Public image of Melania Trump

Trump speaking at a United Nations event

Melania Trump was the subject of extensive media attention and public interest during her tenure as first lady of the United States from 2017 to 2021. Her private nature led many to speculate about her personality, her beliefs, and her thoughts about being first lady. Her wardrobe was of particular interest to the public, not only because it is a common subject discussed in regard to first ladies but because of her past as a fashion model. Also of interest was the fact that she was only the second foreign-born woman to be first lady, which was culturally significant both in the United States and in her home country of Slovenia. Trump had low approval ratings relative to previous first ladies, but she was regularly rated as the most popular member of the Trump family.

Privacy and public speculation

Melania Trump has cultivated her public image by limiting public interaction, minimizing public statements and declining to answer questions about her life. ^[1] Such is the secrecy around her life that one biographer, Mary Jordan, reported that she had to engage in clandestine interactions with associates of the Trumps to get information. The relative lack of information has allowed spectators to impose various interpretations of her life onto Melania. She has been portrayed as an innocent victim of an aggressive husband, an immigrant who was thrust into the public spotlight against her will, a vapid model with no input of her own, and a woman who became successful purely through luck. ^[2] She is often seen as cold by the public, though people who interact with her describe her as a warm presence. ^{[3] [4]} Her private nature is contrasted with her sociable stepdaughter Ivanka, who Donald often put on equal footing with Melania when discussing them and had regularly had them on either side of him when having his photo taken. ^[5]

A protester with a "Free Melania" sign

Melania is seen as a contrast to Donald, as she is more reserved compared to his assertive personality. Both, however, have lived relatively solitary lives. ^[6] First lady biographer Betty Boyd Caroli compared Trump's deliberate obscurity as first lady to Bess Truman, who similarly avoided taking on a large staff or being active in major initiatives while she was first lady. ^[7] CNN White House correspondent Kate Bennett wrote in her biography of Melania Trump that she was "one of the most private and guarded first ladies in modern history". ^[8] Trump's staff were instructed to ignore all media questions while she was first lady, including those about her official activities and where she was at a given time. This led to false rumors that she had abandoned the first ladyship after she was not seen for three weeks in 2018. ^[9]

Rumors persisted throughout the Trump presidency that Melania and Donald had a secret animosity toward one another. This was amplified by her decision not to immediately move to the White House and again upon the discovery that Donald may have committed adultery with Stormy Daniels. Other incidents also provoked speculation, such as a video of her swatting her husband's hand away in May 2017, her trip to see detained children at the border in June 2018, and a tweet in support of LeBron James' charity work a day after Donald criticized the basketball player in August 2018. ^{[10] [8]} One urban legend was widely spread claiming that she had moved out of the White House into a home in Potomac, Maryland, with her parents. ^[11] The rumors led to popular use of the hashtag #FreeMelania by those who believed them. ^[12] Though she disliked the idea that people saw her as helpless, Melania found the campaign amusing. ^[13] This became less common by 2020 as she took a more active role in the administration. ^[14] She was also seen as unhappy because she was rarely seen smiling in public, to which she responded that she does not believe in fake smiles—an effect of her Slovenian upbringing, where smiling socially is less common. ^[15] Chris Christie, who worked closely with the Trumps in the 2016 presidential campaign, cast doubt on the rumors, saying that Melania was independent but supported her husband. ^[16]

Fashion

Trump wearing a coat over her shoulders

As with previous first ladies, Trump's fashion was heavily scrutinized, and particularly expensive pieces were criticized. ^[7] More than other first ladies, her fashion was scrutinized in the context of her past as a fashion model and her marriage to a billionaire. ^[17] Vogue compared her wardrobe as first lady to those of Jacqueline Kennedy and Nancy Reagan, and it said that she preferred "strongly tailored pieces", wearing almost exclusively outfits designed by high-end designers. ^[18] Melania's wardrobe played into fashion diplomacy, in which her clothes delivered political statements or conveyed certain messages. ^[19] In some cases, her lack of political involvement caused a subversion of fashion diplomacy in which "her message is that there is no message". ^[20] Despite her experience in fashion, she disliked that it was such a major aspect of news coverage about her as first lady. ^[21]

