Professor of Classics (Edinburgh)

Professor of Classics University of Edinburgh
Incumbent Douglas Cairns since 2004
Classics
First holder	Laurence Dundas (1708), William Scott Primus (1708).
Website	https://edwebprofiles.ed.ac.uk/profile/douglas-cairns

The Professor of Classics at the University of Edinburgh is the established Chair in Classics in the School of History, Classics and Archaeology. Since 2004 the Chair has been held by Douglas Cairns. Greek and Latin were compulsory for all students at Edinburgh until 1892, when Latin alone could be substituted for Greek. ^[1]

In 1981 the Chair of Greek was left vacant by the retirement of A. J. Beattie, and in 1982 the Chair of Humanity soon followed with the retirement of Ian Campbell. In 1987 the Chairs were reconstituted to form the Professor of Classics. [2]

History

William Carstares, Principal of the University 1703-15, was the driving force behind the creation of 'Dutch' style Chairs at Edinburgh.

Originally, the Chair was divided between the historical Departments of Humanity (Latin) and Greek, and these two Chairs were established during William Carstares restructuring of the University along Dutch lines which abolished the regenting system and created the Faculty of Arts. [3] ^{[4] [5] [5] [6]} Bower notes that the Universities of Amsterdam, Leiden or Utrecht, on which Carsatres' reforms had been based, did not have Chairs of Humanity but only Chairs of Greek (Gracce Linguae Historiarum et Eloquentiae Professor), and he highlights the unique foundation of this Chair. ^[6] However, Carstares' reforms did not establish the first professorships at Edinburgh, since a Chair of Divinity had existed since 1620, and a Chair of Hebrew was appointed alongside the four Regents in 1642, with a Chair of Mathematics added in 1674 and of Physic (Medicine) in 1685. ^[7]

The former Regents of Humanity, William Scott Primus appointed as a Regent in 1695 and Laurence Dundas appointed as a Regent in 1690, who had taught Greek and Latin before Carstares' reforms (the first regens humaniorum literarum were appointed in 1583), were created the inaugural holders of each Chair by Royal Warrant. ^{[3] [8] [5] [9]} At William Scott's creation he was granted the honorific title 'Regius Professor', which had been similarly given to the new Chair of Law, since he had: 'obtained a patent from the Crown for the profession of Greek, by which he was constitute her Majesty's sole Professor of Greek in the University of Edinburgh'. ^{[10] [11]} However, ultimately, Scott failed to get a direct grant from the Crown, he was not made Professor under his specific royal patent, and the honorific has not been retained. ^{[10] [11] [12]}

Unless candidates for the professorships already held Chairs they were subject to a 'trial', that is, an examination of their Greek and Latin before their appointment. However, John Ker, already Professor of Greek at Aberdeen and John HIll, Professor of Greek at St Andrews, avoided such ordeals for it would have been considered insulting to have tested the Professor of another university. ^[6] Further, this practice led to something of a curiosity during the election of George Stuart in 1741 to the Chair of Humanity when both candidates:

'agreed to transmit a message to the electors, stating that each believed the other to be qualified, and that they were rather inclined to refer it to their own choice, without putting them to additional trouble.' ^[10]

The Chairs in Greek and Humanity at the Scottish Universities, whose incumbent professors 'occupied an especial place in the culture of these cities' ^[13] , all came to be quite distinct, and Morris writes (concerning their foundation and holders in the 19th century): ^[14]

'In terms of appointments to chairs in Greek or Humanity each Scottish university seemed to follow a different tradition: the chair of Greek at Glasgow was the preserve of Oxbridge educated scholars [e.g., Daniel Sandford (scholar), Edmund Law Lushington, Richard Claverhouse Jebb]; at Edinburgh no Englishman was successful in applying for either chair [until Harry Goodhart in Humanity and Arthur Wallace Pickard-Cambridge in Greek], whilst at Aberdeen the successful applicants were invariably graduates from that very university.'

