Minnie's Boys

Last updated
Minnie's Boys
MinniesBoys.jpg
Original Cast Recording
Music Larry Grossman
Lyrics Hal Hackady
Book Arthur Marx
Robert Fisher
BasisEarly years of the Marx Brothers
Productions1970 Broadway
2008 Off-Broadway

Minnie's Boys is a musical with a book by Arthur Marx (Groucho Marx's son) and Robert Fisher, music by Larry Grossman, and lyrics by Hal Hackady.

Contents

It provides a behind-the-scenes look at the early days of the Marx Brothers and their relationship with their mother Minnie Marx, the driving force behind their ultimate success.

Production

Development

Producer Sol C. Siegel had developed a project based on the young Marx Brothers in the early 1960s with a script written by Julius J. Epstein, but it was never made.

The producer of the Broadway show was Arthur Whitelaw, who had done the musical You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown . Groucho hoped that Neil Simon would write the book but Simon turned down the job; comedian David Steinberg, a great admirer of the Marx Brothers, did it instead. Groucho disliked Steinberg's work and the job was then offered to his son Arthur and Arthur's writing partner Robert Fisher; the duo had just penned a Broadway comedy hit, The Impossible Years . Arthur Marx later wrote he "embarked on the project with great enthusiasm" but later realised "how wise Neil Simon was to have turned down the project." [1]

Arthur Marx and Fisher wrote a first draft for Minnie's Boys in six weeks. Arthur says the problems began when Whitelaw insisted on a non-realistic second act. Then Whitelaw wanted Totie Fields to play Minnie, who Arthur Marx felt was ideal casting, but Groucho refused to give his permission as he felt Fields was "too Jewish". The role eventually went to Shelley Winters. Arthur Marx wrote "My father was delighted to have the two-time Oscar winner in the show. But ironically, Winters ended up looking and sounding more Jewish in the role than ever Totie Fields would have done. " [2] Arthur Marx would comment that Winters "didn't belong in the show at all." [3]

There was a long preview period lasting for sixty-four performances, during which the creators constantly tinkered with the show. The original choreographer, Patricia Birch, was replaced and there were rumors about replacing Shelley Winters. Arthur Marx says his father was a disruptive influence at rehearsals as he kept telling anecdotes about the past and slowing down progress. Arthur Marx also says he persuaded Whitelaw that the second act needed to be rewritten; the producer agreed but the original director did not so the director was fired and replaced with Stanley Prager. Before Arthur Marx and his partner began rewriting the second act they discovered that Whitelaw and Prager had secretly hired Joseph Stein from Fiddler on the Roof to rewrite the second act from their notes. Arthur eventually went along with this. He says Shelley Winters had trouble remembering her lines and would constantly change her line readings. Arthur Whitelaw was going to fire her and replace her with Totie Fields but it would have cost $300,000 to pay Winters out of her contract, so it was decided to keep her. [4]

Theatre historian Ken Mandelbaum wrote Minnie's Boys "is a fine example of the dangers inherent in skipping a road tryout and the out-of-town reviews that go with it" [5] "It was a mistake not to take the show out of town," agreed Arthur Marx. [6]

Reception

The musical opened on Broadway at the Imperial Theatre officially on March 26, 1970. It was directed by Stanley Prager and choreographed by Marc Breaux, with scenic design by Peter Wexler, costume design by Donald Brooks and lighting by Jules Fisher. [7] The cast featured Shelley Winters as Minnie Marx, Lewis J. Stadlen as Julius "Groucho" Marx, Daniel Fortus as Adolph "Harpo" Marx, Irwin Pearl as Leonard "Chico" Marx, Alvin Kupperman as Herbert "Zeppo" Marx, and Gary Raucher as Milton "Gummo" Marx. [7] [8]

According to Arthur Marx "everything clicked into place" on opening night. "Shelley Winters wasn't half bad. But what made the show was Lew Stadlin's brilliant portrayal of Groucho." [9] The Los Angeles Times said "it may not be a great musical but it is a very nice one." [10] There were also positive reviews from critics such as Richard Watts and Walter Kerr. However there was a highly negative review from Clive Barnes in The New York Times which was felt to have killed the show's commercial prospects. [6]

The musical closed on May 30, 1970 after 80 performances. [8] Minnie's Boys lost an estimated $750,000 on an investment of $550,000.

