The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems

Last updated
The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems
TheAncientTraditionofGeometricProblemsKnorr.jpg
1993 edition cover
Author Wilbur Knorr
GenreMathematics
Publisher Birkhäuser
Publication date
1986

The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems is a book on ancient Greek mathematics, focusing on three problems now known to be impossible if one uses only the straightedge and compass constructions favored by the Greek mathematicians: squaring the circle, doubling the cube, and trisecting the angle. It was written by Wilbur Knorr (1945–1997), a historian of mathematics, and published in 1986 by Birkhäuser. Dover Publications reprinted it in 1993.

Contents

Topics

The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems studies the three classical problems of circle-squaring, cube-doubling, and angle trisection throughout the history of Greek mathematics, [1] [2] also considering several other problems studied by the Greeks in which a geometric object with certain properties is to be constructed, in many cases through transformations to other construction problems. [2] The study runs from Plato and the story of the Delian oracle to the second century BC, when Archimedes and Apollonius of Perga flourished; [1] [3] Knorr suggests that the decline in Greek geometry after that time represented a shift in interest to other topics in mathematics rather than a decline in mathematics as a whole. [3] Unlike the earlier work on this material by Thomas Heath, Knorr sticks to the source material as it is, reconstructing the motivation and lines of reasoning followed by the Greek mathematicians and their connections to each other, rather than adding justifications for the correctness of the constructions based on modern mathematical techniques. [4]

In modern times, the impossibility of solving the three classical problems by straightedge and compass, finally proven in the 19th century, [5] has often been viewed as analogous to the foundational crisis of mathematics of the early 20th century, in which David Hilbert's program of reducing mathematics to a system of axioms and calculational rules struggled against logical inconsistencies in its axiom systems, intuitionist rejection of formalism and dualism, and Gödel's incompleteness theorems showing that no such axiom system could formalize all mathematical truths and remain consistent. However, Knorr argues in The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems that this point of view is anachronistic, [1] and that the Greek mathematicians themselves were more interested in finding and classifying the mathematical tools that could solve these problems than they were in imposing artificial limitations on themselves and in the philosophical consequences of these limitations. [1] [2] [3] [4]

When a geometric construction problem does not admit a compass-and-straightedge solution, then either the constraints on the problem or on the solution techniques can be relaxed, and Knorr argues that the Greeks did both. Constructions described by the book include the solution by Menaechmus of doubling the cube by finding the intersection points of two conic sections, several neusis constructions involving fitting a segment of a given length between two points or curves, and the use of the Quadratrix of Hippias for trisecting angles and squaring circles. [5] Some specific theories on the authorship of Greek mathematics, put forward by the book, include the legitimacy of a letter on square-doubling from Eratosthenes to Ptolemy III Euergetes, [6] a distinction between Socratic-era sophist Hippias and the Hippias who invented the quadratrix, and a similar distinction between Aristaeus the Elder, a mathematician of the time of Euclid, and the Aristaeus who authored a book on solids (mentioned by Pappus of Alexandria), and whom Knorr places at the time of Apollonius. [4] [6]

The book is heavily illustrated, and many endnotes provide sources for quotations, additional discussion, and references to related research. [7]

Audience and reception

The book is written for a general audience, unlike a follow-up work published by Knorr, Textual Studies in Ancient and Medieval Geometry (1989), which is aimed at other experts in the close reading of Greek mathematical texts. [1] Nevertheless, reviewer Alan Stenger calls The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems "very specialized and scholarly". [7] Reviewer Colin R. Fletcher calls it "essential reading" for understanding the background and content of the Greek mathematical problem-solving tradition. [2] In its historical scholarship, historian of mathematics Tom Whiteside writes that the book's occasionally speculative nature is justified by its fresh interpretations, well-founded conjectures, and deep knowledge of the subject. [5]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Constructible number</span> Number constructible via compass and straightedge

In geometry and algebra, a real number is constructible if and only if, given a line segment of unit length, a line segment of length can be constructed with compass and straightedge in a finite number of steps. Equivalently, is constructible if and only if there is a closed-form expression for using only integers and the operations for addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and square roots.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Euclidean geometry</span> Mathematical model of the physical space

Euclidean geometry is a mathematical system attributed to ancient Greek mathematician Euclid, which he described in his textbook on geometry, Elements. Euclid's approach consists in assuming a small set of intuitively appealing axioms (postulates) and deducing many other propositions (theorems) from these. Although many of Euclid's results had been stated earlier, Euclid was the first to organize these propositions into a logical system in which each result is proved from axioms and previously proved theorems.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Straightedge and compass construction</span> Method of drawing geometric objects

In geometry, straightedge-and-compass construction – also known as ruler-and-compass construction, Euclidean construction, or classical construction – is the construction of lengths, angles, and other geometric figures using only an idealized ruler and a pair of compasses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Doubling the cube</span> Ancient geometric construction problem

Doubling the cube, also known as the Delian problem, is an ancient geometric problem. Given the edge of a cube, the problem requires the construction of the edge of a second cube whose volume is double that of the first. As with the related problems of squaring the circle and trisecting the angle, doubling the cube is now known to be impossible to construct by using only a compass and straightedge, but even in ancient times solutions were known that employed other methods.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Angle trisection</span> Construction of an angle equal to one third a given angle

