Carlos Eduardo Robledo Puch (born 19 January 1952[2]), also known as The Angel of Death and The Black Angel, is an Argentine serial killer. He was convicted of at least eleven murders (including the killing of at least one accomplice), one attempted murder, seventeen robberies, involvement in one rape and one attempted rape, one count of sexual abuse, two kidnappings, and two thefts. Most of the offenses occurred in the northern area of Greater Buenos Aires.[3]
Robledo Puch was born on 19 January 1952 to Víctor Robledo Puch, a former technician for General Motors, and Josefa Aída Habendak, a housewife who had emigrated from Germany shortly after World War II.[2] His family descends from Dionisio Puch, a soldier who was governor of the Salta Province, and Martín Miguel de Güemes, a military leader who defended the nation during the War of Independence.[3] Robledo Puch is of maternal German descent.[4] In 1956, when Robledo Puch was four years old, his parents moved the family to Borges Street, Olivos, Buenos Aires Province, where they rented a first-floor apartment above a hardware store. Coming from a hard-working, middle-class family, Puch was known to be shy and quiet like his mother, who took great care of him. Robledo Puch is a football supporter of River Plate.[5] Puch studied piano and learned German during his childhood.[2] He had troubled school years, where he usually stole items from his classmates. In 1967, Puch was caught stealing money from the secretary's office and was expelled from school.[2] Puch, who was victim of bullying at school,[6] had a difficult relationship with his father. After his arrest for the serial killings, Puch's grandmother died suddenly and his mother attempted suicide. His father allegedly blamed Puch for these incidents, which Puch never forgave.[6] Shortly after his capture, Puch threatened his father via letter, telling him that he would kill him the day he was freed.[6] His father eventually divorced Puch's mother and was expelled from his job due to ostracization for his son's actions.[6]
In December 1968, Puch had his first legal encounter when he entered the workshop of a man who worked with bicycles and stole a motorcycle. After being arrested for this robbery, Puch confessed to more than 14 thefts. He was sent to a reformatory, where he spent twenty days under the order of a juvenile court judge.[7] Towards the end of 1969 or early 1970, Puch met Jorge Antonio Ibáñez,[7] who became his accomplice in many robberies and murders. In early 1971, Puch and Ibáñez committed at least four robberies, stealing millions of pesos and spending them on luxurious items for themselves. They were arrested in January 1971 for one of these crimes and were charged with felonies.[7] Puch was released shortly afterwards but was ordered to present himself for a court appearance. Puch and Ibáñez, who had also been released on bail, escaped to Mar del Plata on train.[7]
Serial killings and arrest
Puch's first documented murder occurred on 3 May 1971, when Puch and Ibáñez entered an auto repair shop in Vicente López around midnight,[8] in northern Greater Buenos Aires. Puch shot and killed the shop's owner. He then seriously injured and sexually assaulted his wife, who survived along with her 10-month-old baby daughter.[2][9] Before fleeing with AR$400,000 in cash, Puch shot towards the baby's cradle, failing in his attempt to shoot her.[8] Puch and Ibáñez killed again only days later on 14 May 1971, when they broke into a nightclub in Olivos. There, Puch and Ibáñez stole more than two million pesos in cash from the storage room. Before fleeing, Puch saw an opened door to a small room. When he peered inside, he saw two men sleeping (the watchmen). Puch immediately opened fire, killing them both.[10] Ten days later, on 24 May 1971, Puch and Ibáñez entered a supermarket in Vicente López. Once inside, Puch shot and killed the 61-year-old watchman. He then stole more than five million pesos and drank a whole bottle of whiskey with Ibáñez at the crime scene as a celebration for their success.[10]
