Ancient universities of Scotland

Ancient universities of Scotland. Clockwise from upper left: St Andrews, Glasgow, Aberdeen, Edinburgh.

St Andrews

Glasgow

Aberdeen

Edinburgh

class=notpageimage|

Locations of the ancient universities

The ancient universities of Scotland (Scottish Gaelic : Oilthighean ann an Alba) ^[1] are medieval and renaissance universities that continue to exist in the present day. Together, the four universities are the oldest universities in continuous operation in the English-speaking world after the universities of Oxford and Cambridge. The majority of the ancient universities of the British Isles are located within Scotland, and have a number of distinctive features in common, being governed by a series of measures laid down in the Universities (Scotland) Acts 1858–1966. The Universities (Scotland) Act 1966 uses the term 'older universities' to refer to St Andrews, Glasgow, Aberdeen and Edinburgh. ^[2] The four universities are generally regarded as the country's most selective, eminent and well-ranked universities. ^[6]

In common with the other ancient universities of the United Kingdom, the Scottish ancients find themselves administered in a quite different fashion from the new universities (there are now fifteen universities in Scotland) and are granted a number of privileges as a result of their different status. The ancient universities are part of twenty-seven culturally significant institutions recognised by the British monarchy as privileged bodies of the United Kingdom. ^[7]

Foundation and development

The surviving ancient universities in Scotland are, in order of formation:

Year	Name	Location	Notes
1413	University of St Andrews	St Andrews, Scotland	Founded by a papal bull building on earlier bodies established between 1410 and 1413, but officially recognized in 1413 [8]
1451	University of Glasgow	Glasgow, Scotland	Founded by a papal bull of Pope Nicholas V [9]
1495	University of Aberdeen	Aberdeen, Scotland	King's College was founded in 1495 by papal bull and Marischal College in 1593; they merged in 1860
1582	University of Edinburgh	Edinburgh, Scotland	Established by the town council under the authority of a royal charter granted by James VI

Members

St Andrews

Main articles: History of the University of St Andrews and University of St Andrews

St Salvator's Chapel, St Andrews

The University of St Andrews traces its origin to a society formed in 1410 by Laurence of Lindores, archdeacon Richard Cornwall, bishop William Stephenson and others. Bishop Henry Wardlaw (died 1440) issued a charter in 1411 and attracted the most learned men in Scotland as professors. In 1413 Avignon Pope Benedict XIII issued six bulls confirming the charter and constituting the society a university.

All of the ancient universities with the exception of St Andrews were both universities and colleges, with both titles being used. ^{[10] [11]} However the University of St Andrews was a traditional collegiate university with a number of colleges. Today, only two statutory colleges exist: United College and the much smaller St Mary's College for students of theology.

In 1897 a third college was created when University College Dundee (founded in 1891) was incorporated and absorbed into St Andrews University (1897). University College subsequently became Queen's College (1954). In 1978 Queen's College separated from the University of St Andrews to become the independent University of Dundee. A fourth non-statutory college, St Leonard's College was founded in 1972 using the name of an earlier institution as a formal grouping of postgraduate students. In 2022, the university announced its intention to found New College, which would form a new hub for the schools of economics and finance, international relations, and management. ^[12]

Glasgow

Gilmorehill campus, University of Glasgow

Main article: University of Glasgow

The University of Glasgow was founded in 1451 by a charter or papal bull from Pope Nicholas V, at the suggestion of King James II, giving Bishop William Turnbull, a graduate of the University of St Andrews, permission to add a university to the city's Cathedral. ^[13] It is the second-oldest university in Scotland after St Andrews and the fourth-oldest in the English-speaking world. The universities of St Andrews, Glasgow, and Aberdeen were ecclesiastical foundations, while Edinburgh was a civic foundation. As one of the ancient universities of the United Kingdom, Glasgow is one of only eight institutions to award undergraduate master's degrees in certain disciplines. ^[14]

Aberdeen

Main article: University of Aberdeen

Elphinstone Hall, Aberdeen

No college is mentioned in the foundation bill, only a university and it was the "University of Aberdeen" by that name which was established in 1495. Subsequently, a single college, originally known as St. Mary of the Nativity, was established (it was founded by William Elphinstone, Bishop of Aberdeen, who drafted a request on behalf of King James IV to Pope Alexander VI which resulted in a papal bull being issued). Soon the entity came to be called King's College, after its royal founder James IV.

