Resonance (sociology)

Last updated

Resonance is a quality of human relationships with the world proposed by Hartmut Rosa. Rosa, professor of sociology at the University of Jena, conceptualised resonance theory in Resonanz (2016) to explain social phenomena through a fundamental human impulse towards "resonant" relationships. [1]

Contents

Background

Rosa outlined the cause of several crises of modernity in his monograph on social acceleration and dynamic stabilisation. [2] In this monograph, Rosa put forward social acceleration as the cultural logic of modernity and the cause of the modern burnout crisis, environmental issues, and mass alienation. [3] Resonance sets out to provide a solution to the alienation caused by social acceleration in late modernity. [3] He theorises that resonance, a normative experience in which an individual experiences a transformational, responsive, and affectual relationship to the world, is the solution to the extremes of alienation caused by modernity. [3]

Definition

With the aim of theorising a sociology of 'the good' in dialectical opposite to alienation, Rosa outlines the following definition of resonance:

...a kind of relationship to the world, formed through affect and emotion, intrinsic interest, and perceived self-efficacy, in which subject and world are mutually affected and transformed.

Resonance is not an echo, but a responsive relationship, requiring that both sides speak with their own voice. This is only possible where strong evaluations are affected. Resonance implies an aspect of constitutive inaccessibility.

Resonant relationships require that both subject and world be sufficiently “closed” or self-consistent so as to each speak in their own voice, while also remaining open enough to be affected or reached by each other.

Resonance is not an emotional state, but a mode of relation that is neutral with respect to emotional content. This is why we can love sad stories. [3]

Resonance term

The acoustic term resonance describes a subject–object relationship as a vibrating system in which both sides mutually stimulate each other. However, as with a tuning fork, they do not merely return the received sound, but speak "with their own voice". According to Rosa, the subjects' relational abilities and sense of their places in the world are influenced and reformed by such resonant experiences. Negative or alienated experiences, then, are those which lack resonance, and provide what Rahel Jaeggi terms 'a relation of relationlessness'. [3] [4] Resonance is therefore a way of approaching the question of successful relations between subject and world in the sense of "good life", which marks a significant departure from a critical theory primarily focused on relations of alienation. [5]

In his monograph, Rosa employs a variety of metaphors to illustrate the concept of resonance. He likens it to being one's 'wire to the world' and compares it to the phenomenon of two tuning forks vibrating in harmony, each producing their own distinct voice. onsanoGong Ming .svg
In his monograph, Rosa employs a variety of metaphors to illustrate the concept of resonance. He likens it to being one's 'wire to the world' and compares it to the phenomenon of two tuning forks vibrating in harmony, each producing their own distinct voice.

The possible points of reference of such resonances are ubiquitous and are described in four axes:

For instance, a horizontal relationship of resonance is evidenced in the relationship between the newborn and primary caregivers, by whose reception or rejection of interactions the fundamental attachment patterns develop. Diagonal resonances, are conveyed by Rosa through Rainer Maria Rilke's conception of 'The singing of things', which conveys a feeling of being called by material things, such as mountains, artworks or household possessions. [7] Feeling part of nature, an epoch of history, or a moment of worship is accounted for in the vertical axis resonance.

In all these contexts, resonant experiences are juxtaposed with silent or instrumental world relations, determined by an orientation towards domination and attaining resources, which are primarily concerned with the achievement of a useful goal. [5]  For example, a mountain tour aimed at tourists can either be a resonant experience (as an opportunity to confront the beautiful but challenging walk), or a more purpose-oriented, instrumental, and therefore, "mute" experience.

Rosa states that purely aesthetic, easily accessible encounters with nature are not sufficient for resonance, stating that an "active, even combative and resistant relationship with nature", like a challenging mountain hike, can constitute a self-efficacious world relation. BenNevis2005.jpg
Rosa states that purely aesthetic, easily accessible encounters with nature are not sufficient for resonance, stating that an "active, even combative and resistant relationship with nature", like a challenging mountain hike, can constitute a self-efficacious world relation.

Relations that are controlling, hostile or anixous result in "silent", non-resonant experiences. Rosa argues that much of consumer culture promises resonance commenting "Buy yourself resonance! is the implicit siren song of nearly all advertising campaigns and sales pitches." However, the attempt to control the experience of resonance ends up inhibiting the experience by instrumentalising it. Rosa argues that mediopassivity, a stance of the subject being not entirely active or passive in an experience allows enough uncontrollability for resonance to take place. [8] [9] Another prerequisite for the establishment of resonances are the strong evaluations of the subject, which give the object a significance that goes beyond desire or attractiveness.