Groucho Marx received a playbill credit as the show's advisor; after the show closed, it was revealed that Groucho had made no real contributions, and had basically been paid off so that he would not raise any legal objections to the production. During its brief run, Groucho did help promote the musical by appearing on the Dick Cavett Show with Shelley Winters and the five young actors who portrayed the Marx boys in the show. [11]

Stadlen won both the 1970 Theatre World Award and 1970 Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Performance in a Musical. [12]

According to Ken Mandelbaum the main problem with the show was "its lead female character was never as fascinating or colorful as Gypsy’s Rose. The four boys, extremely well played in the musical, were far more entertaining and interesting than Minnie, but because a star had been hired for the part, the character had to be kept around even when she wasn't needed." However Mandelbaum has called the musical "a crowd pleaser" [13] and it has received many subsequent amateur productions. [14] [6]

The score's song "Mama, a Rainbow" has become a standard for cabaret performers, [15] and was recorded by Steve Lawrence and Jim Nabors soon after the show opened. In the show, the song is performed by Harpo, [16] whose screen and stage persona was always silent.

Cast Album

An original cast album was released by Project Three Records, although the cast album was originally scheduled to be recorded and released by RCA Victor. [17]

Revivals

The show received a 2008 revival staging under the direction of Stuart Ross at Off-Broadway's York Theatre Company. The cast included Erik Liberman, Pamela Myers, Jim Walton, Dan Bogart, Ryan Duncan, Nick Gaswirth, Beth Glover, Don Mayo, Nancy McCall, Emily Shoolin, Kelly Sullivan, and Stuart Zagnit. [18] [19]

Casts

Source: [20] [21]

CharacterOriginal Broadway Cast (1970)Off-Broadway Revival (2008)
Julius "Groucho" Marx Lewis J. Stadlen Erik Lieberman
Leonard "Chico" Marx Irwin PearlRyan Duncan
Adolph "Harpo" Marx Daniel FortusNick Gaswirth
Herbert "Zeppo" Marx Alvin KuppermanDan Bogart
Milton "Gummo" Marx Gary Raucher
Mrs. FlanaganJean BrunoBeth Glover
Mrs. KrupnikJacqueline BrittNancy McCall
Minnie Marx Shelley Winters Pamela Myers
Sam "Frenchie" Marx Arny Freeman Stuart Zagnit
HochmeisterMerwin GoldsmithDon Mayo
Al Shean Mort Marshall Jim Walton
Maxie Richard B. Shull Don Mayo
E.F. Albee Roland Winters Don Mayo
Miss MurdockJacqueline BrittEmily Shoolin
Mrs. McNishJulie KurnitzBeth Glover

Song list

Source: [16] [20]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Groucho Marx</span> American comedian (1890–1977)

Julius Henry "Groucho" Marx was an American comedian, actor, writer, and singer who performed in films and vaudeville on television, radio, and the stage. He is considered one of America's greatest comedians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George S. Kaufman</span> American playwright, theater director and producer (1889–1961)

George Simon Kaufman was an American playwright, theater director and producer, humorist, and drama critic. In addition to comedies and political satire, he wrote several musicals for the Marx Brothers and others. He won the Pulitzer Prize for Drama for the musical Of Thee I Sing in 1932, and won again in 1937 for the play You Can't Take It with You. He also won the Tony Award for Best Director in 1951 for the musical Guys and Dolls.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marx Brothers</span> American comedy troupe (1905–1949)

The Marx Brothers were an American family comedy act that was successful in vaudeville, on Broadway, and in 14 motion pictures from 1905 to 1949. Five of the Marx Brothers' fourteen feature films were selected by the American Film Institute (AFI) as among the top 100 comedy films, with two of them, Duck Soup (1933) and A Night at the Opera (1935), in the top fifteen. They are widely considered by critics, scholars and fans to be among the greatest and most influential comedians of the 20th century. The brothers were included in AFI's 100 Years...100 Stars list of the 25 greatest male stars of Classical Hollywood cinema, the only performers to be included collectively.