A separate university (Marischal College) was founded in 1593. In 1860, King's merged with Marischal College. While both institutions were universities and would be considered ancient, the Act of Parliament uniting the two specified that the date of the foundation of the new united university would be taken to be that of the older King's College.

Aberdeen was highly unusual at this time for having two universities in one city: as 20th-century university prospectuses observed, Aberdeen had the same number as existed in England at the time (the University of Oxford and University of Cambridge). In addition, a further university was set up to the north of Aberdeen in Fraserburgh from 1595, but was closed down about a decade later. A further institute that was established in 1750 under the wishes of Robert Gordon, a wealthy University of Aberdeen alumnus has since evolved into the modern Robert Gordon University.

Edinburgh

New College, Edinburgh

Main article: University of Edinburgh

Founded by the Edinburgh Town Council, the university began as a college of law using part of a legacy left by a graduate of the University of St Andrews, Bishop Robert Reid of St Magnus Cathedral, Orkney. ^[15] The university was established by a royal charter granted by James VI in April 1582, ^[16] and instruction began under the charge of theologian Robert Rollock in October 1583. ^[17] As the first Scottish university to be founded by royal charter at the urging of the 'town council and burges of Edinburgh', rather than through papal bulls as had been the case for the three older universities, this set a new precedent. Despite this difference, it is universally considered one of the seven ancient universities of Britain and Ireland (and ten years older than the youngest ancient university, the Trinity College Dublin), a status affirmed by the Scottish Government. ^[18]

Anomalies

University of Dundee

The University of Dundee gained independent university status by Royal Charter in 1967, having previously been a college of the University of St Andrews. While not governed by the Universities (Scotland) Acts, the institution's Royal Charter provided for it to adopt the characteristics of ancient university governance such as the academic senate, awarding the undergraduate MA degree and electing a Rector.

As a consequence, some sources have grouped the University of Dundee among the ancient universities. ^{[19] [20]} The label has also been used by the university itself. ^[21] In a Scottish Government report published in 2019, Dundee is classified as a 'Chartered' university, alongside Strathclyde, Heriot-Watt, and Stirling, as opposed to an 'Ancient' university. ^[22]

At the installation of the university's Rector in 2007, the Principal and Vice Chancellor Sir Alan Langlands addressed the issue, noting: ^[23]

'The position of Rector is something that Dundee shares with only four other universities in Scotland - the so-called "Ancient Universities". For Dundee to be classed with the "ancients" - at a relatively youthful age of forty - feels a bit like finding someone getting up to offer you their seat on the bus when you feel that you are still a bit on the young side. But we accept this "ancient" tag, with grace, as a mark of our history and distinction and a reinforcement of the University's commitment to student representation at levels.'

University of Aberdeen

Marischal College, a former ancient university now part of the University of Aberdeen.

Despite being held as an ancient university, the University of Aberdeen was only created in 1860. The university was formed by the amalgamation of two existing ancient universities within Aberdeen, which were:

• University and King's College of Aberdeen; founded 1495
• Marischal College and University of Aberdeen; founded 1593

The two universities, generally known simply as King's College and Marischal College, were united into the modern University of Aberdeen by the Universities (Scotland) Act 1858. The Act of Parliament uniting the two universities specified that the date of the foundation of the new united university would be taken to be that of the older King's College, 1495. Another, short-lived, university existed in the Aberdeenshire town of Fraserburgh from 1595 to 1605. ^{[24] [25]}

In modern times, former college names may refer to specific university buildings, such as the King's College and Marischal College buildings in Aberdeen, the Old College and New College at Edinburgh and the 'Old College' to refer to the former buildings of the University of Glasgow before its move in the 19th century to Gilmorehill. ^[26]

Undergraduate Master of Arts degree

Main articles: Master of Arts (Scotland) and Master of Arts (Oxbridge and Dublin)

The ancient universities are distinctive in offering the Magister Artium/Master of Arts (M.A.) as an undergraduate academic degree. This is sometimes known as the Scottish MA, though it is offered by fewer than a third of Scotland's Universities.