Coats were a common trademark of Melania's fashion, and she sometimes wore them on her shoulders without using the sleeves. ^[22] During formal events, she commonly wore Dior dresses accentuated with gloves and wore her hair up. ^[23] Melania worked closely with Hervé Pierre when styling her fashion, but they dismissed the idea that he worked as her wardrobe stylist. ^[24] She retained her previous hair stylist Mordechai Alvow and her previous make up artist Nicole Byrl when she became first lady. ^[25] She preferred to do her own shopping, typically from Net-a-Porter. ^{[26] [27]} The fashion industry generally leans away from the Trump administration's politics, and many fashion designers have stated that they refuse to work with Melania because of political differences. ^[28] When preparing for speeches, she dedicated more attention to her physical appearance than content or delivery, which her staff felt affected her ability to promote her causes. ^[29] In public, Melania came to be known for her distinctive squinting expression that she often wore. ^[30]

Heritage

Since the only other foreign-born first lady, Louisa Adams, was born in London as the daughter of an American, Melania has been seen by the American public as the first foreigner first lady. ^[31] In both the United States and Slovenia, she is seen as ignoring or disregarding her Slovenian heritage. ^{[32] [30]} Having a Slovenian-born woman as the American first lady became a point of national pride in Slovenia, and it gave the nation a sense of recognition on the world stage. ^{[32] [33]} This includes an element of commodification as imagery of the first lady is used as a sort of national brand, particularly in the tourism industry. ^[34] Slovenia was particularly susceptible to this phenomenon as a post-communist nation that had yet to fully develop its own identity. ^[35] Melania Trump's hometown Sevnica has developed a small tourist industry around her, and Melania-themed merchandise was common during her tenure as first lady. These items never use Melania's full name, substituting it with "first lady" or "M", as she is protective of her personality rights. ^[36]

Cultural depictions

Visual art and culture

Bosnian sculptor Stevo Selak created a statue of Trump in 2017. ^{[37] [38]} Madame Tussauds in New York City unveiled a wax sculpture of her in 2018. ^{[39] [40] [41]} Jim Carrey drew a portrait of Trump in 2018. ^{[42] [43]}

On 5 July 2019, a wooden statue carved out of a tree trunk with a chainsaw was unveiled by the Sava river in Rožno, near Trump's hometown Sevnica in Slovenia. The artwork was commissioned by U.S. artist Brad Downey, who hired a local craftsman and artist Aleš Župevc (aka Maxi) to create the statue.^{[ why? ]} The statue is styled after the blue dress she wore during her husband's (Donald Trump) presidential inauguration in 2017. ^[44] Local reception of the statue was mixed; some residents praised it, while others called it a "disgrace" and likened it to Smurfette. ^[45] In July 2020, the statue was torched and removed for its protection. ^{[46] [47]} However, later in 2020 it was replaced with a lookalike statue in bronze. ^[48]

Parodies

Trump has been parodied many times on Saturday Night Live , mostly by Cecily Strong. ^[49] In an interview with Vanity Fair , Strong stated she has "heard through the grapevine" Trump enjoys the parody. ^[49] Maya Rudolph has also impersonated her, ^[50] and Paris Hilton portrayed Trump when she hosted Saturday Night Live. ^[51]

In July 2016, actress Laura Benanti played Trump on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert , satirizing her 2016 Republican National Convention speech that had accusations of plagiarism. ^[52] Benanti has reprised the role several times since, including dressing as "the Ghost of Colonialism" for Halloween, and for Christmas skits. ^{[53] [54] [55]} During the American Music Awards of 2016, Gigi Hadid impersonated her. ^{[56] [57]}

In 2018, Aquaria impersonated Trump during the Snatch Game challenge on the tenth season of RuPaul's Drag Race . ^{[58] [59]} Plastique Tiara impersonated her in the season 11 episode "Trump: The Rusical" (2019). On Our Cartoon President , Trump is voiced by Cody Lindquist ^[60] and on The President Show , she is voiced by Mila Filatova. ^[61]

In the erotic novel Melania: Devourer of Men (2018), Melania Trump is depicted as a manananggal, a creature from Philippine mythology, who must keep her identity hidden after her husband becomes president. The novel has been discussed ^[62] on several ^[63] podcasts. ^[64]

In October 2018, rapper T.I. released a music video with a Melania Trump lookalike dancing naked in a fake Oval Office. ^[65] Trump's then-communications director Stephanie Grisham responded, "Like it or not, she is the first lady and this is the White House. It's disrespectful and disgusting to portray her this way simply because of politics. These kinds of vulgar attacks only further the divisiveness and bias in our country – it needs to stop." ^[66]

In the 2020 Sacha Baron Cohen film Borat Subsequent Moviefilm , a Disney-like parody of Melania is idolized as the ultimate dream for an Eastern European girl, to be married off to an older American man and live in a "golden cage".^{[ citation needed ]}

Gina Gershon portrayed Trump in the off-Broadway show The Trump Family Special. She previously played her in Funny or Die skits. ^[67]