<i>Duck Soup</i> (1933 film) 1933 Marx Brothers film by Leo McCarey

Duck Soup is a 1933 American pre-Code musical black comedy film written by Bert Kalmar and Harry Ruby and directed by Leo McCarey. Released by Paramount Pictures on November 17, 1933, it stars the four Marx Brothers and also features Margaret Dumont, Louis Calhern, Raquel Torres and Edgar Kennedy. Duck Soup was the last of the five Marx Brothers films released by Paramount Pictures. In the film, Groucho portrays the newly installed president of the fictional country of Freedonia. Zeppo is his secretary, while Chico and Harpo are spies for the neighboring country of Sylvania. Relations between Firefly and the Sylvanian ambassador (Calhern) deteriorate during the film, eventually leading the two countries to war.

<i>A Night at the Opera</i> (film) 1935 Marx Brothers film directed by Sam Wood

A Night at the Opera is a 1935 American comedy film starring the Marx Brothers, and featuring Kitty Carlisle, Allan Jones, Margaret Dumont, Sig Ruman, and Walter Woolf King. It was the first of five films the Marx Brothers made under contract for Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer after their departure from Paramount Pictures, and the first after Zeppo left the act. The film was written by George S. Kaufman and Morrie Ryskind from a story by James Kevin McGuinness, with additional uncredited dialogue by Al Boasberg. The film was directed by Sam Wood.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harpo Marx</span> American comedian (1888-1964)

Arthur "Harpo" Marx was an American comedian, actor, mime artist, and harpist, and the second-oldest of the Marx Brothers. In contrast to the mainly verbal comedy of his brothers Groucho and Chico, Harpo's comic style was visual, being an example of vaudeville, clown and pantomime traditions. In all of his movie appearances, he wore a curly reddish blonde wig and did not speak, instead blowing a horn or whistling to communicate. Marx frequently employed props such as a horn cane constructed from a lead pipe, tape, and a bulbhorn.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chico Marx</span> American comedian (1887-1961)

Leonard Joseph "Chico" Marx was an American comedian, actor and pianist. He was the oldest brother in the Marx Brothers comedy troupe, alongside his brothers Arthur ("Harpo"), Julius ("Groucho"), Milton ("Gummo") and Herbert ("Zeppo"). His persona in the act was that of a charming, uneducated but crafty con artist, seemingly of rural Italian origin, who wore shabby clothes and sported a curly-haired wig and Tyrolean hat. On screen, Chico is often in alliance with Harpo, usually as partners in crime, and is also frequently seen trying to con or outfox Groucho. Leonard was the oldest of the Marx Brothers to live past early childhood, the first-born being Manfred Marx who had died in infancy. In addition to his work as a performer, he played an important role in the management and development of the act in its early years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Zeppo Marx</span> American entertainer (1901–1979)

Herbert Manfred "Zeppo" Marx was an American comedic actor. He was the youngest, and last survivor, of the five Marx Brothers. He appeared in the first five Marx Brothers feature films from 1929 to 1933, and then left the act for careers as an engineer and theatrical agent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dick Cavett</span> American talk show host (born 1936)

Richard Alva Cavett is an American television personality and former talk show host. He appeared regularly on nationally broadcast television in the United States from the 1960s through the 2000s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Minnie Marx</span> Mother and manager of the Marx Brothers (1864-1929)

Minnie Marx was the mother and manager of the Marx Brothers, a family of top-billed vaudevillians, top Broadway stars and, finally, film stars. She was also the sister of comedian and vaudeville star Al Shean.

<i>The Man Who Came to Dinner</i> Comedy in three acts by George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart

The Man Who Came to Dinner is a comedy play by George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart. It debuted on October 16, 1939, at the Music Box Theatre in New York City, where it ran until 1941, closing after 739 performances. It then enjoyed a number of New York and London revivals. The first London production was staged at The Savoy Theatre starring Robert Morley and Coral Browne. In 1990, Browne stated in a televised biographical interview, broadcast on UK Channel 4, that she bought the rights to the play, borrowing money from her dentist to do so. When she died, her will revealed that she had received royalties for all later productions and adaptations of the play.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arthur Marx</span> American writer (1921–2011)

Arthur Julius Marx was an American writer, the son of entertainer Groucho Marx and his first wife, Ruth Johnson.

Lewis J. Stadlen is an American stage and screen character actor. He is best known for playing Ira Fried in The Sopranos.

