Ninumbeehan

Last updated

Ninumbeehan
Ninumbeehan dookoodukah.png
Life restoration
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Order: Temnospondyli
Suborder: Stereospondyli
Family: incertae sedis
Genus: Ninumbeehan
So et al., 2024 [1]
Species:
N. dookoodukah
Binomial name
Ninumbeehan dookoodukah
So et al., 2024 [1]

Ninumbeehan (from the Shoshone words ninumbee for mountain-dwelling Little People, -han as a possessive affix) is a genus of stereospondyl temnospondyl from the Late Triassic Jelm Formation of Wyoming. It is represented by the type species, Ninumbeehan dookoodukah, which was named from a holotype and three paratypes; the holotype is from the Serendipity site within the informal Serendipity beds.

Contents

Description

Ninumbeehan dookoodukah is one of several small-bodied Late Triassic temnospondyls that have been named from North America, including the uncertain Latiscopus disjunctus , [2] Rileymillerus cosgriffi , [3] and Chinlestegophis jenkinsi . [4] It also shares some similarities with the small-bodied Almasaurus habbazi [5] from the Late Triassic of Morocco. There are two autapomorphies of N. dookoodukah: (1) a ventrally sloping unornamented posterior process along the midline formed by the postparietals; and (2) anterior dorsal ribs subequal in length to the dorsoventral height of the skull and mandible. [1] It shares with C. jenkinsi and perhaps R. cosgriffi the absence of a distinct lacrimal, but lacks a lateral exposure of the palatine that is found in both of these taxa. A falciform crest of the squamosal, posteriorly situated pineal foramen, otic notch, and developed tabular horn further separate it from R. cosgriffi. The otic notch is more developed than in C. jenkinsi, the cultriform process is narrower, and the supratemporal is subrectangular, more like other stereospondyls than like the subcircular element in C. jenkinsi. The absence of a lacrimal separates it from A. habbazi, as does the expanded posterolateral region of the premaxilla along the lateral narial margin, a wider posterior region of the parietal, a flat cultriform process, and a palatoquadrate fissure.

Much of the skeleton is known for N. dookoodukah. The holotype is represented by a skull, lower jaws, and pectoral girdle in articulation, along with loosely articulated/associated left forelimb, ribs, and intercentra. Other postcrania may be present. The described paratypes also comprise skulls of varying completeness in articulation or association with the lower jaws, pectoral girdle, and axial column. The largest skull is approximately 7 cm in length, larger than C. jenkinsi and R. cosgriffi. Lateral line grooves indicate an aquatic life history, while the wedge-shaped lateral profile is thought to be evidence for inferred burrowing behavior. Like C. jenkinsi and modern caecilians, there is a second row of teeth on the coronoids that lie medial to the primary marginal row on the dentary, a feature originally proposed to link C. jenkinsi to this modern group [4] but subsequently disputed as such a feature occurs in some other stereospondyls. [6] [7] The function of the greatly elongated anterior ribs of N. dookoodukah remains unclear. The limbs are relatively small compared to the skull (about one-third of the length), further suggesting that burrowing was accomplished primarily through head-based functionality.

Discovery and naming

Specimens of N. dookoodukah were collected over several field seasons (2015, 2016, 2018) by field crews from the University of Wisconsin Geology Museum (UWGM). [1] Many of the specimen occur entirely within burrows interpreted as having been used for estivation that are distributed across three sites: DoJo, Independence, and the type locality, Serendipity. Several dozen have been collected, most of which contain some skeletal material. The burrows are predominantly sub-vertical to vertical with a diameter correspondent with the skull width of the encapsulated animal. They are predominantly contained within the host fluvial sandstone that comprises the Serendipity beds, within the upper 10 m of the Jelm Formation, but some penetration into the underlying mudstone is observed. Not all burrows contain skeletal material, and the articulation of remains is variable between burrows. As some spatially adjacent burrows cross-cut one another, it is thought that there were repeated episodes of excavation and thus that the assemblages represent time-averaging rather than a singular event.

