Selenium rectifier

An 8-plate 160 V 450 mA Federal brand selenium rectifier

A selenium rectifier is a type of metal rectifier, invented in 1933. ^[1] They were used in power supplies for electronic equipment and in high-current battery-charger applications until they were superseded by silicon diode rectifiers in the late 1960s. The arrival of the alternator in some automobiles was the result of compact, low-cost, high-current silicon rectifiers. These units were small enough to be inside the alternator case, unlike the selenium units that preceded silicon devices.

The rectifying properties of selenium, amongst other semiconductors, were observed by Braun, Schuster and Siemens between 1874 and 1883. ^[2] The photoelectric and rectifying properties of selenium were also observed by Adams and Day in 1876 ^[3] and C. E. Fitts around 1886, but practical rectifier devices were not manufactured routinely until the 1930s. Compared with the earlier copper-oxide rectifier, the selenium cell could withstand higher voltage, but at a lower current capacity per unit area. ^[4]

Construction

Typical structure of a selenium rectifier

Selenium rectifiers are made from stacks of aluminum or steel plates coated with about 1  μm of bismuth or nickel. A much thicker layer of selenium (50 to 60 μm) doped with a halogen is deposited on top of the thin metal plating. The selenium is then converted into polycrystalline gray (hexagonal) form by annealing. Cadmium selenide forms by reaction of the selenium with the tin-cadmium alloy and the CdSe-Se heterojunction is the active rectifying junction. Each plate is able to withstand about 20 volts in the reverse direction. The metal squares, or disks, also serve as heat sinks in addition to providing a mounting place for the selenium disks. Plates can be stacked indefinitely to withstand higher voltages. Stacks of thousands of miniature selenium disks have been used as high-voltage rectifiers in television sets and photocopy machines.

Use

Selenium rectifiers used in 1950s MADDIDA computer

Selenium rectifier from 1960s. Each plate is 1-inch square.

Selenium rectifiers are able to withstand repetitive significant overload without the need of special protective measures. It is commonly used in electroplating rectifier under 200,000 A and electrostatic precipitators operating between 30 and 100 kV ^[5]

Radio and television receivers used them from about 1947 to 1975 to provide up to a few hundred volts of plate voltage. Vacuum-tube rectifiers had efficiencies of only 60% compared to the 85% of selenium rectifiers, partially because vacuum-tube rectifiers required heating. Selenium rectifiers have no warm-up time, unlike high-vacuum rectifiers. Selenium rectifiers were also cheaper and simpler to specify and install than vacuum tubes. However, they were later replaced by silicon diodes with high efficiencies (close to 100% at high voltages). Selenium rectifiers had the capability to act as current limiters, which can temporarily protect the rectifier during a short circuit and provide stable current for charging batteries.^{[ citation needed ]}

Properties

A selenium rectifier is about the same size as a copper-oxide rectifier, but is much larger than a silicon or germanium diode. Selenium rectifiers have a long but not indefinite service life of 60,000 to 100,000 hours, depending on rating and cooling. The rectifier can show some unforming of the rectifier characteristic after long storage. ^[6] Each cell can withstand a reverse voltage around 25 volts and has a forward voltage drop around 1 volt, which limits the efficiency at low voltages. Selenium rectifiers have an operating temperature limit of 130 °C and are not suitable for high-frequency circuits. ^[7]

Replacement

Selenium rectifiers had a shorter lifespan than desired. In the early stage of failure they produce a modest amount of sweet-smelling gas. Sometimes described as 'sickly-sweet'. At that point the rectification properties are almost totally gone, allowing reverse voltage to leak through the rectifier. During catastrophic failure they produced significant quantities of malodorous and highly toxic hydrogen selenide ^{[8] [9] [10]} that let the repair technician know what the problem was. By far the most common failure mode was a progressive increase in forward resistance, increasing forward voltage drop and reducing the rectifier's efficiency. During the 1960s they began to be superseded by silicon rectifiers, which exhibited lower forward voltage drop, lower cost, and higher reliability. ^[11]

Selenium diode computer logic

In 1961 IBM started developing a low-speed computer logic family ^[12] that used selenium diodes with similar characteristics to silicon but cost less than one cent. The terminal development departments were begging for low cost and did not need speed. It was possible to punch 1/8-inch discs from a sheet of selenium diode. GE claimed that they could make reliable selenium diodes. A design was achieved for a DDTL circuit with two levels of diode logic feeding one alloy transistor and no series input resistor or speed-up capacitor. The family was called SMAL ^[13] or SMALL, for "selenium matrix alloy logic". The alloy transistor proved to be too fast for the selenium diode recovery. To solve this problem, a selenium diode was connected around the base–emitter to slow it down. The two-level logic was similar to the programmable logic array (PLA) that would come on the market many years later. Nearly any static logic function that yielded one output could be achieved with one transistor and a handful of cheap diodes. Several years later the selenium diodes were found to be not reliable and were replaced by silicon diodes. The logic family was packaged on SMS cards. ^[13]

Further reading

• F.T. Selenium Rectifier Handbook; 2nd Ed; Federal Telephone and Radio; 80 pages; 1953. (archive)
• S.T. Selenium Rectifier Handbook; 1st Ed; Sarkes Tarzian; 80 pages; 1950. (archive)

References

1. Hempstead, Colin; Worthington, William (2005-08-08). Encyclopedia of 20th-Century Technology. Routledge. p. 669. ISBN   978-1-135-45551-4. selenium rectifiers, which were invented by Charles E. Fitts in 1933
2. books.google.co.uk
3. books.google.co.uk
4. Peter Robin Morris. A history of the world semiconductor industry, IET, 1990, ISBN   0-86341-227-0, pages 13, 18.
5. Reeves, E. A.; Heathcote, Martin (2013-06-17). Newnes Electrical Pocket Book. Taylor & Francis. p. 95. ISBN   978-1-136-37644-3.
6. Ernst Bleule (ed.), Electronic methods, Academic Press, 1964, ISBN   0-12-475902-5, pages 206–207.
7. H. P. Westman (ed), Reference Data for Radio Engineers Fifth Edition, Howard W. Sams & Co., Inc. 1968, chapter 13.
8. Preston, J. S. (1950-08-22). "Constitution and mechanism of the selenium rectifier photocell". Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences. 202 (1071): 449–466. Bibcode:1950RSPSA.202..449P. doi:10.1098/rspa.1950.0112. ISSN   0080-4630. S2CID   93164294.
9. "Occupational Health Guideline for Hydrogen Selenide" (PDF). cdc.gov. 1978. Retrieved 2022-10-01.
10. PubChem. "Hydrogen selenide". pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. Retrieved 2022-10-01.
11. Selenium, U.S. Department of the Interior.
12. US Patent 3218472: Transistor switch with noise rejection provided by variable capacitance feedback diode.
13. The 1060 Data Communications System (PDF). IBM. p. 2.