<i>A Day in Hollywood / A Night in the Ukraine</i> Musical

A Day in Hollywood / A Night in the Ukraine is a musical comedy consisting of two essentially independent one-act plays, with a book and lyrics by Dick Vosburgh and music by Frank Lazarus. Additionally, songs by other composers are incorporated into the score. The musical premiered in the West End and then ran on Broadway.

<i>The Impossible Years</i> 1965 play by Robert Fisher and Arthur Marx

The Impossible Years is a 1965 comedy play written by Robert Fisher and Arthur Marx, son of comedian Groucho Marx. After two previews, the Broadway production, directed by Arthur Storch, opened on October 13, 1965, at the Playhouse Theatre, where it ran for 670 performances. The original cast included Alan King, Sudie Bond, Bert Convy, Neva Small, and Scott Glenn. Ed McMahon temporarily assumed the role of Dr. Jack Kingsley for eight performances from January 17, 1966, to January 22, 1966, so Alan King could honor a previously scheduled Miami night club engagement.

The surname Marx is a Germanic surname, believed to originate with Mark the Evangelist and the Roman praenomen Marcus, the latter deriving from the god Mars. The similarly-spelled Marks may share etymology with march (territory), especially near Wales, but most British Marxes have Jewish roots, typically in the Rhineland or former Pale of Settlement. Famously, Karl Marx's father, born Herschel HaLevi Mordecai in Saarlouis, assimilated in 1817 or 1818 to Heinrich Marx because Prussia banned Jews from public service. Amateur geneologist Colin Shelley suggests that Marx' prevalence there may have arisen as a macaronic acronym for māšīaḥ rex.

Larry Grossman is an American composer for theatre, television, film, concerts, and cabaret.

Robert "Bob" Fisher was an American playwright, and television and film screenwriter mostly of situational comedy.

Erik Liberman is an American actor, author, and director.

Arthur Whitelaw was an American theatre producer. His most successful productions include You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown and Butterflies Are Free. In a 1970 interview he said "I try to give people what they want."

References

  1. Marx p 376
  2. Marx p 379
  3. Marx p 376
  4. Marx pp 378-382
  5. Mandelbaum, Ken (August 15, 1992). "Minnie's Boys". Not Since Carrie: Forty Years of Broadway Musical Flops. St. Martin's Press. p. 290. ISBN   978-1-4668-4327-1.
  6. 1 2 3 "Minnie's Boys failure laid to Shelley Winters". The Philadelphia Inquirer. 2 September 1973. p. 59.
  7. 1 2 Minnie's Boys. Playbill (vault). retrieved May 8, 2019.
  8. 1 2 Kerr, Walter (April 5, 1970). Kerr on ‘Minnie's Boys’". The New York Times .
  9. Marx p 383
  10. "Stage Review". The Los Angeles Times. 30 March 1970. p. 23 Part 4.
  11. "The Dick Cavett Show, 3/20/70". dickcavettshow.com. Retrieved May 8, 2019.
  12. "Lewis J. Stadlen Awards". ibdb.com. Retrieved May 9, 2019
  13. Mandelbaum p 291
  14. Chandler, Charlotte (2007). Hello, I must be going : Groucho and his friends. p. 177.
  15. Jones, Kenneth (October 21, 2002). " 'Minnie's Boys', the Marx Brothers Musical, Gets Concert Revival Oct. 31, Nov. 3-4". Playbill .
  16. 1 2 "Minnie's Boys Synopsis and Musical Numbers". guidetomusicaltheatre.com. Retrieved May 8, 2019.
  17. Dietz, Dan (September 3, 2015). "Minnie's Boys". The Complete Book of 1970s Broadway Musicals. Rowman & Littlefield. pp. 11–13. ISBN   978-1-4422-5166-3.
  18. Gans, Andrew (May 16, 2008). "Liberman Will Join Myers in Mufti Minnie's Boys". Playbill . Retrieved 2020-10-01.
  19. "Walton to Join Duncan, Liberman, Myers, et al. for York's Minnie's Boys". TheaterMania. Retrieved 2020-10-01.
  20. 1 2 "Minnie's Boys". Playbill. Retrieved 14 May 2020.
  21. Gans, Andrew (May 30, 2008). "Minnie's Boys, with Myers, Walton and Zagnit, Begins York Run May 30". Playbill. Retrieved 2021-05-02.

Notes