Election to the Chairs in the contentious years surrounding The Disruption of 1843 became a proxy for Scotland's religious politics. When J. S. Blackie sought the Chair of Greek he was in competition with the Reverend Charles McDouall, who was prevented from taking the Chair in Hebrew owing to the influence of the Presbytery of Edinburgh, Sir Wiliam Smith, a nonconformist Dissenter who could not, as a result, teach at Oxford or Cambridge, Edmund Lushington, John Conington an avowed Anglo-Catholic, and Leonhard Schmitz, then Rector of the Royal High School. ^{[1] [15] [14]} McDouall was viewed as the Free Church candidate, and Schmitz the Episcopalian candidate, meanwhile the maverick Blackie had refused to unreservedly sign the Confession of Faith at Marischal owing to his sympathies with German rationalism. Indeed, Blackie and his supporters had actually worried that a charge of heresy might be raised against him during the campaign. Blackie eventually won by a single vote -- the casting vote of the Lord Provost. ^{[1] [14]}

Professors of Classics

• 1987-2004:* Reverend CanonJohn Richardson
• 2004-Present: Douglas Cairns

*Now Emeritus Professor.

Professors of Humanity

1. 1708-34:* Laurence Dundas
2. 1728-34:* Adam Watt
3. 1734-41: John Ker
4. 1741-75: George Stuart
5. 1775-1805: John Hill
6. 1806-20: Alexander Christison
7. 1820-63: James Pillans
8. 1863-90: William Young Sellar
9. 1890-95: Harry Chester Goodhart
10. 1895-1916:** William Ross Hardie
11. 1919-48: Oliffe Legh Richmond
12. 1948-59: Michael Grant
13. 1959-1982: Ian M. Campbell

*Chair shared (Watt predeceased Dundas). ^[8]

**Chair vacant from 1916-19.

• 
  John Hill by Henry Raeburn.
• 
  Alexander Christison.
• 
  James Pillans (bust in the Playfair Library)
• 
  Wiliam Young Sellar.
• 
  Ian M. Campbell

Literary forger William Lauder applied unsuccessfully to succeed Adam Watt, having previously been his assistant, but he was instead succeeded by John Ker, who until then held the Chair of Greek at King's College, Aberdeen. ^{[8] [10]} William Sellar who, along with Harry Goodhart, gives his name to the Sellar, Goodhart and Giles Classical Library of the Department of Classics which was instituted by private subscription in 1897. ^[16]

• 
• 
• 

Professors of Greek

1. 1708-1729: Willam Scott Primus
2. 1729-1730: William Scott Secundus
3. 1730-1753:* Colin Drummond
4. 1738-41:* Robert Law
5. 1741-1772:** Robert Hunter
6. 1772-1805: Andrew Dalzell
7. 1805-1851: George Dunbar
8. 1852-1882: John Stuart Blackie
9. 1882-1903: Samuel H. Butcher
10. 1902-28: Alexander Wiliam Mair
11. 1928-30: SirArthur Wallace Pickard-Cambridge
12. 1930-51: Sir William Moir Calder
13. 1951-81: Arthur J ames Beattie

*Chair shared from 1738-53.

**In 1772 Hunter sold the Chair to Dalzell for £300 'and a liferent of the salary' as sanctioned by the Town Council, since without pensions the aging professors often only had their Chairs as assets in old . ^{[10] [13]}

• 
  Andrew Dalzell.
• 
  Andrew Dalzell by Henry Raeburn
• 
  George Dunbar (bust in the Playfair Library)
• 
  J. S. Blackie.
• 
  S. H. Butcher
• 
  Sir A. W. Pickard-Cambridge.
• 
  A. J. Beattie

Caricature of Blackie before the Greek class in The Strand .

Colin Drummond (brother of Adam Drummond) was first appointed as a Regent of Philosophy in 1707, and then to the Chair of Logic and Metaphysics in 1708 where he taught David Hume, before he took up the Chair of Greek in 1730. ^[10] During J. S. Blackie's tenure of the Greek Chair, he taught Robert Louis Stevenson, and Stevenson would later write:

'Although I am the holder of a certificate of attendance in the Professor's own hand, I cannot remember to have been present in the Greek class above a dozen time. Professor Blackie was even kind enough to remark (more than once) while in the very act of writing the document above referred to, that he did not know my face.' ^[17]

Comparably, Sir Walter Scott, who was taught by Dalzell, records angering the Professor:

'I had the audacity to produce a composition in which I weighted Homer against Ariosto and pronounced him wanting in the balance[...] The wrath of the Professor was extreme[...] He pronounced upon me the severe sentence that dunce I was and dunce I would remain[...] which however, my excellent and learned friend lived to revoked over a bottle of Burgundy, at our Literary Club at Fortune's, of which he is a distinguished members'. ^[18]

In 1983, E. K. Borthwick was appointed to a personal chair in Greek at Edinburgh, but this is not to be confused with the established Chair.

