Serving His Children

Last updated

Serving His Children (SHC) [1] is a Christian nonprofit organization, based in southeast Uganda. It was started by Renee Bach in 2009. She at first gave free meals to families in need, then offering free medical treatment for malnourished children along with community support regarding malnourishment. Bach's work has been marred with allegations of recklessness and incompetency. Bach has denied many allegations and stated that she never presented herself as a doctor—as she has no formal training.

Contents

In 2019, a lawsuit was levelled against her by two mothers who claimed that SHC were responsible for their children's deaths. It was settled in 2020, with each of the mothers receiving around $9,500, and with no admission of liability from SHC. [2] Following the first lawsuit, the Uganda Medical and Dental Practitioners Council conducted an independent investigation. They were "unable to support allegations that children died in large numbers due to the services of S.H.C" and "did not find evidence that Ms. Renée Bach, Director of S.H.C., was treating children." [3]

History

In 2007, while a teenager, Bach went on an evangelical missionary trip to Jinja, Uganda, to work at a missionary-run orphanage, where she stayed for nine months. After returning from the trip in 2009, Bach stated that she felt "like there was something that [she] was supposed to do", and decided to return to Jinja to start a charity organization through funds raised by local church circles in Bedford, believing it was God's calling for her. [4] She later stated that she traveled to Uganda with a "white savior mentality". [5] Originally based in a home Bach had rented in the Masese district of Jinja, the organization started out by providing neighborhood children free biweekly meals, and the charity eventually came to be called Serving His Children (SHC). She often drove ill children to Nalufenya, the local pediatric hospital. [4] After word spread of the charity throughout Jinja, a staffer from Nalufenya asked for Bach's help with their severely malnourished children, leading Bach to turn the house she had rented into a nutrition center wherein these malnourished children could be restored back to health while their parents lived there. [6] The group's mission statement claimed it was "working to end malnutrition in families and communities" and "partner[ing] with the government of Uganda to provide inpatient therapeutic care for children suffering from severe acute malnutrition". [7]

In 2011, SHC was registered as a non-governmental organization in the country. [5] [7] By this time, Bach had stocked the center with medical equipment and had hired several Ugandan nurses during the day. However, she had hired no doctors, nor had she obtained a health license for the center. Therefore, Bach herself had taken control of much of the care that took place at the center. [6] According to multiple testimonies from those involved with SHC, Bach purported herself to be a trained medical professional while working at the center, personally administering intravenous drips into the veins of patients and performing blood transfusions despite her complete lack of professional training. [4] [7] According to former SHC volunteer and American registered nurse Jacqueline Grace Kramlich, Bach ignored practices including hand washing and glove-wearing, defied local doctors' orders—believing she knew better, and that God would instruct her [5] [3] —carried out various procedures without oversight from a doctor, and based her practice on her "gut feelings" and the book Where There Is No Doctor . [1] [5] In a deleted blog post from Bach, she wrote that she administered oxygen to a child whose temperature, blood sugar and hemoglobin were checked. The child reportedly received an intravenous drip and blood transfusion. [8]

Many of the children brought to SHC were suffering from conditions that the center was not qualified to deal with, including malaria, pneumonia, and tuberculosis, and were only permitted by Ugandan law and international guidelines to be treated in a higher-level health center. In 2011, 20 percent of the children in SHC's care died, which some attribute to the lack of trained medical staff at SHC.[ citation needed ] The death rate dropped to 18 percent the following year, and, after Bach hired two doctors at the nutrition center in 2013, it fell to 10 percent. [6] Gideon Wamasebu, the district health officer of Manafwa, worked with SHC in 2012 and said that it was he, not Bach, who was in charge of overseeing patients at that time. [3]

In 2013, Bach's mother was named the director of Serving His Children. [3] By 2014, it had become a licensed health facility in the Jinja district, though the license expired by the end of the year. The facility was shut down in 2015 following complaints and a two-hour inspection. [5]

In 2017, SHC, in partnership with Uganda's Ministry of Health, opened an inpatient treatment center in Mayuge District and began outpatient treatment services for malnourished children. Community support was later offered. [5] In 2019, Bach stepped down from her role as Serving His Children's program director, temporarily returning to the United States in a volunteer role to help fundraise for her organization's team in Uganda. [5] The following year she said she would no longer practice medicine in Uganda and announced the dissolution of SHC. [9] [10]

