Pennhurst State School and Hospital

Pennhurst State School and Hospital
Pennhurst Memorial & Preservation Alliance
Geography
Location	Spring City, Pennsylvania, United States
Coordinates	40°11′37″N75°33′37″W / 40.193717°N 75.560162°W / 40.193717; -75.560162
Organization
Care system	Private
Funding	Government hospital
Type	Specialist
Services
Standards	Psychiatric hospital
Beds	3,350 (1950) [1]
Speciality	Care of the physically and mentally disabled
Helipad	No
History
Opened	November 23, 1908 (1908-11-23)
Closed	December 9, 1987 (1987-12-09)
Links
Website	www.preservepennhurst.org
Lists	Hospitals in Pennsylvania
Building details
Former names	Eastern State Institution for the Feeble-Minded and Epileptic
Alternative names	Pennhurst School
General information
Status	Partially operational – private property
Type	Previous: Hospital Current: Museum & tourist attraction
Architectural style	Jacobean Revival
Elevation	233 feet (71 m) [2]
Current tenants	Pennhurst Memorial & Preservation Alliance
Owner	Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
Technical details
Material	Brick, steel, and concrete (all buildings)
Floor count	List of building count Administration Building – 4 Assembly Building – 4 Devon Hall – 5 Kitchens/Dining Halls – 4 Hershey Hall – 5 Hospital – 4 Industry Halls – 4 Laundry Facilities – 4 Limerick Hall – 5 Mayflower Hall – 5 Penn Hall – 4 Philadelphia Hall – 4 Quaker Hall – 4 Rockwell Hall – 4 Tinicum Hall – 4 Union Hall – 5 Vincennes Hall – 5 Superintendent's Residence – 3
Floor area	Total area: 636,454 sq ft (59,128.5 m2) List of buildings area Administration Building – 29,128 sq ft (2,706.1 m2) Assembly Building – 27,102 sq ft (2,517.9 m2) Devon Hall – 103,840 sq ft (9,647 m2) Kitchens/Dining Halls – unknown Hershey Hall – 29,128 sq ft (2,706.1 m2) Hospital – 86,632 sq ft (8,048.4 m2) Industry Halls – 23,182 sq ft (2,153.7 m2) Laundry Facilities – 42,872 sq ft (3,982.9 m2) Limerick Hall – 43,270 sq ft (4,020 m2) Mayflower Hall – 45,740 sq ft (4,249 m2) Penn Hall – 34,208 sq ft (3,178.0 m2) Philadelphia Hall – 14,448 sq ft (1,342.3 m2) Quaker Hall – 27,440 sq ft (2,549 m2) Rockwell Hall – 25,200 sq ft (2,340 m2) Tinicum Hall – 32,628 sq ft (3,031.2 m2) Union Hall – 31,708 sq ft (2,945.8 m2) Vincennes Hall – 36,600 sq ft (3,400 m2) Superintendent's Residence – 3,460 sq ft (321 m2) Haunted House - 4,640 sq ft (431 m2)
Lifts/elevators	1 (Hospital)
Grounds	At open: 112 acres (45 ha) At close: 1,400 acres (570 ha)
Pennhurst State School and Hospital
Pennsylvania Historical Marker
PHMC dedicated	April 10, 2010 (2010-04-10) [3]

Pennhurst State School and Hospital, originally known as the Eastern Pennsylvania State Institution for the Feeble-Minded and Epileptic was a state-run institution for mentally and physically disabled individuals of Southeastern Pennsylvania located in Spring City. ^[4] After 79 years of controversy, it closed on December 9, 1987. ^[5]

History

Overview

In 1903, the Pennsylvania Legislature authorized the creation of the Eastern State Institution for the Feeble-Minded and Epileptic and a commission was organized to take into consideration the number and status of the feeble-minded and epileptic persons in the state and determine a placement for construction to care for these residents. This commission discovered 1,146 feeble-minded persons in insane hospitals and 2,627 in almshouses, county-care hospitals, reformatories, and prisons, who were in immediate need of specialized institutional care.

The legislation stated that the buildings would be in two groups, one for the educational and industrial department, and one for the custodial or asylum department. The institution was required to accommodate no fewer than five hundred inmates or patients, with room for additions. Wesley White, the former president of the American Association of Medical Dosimetrists, was appointed superintendent of the facility. ^[6]

Construction and design

Building designation

From 1903 to 1908, the first buildings were constructed on 633.913 acres (256.535 ha) of Crab Hill in Spring City, Pennsylvania, Chester County on what was referred to as the lower campus. Of the first few buildings constructed, 'F' was the girl's dining room, 'G' was the kitchen and storeroom, 'H', 'I' and 'K' were cottages for girls, 'N' was the boys' dining room, 'P' was the teacher's home, 'Q', T', 'U' and 'V' were cottages for boys, 'R' was a school, 'W' was laundry and sewing, and 'X' was the power house.