Prizes named for the professors

S. H. Butcher gives his name to the Butcher Memorial Prize in Greek, awarded to the best student in Greek 1, and William Scott and George Dunbar to the Scott and Dunbar Prize in Greek, awarded to the most deserving student in the Greek class.

At Laurence Dundas' death in 1734 he 'bequeathed 9000 merks (£500) as a perpetual fund for educating three bursars, with a preference to persons with the surname of Dundas'. [10]

See also

• Regius Professor of Greek (Oxford)
• Regius Professor of Greek (Cambridge)
• MacDowell Professor of Greek (Glasgow)
• Professor of Humanity (Glasgow)
• Regius Professor of Humanity (Aberdeen)
• Professor of Greek (University College London)
• Professor of Latin (University College London)

References

1. Wallace, Stuart (2006). John Stuart Blackie. Edinburgh: EUP. p. 174.
2. "Humanity - Our History". ourhistory.is.ed.ac.uk. Retrieved 2025-02-25.
3. Dalzell, Andrew (1862). History of the University of Edinburgh. Edinburgh: Edmonston and Douglas. pp. 299–300.
4. Horn, D. B. (1967). A Short History of the University of Edinburgh: 1556-1889. EUP. p. 41.
5. Nicholas Philippson in Robert D. Anderson, Michael Lynch (2003). The University of Edinburgh: An Illustrated History. Edinburgh. p. 61.
6. Bower, Alexander (1817). The history of the University of Edinburgh; chiefly compiled from original papers and records (vol. II). Edinburgh: Oliphant, Waugh and Innes. p. 299.
7. Mijers, Esther (2012). 'The Netherlands, William Carstares, and the Reform of Edinburgh University, 1690–17151' in Feingold, M. (ed.) 2015, History of Universities XXV/2. Oxford.: OUP (published 2015). pp. 114–5.
8. Emerson, Roger, L. (2008). Academic Patronage in the Scottish Enlightenment. Edinburgh: EUP. pp. 253–4.
9. Mijers, Esther (2012). 'News from the Republick of Letters': Scottish Students, Charles Mackie and the United Provinces, 1650–1750. Leiden: Brill. p. 112.
10. Grant, Sir Alexander (1884). The story of the University of Edinburgh during its first three hundred years (vol. 1). London. pp. 318–19.
11. Stewart, M. A. (1990). 'The Origins of the Scottish Greek Chairs' in Craik, E. M. (ed.), Owls to Athens: Essays on Classical Subjects presented to Sir Kenneth Dover. Oxford: OUP. p. 395.
12. Cairns, J. W. (207). "The Origins of the Edinburgh Law School: the Union of 1707 and the Regius Chair" (PDF). Edinburgh Law Review . 11 (3): 300–48. doi:10.3366/elr.2007.11.3.300.
13. Morris, M. (2008). 'The Democratic Intellect Preserved' in Hallett, J. P., & Stray, C. (eds) British Classics Outside England: The Academy and Beyond. Baylor, Texas: Baylor University Pres. pp. 15–6.
14. Morris, M. J. (2008). 'A Manly Desire to Learn ': the Teaching of the Classics in Nineteenth Century Scotland. PhD Thesis, OU. pp. 70–1.
15. "Hebrew - Our History". ourhistory.is.ed.ac.uk. Retrieved 2025-03-02.
16. Bell, Margaret, B. (1982). 'Faculty and Class Libraries' in Edinburgh University Library 1580-1980: A Collection of Historical Essays. Edinburgh University Library. pp. 166–7.
17. Stevenson, R. L. (1886). 'Some College Memories' in The New Amphion. Edinburgh: EUP.
18. Lockhart, J. G. (1893). Memoir of the Early Life of Sir Walter Scott. p. 12.