Stationary High Altitude Relay Platform

Last updated June 03, 2022

SHARP, short for Stationary High Altitude Relay Platform, was an experimental aircraft using beam-powered propulsion designed by the Communications Research Centre Canada (CRC) and built by the University of Toronto Institute for Aerospace Studies (UTIAS) during the 1980s. SHARP used microwaves to provide energy from a ground station that powered electric motors spinning propellers to keep the aircraft aloft. The power was also used for the onboard electronics. SHARP could remain aloft indefinitely, and was intended to be used as a sort of low-altitude communications satellite for smaller geographical areas.

History

Background

The concept of using beamed power for aircraft propulsion was invented almost single-handedly by William C. Brown.^[1] After joining Raytheon in the 1940s, Brown started work on improving their magnetron products. This led to the development of the crossed-field amplifier, a simple, reliable and highly efficient microwave amplifier. He later worked with colleagues to develop the rectenna, which receives microwaves (the (an)"tenna") and converts them directly to DC power (the "rect"ifier).^[2]

Brown now had a system that could convert input power to microwaves with up to 70% efficiency and convert it back to electric power with 70% efficiency, resulting in an overall efficiency of about 50%. Brown looked for applications of the technology, working on both solar power satellites (SPS) and the High Altitude Powered Platform (HAPP) concept. This research went as far as flying a model helicopter using beamed power in 1965.^[3]

NASA also invested in the rectenna concept as part of their SPS work. This was tested in a ground-to-ground experiment in 1975,^[4] and as part of this they developed lightweight versions of the rectenna. In 1982, Brown and James Trimer (of NASA) announced a new version of the rectenna using printed circuit techniques that reduced the weight by ten times.^[2] This made aircraft applications much more attractive.

Relay platform

In the era before narrow-angle broadcasting from communications satellites was possible, television broadcasters faced the problem of only having technology that was suitable for greater metropolitan areas on the order of 100 km using conventional ground-mounted antennas, or large portions of the continent using satellites. Addressing the range between these two extremes normally required a network of repeater antennas, which were expensive given the smaller populations they normally served.

Since a satellite was too high, and a terrestrial antenna too low, what was needed was a platform between the two, covering an area of a few hundred kilometers in radius – about the size of a Canadian province. To do this the platform would have to fly at about 70,000 feet (21 km) altitude. Aircraft and helicopters could do this, but only with short endurances. Super-high-altitude aerostats were another possibility. Of the available technologies, helicopters appeared to be too heavy, and aerostats, jokingly referred to as the "Gossamer Hindenberg", were not well understood. An electrically powered ultralight aircraft appeared to be the best solution. At the time, a system using solar cells and batteries was considered too heavy.^[5]

The economics of the system were attractive as a replacement for conventional satellites even in some large-area deployments. The CRC estimated the aircraft would cost about $100,000 each, and operate for $2 to $3 million a year. In contrast, just launching a satellite cost about $150 million. Additionally, whereas a satellite of the era might have a lifetime of about 10 years, the aircraft could be periodically returned to the ground for servicing and upgrades, allowing it to operate indefinitely. They felt this would be attractive to third world markets.^[5]

SHARP

Following the work of HAPP, the CRC started work on their own version with the specific intent of making a communications platform. SHARP would use an 80 m diameter array of small parabolic dishes beaming 500 kW of power to the aircraft at 5.8 GHz frequency. At altitude, the beam was focussed down to an area just larger than the aircraft. The aircraft normally flew in a circle about 2 km across, so the beam only needed to steer a few degrees.^[2]

In 1981 SED Systems was awarded a contract to study the power requirements of a communications platform, while John F. Martin of Martin Communications and James DeLaurier at UTIAS studied aircraft configurations. In September 1982 the Department of Communications gave the go-ahead to form a formal study group within the CRC, which studied rectenna design, leading to several patents on thin-film versions.^[2]

In 1982 UTIAS built a prototype of the aircraft with a 1.3 meter high aspect-ratio wing mounted just above the fuselage, and a conventional t-tail at the rear. This model was powered by a small gasoline engine and did not support a rectenna. The prototype demonstrated several aerodynamic problems, leading to an improved design that moved the horizontal stabilizer to the front of the aircraft into a canard configuration. This underwent wind tunnel testing at UTIAS during 1985 and 86.^[2]

All of these studies culminated in the go-ahead to build an eighth-scale model of the proposed production SHARP vehicle that would be powered by two small electric motors. Power for takeoff would be provided by batteries, until it gained enough altitude that it could acquire the microwave beam and self-power from that point on. The model, with a 4.5 meter wingspan, was built during 1987.^[2]

Its maiden flight at the CRC took place on 17 September 1987. The system worked as expected, allowing launch by the batteries and capture by the 1 kW broadcaster shortly after takeoff. The initial 20-minute flight time was extended to over an hour by 5 October, and on the 6th a public demonstration was made for the Minister of Communications, Flora MacDonald.^[2] Their work won the "Diplôme d'Honneur" from the Fédération Aéronautique Internationale in 1988.