'P' was used as a temporary administration building until the institution's opening in 1918 along with the opening of 'L' and 'M' in 1919. In 1921, Whitman and Wilson I and II were constructed along with Penn Hall for employee housing; in 1929, the assembly building was complete and functioned as the gymnasium and auditorium.

The buildings on lower campus are currently labeled with letters such as 'F', 'I', 'K', 'P', 'Q', 'R', 'N', 'U', 'V', 'T', 'W' and 'X' with names later assigned in the 1960s (see below).

In 1930, the first buildings on the upper campus, otherwise known as the female colony, were completed and named Pershing, Buchanan, Audubon and Keystone. Capitol Hall was erected after World War II along with Devon constructed on lower campus. Horizon Hall opened later in 1971.

Lower campus buildings

Administration, Philadelphia, Quaker, Rockwell, Franklin, Nobel, Union, Vincennes, Tinicum, Industry, Penn, Devon, Mayflower, Limerick, Assembly, Storeroom, Laundry, Whitman, Wilson I, Wilson II, Hershey

(Rockwell, Nobel, Franklin and Hershey were all demolished in 2020)

Upper campus buildings

Pershing, Buchanan, Audubon, Keystone, Capitol, Horizon

(Buchanan, Audubon, Keystone, Capital were demolished in 2018)

Appearance

Birds Eye View of Campus, 1934

The older buildings, designed by Phillip H. Johnson, were two-storied, and made of red brick, terra cotta, and granite trimmings. They were connected by fire-proof tunnels with walkways on top of the tunnels for the use of transporting residents, with a parallel steam piping system, and were distributed on the 1,400-acre (570 ha) campus in the cottage plan formation. The buildings were designed to provide a large number of small rooms occupied by two to three beds, a few small dormitories with eight to ten beds, and a large day room for exercise. George Lovatt was the architect for several of the buildings constructed post-1937.

The central administration building had two side porte-cocheres, a front portico and a copper cupola in the center of the roof. The hospital building, Whitman, and Wilson I and II were not tunnel-connected, nor was Penn Hall and the power house. The remaining cottage buildings are L- and I-shaped with the exception of dietary, which was Y-shaped, and Devon Hall, which was H-shaped.

Railroad

The Pennsylvania Railroad created a Pennhurst Station on its Schuylkill Division. Coal and other supplies were delivered by rail. Tracks are still visible under the pavement behind dietary and Devon Hall, which allowed boxcars to be brought directly onto the main campus. The railroad tracks have been removed and are now part of the Schuylkill River Trail.

General operation

Opening

On November 23, 1908, "Patient number 1" was admitted to the hospital. ^[7] Within four years of operation, Pennhurst was overcrowded and under pressure to admit immigrants, orphans, and criminals.^{[ citation needed ]}

Classification

Residents were classified into mental categories of imbecile or insane, into physical categories of epileptic or healthy, and into dental categories of good, poor or treated teeth when admitted.

Industries

Residents were assigned to mattress-making, shoemaking and repair, grading, farming, laundry, domestic duties, sewing, baking, butchering, painting, and working in the store.^{[ citation needed ]}

Segregation and eugenics

In 1913, the legislature appointed a Commission for the Care of the Feeble-Minded which stated that disabled people were unfit for citizenship and posed a menace to the peace, and thus recommended a program of custodial care. Furthermore, the Commission desired to prevent the intermixing of the genes of those imprisoned with the general population. In the Biennial Report to the Legislature submitted by the Board of Trustees, Pennhurst's Chief Physician quoted Henry H. Goddard, a leading eugenicist, as follows:

Every feeble-minded person is a potential criminal. The general public, although more convinced today than ever before that it is a good thing to segregate the idiot or the distinct imbecile, they have not as yet been convinced as to the proper treatment of the defective delinquent, which is the brighter and more dangerous individual. ^[8]

Treatment of women

In 1916, the Board of Trustees initiated a plan to construct cottages specifically for women to segregate them from the men, in part to prevent pregnancies.^{[ citation needed ]}

Conditions exposed

In 1968, conditions at Pennhurst were exposed in a five-part television news report anchored by local WCAU-TV correspondent Bill Baldini. ^{[9] [10]}

In 1981, a Time magazine article described the place as having "a history of being understaffed, dirty and violent." ^[11] In 1983, nine employees were indicted on charges ranging from slapping and beating patients (including some in wheelchairs) to arranging for patients to assault each other. ^[12]

The Halderman Case, ^[13] which resulted in the closure of the institution, also detailed widespread patient abuse.