If an attempt is made to outline as resonance what people seek and long for in their innermost being, it is by no means conceived as a permanent state that can be established, but always as a selective, momentary success or self-transformation that stands out against the background of a world that is predominantly silent, instrumental. Resonance in this sense is therefore essentially characterized by the fact that it cannot be produced systematically and intentionally, but is ultimately unavailable. Nevertheless, Rosa calls for institutional reforms which are geared towards resonance and avoid the kinds of extractive instrumental activity which cause alienation. [1]

Social theory

As a sociological theory, resonance theory deals with the social conditions that promote or hinder successful world relationships. The conditions of modernity have created what he terms social acceleration, an approach to time which is geared towards increasing resources and innovations in as short a time as possible. [2] This results in a logic of increase, which requires a constant continuation of improvement and multiplication of resources. This is accompanied by an increasing pressure to accelerate: in order to maintain the status quo within a modern society, societies must continually increase the number of services, innovations and material production opportunities. Rosa sees this mode of dynamic stabilization as the defining characteristic of modernity. [2] While pre-modern societies transform themselves adaptively, i.e. in response to changed conditions, modern society is virtually defined by its compulsion for continuous economic, social and technological transformation. [10]

Rosa uses Turner's Rain, Steam and Speed to visualise modernity's social acceleration, seeing "clearly the effort to translate the dynamization and fragmentation of the experience of space and the world into a new formal language." Rain Steam and Speed the Great Western Railway.jpg
Rosa uses Turner's Rain, Steam and Speed to visualise modernity's social acceleration, seeing "clearly the effort to translate the dynamization and fragmentation of the experience of space and the world into a new formal language."

While the current phase of late modernism is characterized by a high resonance sensitivity and expectation of its subjects, the mode of dynamic stabilization results in a loss of resonance. Rosa notes three essential manifestations of the current crisis of modernity:

Resonance theory is thus in the tradition of critical theory from Marx to Adorno and Horkheimer to Habermas and Honneth. [3] It shares the central finding of alienation as an obstacle to a successful life, but attempts to contrast this with a positive counter-concept, the concept of resonance. Honneth, for example, has already made this attempt with the concept of recognition. [11] Despite critiques of the vagueness of the concept of resonance, Rosa sees this as a universal concept that includes concepts such as recognition, justice or self-efficacy.

Policies

Rosa says that “this sociology of human relationships to the world does not pursue its own political agenda”. [3] However, he claims that resonance can serve as a driver in political debates, providing a standard for action. [3] He lists, for instance:

Rosa finds some consonance between resonance and Habermas's concept of communicative action. [12] [3] However, he criticises Habermas for mainly considering ‘intersubjective resonant relationships’, and ignoring relationships to the world, to things, and non-humans. [3] Moreover, he suggests that Habermas overlooks the aesthetic and emotional relationships evidenced in Fromm, Marcuse and Adorno. He finds more alignment in Honneth’s theory of recognition, in which:

…understanding is geared toward inner accordance with and the communicative accommodation of Others … recognition, in the three forms of love/friendship, legal recognition, and social esteem, establishes three kinds of resonant axes to the social world that allow individuals to experience self-confidence, self-respect, and self-esteem. [2]

In advocating for a system which emphasises a plurality of voices and is critical of escalatory logics, resonance is critical of both excessive bureaucracy and social acceleration. Rosa advocates for policies which help achieve a ‘paradigm shift from the logic of escalation to sensitivity to resonance', prefacing that “This does not mean that there be no space for competition in markets”, but instead more regulation against "blind escalation". [3]

Reception

Rosa has been credited for his search for a far-reaching framework for addressing social issues issues in a matter quite contrasted with a critical theory which looks at the world in negative terms, often summarised with Adorno's "There is no right life in the wrong one". [5] Such an appreciation of resonance theory as a positive continuation of critical theory can be found with Anna Henkel. [5] Micha Brumlik sees in the comprehensive combination of interdisciplinary strands the completion, but with it also the end, of critical theory, which thereby loses its "theoretically informed irreconcilability looking coldly at society". On the other hand, Brumlik states that this comprehensive derivation of the concept of resonance from a multitude of perspectives and contexts is flawed since "resonance" has an almost arbitrary effect that lacks conceptual precision. [5]  Brumlik concludes that it is therefore ultimately unsuitable as a social-philosophical basic concept. [5]