The taxon was named by researchers from the University of Wisconsin-Madison, George Washington University, University of Exeter, the Field Museum of Natural History, the Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation, and a local school system (Fort Washakie Schools) and preservation office (Eastern Shoshone Tribal Historic Preservation Office). [1] The species epithet, dookoodukah, is derived from the Shoshone words dookoo for flesh and dukah for eater, giving a full etymological meaning of 'Little People's flesh eater', honouring the Little People and referencing the sharp teeth of the fossil. [1]

Paleoecology

While temnospondyls have been previously discovered in burrows, [4] [8] N. dookoodukah is proposed to represent the first definitive instance of a temnospondyl with demonstrated capacity for constructing a burrow, [1] rather than being a potential opportunistic reuser. [8] The authors proposed that this largely aquatic taxon would have burrowed into point bar deposits in the river channel during dry periods, potentially over many seasons to years. As the near-equatorial regions of Pangea were subjected to a megamonsoon system, [9] pronounced seasonality likely typified the paleoenvironment, with estivation as one adaptive strategy, similar to many modern amphibians that utilize burrowing in monsoonal climates. The exact age of the Jelm Formation remains unresolved, but the overlying Popo Agie Formation has been dated to the mid-late Carnian (231-227 Ma), [10] so the Serendipity beds may have been deposited prior to the Carnian Pluvial Episode. The presence of abundant temnospondyl remains suggests, contrary to previous hypotheses, that the paucity of vertebrate fossils in the Carnian of North America may be related to sampling and not to a harsh environment leading to scarcity. The authors also suggest that estivation, either in directly constructed burrows or repurposed burrows, [8] may have been more widespread and potentially explain temnospondyls' survival across the end-Permian mass extinction and subsequent radiation into Triassic habitats across the globe. [1]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caecilian</span> Order of amphibians

Caecilians are a group of limbless, vermiform (worm-shaped) or serpentine (snake-shaped) amphibians with small or sometimes nonexistent eyes. They mostly live hidden in soil or in streambeds, and this cryptic lifestyle renders caecilians among the least familiar amphibians. Modern caecilians live in the tropics of South and Central America, Africa, and southern Asia. Caecilians feed on small subterranean creatures such as earthworms. The body is cylindrical and often darkly coloured, and the skull is bullet-shaped and strongly built. Caecilian heads have several unique adaptations, including fused cranial and jaw bones, a two-part system of jaw muscles, and a chemosensory tentacle in front of the eye. The skin is slimy and bears ringlike markings or grooves and may contain scales.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Temnospondyli</span> Ancestors of modern amphibians adapted to life on land

Temnospondyli or temnospondyls is a diverse ancient order of small to giant tetrapods—often considered primitive amphibians—that flourished worldwide during the Carboniferous, Permian and Triassic periods, with fossils being found on every continent. A few species continued into the Jurassic and Early Cretaceous periods, but all had gone extinct by the Late Cretaceous. During about 210 million years of evolutionary history, they adapted to a wide range of habitats, including freshwater, terrestrial, and even coastal marine environments. Their life history is well understood, with fossils known from the larval stage, metamorphosis and maturity. Most temnospondyls were semiaquatic, although some were almost fully terrestrial, returning to the water only to breed. These temnospondyls were some of the first vertebrates fully adapted to life on land. Although temnospondyls are amphibians, many had characteristics such as scales and large armour-like bony plates (osteoderms) that generally distinguish them from the modern soft-bodied lissamphibians.

<i>Metoposaurus</i> Extinct genus of temnospondyls

Metoposaurus meaning "front lizard" is an extinct genus of stereospondyl temnospondyls, known from the Late Triassic of Germany, Italy, Poland, and Portugal. This mostly aquatic animal possessed small, weak limbs, sharp teeth, and a large, flat head. This highly flattened creature mainly fed on fish, which it captured with its wide jaws lined with needle-like teeth. Many Metoposaurus mass graves have been found, probably from creatures that grouped together in drying pools during drought.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stereospondyli</span> Extinct suborder of amphibians

The Stereospondyli are a group of extinct temnospondyl amphibians that existed primarily during the Mesozoic period. They are known from all seven continents and were common components of many Triassic ecosystems, likely filling a similar ecological niche to modern crocodilians prior to the diversification of pseudosuchian archosaurs.