Medical activities

Former worker Semei Jolley Kyebanakola claimed that Bach "encouraged mothers to escape" from a children's hospital in Jinja and bring their babies to her facility for treatment instead. He also asserted that she was often seen wearing a stethoscope and said she also wore a "clinical coat." [5] Bach denied his claim of helping mothers escape, noting that due to his profession as a gardener he had limited contact with the children. She also stated that he was aware that she was not versed in medicine. [5]

Charles Olweny, the former field manager, raised concerns over the alleged "high death rate": "On average, I would drive at least seven to ten dead bodies of children back to their villages each week." Bach denied this and showed that from 2010 to 2018, 119 deaths out of 3,596 total patients occurred a rate of 3.3%, lower than the average 20–30% rate when dealing with malnourishment. [5] NPR reported the death rate in 2011 as 20% and 10% in 2013; from 2010 to 2015, 105 children died out of all total of 940 treated.

Lawsuits

On January 21, 2019, a lawsuit was filed in the High Court of Uganda by the Women's Probono Initiative, an advocacy group that provides free legal services to women in Uganda. They sought monetary damages for two mothers whose children died in Bach's care, as well as accountability for 105 other cases. [1] [5] They filed the case on a basis of human-rights violations and of class discrimination. [3]

The first mother named in the lawsuit, Zubeda Gimbo, said that a woman affiliated with SHC collected her son for treatment; he died three days later. [5] He had malaria, a respiratory infection, anemia, and dehydration from diarrhea. [3] Gimbo was compensated with USh  50,000/= (roughly US$13.50). [5] Zuriah Namutamba, Gimbo's mother, claimed that Bach administered medicine to him and placed him on oxygen. [1] Bach was not in Uganda at the time. [5] Gimbo and other mothers were under the impression that Bach was a trained doctor. [1]

The second mother named in the lawsuit, Annet Kakai, said that she was advised, by a woman named Futama, to take her year-old son to a facility for feeding. Before doing so, Kakai was informed that he had tuberculosis. Upon arriving at the facility, a woman—later identified as Bach—collected him, in an hour dismissed them and said to come back the next day. [5] When they returned, SHC staff drove them to a state-run medical center. They were discharged two days later without any further instructions or medication for her son. SHC staff compensated Kakai with USh.2,000/= (less than $1). Her son soon became ill and died three days later. Kakai believed that SHC were responsible for his death. Bach responded by saying that there was no one named Futama who worked for the nonprofit and no records showed him being admitted to SHC. [5] [3] Both mothers supported the claim that Bach was often seen in medical clothing, with a stethoscope. [8]

In July 2020, the lawsuit reached an out-of-court settlement; $9,500 to each of the mothers and SHC being deemed not responsible for either child's death. [9] [10] Bach has stated her belief that the lawsuit was the result of personal "vendetta" by former employees and members of the community who disliked her. [5]

Advocacy group No White Saviors have said that they seek to file cases against SHC. [9] In January 2021, four Ugandan families sued SHC for the deaths of three children; No White Saviors had raised $16,000 to pay legal fees for the families. [10] [11]

Media response

After the initial lawsuit was filed, the story was reported by international media; NPR, The Guardian, NBC News, " Good Morning America," ABC News and Atlanta Black Star all ran stories. Bach issued a response on the Fox News Network. Local newspapers in Virginia reported that Bach was accused of actions "leading to the deaths of hundreds of children." Journalists from Ireland, the Netherlands, Germany and Australia were all present in the courtroom. [3] In 2020, a podcast produced by iHeartRadio investigated the story, including interviews with both Bach and Ugandan healthcare workers. [12]

In 2023, a documentary series Savior Complex revolving around the story featuring Bach, premiered on September 26, 2023, on HBO. [13]

Investigation

Following the first lawsuit, the Uganda Medical and Dental Practitioners Council conducted an independent investigation. They were "unable to support allegations that children died in large numbers due to the services of S.H.C" and "did not find evidence that Ms. Renée Bach, Director of S.H.C., was treating children.", and stated that the local community and health workers "were appreciative of her work". [3]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rebecca Lee Crumpler</span> American physician (1831–1895)

Rebecca Lee Crumpler, born Rebecca Davis,, was an American physician, nurse and author. After studying at the New England Female Medical College, in 1864 she became the first African American woman to become a doctor of medicine in the United States. Crumpler was also one of the first female physician authors in the nineteenth century. In 1883, she published A Book of Medical Discourses. The book has two parts that cover the prevention and cure of infantile bowel complaints, and the life and growth of human beings. Dedicated to nurses and mothers, it focuses on maternal and pediatric medical care and was among the first publications written by an African American on the subject of medicine.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Unassisted childbirth</span>