Other critics refer to Rosa's alleged recourse to the intellectual world of Romanticism. [13] Rosa does indeed frequently refer to the sensitivity to resonance implicit in Romanticism, even in conscious contradiction of rationalist concepts, but at the same time sees the danger of Romanticism's championing of purely subjective emotion instead of resonance. [1] Thus he rather describes the continuing effect of the resonance concepts of Romanticism in modernity, without propagating a return to it. [1]

Rosa's book argues that the socio-political outlook on concrete solutions is poor and he has publicly shared his dissatisfaction with the paths to post-growth suggested in his original monograph. [3] [14] Despite reference to political reform proposals such as that of a universal basic income and emerging pilot projects of post-growth economies, Rosa does not necessarily provide a direct route to this:

It is akin to the question of how humanity was able to move out of the social formations of the “Middle Ages” into modernity. Both cases involve a fundamental transformation of humanity’s relationship to the world that sets subjective and institutional, cultural and structural, cognitive, affective and habitual levels in motion all at once, without either a clear starting point or a unilinear direction of propagation. The theory of resonance articulated here, however, attempts to provide a small building block by at least making it possible to again perceive a different form of existence. [3]

Literary theorist Rita Felski, one of the originators of postcritique, which advocates for a literary theory which moves beyond the hermeneutics of suspicion, has celebrated resonance theory as an educational approach which is inclusive of both critical theory and aesthetic appreciation. [15] Felski argues that resonance provides an alternative to parametric and instrumental approaches to education, and makes the case for educational experiences that "speak[s] to the force of intellectual engagement for its own sake", based on attachment, enchantment and affect. [15]

There is a particular interest in Rosa's ideas in education research. Several studies investigating the possibility of resonant school structures and pedagogies have been published. [16] [17] [18] [19] [20]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jürgen Habermas</span> German social theorist and philosopher (born 1929)

Jürgen Habermas is a German philosopher and social theorist in the tradition of critical theory and pragmatism. His work addresses communicative rationality and the public sphere.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Herbert Mead</span> American philosopher, sociologist, and psychologist (1863–1931)

George Herbert Mead was an American philosopher, sociologist, and psychologist, primarily affiliated with the University of Chicago. He was one of the key figures in the development of pragmatism. He is regarded as one of the founders of symbolic interactionism, and was an important influence on what has come to be referred to as the Chicago School of Sociology.

Universal pragmatics (UP), more recently placed under the heading of formal pragmatics, is the philosophical study of the necessary conditions for reaching an understanding through communication. The philosopher Jürgen Habermas coined the term in his essay "What is Universal Pragmatics?" where he suggests that human competition, conflict, and strategic action are attempts to achieve understanding that have failed because of modal confusions. The implication is that coming to terms with how people understand or misunderstand one another could lead to a reduction of social conflict.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antipositivism</span> Theoretical stance in social science

In social science, antipositivism is a theoretical stance which proposes that the social realm cannot be studied with the methods of investigation utilized within the natural sciences, and that investigation of the social realm requires a different epistemology. Fundamental to that antipositivist epistemology is the belief that the concepts and language researchers use in their research shape their perceptions of the social world they are investigating and seeking to define.

In sociology, the term rationalization was coined by Max Weber, a German sociologist, jurist, and economist. Rationalization is the replacement of traditions, values, and emotions as motivators for behavior in society with concepts based on rationality and reason. The term rational is seen in the context of people, their expressions, and or their actions. This term can be applied to people who can perform speech or in general any action, in addition to the views of rationality within people it can be seen in the perspective of something such as a worldview or perspective (idea). For example, the implementation of bureaucracies in government is a kind of rationalization, as is the construction of high-efficiency living spaces in architecture and urban planning. A potential reason as to why rationalization of a culture may take place in the modern era is the process of globalization. Countries are becoming increasingly interlinked, and with the rise of technology, it is easier for countries to influence each other through social networking, the media and politics. An example of rationalization in place would be the case of witch doctors in certain parts of Africa. Whilst many locals view them as an important part of their culture and traditions, development initiatives and aid workers have tried to rationalize the practice in order to educate the local people in modern medicine and practice.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Axel Honneth</span> German philosopher (born 1949)

Axel Honneth is a German philosopher who is the Professor for Social Philosophy at Goethe University Frankfurt and the Jack B. Weinstein Professor of the Humanities in the department of philosophy at Columbia University. He was also director of the Institut für Sozialforschung in Frankfurt am Main, Germany between 2001 and 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lifeworld</span> Epistemological concept

Lifeworld may be conceived as a universe of what is self-evident or given, a world that subjects may experience together. The concept was popularized by Edmund Husserl, who emphasized its role as the ground of all knowledge in lived experience. It has its origin in biology and cultural Protestantism.