On 13 June 1971, Puch and Ibáñez kidnapped a 16-year-old girl from a Buenos Aires highway. The girl, who had been involved in street prostitution, was forced into Puch's car at gunpoint. After driving away to a secluded area, Ibáñez sexually assaulted the girl and then ordered her out of the car. Puch told the girl to walk without looking backwards and shot her five times, killing her. It is unclear whether Puch also indulged in the sexual assault.[2][8] Puch murdered another female on 24 June 1971, when, along with Ibáñez, they kidnapped a 22-year-old woman who had just left her boyfriend's house near the site where the 16-year-old girl had been murdered. Puch and Ibáñez drove the woman to another secluded area, where Ibáñez attempted to rape her. It is also unclear whether Puch took part in this sexual assault. Ibáñez then ordered the woman to exit the car and Puch followed her, shooting her multiple times in the back, killing her.[8][9]
On 5 August 1971, Puch's accomplice Ibáñez died in a confusing car accident that occurred while Puch was driving. Later rumors alleged that Puch could have killed Ibáñez and staged the accident as an alibi for Ibáñez's murder.[10] As a result, Puch looked for another accomplice, finally acquainting himself with Héctor Somoza. They committed their first crime together on 15 November 1971 when they entered a supermarket in the northern area of Greater Buenos Aires. Puch and Somoza did not take anything as Puch was surprised by the 50-year-old watchman, whom he killed by shooting him multiple times. [8][9][10] Two days later, on 17 November 1971, Puch and Somoza broke into an auto agency and stole AR$90,000 in cash. Before fleeing, Puch shot and killed the sleeping watchman, who had raised his concerns in regards to the deaths of other watchmen in the area. At that point police began to suspect serial murders.[8][2] Puch's last murder in 1971 occurred on 25 November, when, along with Somoza, he broke into a Dodge agency. Puch and Somoza stole 1.5 million pesos. Before escaping, Puch took the watchman to the second floor of the agency and shot him three times, killing the man.[8][9][10]
Puch committed his last murder on 3 February 1972, when, along with Somoza, he broke into a hardware store in Tigre, Buenos Aires. Once inside the store, Puch encountered the watchman and, at gunpoint, locked the man up inside a small room. Minutes later, Puch returned, opened the door, and killed the man with two gunshots. After the watchman was murdered, Puch and Somoza tried to open the safe vault. In a confusing incident, Somoza grabbed Puch, which Puch interpreted as an attempt to kill him. Puch then took his handgun and shot Somoza, killing him.[2][10] Puch tried to cover up Somoza's identity by burning his face and hands with a blowtorch. Puch then escaped with some cash but forgot that Somoza had his (Puch's) identification card in his pockets, which would eventually lead to Puch's arrest.[10][8][9][2]
Puch was arrested on 4 February 1972, after Puch's identity card was found in Somoza's pants pocket, which made the police interview his family, who said that he had been with Puch lately. He had just turned 20.[11]
Trial
Puch's trial began more than eight years after his arrest, on 4 August 1980, where Puch faced 36 charges, including eleven counts of aggravated murder.[12] Puch blamed his first accomplice Ibáñez for many of the crimes and stood defiant in court, where he referred to the whole process as a "farce."[12] The trial extended for four months, where 92 witnesses accused Puch of committing the crimes. Prior and during the process, a forensic psychiatrist named Osvaldo Raffo, determined that Puch was a psychopath who represented a threat to society.[2] Puch, who met with Raffo over 25 times during the evaluations, later accused Raffo of lying and gaining fame at his expense.[2]
On 27 November 1980, the trial concluded with a unanimous verdict from the three presiding judges. Robledo Puch was sentenced to life imprisonment with the accessory of "indeterminate reclusion"; the maximum possible sentence under Argentine law.[13][2][14] After the verdict was read, Puch delivered his last words to the court saying: "This was a Roman circus. I was judged and sentenced beforehand."[15]
Robledo Puch later denied his involvement in the murders he was accused of, saying he was tortured and coerced into a confession. He did not deny any of the thefts he was accused of. The only survivor (eyewitness), who did not appear or testify in court for health reasons, said that the man who had raped and shot her had long hair, which indicated Ibáñez. Robledo Puch had short curly hair.[16]