Closure

In 1977, U.S. District Judge Raymond J. Broderick ruled that the conditions at Pennhurst State School violated patients' constitutional rights. The lawsuit that led to his ruling was filed May 30, 1974, by Philadelphia attorney David Ferleger ^[14] representing the patients. The suit was later joined by the United States and by the Pennsylvania Association for Retarded Citizens. The facility was ultimately closed in 1987. The 1,156 people who lived there on the date of the Court's order (March 17, 1978) moved into small community homes called Community Living Arrangements. These settings supported three or fewer people, with 24 hour staffing if needed. This process of deinstitutionalization required nine years, and included discussion of treatment plans with each person and family. ^{[15] [13]}

Halderman v. Pennhurst State School and Hospital

The allegations of abuse led to the first lawsuit of its kind in the United States, a federal class action, Pennhurst State School and Hospital v. Halderman , ^[16] which asserted that those with developmental disabilities in the care of the state have a constitutional right to appropriate care and education. ^[17] Terri Lee Halderman had been a resident of Pennhurst, and following multiple episodes of abuse, she and her family filed suit in the federal district court. The suit started after Halderman had visited her parents at home and was found to have unexplained bruises. Although the case was not expected to reach the level it did, the courts later found that conditions at Pennhurst were unsanitary, inhumane and dangerous, violating the Fourteenth Amendment, and that Pennhurst used cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments, as well as the Pennsylvania Mental Health and Retardation Act of 1966 (MH/MR). ^[18] The District Court ruled that certain of the patients' rights had been violated. The District Court decision was the first time that any federal court ruled that an institution must be closed based on a constitutional right to community services. ^{[19] [20]}

The rulings collectively lent credence to the nascent "deinstitutionalization" movement, which sought to move mental patients from hospitals to halfway houses or reintegrate them into their families. ^[11] The rulings also aligned with the increasing tendency of federal courts to take control of school districts, prisons and other state institutions in order to enforce citizens' rights. ^[11] Ultimately, however, the U.S. Supreme Court vacated the judgment based on the Eleventh Amendment principle that federal courts cannot order state officials to comply with state laws. ^[21] As noted below, the institution was eventually closed pursuant to a settlement agreement that required that community-based services be offered to all of its residents.

The case became an important rule of law known as the Pennhurst Doctrine, which has been cited by state attorneys general as binding precedent under United States constitutional law. ^[22]

Modern day

The Pennhurst Memorial and Preservation Alliance traveling exhibit on display in the Russell Senate Office Building rotunda, Washington, D.C., June 27, 2016

The United States Department of Veterans Affairs acquired the upper campus and began work to renovate it as a veterans' home. In 1986, the upper campus cottage units reopened as the Southeastern Veterans' Center. In 1990, renovations began on Horizon Hall, one of the newest buildings at Pennhurst, as part of a project to establish a nursing facility at the veterans' center. It reopened in 1993 as Coates Hall. ^[23] After many years of determining what to do with Pennhurst, Congressman Jim Gerlach sought to establish a Federal veteran's cemetery at Pennhurst in 2003 but the VA rejected the proposal.^{[ citation needed ]}

In 2001, the state adopted the Keystone Principles concerning the state's duties to maintain historic property and to consult with the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission before transferring the property into private hands. Chester County officials approved a private development and Pennhurst was sold to a developer, Pennhurst Associates, for two million dollars. The Pennhurst Memorial and Preservation Alliance (PMPA) was formed to advocate for certain uses of the site.^{[ citation needed ]}

Pennhurst was added to Pennsylvania's list of the most at-risk Pennsylvania properties as well as the International Coalition of Sites of Conscience, a worldwide network of historic sites specifically dedicated to remembering struggles for justice.^{[ citation needed ]}

In partnership with the Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphia, PMPA obtained a grant to complete a re-use design and feasibility study of the Pennhurst campus. By 2010, the administration building had been partially renovated and reopened as the Pennhurst Asylum seasonal haunted attraction. The attraction has been successful, though controversial among locals and those previously affiliated with Pennhurst. ^{[24] [25]}

Penn Organic Recycling LLC operated on 4.5-acre (1.8 ha) of Pennhurst, offering topping, composting and food waste services. The Department of Environmental Protection permitted the composting operation at Pennhurst to maintain no more than 25 tons. It is no longer in operation.^{[ citation needed ]}

In 2015, the Pennhurst Memorial and Preservation Alliance began working with the Southeastern Veterans' Center to obtain the superintendent's residence for a future museum and interpretive center.^{[ citation needed ]}

By the end of 2016, demolition had begun on some of the buildings on the upper campus.^{[ citation needed ]}