<i>Laidleria</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Laidleria is an extinct genus of temnospondyl that likely lived between the Early to Middle Triassic, though its exact stratigraphic range is less certain. Laidleria has been found in the Karoo Basin in South Africa, in Cynognathus Zone A or B. The genus is represented by only one species, L. gracilis, though the family Laidleriidae does include other genera, such as Uruyiella, sister taxon to Laidleria, which was discovered and classified in 2007. 

<i>Eocyclotosaurus</i> Extinct genus of temnospondyls

Eocyclotosaurus is an extinct genus of mastodonsauroid temnospondyl from the Middle Triassic (Anisian). The name Eocyclotosaurus means "dawn round-eared lizard". It is characterized as a capitosauroid with a long and slender snout, closed otic fenestra, and small orbits. It measured over one metre and had a 22 cm skull.

<i>Deltasaurus</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Deltasaurus is an extinct genus of Carnian temnospondyl amphibian of the family Rhytidosteidae.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rhinesuchidae</span> Extinct family of temnospondyls

Rhinesuchidae is a family of tetrapods that lived primarily in the Permian period. They belonged to the broad group Temnospondyli, a successful and diverse collection of semiaquatic tetrapods which modern amphibians are probably descended from. Rhinesuchids can be differentiated from other temnospondyls by details of their skulls, most notably the interior structure of their otic notches at the back of the skull. They were among the earliest-diverging members of the Stereospondyli, a subgroup of temnospondyls with flat heads and aquatic habits. Although more advanced stereospondyls evolved to reach worldwide distribution in the Triassic period, rhinesuchids primarily lived in the high-latitude environments of Gondwana during the Guadalupian and Lopingian epochs of the Permian. The taxonomy of this family has been convoluted, with more than twenty species having been named in the past; a 2017 review recognized only eight of them to be valid. While several purported members of this group have been reported to have lived in the Triassic period, most are either dubious or do not belong to the group. However, at least one valid genus of rhinesuchid is known from the early Triassic, a small member known as Broomistega. The most recent formal definition of Rhinesuchidae, advocated by Mariscano et al. (2017) is that of a stem-based clade containing all taxa more closely related to Rhinesuchus whaitsi than to Lydekkerina huxleyi or Peltobatrachus pustulatus. A similar alternate definition is that Rhinesuchidae is a stem-based clade containing all taxa more closely related to Uranocentrodon senekalensis than to Lydekkerina huxleyi, Trematosaurus brauni, or Mastodonsaurus giganteus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stereospondylomorpha</span> Extinct clade of temnospondyls

Stereospondylomorpha is a clade of temnospondyls. It includes the superfamily Archegosauroidea and the more diverse group Stereospondyli. Stereospondylomorpha was first proposed by Yates and Warren (2000), who found Archegosauroidea and Stereospondyli to be sister taxa in their phylogenetic analysis. A similar clade is Archegosauriformes, named by Schoch and Milner (2000), which includes Stereospondyli and some Permian temnospondyls that are similar in appearance to stereospondyls, including the archegosauroids. However, according to Schoch and Milner's phylogeny, Archegosauroidea is a paraphyletic group of taxa that are successively basal to Stereospondyli, rather than a monophyletic sister taxon.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Limnarchia</span> Extinct clade of temnospondyls

Limnarchia is a clade of temnospondyls. It includes the mostly Carboniferous-Permian age Dvinosauria and the mostly Permian-Triassic age Stereospondylomorpha. The clade was named in a 2000 phylogenetic analysis of stereospondyls and their relatives. Limnarchia means "lake rulers" in Greek, in reference to their aquatic lifestyles and long existence over a span of approximately 200 million years from the Late Carboniferous to the Early Cretaceous. In phylogenetic terms, Limnarchia is a stem-based taxon including all temnospondyls more closely related to Parotosuchus than to Eryops. It is the sister group of the clade Euskelia, which is all temnospondyls more closely related to Eryops than to Parotosuchus. Limnarchians represent an evolutionary radiation of temnospondyls into aquatic environments, while euskelians represent a radiation into terrestrial environments. While many euskelians were adapted to life on land with strong limbs and bony scutes, most limnarchians were better adapted for the water with poorly developed limbs and lateral line sensory systems in their skulls.