Universities (Scotland) Acts

Main article: Ancient university governance in Scotland

The Universities (Scotland) Acts created a distinctive system of governance for the ancient universities in Scotland, the process beginning with the 1858 Act and ending with the 1966 Act. Despite not being founded until after the first in these series of Acts, the University of Dundee shares all the features contained therein.

As a result of these Acts, each of these universities is governed by a tripartite system of General Council, University Court, and Academic Senate.

The chief executive and chief academic is the University Principal who also holds the title of Vice-Chancellor as an honorific. The Chancellor is a titular non-resident head to each university and is elected for life by the respective General Council, although in actuality a good number of Chancellors resign before the end of their "term of office".

Each also has a students' representative council (SRC) as required by statute, although at the University of Aberdeen this has recently been renamed, the Students' Association Council (the Students' Association having been the parent body of the SRC). ^[27]

Status

HESA Student Body (2021/22) ^[28]

University	Scottish students	rUK students	Non-UK students	Non-UK (%)	Under- graduates	Post- graduates	Post- graduates (%)	Total students
Aberdeen	9,750	2,120	4,690	28.3%	10,140	6,425	38.8%	16,565
Edinburgh	11,300	11,900	18,050	43.8%	26,000	15,245	37.0%	41,250
Glasgow	20,520	5,075	17,390	40.5%	23,460	19,520	45.4%	42,980
St Andrews	3,165	3,230	5,425	45.9%	9,345	2,475	20.9%	11,820

Student body

In the 2021–22 academic year, 112,615 students were enrolled at the four institutions: 44,735 were from Scotland (39.7%), 22,325 from the rest of the United Kingdom (19.8%) and 45,555 were from overseas (40.5%).

The Scottish Government enforces a quota on the number of undergraduate places available for students from Scotland and as a result, entry to the four universities are selective. Entrance typically requires strong performances in standardised exams as represented by the average scores of new entrants when converted to UCAS points. All four universities were in the top ten British universities by entry standards for 2021 entry with St Andrews: 1st, Glasgow: joint 3rd (along with Cambridge), Edinburgh: 7th and Aberdeen: joint 10th (along with Durham). ^[29]

Students from private education are over-represented at the ancient universities with the four universities hosting the highest proportion of privately educated students out of all Scottish universities in 2020/21 (St Andrews: 36.9%, Edinburgh: 35.5%, Glasgow: 16.1% and Aberdeen: 15.8%). ^[30] St Andrews' and Edinburgh's higher proportion of private school students are due to the two universities recruiting "substantial numbers of students from the rest of the United Kingdom, many of whom come from prosperous English families and attended private schools" according to a report commissioned for the Scottish Government. ^[31] In Scotland, around 4 per cent of the school-age population attend private schools ^[32] and 11 per cent of all higher education students in Scottish institutions have attended private schools. ^[33]

Funding and finances

The total annual income for the ancient universities for 2021–22 was £2.75 billion of which £631.8 million was from research grants and contracts, with an operating deficit of £247.8 million. The universities hold a total endowment value of £938 million and net assets of £4.17 billion. £508.4 million was received from the Scottish Funding Council via grants and £110.2 million was received from tuition fees of Scotland-domiciled students. Further tuition fees of £142.9 million was received from students from the rest of the United Kingdom and £787 million was received from overseas students. The table below is a record of each ancient universities' financial data for the 2021–22 financial year:

By figures

University	Government funding body grants (£m)	Scottish Teaching income (£m)	rUK Teaching income (£m)	non-UK Teaching income (£m)	Overall Teaching income (£m)	Research income (£m)	Total income (£m)	Operating surplus (£m)	Endowment value (£m)	Net Assets (£m)
University of Aberdeen [34]	86.9	17.1	9.3	61.8	89.9	50.8	260.9	—52.4	58.1	337.2
University of Edinburgh [35]	198.3	39.9	85.4	342.0	497.0	324.0	1,262.4	—95.0	541.0	2,483.6
University of Glasgow [36]	179.0	46.6	23.0	284.9	375.4	196.1	923.6	—75.0	225.8	981.8
University of St Andrews [37]	44.2	6.6	25.2	98.3	137.4	53.3	305.7	—26.0	113.1	368.0

By percentage

University	Government Funding income as % of Total income	Scottish Teaching income as % of teaching income	rUK Teaching income as % of teaching income	non-UK Teaching income as % of teaching income	Overall Teaching income as % of Total income	Research income as % of Total income	Surplus as % of Total income
University of Aberdeen [34]	33.3%	19.0%	10.3%	68.8%	34.5%	19.5%	—20.08%
University of Edinburgh [35]	15.7%	8.0%	17.2%	68.8%	39.4%	26.3%	—7.50%
University of Glasgow [36]	19.4%	12.4%	6.1%	75.9%	40.6%	21.2%	—8.11%
University of St Andrews [37]	14.5%	4.8%	18.3%	71.6%	44.9%	17.4%	—8.44%

Rankings

See also: Rankings of universities in the United Kingdom

In the 2024 national league table rankings, the ancient universities of Scotland are placed within the top twenty in both of The Guardian University Guide and in The Times/Sunday Times Good University Guide. In the 2024 global rankings, three of the ancient universities featured in the world's top 200 universities in both of the QS and the Times Higher Education World University Rankings.

University	Complete 2024 (National) [38]	Guardian 2024 (National) [39]	Times/Sunday Times 2024 (National) [40]	ARWU 2023 (Global) [41]	QS 2024 (Global) [42]	THE 2024 (Global) [43]
University of Aberdeen	35	12	19	201–300	208	201–250
University of Edinburgh	12	14	13	38	22	30=
University of Glasgow	26	13	12	101–150	76	87=
University of St Andrews	4	1	1	301–400	95	193=

Criticism

The ancient universities have faced criticism for their inability to attract more students from disadvantaged backgrounds. ^{[44] [5]} In 2014, approximately 48 per cent of the undergraduate population at the four universities comprises Scottish students, ^[45] with over half of them having received their education from independent schools in Scotland. 71 per cent of independent school entrants gained a place in one of the four ancient universities, compared with only 29 per cent of state school entrants. ^[32] In addition, fewer than one in seven students at the four ancient universities in Scotland are from working-class backgrounds. ^[46] Alumni dominate the top levels of the civil service, law, politics, and media. Notably, more than half of Scotland's top media professionals and 46 per cent of the country's MPs are alumni of these universities. ^[47] Graduates from the ancients hold a greater influence in the Scottish Government, with 90 per cent of cabinet members and 70 per cent of all ministers having attended one of the ancients. ^[48] This has prompted claims of elitism, social division and the universities being less inclusive. ^[49]

Following increasing pressures to address widening access concerns, ^[50] in 2019, the Scottish Government ordered universities to create lower admissions thresholds for applicants from disadvantaged backgrounds. ^[4] Alex Massie of The Times has commented that the new widening access targets for Scotland-domiciled students have now meant that there is "no chance" of admission into competitive courses at the ancient universities unless Scottish applicants have a widening access flag in their application. ^{[51] [52]} Scotland’s Commissioner for Fair Access, Sir Peter Scott, had previously stated that middle-class Scottish students with strong academic results had "no entitlement" to enter ancient universities. ^[53] Concerns over the Scottish Government's approach to funding has also led to accusations that the ancients are incentivised to attract students from the rest of the United Kingdom and from overseas, with all ancient universities of Scotland amongst the most reliant universities in the UK for teaching income from international students. ^[54]

For the 2016-17 admissions cycle, ancient universities were criticised for the number of clearing places they had for Scottish students. Edinburgh offered 130 courses to students from the rest of the United Kingdom, but only one to Scottish students. Similarly, Aberdeen only offered one course in clearing for Scottish students but 79 for the rest of the UK, while Glasgow offered 5 and 497 courses respectively. St Andrews did not participate in clearing and offered no courses to either Scottish students or students from the rest of the UK. ^[55]