Unassisted childbirth (UC) refers to the process of intentionally giving birth without the assistance of a medical birth attendant. It may also be known as freebirth, DIY (do-it-yourself) birth, unhindered birth, and unassisted home birth. Unassisted childbirth is by definition a planned process, and is thus distinct from unassisted birth due to reasons of emergency, lack of access to a skilled birth attendant, or other. It is also different from homebirth, although most UCs also happen within the home.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lucille Teasdale-Corti</span> Canadian doctor

Lucille Teasdale-Corti was a Canadian physician and pediatric surgeon, who worked in Uganda from 1961 until her death in 1996. Despite considerable hardship, including civil war and the AIDS epidemic, she cofounded with her husband a university hospital in the north of Uganda.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mary Carson Breckinridge</span> Founder of the American FNS (1881–1965)

Mary Carson Breckinridge was an American nurse midwife and the founder of the Frontier Nursing Service (FNS), which provided comprehensive family medical care to the mountain people of rural Kentucky. FNS served remote and impoverished areas off the road and rail system but accessible by horseback. She modeled her services on European practices and sought to professionalize American nurse-midwives to practice autonomously in homes and decentralized clinics. Although Breckinridge's work demonstrated efficacy by dramatically reducing infant and maternal mortality in Appalachia, at a comparatively low cost, her model of nurse-midwifery never took root in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sara Josephine Baker</span> American physician (1873–1945)

Sara Josephine Baker was an American physician notable for making contributions to public health, especially in the immigrant communities of New York City. Her fight against the damage that widespread urban poverty and ignorance caused to children, especially newborns, is perhaps her most lasting legacy. In 1917, she noted that babies born in the United States faced a higher mortality rate than soldiers fighting in World War I, drawing a great deal of attention to her cause. She also is known for (twice) tracking down Mary Mallon, better known as Typhoid Mary.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nsambya Hospital</span> Private faith-based community, teaching hospital in Uganda

St. Francis Hospital Nsambya, commonly known as Nsambya Hospital, is a hospital in Kampala, the capital of Uganda and the largest city in that country.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Conrad Murray</span> American physician and convict

Conrad Robert Murray is a Grenadian-American former cardiologist who was the personal physician of Michael Jackson, providing medical treatment to help him sleep on the day Jackson died in 2009. In 2011, Murray was convicted of involuntary manslaughter in Jackson's death for having inadvertently overdosed him with a powerful surgical anesthetic, propofol, which was being improperly used as a bedtime sleep agent. Murray served a little less than two years out of his original four-year prison sentence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cicely Williams</span> Jamaican physician (1893–1992)

Cicely Delphine Williams, OM, CMG, FRCP was a Jamaican physician, most notable for her discovery and research into kwashiorkor, a condition of advanced malnutrition, and her campaign against the use of sweetened condensed milk and other artificial baby milks as substitutes for human breast milk.

Irene Gleeson was a Christian missionary to the children of Kitgum District, northern Uganda, whose lives were disrupted first by war then by HIV/AIDS. She was awarded an Officer of the Order of Australia in 2009 for "service to international relations, particularly through sustained aid for children affected by war and HIV-AIDS in Northern Uganda"

Anne Merriman, MBE, MCommH, FRCPI, FRCP is a British doctor, known for her pioneering work and influential research into palliative care in developing countries in Africa. She has campaigned to make affordable oral morphine widely available.

Sarah Rebecca Parrish known as Dr. Rebecca Parish, was an American medical missionary and physician in the Philippines.

Katie Davis Majors is an American missionary and author who established a mission in Jinja, Uganda in 2007. Her work led to the founding of a school and provision of other services in Jinja, which now operate under the auspices of the Tennessee-based not-for-profit, Amazima Ministries International (AMI).

Anne Deborah Atai Omoruto was a Ugandan family physician, public health specialist, and academic. In 2014, she led a team of 12 Ugandan physicians as part of the World Health Organization's response to the Ebola outbreak in Liberia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jane Aceng</span> Ugandan pediatrician, politician

Jane Ruth Aceng is a Ugandan pediatrician and politician. She is the Minister of Health in the Cabinet of Uganda. She was appointed to that position on 6 June 2016. Before that, from June 2011 until June 2016, she served as the Director General of Medical Services in the Ugandan Ministry of Health.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Salome Karwah</span> Liberian nurse

Salomé Karwah was a Liberian nurse who was named co-Person of the Year by Time magazine in 2014 for her efforts to combat the West African Ebola virus epidemic. She appeared on the cover of Time in December 2014 with other health care workers and colleagues working to end the epidemic. Karwah survived ebola herself, before returning to work with Médecins Sans Frontières to help other patients afflicted with the disease. The actions of Karwah and other health care professionals are believed to have saved lives of thousands. However, two years later, Karwah died from complications of childbirth; her widower suggested that this might have been due to the widespread, mistaken belief that ebola survivors can still transmit the virus. Even before the ebola outbreak, Liberia had one of the highest rates of maternal mortality in the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Maura Lynch</span> Irish Doctor and Catholic Nun

Sr. Dr. Maura Lynch was an Irish doctor, a nun, and proponent of women's health.