In 2017, bookings for daytime history tours, photography tours, and overnight paranormal investigations became available through the haunted attraction's website. Proceeds from the tours go towards the upkeep of the grounds and restoration of the remaining buildings.^{[ citation needed ]}

The Travel Channel's television show Destination Fear filmed at the location for the fifth episode of their first season in 2019 . ^[26]

By 2020, Hershey, Rockwell, and Dietary halls were all deemed unsafe for reuse. That March, demolition began and by November, all three buildings had been demolished.^{[ citation needed ]}

On June 8, 2021 heavy metal band Motionless in White performed their Deadstream 2: Live at Pennhurst concert on the grounds in front of the main building entrance. The concert was streamed the following day.^{[ citation needed ]}

See also

• Mental health

References

1. W.A. Phillips (1954). "Pennhurst State School" (PDF). Preserve Pennhurst. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. p. 3. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
2. U.S. Geological Survey Geographic Names Information System: Pennhurst State School
3. "PHMC Historical Markers Search". Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Archived from the original (Searchable database) on March 21, 2016. Retrieved January 25, 2014.
4. "About Pennhurst State School and Hospital". Preserve Pennhurst. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
5. Yakutchik, Maryalice (January 24, 1988). "Closing Pennhurst sets rights precedence". Reading Eagle. Reading, PA. pp. A-1, A-3. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
6. Shafter, Albert J. (October 1971). "In The News". Mental Retardation. Vol. 9, no. 5. p. 29.
7. "Pennhurst Timeline". www.preservepennhurst.com. Retrieved November 10, 2023.
8. Law Notes (22 ed.). E. Thompson Company. November 1918. p. 149. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
9. "Pennsylvania Settles Key Suit on Facilities for the Retarded". The New York Times. July 15, 1984. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
10. "Suffer The Little Children" (video). Preserve Pennhurst. © NBC10 Philadelphia. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
11. "Patients' Rights". TIME. Vol. 117, no. 18. May 4, 1981. p. 60.
12. "Workers Indicted in Patient Abuse". The New York Times. November 4, 1983. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
13. Halderman v. Pennhurst State Sch. Hospital, 612F.2d84 (3d Cir.1979).
14. Original Court Docket, http://www.elpeecho.com/pennhurst/PDF/CourtDocs/A2-Docket-MR-PA-0002-9001.pdf
15. Conroy, J. & Bradley, V. (1985). The Pennhurst Longitudinal Study: A Report of Five Years of Research and Analysis (PDF). Temple University Institute on Disabilities. p. 85.
16. Halderman v. Pennhurst State School & Hospital, 446F. Supp.1295 (E.D. Pa.1978).
17. U.S. District Court, e.D., Pennsylvania. (1977). "Halderman v. Pennhurst State School and Hospital. 23 Dec 1977". Federal Supplement. 446: 1295–329. PMID   11646079.
18. "Pennsylvania Mental Health and Retardation Act of 1966" (PDF). Temple University. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Archived from the original (PDF) on November 27, 2014. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
19. Scott, P.M.; Ferleger, D. (1983). "Rights and dignity: Congress, the Supreme Court, and people with disabilities after Pennhurst". Western New England Law Review. 5 (3): 327–61. PMID   11658602.
20. Anti-Institutionalization and the Supreme Court, 14 Rutgers L.Rev. 595 (1983).
21. Pennhurst State School and Hospital v. Halderman , 4512101 (U.S. 11981).
22. Raphael, Stuart (November 3, 2014). "Brief on Behalf of Amici in Halbig v. Burwell (D.C. Cir. 14-5018)". pp. 11–12. Retrieved December 4, 2014. When Congress seeks the States' cooperation to implement Federal legislation enacted under the Spending Clause, the States are entitled to clear notice about the conditions that will be imposed.
23. "Southeastern Veterans' Center". www.portal.state.pa.us. Archived from the original on September 22, 2010. Retrieved January 15, 2022.
24. Walters, Patrick (September 22, 2010). "Mental health pros boo haunted house at Pa. asylum". Boston.com. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
25. Ellingsworth Jr., Phil (October 24, 2011). "Another scary year at Pennhurst causes new concerns with neighbors". The Delaware County Daily Times. Retrieved January 17, 2016.
26. "Destination Fear" Pennhurst State School (TV Episode 2019) - IMDb , retrieved October 26, 2021

External links

• Antiquity Echoes History, present day photos, and video of Pennhurst State School and Hospital
• Wayne Benner Ultimate Pennhurst Photo Collection by Wayne Benner
• Photadyta History and Photographs
• Soul-Imagery.com Pennhurst Gallery
• Pennhurst Memorial and Preservation Alliance
• i go home , a documentary about former residents and the closure of Pennhurst