Approval ratings and historical ranking

During the 2016 presidential election, Trump became the only candidate's spouse to have a negative approval rating since polling began in 1988. ^[68] Her approval rating did not significantly change throughout the campaign because her favorable and unfavorable ratings increased at the same rate when her name recognition increased. ^[69] Scandals involving Melania, including plagiarism accusations and scrutiny of her modeling career, may have been factors on her approval rating during the campaign. Her relative absence from the campaign also conflicted with the public's expectation of a candidate's spouse's role. ^[70]

As First Lady, Trump managed to improve her approval ratings from 2016 to mid-2018. ^[71] CNN had her at 36% approval upon her husband's inauguration, ^[72] and Gallup found her at 37% approval when she was staying in New York at the beginning of her tenure. ^[73] The former poll showed that 23% had no opinion, significantly higher than expected for an incoming first lady. ^[72] The two preceding first ladies had approval ratings above 70% at the start of their respective tenures. ^[74] A year into her tenure, she was the most popular member of the Trump family among the public. ^[72] Melania received public sympathy in 2018, following allegations that Donald had engaged in extramarital affairs. ^[75] A CNN poll in January 2018 found that she had an approval rating of 47%, compared to the president's 40%. ^[72] This rose to 57% in the poll's April edition, after the fallout of the allegations occurred. ^[76] In December 2018, CNN reported that Melania's strongest base of support came from older, white, male Republicans and conservatives, while she had the least approval from women who were young or college-educated. ^[77]

In March 2019, YouGov reported that Melania Trump, with 51% approval, was polling more popularly among the American public than other members of her family: her husband Donald, stepchildren Donald Jr., Eric, and Ivanka, and her stepson-in-law Jared Kushner. ^[78] In August 2020, Morning Consult, in conjunction with Politico, reported that Melania, with 45% approval, was polling more favorably among the American public than any other Republican figures listed in the survey, including her family members, Vice President Mike Pence, Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell, and House minority leader Kevin McCarthy. ^[79]

In Gallup's annual poll of the most admired women, Melania Trump ranked in the top ten in each of her years as first lady but never topped the list. She joined Bess Truman and Lady Bird Johnson as the only American first ladies who had never been named the most admired woman in this survey since Gallup had begun conducting the annual survey in the 1940s. ^[80]

Trump finished her tenure in 2021 as the least popular first lady ever polled, according to polling by CNN, SRSS, and Gallup. Her final approval rating was 42%, and her final disapproval rating was 47%; she was the only first lady who finished with a net disapproval rating. Previous first ladies since the 1970s had final popularity ratings of 71% on average. The second-least popular first lady polled was Hillary Clinton, with a final approval rating of 52% and a final disapproval rating of 39%. ^[81]

In December 2020, the Siena College Research Institute released a study surveying scholars and historians on their assessments of American first ladies. It was the fifth such first ladies study that the Institute had conducted since 1982, and the first in which Trump appeared. Trump was ranked as being the worst of 40 assessed American first ladies, ^[82] receiving the lowest assessments in all of the metrics that were weighed. ^[83]

See also

• Cultural depictions of Ivanka Trump
• Melania Trump replacement conspiracy theory
• Public image of Donald Trump