<i>Lapillopsis</i> Extinct genus of temnospondyls

Lapillopsis is an extinct genus of stereospondyl temnospondyl within the family Lapillopsidae. Fossils belonging to the genus have been found in the Arcadia Formation of Queensland, Australia.

<i>Rhineceps</i> Extinct genus of temnospondyls

Rhineceps is an extinct genus of temnospondyl amphibian in the family Rhinesuchidae. Rhineceps was found in Northern Malawi in Southern Africa known only from its type species R. nyasaensis. Rhineceps was a late Permian semi-aquatic carnivore that lived in streams, rivers, lakes or lagoons. Rhineceps is an early divergent Stereopondyl within the family Rhinesuchidae, which only existed in the late Permian (Lopingian) and failed to survive the Permian-Triassic extinction unlike other stereospondyl families.

Rileymillerus is an extinct genus of temnospondyl amphibian from the Late Triassic Post Quarry in the Dockum Group of Texas that was described by John Bolt and Sankar Chatterjee in 2000. The holotype, a nearly complete skull with articulated jaws, is housed at the Museum of Texas Tech University. The genus is named for Riley Miller, who allowed Chatterjee to work on the Post Quarry, and the species is named for the paleontologist John Cosgriff.

The Popo Agie Formation is a Triassic geologic formation that crops out in western Wyoming, western Colorado, and Utah. It was deposited during the Late Triassic in fluvial (river) and lacustrine (lake) environments that existed across much of what is now the American southwest. Fragmentary fossils of prehistoric reptiles and amphibians, including pseudosuchian reptiles and temnospondyl amphibians, have been discovered in the Popo Agie Formation. Dinosaur remains are also among the fossils that have been recovered from the formation, although none have yet been referred to a specific genus.

Chinlestegophis is a diminutive Late Triassic stereospondyl that has been interpreted as a putative stem caecilian, a living group of legless burrowing amphibians. If Chinlestegophis is indeed both an advanced stereospondyl and a relative of caecilians, this means that stereospondyls survived to the present day; historically the group was thought to have gone extinct by the early Cretaceous. Chinlestegophis jenkinsi, the type and only species, is known from two partial skulls discovered in the Chinle Formation in Colorado.

<i>Manubrantlia</i> Extinct genus of temnospondyls

Manubrantlia was a genus of lapillopsid temnospondyls from the Early Triassic Panchet Formation of India. This genus is only known from a single holotype left jaw, given the designation ISI A 57. Despite the paucity of remains, the jaw is still identifiable as belonging to a relative of Lapillopsis. For example, all three of its coronoid bones possessed teeth, the articular bone is partially visible in lateral (outer) view, and its postsplenial does not contact the posterior meckelian foramen. However, the jaw also possesses certain unique features which justify the erection of a new genus separate from Lapillopsis. For example, the mandible is twice the size of any jaws referred to other lapillopsids. The most notable unique feature is an enlarged "pump-handle" shaped arcadian process at the back of the jaw. This structure is responsible for the generic name of this genus, as "Manubrantlia" translates from Latin to the English expression "pump-handle". The type and only known species of this genus is Manubrantlia khaki. The specific name refers to the greenish-brown mudstones of the Panchet Formation, with a color that had been described as "khaki" by the first British geologists who studied the formation.

Latiscopus disjunctus is a small Late Triassic temnospondyl collected in 1940 by a Works Projects Administration crew working near Otis Chalk, Texas that was described by John Wilson in 1948.

Oryctorhynchus is an extinct genus of rhynchosaur from the Late Triassic (Carnian-Norian)-aged Wolfville Formation of Nova Scotia, Canada that may have been the same animal as Beesiiwo. The type species, O. bairdi, was named and described in 2020. It was originally seen as a species of Hyperodapedon until 2020.

<i>Triassurus</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Triassurus is an extinct genus of amphibian, and the oldest member of Caudata. It is known from the Middle to Upper Triassic (Ladinian-Carnian) aged Madygen Formation in Kyrgyzstan. The type species is T. sixtelae.