Social alienation is a person's feeling of disconnection from a group – whether friends, family, or wider society – with which the individual has an affiliation. Such alienation has been described as "a condition in social relationships reflected by (1) a low degree of integration or common values and (2) a high degree of distance or isolation (3a) between individuals, or (3b) between an individual and a group of people in a community or work environment [enumeration added]". It is a sociological concept developed by several classical and contemporary theorists. The concept has many discipline-specific uses and can refer both to a personal psychological state (subjectively) and to a type of social relationship (objectively).

In sociology, communicative action is cooperative action undertaken by individuals based upon mutual deliberation and argumentation. The term was developed by German philosopher-sociologist Jürgen Habermas in his work The Theory of Communicative Action.

<i>The Theory of Communicative Action</i> 1981 book by Jürgen Habermas

The Theory of Communicative Action is a two-volume 1981 book by the philosopher Jürgen Habermas, in which the author continues his project of finding a way to ground "the social sciences in a theory of language", which had been set out in On the Logic of the Social Sciences (1967). The two volumes are Reason and the Rationalization of Society, in which Habermas establishes a concept of communicative rationality, and Lifeworld and System: A Critique of Functionalist Reason, in which Habermas creates the two level concept of society and lays out the critical theory for modernity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Egalitarian dialogue</span> Organisational communication strategy

Egalitarian dialogue is a dialogue in which contributions are considered according to the validity of their reasoning, instead of according to the status or position of power of those who make them. Although previously used widely in the social sciences and in reference to the Bakhtinian philosophy of dialogue, it was first systematically applied to dialogical education by Ramón Flecha in his 2000 work Sharing Words. Theory and Practice of Dialogic Learning.

<i>The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity</i> 1985 book by Jürgen Habermas

The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity: Twelve Lectures is a 1985 book by the philosopher Jürgen Habermas, in which the author reconstructs and deals in depth with a number of philosophical approaches to the critique of modern reason and the Enlightenment "project" since Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel and Friedrich Nietzsche, including the work of 20th century philosophers Max Horkheimer, Theodor Adorno, Martin Heidegger, Michel Foucault, Jacques Derrida, Cornelius Castoriadis and Niklas Luhmann. The work is regarded as an important contribution to Frankfurt School critical theory. It has been characterized as a critical evaluation of the concept of world disclosure in modern philosophy.

Research methodology based on intersubjective dialogue and an egalitarian relationship between the research team and those being researched .Current societies are characterized for using dialogue in different domains, seeing it as necessary for social progress and for avoiding different social conflicts. Critical communicative methodology is characterized for its dialogic orientation in different aspects of the research.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nikolas Kompridis</span> Canadian philosopher

Nikolas Kompridis is a Canadian philosopher and political theorist. His major published work addresses the direction and orientation of Frankfurt School critical theory; the legacy of philosophical romanticism; and the aesthetic dimension(s) of politics. His writing touches on a variety of issues in social and political thought, aesthetics, and the philosophy of culture, often in terms of re-worked concepts of receptivity and world disclosure—a paradigm he calls "reflective disclosure".

In Marxist philosophy, reification is the process by which human social relations are perceived as inherent attributes of the people involved in them, or attributes of some product of the relation, such as a traded commodity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Critical theory</span> Approach to social philosophy

A critical theory is any approach to humanities and social philosophy that focuses on society and culture to attempt to reveal, critique, and challenge or dismantle power structures. With roots in sociology and literary criticism, it argues that social problems stem more from social structures and cultural assumptions than from individuals. Some hold it to be an ideology, others argue that ideology is the principal obstacle to human liberation. Critical theory finds applications in various fields of study, including psychoanalysis, film theory, literary theory, cultural studies, history, communication theory, philosophy, and feminist theory.

Han Sang-jin is a South Korean sociologist in the tradition of critical theory, known for his Joongmin theory. He is professor emeritus at the department of sociology, Seoul National University, Korea, and a distinguished visiting professor at Peking University, China. He has lectured as visiting professor at Columbia University in New York, United States, School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences in Paris, France, the University of Buenos Aires in Argentina, and Kyoto University in Japan. His major areas of interest are: social theory, political sociology, human rights and transitional justice, middle class politics, participatory risk governance, Confucianism and East Asian development.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hartmut Rosa</span> German sociologist

Hartmut Rosa is a German sociologist and political scientist, most well known for his theory of resonance and temporal sociology of social acceleration.