Angle trisection is a classical problem of straightedge and compass construction of ancient Greek mathematics. It concerns construction of an angle equal to one third of a given arbitrary angle, using only two tools: an unmarked straightedge and a compass.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Squaring the circle</span> Problem of constructing equal-area shapes

Squaring the circle is a problem in geometry first proposed in Greek mathematics. It is the challenge of constructing a square with the area of a given circle by using only a finite number of steps with a compass and straightedge. The difficulty of the problem raised the question of whether specified axioms of Euclidean geometry concerning the existence of lines and circles implied the existence of such a square.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mathematics of paper folding</span> Overview of the mathematics of paper folding

The discipline of origami or paper folding has received a considerable amount of mathematical study. Fields of interest include a given paper model's flat-foldability, and the use of paper folds to solve mathematical equations up to the third order.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pappus of Alexandria</span> 4th century Greek mathematician

Pappus of Alexandria was a Greek mathematician of late antiquity known for his Synagoge (Συναγωγή) or Collection, and for Pappus's hexagon theorem in projective geometry. Almost nothing is known about his life except for what can be found in his own writings, many of which are lost. Pappus apparently lived in Alexandria, where he worked as a mathematics teacher to higher level students, one of whom was named Hermodorus.

In geometry, a quadratrix is a curve having ordinates which are a measure of the area of another curve. The two most famous curves of this class are those of Dinostratus and E. W. Tschirnhaus, which are both related to the circle.

In geometry, a trisectrix is a curve which can be used to trisect an arbitrary angle with ruler and compass and this curve as an additional tool. Such a method falls outside those allowed by compass and straightedge constructions, so they do not contradict the well known theorem which states that an arbitrary angle cannot be trisected with that type of construction. There is a variety of such curves and the methods used to construct an angle trisector differ according to the curve. Examples include:

Dinostratus was a Greek mathematician and geometer, and the brother of Menaechmus. He is known for using the quadratrix to solve the problem of squaring the circle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Neusis construction</span> Geometric construction used in Ancient Greek mathematics

In geometry, the neusis is a geometric construction method that was used in antiquity by Greek mathematicians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nicomedes (mathematician)</span> Ancient Greek mathematician (c. 280–210 BC)

Nicomedes was an ancient Greek mathematician.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Timeline of ancient Greek mathematicians</span>

This is a timeline of mathematicians in ancient Greece.

The following is a timeline of key developments of geometry:

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wilbur Knorr</span> American historian of mathematics (1945–1997)

Wilbur Richard Knorr was an American historian of mathematics and a professor in the departments of philosophy and classics at Stanford University. He has been called "one of the most profound and certainly the most provocative historian of Greek mathematics" of the 20th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quadratrix of Hippias</span> Curve where spinning and moving lines cross

The quadratrix or trisectrix of Hippias is a curve which is created by a uniform motion. It is one of the oldest examples for a kinematic curve. Its discovery is attributed to the Greek sophist Hippias of Elis, who used it around 420 BC in an attempt to solve the angle trisection problem. Later around 350 BC Dinostratus used it in an attempt to solve the problem of squaring the circle.

<i>Geometric Exercises in Paper Folding</i> 1893 book on making polygons with origami

Geometric Exercises in Paper Folding is a book on the mathematics of paper folding. It was written by Indian mathematician T. Sundara Row, first published in India in 1893, and later republished in many other editions. Its topics include paper constructions for regular polygons, symmetry, and algebraic curves. According to the historian of mathematics Michael Friedman, it became "one of the main engines of the popularization of folding as a mathematical activity".

Geometric Constructions is a mathematics textbook on constructible numbers, and more generally on using abstract algebra to model the sets of points that can be created through certain types of geometric construction, and using Galois theory to prove limits on the constructions that can be performed. It was written by George E. Martin, and published by Springer-Verlag in 1998 as volume 81 of their Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics book series.

Geometric Origami is a book on the mathematics of paper folding, focusing on the ability to simulate and extend classical straightedge and compass constructions using origami. It was written by Austrian mathematician Robert Geretschläger and published by Arbelos Publishing in 2008. The Basic Library List Committee of the Mathematical Association of America has suggested its inclusion in undergraduate mathematics libraries.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Drucker, Thomas (December 1991), "Review of The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems", Isis , 82 (4): 718–720, JSTOR   233339
  2. 1 2 3 4 Fletcher, C. R. (1988), "Review of The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems", Mathematical Reviews , MR   0884893
  3. 1 2 3 Neuenschwander, E., "Review of The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems", zbMATH (in German), Zbl   0588.01002
  4. 1 2 3 Caveing, Maurice (July–December 1991), "Review of The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems", Revue d'histoire des sciences (in French), 44 (3/4): 487–489, JSTOR   23632881
  5. 1 2 3 Whiteside, D. T. (September 1990), "Review of The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems", The British Journal for the History of Science , 23 (3): 373–375, JSTOR   4026791
  6. 1 2 Bulmer-Thomas, Ivor (1989), "Ancient geometry (review of The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems)", The Classical Review , New Series, 39 (2): 364–365, JSTOR   711650
  7. 1 2 Stenger, Allen (February 2013), "Review of The Ancient Tradition of Geometric Problems", MAA Reviews, Mathematical Association of America
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.