<i>Funcusvermis</i> Extinct genus of amphibians

Funcusvermis is an extinct genus of stem-caecilian from the Late Triassic of Arizona. It is based on a large sample of jaws and other skull and postcranial fragments, discovered in an approximately 220 million years old layer of rock in the Blue Mesa Member of the Chinle Formation at Petrified Forest National Park. There is a single species, called Funcusvermis gilmorei.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 So, Calvin; Kufner, Aaron M.; Pardo, Jason D.; Edwards, Caian L.; Price, Brandon R.; Bevitt, Joseph J.; LeClair-Diaz, Amanda; St. Clair, Lynette; Mann, Josh; Teran, Reba; Lovelace, David M. (2024-10-30). "Fossil amphibian offers insights into the interplay between monsoons and amphibian evolution in palaeoequatorial Late Triassic systems". Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 291 (2033). doi:10.1098/rspb.2024.1041. ISSN   0962-8452. PMC   11521612 . PMID   39471852.
  2. Wilson, John Andrew (1948). "A Small Amphibian from the Triassic of Howard County, Texas". Journal of Paleontology. 22 (3): 359–361. ISSN   0022-3360. JSTOR   1299405.
  3. Bolt, John R.; Chatterjee, Sankar (2000). "A new temnospondyl amphibian from the Late Triassic of Texas". Journal of Paleontology. 74 (4): 670–683. Bibcode:2000JPal...74..670B. doi:10.1017/s0022336000032790. ISSN   0022-3360.
  4. 1 2 3 Pardo, Jason D.; Small, Bryan J.; Huttenlocker, Adam K. (2017-06-19). "Stem caecilian from the Triassic of Colorado sheds light on the origins of Lissamphibia". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 114 (27): E5389 –E5395. Bibcode:2017PNAS..114E5389P. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1706752114 . ISSN   0027-8424. PMC   5502650 . PMID   28630337.
  5. Dutuit, J.-M. (1972). "Un nouveau genre de Stégocephale du Trias Supérieur Marocain: Almasaurus habbazi". Bulletin du Museum national d'histoire naturelle, Paris. 3: 73–77.
  6. Kligman, Ben T.; Gee, Bryan M.; Marsh, Adam D.; Nesbitt, Sterling J.; Smith, Matthew E.; Parker, William G.; Stocker, Michelle R. (2023-01-25). "Triassic stem caecilian supports dissorophoid origin of living amphibians". Nature. 614 (7946): 102–107. Bibcode:2023Natur.614..102K. doi:10.1038/s41586-022-05646-5. ISSN   0028-0836. PMC   9892002 . PMID   36697827.
  7. Marjanović, David; Maddin, Hillary C.; Olori, Jennifer C.; Laurin, Michel (2024-01-10). "The new problem of Chinlestegophis and the origin of caecilians (Amphibia, Gymnophionomorpha) is highly sensitive to old problems of sampling and character construction". Fossil Record. 27 (1): 55–94. Bibcode:2024FossR..27...55M. doi: 10.3897/fr.27.e109555 . ISSN   2193-0074.
  8. 1 2 3 Fernandez, Vincent; Abdala, Fernando; Carlson, Kristian J.; Cook, Della Collins; Rubidge, Bruce S.; Yates, Adam; Tafforeau, Paul (2013-06-21). "Synchrotron Reveals Early Triassic Odd Couple: Injured Amphibian and Aestivating Therapsid Share Burrow". PLOS ONE. 8 (6): e64978. Bibcode:2013PLoSO...864978F. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0064978 . ISSN   1932-6203. PMC   3689844 . PMID   23805181.
  9. Parrish, Judith Totman (1993). "Climate of the Supercontinent Pangea". The Journal of Geology. 101 (2): 215–233. Bibcode:1993JG....101..215P. doi:10.1086/648217. ISSN   0022-1376.
  10. Lovelace, David M.; Fitch, Adam J.; Schwartz, Darin; Schmitz, Mark (2023-10-06). "Concurrence of Late Triassic lithostratigraphic, radioisotopic, and biostratigraphic data support a Carnian age for the Popo Agie Formation (Chugwater Group), Wyoming, USA". Geological Society of America Bulletin. 136 (5–6): 2305–2324. doi:10.1130/B36807.1. ISSN   0016-7606.