After SHARP

In spite of its success, SHARP research ended as part of a larger draw-down of the Canadian research budgets. Ready for testing long-duration flights, field mice attacked the SHARP aircraft while it was in storage, and the flights never took place.^[2]

The work was picked up in Japan at the Radio Atmospheric Science Centre at Kyoto University. Starting immediately after the SHARP successes, Professor Hiroshi Matsumoto developed a similar vehicle, which flew on 29 August 1992.^[6]

Compared to SHARP, their MILAX (Microwave Lifted Airplane Experiment) vehicle had two new design features. The rectenna on the aircraft was embedded in the wings and tail surfaces, eliminating the need for the separate antenna body. The broadcast antenna was based on an active phased array, allowing it to steer without physical movement. The system was tested by mounting the broadcast antenna on the back of a light truck, and driving it around while MILAX followed.^[7]

Another beamed-power experiment in Japan was the ETHER project, which beamed 5.8 kW of power to a helium-inflated airship.^[8]

In the years since the system was first proposed, advances in solar cells and battery technology have upset the initial calculations. The NASA Pathfinder demonstrated long-duration solar powered flight in a role essentially identical to SHARP. In the 2000s, Titan Aerospace began development of such a vehicle specifically for the communications role, in this case as an internet relay.^[9]

Related Research Articles

Microwave is a form of electromagnetic radiation with wavelengths ranging from about one meter to one millimeter corresponding to frequencies between 300 MHz and 300 GHz respectively. Different sources define different frequency ranges as microwaves; the above broad definition includes both UHF and EHF bands. A more common definition in radio-frequency engineering is the range between 1 and 100 GHz. In all cases, microwaves include the entire SHF band at minimum. Frequencies in the microwave range are often referred to by their IEEE radar band designations: S, C, X, K_u, K, or K_a band, or by similar NATO or EU designations.

Beam-powered propulsion, also known as directed energy propulsion, is a class of aircraft or spacecraft propulsion that uses energy beamed to the spacecraft from a remote power plant to provide energy. The beam is typically either a microwave or a laser beam and it is either pulsed or continuous. A continuous beam lends itself to thermal rockets, photonic thrusters and light sails, whereas a pulsed beam lends itself to ablative thrusters and pulse detonation engines.

A Doppler radar is a specialized radar that uses the Doppler effect to produce velocity data about objects at a distance. It does this by bouncing a microwave signal off a desired target and analyzing how the object's motion has altered the frequency of the returned signal. This variation gives direct and highly accurate measurements of the radial component of a target's velocity relative to the radar.

A rectenna is a special type of receiving antenna that is used for converting electromagnetic energy into direct current (DC) electricity. They are used in wireless power transmission systems that transmit power by radio waves. A simple rectenna element consists of a dipole antenna with an RF diode connected across the dipole elements. The diode rectifies the AC induced in the antenna by the microwaves, to produce DC power, which powers a load connected across the diode. Schottky diodes are usually used because they have the lowest voltage drop and highest speed and therefore have the lowest power losses due to conduction and switching. Large rectennas consist of an array of many power receiving elements such as dipole antennas.

Wireless power transfer (WPT), wireless power transmission, wireless energy transmission (WET), or electromagnetic power transfer is the transmission of electrical energy without wires as a physical link. In a wireless power transmission system, a transmitter device, driven by electric power from a power source, generates a time-varying electromagnetic field, which transmits power across space to a receiver device, which extracts power from the field and supplies it to an electrical load. The technology of wireless power transmission can eliminate the use of the wires and batteries, thus increasing the mobility, convenience, and safety of an electronic device for all users. Wireless power transfer is useful to power electrical devices where interconnecting wires are inconvenient, hazardous, or are not possible.

The NASA Pathfinder and NASA Pathfinder Plus were the first two aircraft developed as part of an evolutionary series of solar- and fuel-cell-system-powered unmanned aerial vehicles. AeroVironment, Inc. developed the vehicles under NASA's Environmental Research Aircraft and Sensor Technology (ERAST) program. They were built to develop the technologies that would allow long-term, high-altitude aircraft to serve as atmospheric satellites, to perform atmospheric research tasks as well as serve as communications platforms. They were developed further into the NASA Centurion and NASA Helios aircraft.

AeroVironment, Inc. is an American defense contractor headquartered in Arlington, Virginia, that designs and manufactures unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). Dr. Paul B. MacCready Jr., a designer of human-powered aircraft, founded the company in 1971. The company is best known for its lightweight human-powered and solar-powered vehicles. The company is the US military's top supplier of small drones — notably the Raven, Switchblade, Wasp and Puma models.

UAVs include both autonomous drones and remotely piloted vehicles (RPVs). A UAV is capable of controlled, sustained level flight and is powered by a jet, reciprocating, or electric engine. In the twenty first century technology reached a point of sophistication that the UAV is now being given a greatly expanded role in many areas of aviation.