Later universities

Main articles: Universities in Scotland and List of UK universities by date of foundation

Following the creation of the ancient universities before the end of the 16th century, no other universities were formed in Scotland until the twentieth century. The first 'new university' of the era was the University of Strathclyde which received its royal charter in 1964, although it traces its origins back to the Andersonian Institute (also known at various times as Anderson's College and Anderson's University) founded in 1796. ^{[56] [57] [58] [59]}

See also

• List of oldest universities in continuous operation
• Ancient universities, oldest universities in Great Britain and Ireland
• Colonial colleges, oldest universities in the United States of America
• Imperial Universities, oldest universities founded during the Empire of Japan
• Sandstone universities, oldest universities in Australia
• Red Brick universities
• Plate glass universities
• List of universities in Scotland
• Ancient university governance in Scotland

References

1. "Sabhal Mòr Ostaig - Naidheachd - Prionnsabal Oilthigh Obar Dheathain a' toirt seachad Òraid an t-Sabhail". www.smo.uhi.ac.uk.
2. s.16
3. Ancient universities of Scotland#Rankings
4. Johnson, Simon (13 February 2019). "Scotland's ancient universities unveil lower entry grades for poor youngsters". The Telegraph.
5. "Privately educated Scots dominate top jobs". The Scotsman. 7 December 2015.
6. rankings, ^[3] eminent, ^[4] and highly-selective ^[5]
7. Elston, Laura (7 March 2023). "King invites leading institutions to reaffirm loyalty to him at historic ceremony". The Independent.
8. Jobson Lyon, Charles (2009). The History of St. Andrews, Ancient and Modern. BiblioLife. p. 68. ISBN   978-1103782949.
9. Devine, Thomas (1995). Glasgow: Beginnings to 1830. Manchester University Press. p. 3. ISBN   9780719036910.
10. "Philosophy". The University of Edinburgh.
11. "Slezer's Scotland". National Library of Scotland. Retrieved 12 October 2016.
12. "New College - Alumni and supporters - University of St Andrews". www.st-andrews.ac.uk. Retrieved 31 July 2022.
13. University of Glasgow – Who, Where and When. Retrieved 22 April 2006 Archived 27 March 2006 at the Wayback Machine
14. "University of Glasgow". Uniserv Education. 12 January 2016. Archived from the original on 27 October 2019. Retrieved 4 August 2019.
15. A Short History of the University of Edinburgh: 1556–1889. Horn, D. B. 1967.
16. "Charter by King James VI, 14 April 1582". University of Edinburgh - Our History. Archived from the original on 23 May 2018. Retrieved 16 August 2021.
17. "Robert Rollock (1555-1599)". University of Edinburgh - Our History. Archived from the original on 30 March 2019. Retrieved 16 August 2021.
18. "Statistics Publication Notice: Lifelong Learning Series: Higher Education Students and Qualifiers at Scottish Institutions 2009-10 - gov.scot".
19. "Universities funding war flares again". www.scotsman.com.
20. McIntosh, Lindsay. "Reforms could do real damage, says Edinburgh university chief" – via www.thetimes.co.uk.
21. "University of Dundee: Press Release". app.dundee.ac.uk.
22. "Finances of Scottish Universities" (PDF). audit-scotland.gov.uk. Audit Scotland. Retrieved 19 September 2019.
23. "University of Dundee : External Relations : Press Office". 14 June 2011. Archived from the original on 14 June 2011.
24. "Fraserburgh from The Gazetteer for Scotland". www.scottish-places.info.
25. University of Aberdeen. Marischal College; Anderson, Peter John; Johnstone, James Fowler Kellas (1889–1898). Fasti Academiae Mariscallanae Aberdonensis : selections from the records of the Marischal College and University, MDXClll-MDCCCLX. Robarts - University of Toronto. Aberdeen : Printed for the New Spalding Club.
26. "Scran Web Site". Scran.