Johanna Meehan was an American philosopher, academic and author. She was McCay-Casady Professor of Humanities and Philosophy at Grinnell College.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Social acceleration</span> Sociological concept

Social acceleration is a sociological concept of time in late modernity developed by German sociologist Hartmut Rosa. It was featured in his book Beschleunigung. Die Veränderung der Zeitstrukturen in der Moderne.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Rosa, Hartmut (2016). Resonanz. Eine Soziologie der Weltbeziehung. Berlin: Suhrkamp Verlag. ISBN   978-3-518-58626-6.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Rosa, Hartmut (2013). Social Acceleration: A New Theory of Modernity. Translated by Wagner, James. Columbia University Press. ISBN   978-0-231-14835-1.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Rosa, Hartmut (2019). Resonance: A Sociology of our Relationship to the World. Translated by Wagner, James. Polity.
  4. ↑ Jaeggi, Rahel; Neuhouser, Frederick; Smith, Alan (2014-08-26). Alienation. Columbia University Press. doi:10.7312/columbia/9780231151986.001.0001. ISBN   978-0-231-15198-6.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Brumlik, Micha. Resonanz oder: Das Ende der kritischen Theorie. pp. 120–123.
  6. ↑ Rosa, Hartmut (2018). "The idea of resonance as a sociological concept". Global Dialogue. 8 (2): 41–44.
  7. ↑ Shabasson, Daniel S (2015). "English translation of Rilke's poem "Ich furchte mich so vor der Menschen Wort "Menschen Wort"". Academic Works.
  8. ↑ Rosa, Hartmut Rosa (2020). The Uncontrollability of the World. Polity.
  9. ↑ Rosa, Hartmut (2023). "Resonance as a medio-passive, emancipatory and transformative power: a reply to my critics". The Journal of Chinese Sociology. 10 (1). doi: 10.1186/s40711-023-00195-4 .
  10. 1 2 Rosa, Hartmut (2015). Beschleunigung: die Veränderung der Zeitstrukturen in der Moderne. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp. ISBN   978-3-518-29360-7.
  11. ↑ Honneth, Axel (2012). The I in We: studies in the theory of recognition. Cambridge: Polity press. ISBN   978-0-7456-5233-7.
  12. ↑ "The communicative concept of action", Understanding Habermas : Communicative Action and Deliberative Democracy, Bloomsbury Academic, ISBN   978-1-4742-1321-9 , retrieved 2024-04-30
  13. ↑ Thomä, Dieter (8 July 2016). Hartmut Rosa: Soziologie mit der Stimmgabel. ISSN   0044-2070.
  14. ↑ "Against Aggression: Monstrous and Resonant Forms of Uncontrollability". YouTube. Nov 28, 2023. 1:23:30. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
  15. 1 2 Felski, Rita (2020). "Resonance and Education". Journal for Research and Debate. 3 (9). doi: 10.17899/on_ed.2020.9.2 . ISSN   2571-7855.
  16. ↑ Prouteau, François; Hétier, Renaud; Wallenhorst, Nathanaël (2022-06-15). "Critique, Utopia and Resistance: Three Functions of Pedagogy of Resonance in the Anthropocene". Vierteljahrsschrift für wissenschaftliche Pädagogik. 98 (2): 202–215. doi:10.30965/25890581-09703042. ISSN   0507-7230. S2CID   251428034.
  17. ↑ Frydendal, Stine; Thing, Lone Friis (2023-01-05). "PE as resonance? The role of physical education in an accelerated education system". Sport, Education and Society: 1–13. doi:10.1080/13573322.2022.2161502. ISSN   1357-3322. S2CID   255721204.
  18. ↑ Göllner, Michael; Honnens, Johann; Krupp, Valerie; Oravec, Lina; Schmid, Silke, eds. (2023). 44. Jahresband des Arbeitskreises Musikpädagogische Forschung: = 44th Yearbook of the German Association for Research in Music Education. Musikpädagogische Forschung Research in Music Education. Münster New York: Waxmann. ISBN   978-3-8309-4764-6.
  19. ↑ López-Deflory, Camelia; Perron, Amélie; Miró-Bonet, Margalida (2023). "Social acceleration, alienation, and resonance: Hartmut Rosa's writings applied to nursing". Nursing Inquiry. 30 (2): e12528. doi:10.1111/nin.12528. hdl: 20.500.13003/18260 . ISSN   1320-7881. PMID   36115014.
  20. ↑ Shim, Seung-hwan (2022-12-08). "Resonance as an educational response to alienation and acceleration in contemporary society". Asia Pacific Education Review. doi:10.1007/s12564-022-09814-0. ISSN   1598-1037. S2CID   254479780.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.