | 1860–1880 |
| Eagar, Geoffrey Geoffrey Eagar [t] | West Sydney | 1863–1864, 1865–1869 |
| Eckford, Joseph Joseph Eckford | Wollombi | 1860–1872, 1877–1882 |
| Egan, Daniel Daniel Egan | Eden | 1856–1870 |
| Emmanuel, Samuel Samuel Emmanuel [r] | Argyle | 1862–1864 |
| Faucett, Peter Peter Faucett [j] | Yass Plains | 1856–1859, 1860, 1861–1865 |
| Flett, Henry Henry Flett | Hastings | 1859–1864 |
| Forster, Robert Henry Mariner Robert Forster [n] | New England | 1862–1864, 1870–1877 |
| Forster, William William Forster [c] | East Sydney | 1856–1860, 1861–1864, 1864–1869, 1869–1874, 1875–1876, 1880–1882 |
| Garrett, John John Garrett [l] | Shoalhaven | 1859–1861 |
| Garrett, Thomas Thomas Garrett | Monaro | 1860–1871, 1872–1891 |
| Gordon, Hugh Hugh Gordon [k] | Tenterfield | 1861–1869 |
| Gray, Samuel Samuel Gray [aa] | Kiama | 1859–1864, 1874–1880, 1882–1885 |
| Hannell, James James Hannell | Newcastle | 1860–1869, 1872–1874 |
| Harpur, Joseph Joseph Harpur [e] | Patrick's Plains | 1861–1864 |
| Hart, James James Hart | Bathurst | 1858–1872 |
| Haworth, Robert Robert Haworth | Illawarra | 1860–1864 |
| Hay, John John Hay | Murray | 1856–1867 |
| Holroyd, Arthur Arthur Holroyd [a] | Parramatta | 1856–1857, 1861–1864 |
| Holt, Thomas Thomas Holt [f] | Newtown | 1856–1857, 1861–1864 |
| Hoskins, James James Hoskins [v] | Goldfields North | 1859–1863, 1868–1882 |
| Irving, Clark Clark Irving | Clarence | 1856–1858, 1859–1864 |
| Lackey, John John Lackey | Parramatta | 1860–1864, 1867–1885 |
| Lang, John Dunmore John Lang | West Sydney | 1859–1869 |
| Laycock, John John Laycock | Central Cumberland | 1859–1864 |
| Leary, Joseph Joseph Leary | Narellan | 1860–1864, 1869–1872, 1876–1880 |
| Lesley, William William Lesley [e] | Patrick's Plains | 1860–1861 |
| Lewis, Thomas Thomas Lewis [s] | Northumberland | 1860–1862 |
| Lord, George George Lord | Bogan | 1856–1877 |
| Love, William William Love | West Sydney | 1860–1864 |
| Lucas, John John Lucas | Canterbury | 1860–1869, 1871–1880 |
| Macleay, William John William Macleay | Murrumbidgee | 1856–1859, 1860–1874 |
| Macpherson, Allan Allan Macpherson [w] | Central Cumberland | 1863–1868 |
| Markham, George George Markham [n] | New England | 1860–1862 |
| Martin, James James Martin [o] [y] | Orange, Tumut | 1856–1860, 1862–1873 |
| Mate, Thomas Thomas Mate | Hume | 1860–1869 |
| McArthur, Alexander Alexander McArthur [f] | Newtown | 1859–1861 |
| Meston, Robert Robert Meston [k] | Tenterfield | 1860–1861 |
| Milford, Henry Henry Milford [z] | Braidwood | 1864 |
| Moriarty, Merion Merion Moriarty [z] | Braidwood | 1860–1864 |
| Morrice, John John Morrice | Camden | 1860–1872 |
| Morris, Augustus Augustus Morris | Balranald | 1859–1864 |
| Murray, Terence Aubrey Terence Murray [r] | Argyle | 1856–1862 |
| O'Brien, Henry Henry O'Brien [j] | Yass Plains | 1860–1861 |
| Parkes, Henry Henry Parkes [c] [aa] | East Sydney, Kiama | 1856, 1858, 1859–1861, 1864–1870, 1872–1895 |
| Peisley, John John Peisley [o] | Orange | 1860–1862 |
| Piddington, William William Piddington | Hawkesbury | 1856–1877 |
| Raper, Edward Edward Raper | Canterbury | 1860–1864 |
| Redman, William William Redman | Queanbeyan | 1860–1864 |
| Robertson, John John Robertson [b] [l] | Upper Hunter, Shoalhaven | 1856–1861, 1862–1865, 1865–1866, 1866–1870, 1870–1877, 1877–1878, 1882–1886 |
| Rotton, Henry Henry Rotton | Hartley | 1858–1864 |
| Rusden, Francis Francis Rusden | Gwydir | 1856–1857, 1860–1864 |
| Ryan, James Tobias James Ryan | Nepean | 1860–1872 |
| Ryan, John Nagel John Ryan | Lachlan | 1859–1864 |
| Sadleir, Richard Richard Sadleir [g] | Lower Hunter | 1861–1864 |
| Samuel, Saul Saul Samuel [m] | Wellington | 1859–1860, 1862–1872 |
| Scott, Alexander Walker Alexander Scott [g] | Lower Hunter | 1856–1861 |
| Shepherd, Isaac Isaac Shepherd | St Leonards | 1860–1864 |
| Smart, Thomas Thomas Smart | Glebe | 1860–1869 |
| Stewart, Robert Robert Stewart | East Sydney | 1860–1864, 1866–1869 |
| Sutherland, John John Sutherland | Paddington | 1860–1881, 1882–1889 |
| Suttor Sr., William William Suttor [ab] | East Macquarie | 1856–1859, 1860–1872 |
| Terry, William Samuel Terry | Mudgee | 1859–1869, 1871–1881 |
| Tighe, Atkinson Atkinson Tighe [s] | Northumberland | 1862–1869, 1882–1884 |
| Walker, William William Walker | Windsor | 1860–1869 |
| Walsh, Charles Hamilton Charles Walsh [d] | Goulburn | 1860–1861 |
| Watt, William Redfern William Watt [q] | Carcoar | 1859–1862 |
| Weekes, Elias Elias Weekes | West Maitland | 1856–1864 |
| Wilson, Bowie Bowie Wilson | Goldfields South | 1859–1872 |
| Windeyer, William Charles William Windeyer [t] | Lower Hunter | 1859–1862, 1866–1872, 1876–1879 |
| Wisdom, Robert Robert Wisdom | Goldfields West | 1859–1872, 1874–1887 |