27. "University of Aberdeen Students' Association Constitution". Archived from the original on 8 April 2007. Retrieved 21 April 2007.
28. "Where do HE students study?: Students by HE provider". HESA. HE student enrolments by HE provider. Retrieved 8 February 2023.
29. "University League Tables entry standards 2024". The Complete University Guide.
30. "Widening participation: UK Performance Indicators: Table T2a - Participation of under-represented groups in higher education". Higher Education Statistics Authority. hesa.ac.uk. Retrieved 8 February 2023.
31. "Maintaining the Momentum Towards Fair Access Annual Report 2022" (PDF). gov.scot. Scottish Government. Retrieved 1 April 2023.
32. Johnson, Simon (27 May 2016). "Poor Scots 'squeezed out of university by SNP cap on places'". The Telegraph. Retrieved 7 July 2016.
33. "Re-Committing to Fair Access: A Plan for Recovery Annual Report 2021" (PDF). gov.scot. Scottish Government. Retrieved 1 April 2023.
34. "Annual Reports & Accounts 2022" (PDF). University of Aberdeen. Retrieved 16 January 2023.
35. "Annual Report and Accounts for the Year to 31 July 2022" (PDF). The University of Edinburgh. Retrieved 29 January 2023.
36. "Reports and Financial Statements for the year to 31 July 2022" (PDF). University of Glasgow. Retrieved 18 January 2023.
37. "Reports and Financial Statements of the University Court for the year to 31 July 2022" (PDF). University of St Andrews. Retrieved 18 January 2023.
38. "Complete University Guide 2024". The Complete University Guide. 7 June 2023.
39. "Guardian University Guide 2024". The Guardian. 9 September 2023. Retrieved 11 September 2023.
40. "Good University Guide 2024". The Times. 15 September 2023. Retrieved 15 September 2023.
41. "Academic Ranking of World Universities 2023". Shanghai Ranking Consultancy. 15 August 2023.
42. "QS World University Rankings 2024". Quacquarelli Symonds Ltd. 27 June 2023.
43. "THE World University Rankings 2024". Times Higher Education. 28 September 2023. Retrieved 28 September 2023.
44. "Scotland's ancient universities urged to do more to attract disadvantaged students". The Herald. 13 June 2019.
45. Havergal, Chris (8 July 2016). "Winning a university place getting harder for Scots, report shows". Times Higher Education. Retrieved 8 July 2016.
46. "Elitist Scotland?" (PDF). Social Mobility and Child Poverty Commission. Retrieved 3 December 2015.
47. "Top echelons of Scottish society are 'dominated' by elite private schools and top universities". The Independent. 3 December 2015.
48. "Revealed: former students of Scotland's 'ancient' universities control Holyrood". The Herald. 9 August 2016.
49. "Half of Scotland's MPs educated at the country's four ancient universities". The Herald. 25 May 2015.
50. "Political pressure mounts on Ancient universities to recruit more disadvantaged students". The Herald. 31 May 2017.
51. Massie, Alex (24 January 2023). "Our university admissions system is a joke". The Times.
52. Massie, Alex (16 May 2023). "'Free' tuition fees cost Scottish students dear". The Times.
53. "Lesley Riddoch: University quotas can't fix economic inequality". The Scotsman. 29 December 2016.
54. Massie, Alex (17 January 2024). "University cuts prove education has never been the SNP's priority". The Times.
55. Johnson, Simon (20 August 2016). "SNP under attack over free tuition cap as number of Scots missing out on university place almost doubles". The Telegraph. Retrieved 23 August 2016.
56. "About Strathclyde: Our location and heritage: History". University of Strathclyde. Archived from the original on 13 October 2016. Retrieved 12 October 2016.
57. "The 'Andersonian' – The First Technical College". technicaleducationmatters.org. 11 October 2009. Retrieved 12 October 2016.
58. "BBC - A History of the World - Object : Anderson's University, Glasgow". www.bbc.co.uk.
59. "Anderson's College, Glasgow - University of Strathclyde Archives". atom.lib.strath.ac.uk.