Research
In Hagarism:The Making of the Islamic World (1977),Cook and his associate Patricia Crone provided a new analysis of early Islamic history by studying the only surviving contemporary accounts of the rise of Islam. They fundamentally questioned the historicity of the Islamic traditions about the beginnings of Islam. Thus they tried to produce the picture of Islam's beginnings only from non-Arabic sources. By studying the only surviving contemporary accounts of the rise of Islam,which were written in Armenian,Greek,Aramaic and Syriac by witnesses,they reconstructed a significantly different story of Islam's beginnings,compared with the story known from the Islamic traditions. Cook and Crone claimed to be able to explain exactly how Islam came into being by the fusion of various near eastern civilizations under Arabic leadership. Later,Michael Cook refrained from this attempt of a detailed reconstruction of Islam's beginnings,and concentrated on Islamic ethics and law. [2] Patricia Crone later suggested that the book was “a graduate essay" and "a hypothesis," not "a conclusive finding.” [3]
In his work Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong in Islamic Thought (Cambridge,2000),Michael Cook,in the chapter on the doctrine of al-Amr bi'l-Maʿrūf wa'l-Nahy ʿan il-Munkar among the Ibāḍīs,makes a comparison between western and eastern Ibāḍism and with the doctrines of the other Islamic sects and schools. The eastern and western Ibāḍīs represent two distinct historical communities with largely separate literary heritages,at least until,roughly,the beginning of the twentieth century. There are occasional links between them:one shared literary borrowing (Māwardī,Ghazālī),the unusual doctrine that the verbal obligation does not lapse when the offender will not listen,the equally unusual interest in women as performers of the duty. Differences are likely to reflect the very different political histories of the two wings of the sect. In Oman,the resilience of the Imamate down the centuries finds obvious and direct expression in the frequency with which the Omani sources link forbidding wrong with this institution. In the West,where the vacuum left by the disappearance of the Imamate was filled in part by clerical organisation and authority,the scholars seem to have become less cautious about the role of the individual performer. Comparing the Ibāḍīdoctrine of forbidding wrong with the doctrines of other Islamic sects and schools,the significant point is that,left aside the close association of forbidding wrong with righteous rebellion and state-formation which the Ibāḍīs share with the Zaydīs,Ibāḍīviews do not in any systematic way diverge from those of the Islamic mainstream. [4]
Cook is also known for synthetic works for a general audience,including The Koran:A Very Short Introduction (Oxford,2000) and A Brief History of the Human Race (Norton,2003). Cook served as general editor of The New Cambridge History of Islam,which covers fourteen centuries of Muslim history. This six-volume project was selected as winner of the 2011 Waldo G. Leland Prize for the “most outstanding reference tool in the field of history”published between 1 May 2006,and 30 April 2011.
Criticism
Robert Bertram Serjeant described Hagarism as "bitterly anti-Islamic" and "anti-Arabian" in 1978. [5] Cook's 2014 work,Ancient Religions,Modern Politics,has been criticized by Duke Religion scholar,Bruce Lawrence,as an "anti-Islam manifesto." [6]
Cook addresses his approach to navigating the politics of scholarship on Islam in a video for the Nicholas D. Chabraja Center for Historical Studies. In his words,he claims that "I personally see my academic role not as being anybody's advocate for or against. I hold onto a kind of ideal of objectivity,which I am sure I don't fully realize...I didn't like the philo-Islamic pull and I don't like the anti-Islamic pull. They are kind of a distraction from scholarship." [7]
This page is based on this
Wikipedia article Text is available under the
CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