Notes

1. Jordan 2020, pp. 26–27.
2. Jordan 2020, p. 27.
3. Collins, Lauren (May 9, 2016). "The Model American: Melania Trump is the exception to her husband's nativist politics". The New Yorker. Archived from the original on November 19, 2018. Retrieved May 3, 2016.
4. Bennett 2019, p. 152.
5. Bennett 2019, pp. 160–165.
6. Jordan 2020, p. 28.
7. Caroli 2019, p. 342.
8. Bennett 2019, p. 2.
9. Jordan 2020, p. 251.
10. Caroli 2019, p. 346.
11. Bennett 2019, p. 199.
12. Jordan 2020, p. 21.
13. Jordan 2020, pp. 275–276.
14. Jordan 2020, pp. 281–282.
15. Bennett 2019, pp. 47, 57.
16. Jordan 2020, p. 6.
17. Bennett 2019, p. 247.
18. Barsamian, Edward (July 30, 2017). "Melania Trump Redefining First Lady Style". Vogue. Archived from the original on January 12, 2018. Retrieved January 11, 2018.
19. Bennett 2019, pp. 238, 242.
20. Vidmar Horvat 2021, p. 449.
21. Bennett 2019, p. 251.
22. Bennett 2019, p. 241.
23. Bennett 2019, p. 242.
24. Bennett 2019, pp. 226–228.
25. Bennett 2019, pp. 243–244.
26. Bennett 2019, p. 37.
27. Bennett 2019, p. 227.
28. Bennett 2019, pp. 231–232.
29. Jordan 2020, pp. 245–246.
30. Ioffe, Julia (April 27, 2016). "Melania Trump on Her Rise, Her Family Secrets, and Her True Political Views: "Nobody Will Ever Know"". GQ. Archived from the original on September 6, 2017. Retrieved April 29, 2016.
31. Vidmar Horvat 2021, pp. 447–448.
32. Vidmar Horvat 2021, p. 448.
33. Pušnik & Jontes 2021, pp. 464–465.
34. Pušnik & Jontes 2021, p. 465.
35. Pušnik & Jontes 2021, p. 465.
36. Bennett 2019, pp. 49–50.
37. "Statue of first lady Melania Trump raises eyebrows for odd resemblance". AOL. June 6, 2017. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
38. Damien, Sharkov (May 13, 2017). "Melania Trump could soon have a statue". Newsweek. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
39. "Melania Trump's Wax Figure Is Here and Twitter Is Having a Field Day". Glamour. April 26, 2018. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
40. "Madame Tussauds' new Melania Trump wax sculpture sends mesmerized Sean Spicer stammering for words". New York Daily News. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
41. "Sean Spicer Unveils Melania Trump Wax Figure at N.Y.C. Madame Tussauds — And You Can Make Her Talk!". People. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
42. Young, Julius (June 4, 2018). "Jim Carrey trolls Melania Trump in latest politically charged artwork". Fox News. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
43. Kenneally, Tim (June 22, 2018). "Jim Carrey Rips Melania Trump and Her 'Really Don't Care' Jacket in New Artwork". SFGate. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
44. "'It's a disgrace': Melania Trump gets first statue in home country Slovenia". United Kingdom: ITV. July 5, 2019. Retrieved July 6, 2019.
45. Kelly Taylor Hayes (July 5, 2019). "'A disgrace': Melania Trump statue unveiled in her Slovenian hometown divides residents". Fox 4. Retrieved July 6, 2019.
46. "Arsonist targets statue of Melania Trump in first lady's hometown". July 9, 2020.
47. Novak, Marja (July 9, 2020). "U.S. First lady Melania Trump statue set on fire in Slovenia". Reuters.
48. "'Frustrations at US policies' behind Melania Trump statue, says artist". TheGuardian.com . September 19, 2020.
49. Stefansky, Emma (February 4, 2018). "Cecily Strong Says Melania Likes Her S.N.L. Impression". Vanity Fair. Retrieved March 26, 2019.
50. "Maya Rudolph Breaks out Melania Trump Impression for New NBC Variety Show". The Hollywood Reporter. June 2016. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
51. "'I'm a Ratings Machine': A History of Donald Trump on SNL". People. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
52. "Melania Trump spoof on 'The Late Show with Stephen Colbert'". Los Angeles Times. July 19, 2016. Archived from the original on November 8, 2016. Retrieved March 25, 2019.
53. Quinn, Dave (October 17, 2018). "Faux Melania Trump Says She's Going as the 'Ghost of Colonialism' for Halloween — Watch the Clip". People. Retrieved March 25, 2019.
54. Haysom, Sam (December 21, 2018). "'Melania Trump' stars in parody White House Christmas message". Mashable. Retrieved March 25, 2019.
55. Park, Andrea (November 20, 2018). "Laura Benanti as Melania Trump Tells Stephen Colbert She Wants Donald to Fire Her Next". W Magazine. Retrieved March 26, 2019.
56. "Gigi Hadid roasted for Melania impression". CNN. November 21, 2016. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
57. Bryant, Kenzie (November 22, 2016). "Gigi Hadid Stands Behind Her Melania Trump Impression". Vanity Fair. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
58. "Aquaria Channeled Melania Trump for 'RuPaul's Drag Race'". PAPER. May 4, 2018. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
59. "'Drag Race' Winner Aquaria Talks Victory, Melania Trump & That Butterfly Snafu". Billboard. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
60. "Donald Trump / Jeff Bergman - 'Our Cartoon President': Meet the Voices Behind Trump and Co". The Hollywood Reporter. February 11, 2018. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
61. Grant, Sarah (November 7, 2016). "Election's Best Trump Impersonator Reveals His Secrets". Rolling Stone. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
62. "Myth Monsters Podcast - Episode 17: Manananggal". January 30, 2022.
63. "Cryptid Book Club Episode 07: Melania: Devourer of Men". August 4, 2024.
64. "MANANANGGAL IN MANHATTAN". March 27, 2022.
65. Aniftos, Rania (October 12, 2018). "T.I. Gets a Striptease From Melania Trump Look-Alike in the Oval Office in New Video: 'Dear 45, I Ain't Kanye'". Billboard. Retrieved March 25, 2019.
66. Bennett, Kate (October 17, 2018). "First lady's office calls out T.I. for 'disgusting' video depicting Melania Trump". CNN. Retrieved March 25, 2019.
67. "Who's the Best Melania Trump Impersonator?". Inside Edition. August 25, 2018. Retrieved March 28, 2019.
68. Elder, Frederick & Burrell 2018, p. 107.
69. Elder, Frederick & Burrell 2018, pp. 114–115.
70. Elder, Frederick & Burrell 2018, pp. 109–110.
71. Elder, Laurel; Frederick, Brian; Burrell, Barbara (June 15, 2018). "Analysis | Why Melania Trump isn't as popular as Laura Bush or Michelle Obama". Washington Post. Retrieved January 20, 2021.
72. Bennett 2019, p. 148.
73. Caroli 2019, p. 341.
74. Bennett 2019, pp. 148–149.
75. Caroli 2019, p. 344.
76. Bennett 2019, pp. 216–217.
77. Bennett, Kate (December 13, 2018). "Melania Trump's poll numbers plummet". CNN . Retrieved January 20, 2021.
78. Frankovic, Kathy (March 7, 2019). "Melania remains the most popular Trump; Kushner security clearance seen as problematic". today.yougov.com. YouGov. Retrieved January 19, 2021.
79. Easley, Cameron (August 25, 2020). "As Trump family dominates RNC, poll shows they're most popular GOP figures". Morning Consult . Retrieved January 22, 2021.
80. Jones, Jeffrey M. (December 29, 2020). "Donald Trump, Michelle Obama Most Admired in 2020". Gallup.com. Retrieved January 19, 2021.
81. Enten, Harry (January 19, 2021). "The worst final popularity rating ever for a first lady belongs to Melania Trump". CNN. Retrieved January 19, 2021.
82. "Eleanor Roosevelt America's Top First Lady for 6th Consecutive Time Abigail Adams Finishes a Close Second; Michelle Obama Moves to Third First Lady Initiatives – Lady Bird Johnson (Environmental Protection) Did Most to Raise Awareness and Address the Issue; Obama (Childhood Obesity), Betty Ford (Women's Rights), and Barbara Bush (Literacy) Made Major Contributions Jackie Kennedy - 4th but First on Being a White House Steward & Public Image" (PDF). scri.siena.edu. Siena College Research Institute. December 9, 2020. Retrieved March 6, 2024.
83. "Copy of FirstLadies_Full Rankings_working_dl_2.xls" (PDF). scri.siena.edu. Siena College Research Institute. December 2020. Retrieved March 6, 2024.