Ruth Robertson Berrey was an American pediatrician, educator, and a medical missionary to Nigeria. Berrey was active within the Alabama Pediatric Society and became a fellow in the American Academy of Pediatrics. As a medical missionary, she helped children in Nigeria and helped reduce leprosy in the population. As a public health officer in four Alabama counties, she conducted clinics for the detection of tuberculosis, cancer, diabetes, sickle cell anemia, and other diseases.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Primah Kwagala</span> Ugandan civil and human rights lawyer

Primah Kwagala is a Ugandan civil and human rights lawyer and CEO of the Women’s Probono Initiative (WPI) in Uganda. She has handled cases involving illegal detentions in health facilities, access to emergency obstetric care and to free vital medicines, and more. She is the Chairperson of Female Lawyers in the Uganda Law Society. Kwagala was awarded the 2020 Peace and Reconciliation Prize that was awarded by H.E Albrecht Conze, the German Ambassador in Uganda, H.E Jules-Armand ANIAMBOSSOU who is the Ambassador of France to Uganda and Henry Oryem Okello the State Minister for Foreign Affairs at the 57th Anniversary celebrations of Elysee Treaty. On Women's Day in the year, 2022, she was named by the U. S Embassy in Uganda as one of Uganda's Outstanding women of Courage and she was awarded with EU Human Right Defenders Award 2022.

No White Saviors is an anti-white saviorism social media campaign, predominately present on Instagram. It was launched by two social workers in 2018.

Savior Complex is an American true crime documentary series directed and produced by Jackie Jesko. It explores the case of Serving His Children, a nonprofit organization founded by Renee Bach. Allegations arise when Bach treated sick children without medical qualifications, resulting in the deaths of children on the charity’s watch.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Beaumont, Alon Mwesigwa Peter (2019-10-17). "Did children die because of 'white saviour' Renee Bach?". The Guardian . ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 2021-01-30.
  2. ↑ Aizenman, Nurith (July 31, 2020). "U.S. Missionary With No Medical Training Settles Suit Over Child Deaths At Her Center". NPR . Retrieved July 25, 2021.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Levy, Ariel (April 6, 2020). "A Missionary on Trial". The New Yorker . Retrieved 2021-01-30.
  4. 1 2 3 Levy, Ariel (April 6, 2020). "A Missionary on Trial". The New Yorker . Retrieved October 5, 2020.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 Winsor, Morgan (July 18, 2019). "Renee Bach wasn't a doctor, but she still treated many patients in Uganda, lawsuit says". ABC News . Retrieved 2021-01-30.
  6. 1 2 3 Aizenman, Nurrith; Gharib, Malaka (August 9, 2019). "American With No Medical Training Ran Center For Malnourished Ugandan Kids. 105 Died". NPR . Retrieved January 30, 2021.
  7. 1 2 3 Mwesigwa, Alon; Beaumont, Peter (October 17, 2019). "Did children die because of 'white saviour' Renee Bach?". The Guardian . Kampala, Uganda. Retrieved October 4, 2020.
  8. 1 2 Hayden, Sally (June 28, 2019). "'White saviourism' under scrutiny after child deaths in Uganda". The Irish Times . Retrieved 2021-01-31.
  9. 1 2 3 Aizenman, Nurith (July 31, 2020). "U.S. Missionary With No Medical Training Settles Suit Over Child Deaths At Her Center". NPR . Retrieved 2021-01-30.
  10. 1 2 3 McCool, Alice (2020-07-28). "US missionary accused over Uganda child deaths settles out of court". The Guardian . Retrieved 2021-01-31.
  11. ↑ McCool, Alice (2021-01-22). "US missionary faces new legal action over child deaths at Uganda health centre". The Guardian . Retrieved 2021-01-31.
  12. ↑ "The Missionary".
  13. ↑ Zhan, Jennifer (September 6, 2023). "Of Course Renee Bach Defends Herself in Savior Complex". Vulture . Retrieved September 6, 2023.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.