Parole applications and incarceration
Robledo Puch in prison, 1973
On 7 July 1973, Puch briefly escaped from prison, only to be recaptured three days later in downtown Buenos Aires. His mother, who appeared in the media defending her son and denying that he had committed the murders, was confronted by an angry reporter who asked her if she believed in her son's innocence. Puch's mother responded that she knew that her son "had done some things [...] but not all of them."[17]
In July 2000, Puch became eligible for parole; he did not submit a petition.[18]
In 2003, Puch was briefly transferred to a psychiatric hospital, where he was evaluated after he dressed as Batman and set fire to the workshop of the prison where he was serving his sentence in Olavarría. After being found competent, he was returned to prison.[19] In 2007 he was transferred to another prison in Azul, Buenos Aires.[19]
On 27 May 2008, Puch submitted a petition of request to be paroled. The judge who reviewed his petition denied him parole considering him to still be a threat to society.[20]
In November 2013, he requested a review of his sentence or, failing that, his execution by lethal injection, even though the death penalty was not legal in Argentina. The Supreme Court of Justice denied both the request for review and the request for execution, the latter of which would have been illegal.[21]
On 27 March 2015, the Supreme Court of Justice rejected an appeal filed by Robledo Puch against the aforementioned judicial decision whereby he was denied parole.[22]
In May 2019, Puch was rushed to a hospital from prison after he showed signs of intoxication related to side effects of a medication aimed at treating depression.[19]
In March 2023, during an interview with América 24, Puch denied his crimes and blamed others for them. Puch said that he was "constantly suffering" in prison and that he wished to be "euthanized."[23] Puch has a history of demanding that he be executed (even though the death penalty is not a legal punishment in Argentina), including in 2013, when he asked to be executed via lethal injection if his parole application was denied.[24]
In June 2023, judge Oscar Roberto Quintana of the Court of Guarantees and Appeals, turned down his parole request once again, citing that Puch suffers from "inconsistent emotions [...] which could be expressed in an erratic way," adding that Puch also has "paranoid reflections."[25] Judge Quintana also rejected the transfer to a nursing home, saying that Puch refuses psychiatric treatment, and that he has not worked since 1992.[26]
As of 2024[update], Robledo Puch has spent over 51 years in prison, making him the longest-serving prisoner in South America.[17]
↑ Under Article 52 of the Argentine penal code, Robledo Puch received the harshest sentence under Argentine law, in which a defendant can be remanded in custody for the rest of their lives.[1]
Related Research Articles
Pedro Alonso López, also known as The Monster of the Andes, is a Colombian serial killer, child rapist, and fugitive who murdered a minimum of 110 people, mostly young women and girls, from 1969 to 1980. López claimed to have murdered over 300 people. He is considered by many as one of the most prolific serial killers and rapists in history.
José Luis Cabezas was an Argentine news photographer and reporter who worked for Noticias, a leading local newsmagazine. Cabezas gained notoriety after he was kidnapped and killed by people hired by Alfredo Yabrán in retaliation for having taken a photo of him in Pinamar –a seaside resort in Atlantic Coast– in February 1996. The photo, which displayed Yabrán and his wife, was published on the cover of Noticias magazine in March 1996, unveiling Yabrán's face to public.
Narciso Ibáñez Menta was a Spanish theatre, film, and television actor.
Cayetano Santos Godino, also known as El Petiso Orejudo, was an Argentine serial killer who terrorized Buenos Aires at age 16. In the early 20th century he was responsible for the murder of four children, the attempted murder of another seven children, and seven counts of arson.
Instinto Asesino is a series produced by Endemol Argentina for the Discovery Channel. Each episode portrays a notorious Criminal case that occurred in a country in Latin America. So far, cases depicted occurred in Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Mexico and Venezuela.