References

• Bennett, Kate (2019). Free, Melania. Flatiron Books. ISBN   978-1-250-30737-8.
• Caroli, Betty Boyd (2019). "Chapter 11: The Ever-Changing Role of First Lady". First Ladies: The Ever Changing Role, from Martha Washington to Melania Trump. Oxford University Press. pp. 333–348. ISBN   978-0-19-066913-3.
• Elder, Laurel; Frederick, Brian; Burrell, Barbara (2018). American Presidential Candidate Spouses: The Public's Perspective. Palgrave Macmillan. ISBN   978-3-319-73878-9.
• Jordan, Mary (2020). The Art of Her Deal: The Untold Story of Melania Trump. Simon and Schuster. ISBN   978-1-9821-1340-7.
• Pušnik, Maruša; Jontes, Dejan (2021). "Mediji in Spontani Nacionalizem: Primer Melanie Trump" [Media and Spontaneous Nationalism: The Case of Melania Trump](PDF). Teorija in Praksa (in Slovenian). 58 (2): 464–480. doi:10.51936/tip.58.2.464-480. ISSN   0040-3598.
• Vidmar Horvat, Ksenija (2021). "Postimperialni Patriarhat In Karnevaleskna Periferija: Melania Trump V Transnacionalni Javnosti" [Post-Imperial Patriarchy and the Carnivalesque Periphery: Melania Trump Within a Transnational Public](PDF). Teorija in Praksa (in Slovenian). 58 (2): 447–463. doi:10.51936/tip.58.2.447-463. ISSN   0040-3598.

Further reading

• Film: Looking for Melania Trump (2020). Director: Laura Haïm. Length: 58 min.