Airborne wind energy (AWE) is the direct use or generation of wind energy by the use of aerodynamic or aerostatic lift devices. AWE technology is able to harvest high altitude winds, in contrast to wind turbines, which use a rotor mounted on a tower.

Microwave transmission is the transmission of information by electromagnetic waves with wavelengths in the microwave range of the electromagnetic spectrum. Microwave signals are normally limited to the line-of-sight, so long-distance transmission using these signals requires a series of repeaters forming a microwave relay. It is possible to use microwave signals in over-the-horizon communications using tropospheric scatter, but such systems are expensive and generally used only in specialist roles.

James D. DeLaurier is an inventor and professor emeritus of the University of Toronto Institute for Aerospace Studies. He is a leader in design and analysis of lighter than air vehicles and flapping winged aircraft.

An electric aircraft is an aircraft powered by electricity, almost always via one or more electric motors which drive propellers. Electricity may be supplied by a variety of methods, the most common being batteries.

Space-based solar power is the concept of collecting solar power in outer space by solar power satellites (SPS) and distributing it to Earth. Sunlight is brighter outside the atmosphere, and can shine all the day. Space-based solar power systems convert sunlight to some other form of energy which can be transmitted through the atmosphere to receivers on the Earth's surface. It is attractive to those seeking large-scale solutions to anthropogenic climate change or fossil fuel depletion.

The Defense Satellite Communications System (DSCS) is a United States Space Force satellite constellation that provides the United States with military communications to support globally distributed military users. Beginning in 2007, DSCS is being replaced by the Wideband Global SATCOM system. A total of 14 DSCS-III satellites were launched between the early 1980s and 2003. Two satellites were launched aboard the Space Shuttle Atlantis in 1985 during the STS-51-J flight. As of 14 September 2021, six DSCS-III satellites were still operational. DSCS operations are currently run by the 4th Space Operations Squadron out of Schriever Space Force Base.

Radio is the technology of signaling and communicating using radio waves. Radio waves are electromagnetic waves of frequency between 30 hertz (Hz) and 300 gigahertz (GHz). They are generated by an electronic device called a transmitter connected to an antenna which radiates the waves, and received by another antenna connected to a radio receiver. Radio is very widely used in modern technology, in radio communication, radar, radio navigation, remote control, remote sensing, and other applications.

Atmospheric satellite or pseudo-satellite is a marketing term for an aircraft that operates in the atmosphere at high altitudes for extended periods of time, in order to provide services conventionally provided by an artificial satellite orbiting in space.

The Intelsat VI series of satellites were the 8th generation of geostationary communications satellites for the Intelsat Corporation. Designed and built by Hughes Aircraft Company (HAC) in 1983-1991, there were five VI-series satellites built: 601, 602, 603, 604, and 605.

An optical rectenna is a rectenna that works with visible or infrared light. A rectenna is a circuit containing an antenna and a diode, which turns electromagnetic waves into direct current electricity. While rectennas have long been used for radio waves or microwaves, an optical rectenna would operate the same way but with infrared or visible light, turning it into electricity.

SSETI Express was the first spacecraft to be designed and built by European students and was launched by the European Space Agency. SSETI Express is a small spacecraft, similar in size and shape to a washing machine. On board the student-built spacecraft were three CubeSat picosatellites, extremely small satellites weighing around one kg each. These were deployed one hour and forty minutes after launch. Twenty-one university groups, working from locations spread across Europe and with very different cultural backgrounds, worked together via the internet to jointly create the satellite. The expected lifetime of the mission was planned to be 2 months. SSETI Express encountered an unusually fast mission development: less than 18 months from kick-off in January 2004 to flight-readiness.

The Facebook Aquila is an experimental solar-powered drone developed by Facebook for use as an atmospheric satellite, intended to act as relay stations for providing internet access to remote areas. It first flew on 28 June 2016 with a second aircraft successfully flying in 2017. Internal development of the Aquila aircraft was stopped in June 2018.

References

Notes

↑ Sheldon Hochheiser, "William C. Brown: Biography", IEEE Global History Network, 29 August 2008
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 George Jull, "An Overview of SHARP", Friends of the CRC, July 1997
↑ William Brown, "Experimental Airborne Microwave Supported Platform, Final rept. Jun 1964-Apr 1965", RADC-TR-65-188, Rome Air Force Base, December 1965
↑ Matsumoto, pg. 7
1 2 Doug Payne, "Communications satellites come down to Earth", New Scientist, 26 May 1983, pg. 545
↑ Gregg Maryniak, "Status of international experimentation in wireless power transmission", Solar Energy, Volume 56 Issue 1 (January 1996), pg. 87-91
↑ Matsumoto, pg. 9
↑ Y. Fujino et al., "Dual Polarization Microwave Power Transmission System for Microwave Propelled Airship Experiment", Proceedings of ISAP '96, pg. 393-396
↑ "Google buys "atmospheric satellite" builder Titan Aerospace". Arstechnical. 14 April 2014.

Bibliography

Hiroshi Matsumoto, "Japanese Research for a Bright and Clean Energy from Space", Kyoto University, 2003