Gustavo Romero Tercero, also known as "The Valdepeñas Killer," is an incarcerated Spanish murderer and rapist.
El Angel is a 2018 Argentine-Spanish true crime film directed by Luis Ortega. It was screened in the Un Certain Regard section at the 2018 Cannes Film Festival. It is inspired by the true story of Argentine serial killer Carlos Robledo Puch. It was selected as the Argentine entry for the Best Foreign Language Film at the 91st Academy Awards, but it was not nominated.
Cayetano Domingo Grossi was the first known serial killer in Argentinian history. He murdered five of his own neonatal children that were born as the result of his rape of his two stepdaughters. For this reason he was sentenced to death and executed by firing squad on April 6, 1900.
Francisco Antonio Laureana was a young Argentine man killed by the Buenos Aires police, who believed him to be a rapist and serial killer called The Satyr of San Isidro, who for a period of six months—from 1974 and 1975—raped women, 13 of whom he murdered. He killed most of his victims on Wednesdays and Thursdays near 6:00 p.m.
Laura Alonso is an Argentine politician who served as head of the Anti-Corruption Bureau of Argentina from 2015 to 2019 during the presidency of Mauricio Macri. She also served as member of the Chamber of Deputies from 2009 to 2015. Previously, she was Executive Director of Poder Ciudadano, the Argentine chapter of Transparency International.
Javier Hernán Pino is an Argentine serial killer. Between February and October 2015, he befriended and deceived five people into trusting him, before shooting them in the head with a silenced pistol and robbing them of their belongings. For his crimes, he was sentenced to three counts of life imprisonment, which he is now serving at the Coronda Prison in Santa Fe Province.
Mateo Banks y Keena was an Argentine spree killer who murdered six members of his family, in addition to two of the family's employees. The crimes occurred on two of the family's rural estates at Parish, near Azul, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina, on 18 April 1922.
The 2020 COVID-19 pandemic in Argentina affected the human rights situation in the country.
Carmel: Who Killed María Marta? is a 2020 Argentine true crime documentary miniseries directed by Alejandro Hartmann.
Lorenzo "Toto" Ferro is an Argentine actor, singer and songwriter. He gained recognition for playing Robledo Puch in the 2018 film El ángel. His television roles include Cristian Pardo in the third season of El marginal (2019) and Alex Hodoyan in the third season of Narcos: Mexico (2021). Ferro releases music under the stage name Kiddo Toto. He has released two studio albums: Resfriado (2019) and Mansión helada (2021).
The Madman of the route is the nickname given to an alleged serial killer active in Mar de Plata, Argentina from 1996 to 1999. The allegations claim that a single killer is responsible for the murders and disappearances of at least 14 prostitutes, some of which were later found raped and mutilated near highways, sometimes with words written on their bodies.
Diego Casanova is an Argentine serial killer who murdered six people between 2004 and 2016. Casanova is known as The Prisoner Killer as he murdered five inmates while imprisoned. Additionally, he participated in sixty-seven fights and several riots in prison. Experts describe Casanova as an extremely dangerous prisoner with psychopathic behavior, and one of the cruelest serial killers in Argentine history.
The murder of Natalia Mariel Melmann, a 15-year-old Argentine student, occurred on 4 February 2001, in Miramar, Buenos Aires. Five police officers were found guilty of her kidnap, torture, rape and murder.
Roberto José Carmona, known as The Human Hyena, is an Argentine thief, rapist and serial killer. Initially imprisoned for killing a teenage girl in 1986, Carmona proceeded to kill two inmates in separate incidents and culminating with the murder of a taxi driver during an escape attempt in 2022.
Cesáreo Ángel Cardozo was an Argentinian military officer who has been Chief of the Argentine Federal Police. He was Military Attache to Chile, Interim Minister of Interior of Argentina in the Military Junta of 1976. Serving as chief of the police in 1976, he was assassinated when a bomb placed by the Montoneros exploded under his bed at his home in Buenos Aires.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
