The Bomber Mafia

Last updated

The Bomber Mafia: A Dream, a Temptation, and the Longest Night of the Second World War
The Bomber Mafia.jpg
Hardcover edition
Author Malcolm Gladwell
LanguageEnglish
SubjectThe Bomber Mafia
GenreNon-fiction
Publisher Little, Brown and Company
Publication date
April 27, 2021
Publication placeUnited States
Media typeprint, audiobook, e-book
Pages256
ISBN 978-0-316-29661-8
OCLC 1232272458
Preceded by Talking to Strangers  
Followed by Revenge of the Tipping Point  

The Bomber Mafia: A Dream, a Temptation, and the Longest Night of the Second World War is a 2021 book by Malcolm Gladwell that examines the US Bomber Mafia of World War II, which advocated precision aerial bombing as a means to win a war. Gladwell stated the audiobook for The Bomber Mafia came about as an expansion of material from his podcast Revisionist History , and that the print book originated from the audiobook. The book follows the Bomber Mafia, especially Major General Haywood S. Hansell, and the development of a high-altitude precision aerial bombardment strategy in World War II as a means to limit casualties. After difficulties in applying the Bomber Mafia's theoretical strategy, Major General Hansell was replaced by Major General Curtis LeMay, who utilized tactical changes such as attacking Japanese population centers with napalm to ensure a Japanese surrender. Upon release, The Bomber Mafia was met with mixed reviews, with reviewers praising its audiobook version but criticizing the book for a lack of detail and factual accuracy.

Contents

Author

The author of the book is Malcolm Gladwell, an English-born Canadian journalist, author, and public speaker. [1] [2] [3] In 2016, Gladwell started Revisionist History , a history-focused podcast that "re-examines something from the past – an event, a person, an idea, even a song – and asks whether we got it right the first time". [4] He devoted four episodes of the fifth season of Revisionist History to air power in World War II, and stated the audiobook served as an expansion of material from the podcast. The Bomber Mafia began as an audiobook, and later transitioned into a print book. [5] [6]

Content

The book follows the story of the Bomber Mafia, a group of American military officers, especially Major General Haywood S. Hansell, as they developed a military doctrine of daylight strategic bombing as a means to defeat an enemy with precision high-altitude aerial bombardment. [7] This could lead to a minimum of war-time casualties with new technology such as the Norden bombsight. [8] In that regard, this was at odds with Britain's Royal Air Force' doctrine of area bombing under the command of Marshal of the Royal Air Force Sir Arthur Harris. [9]

When the United States entered World War II, the Bomber Mafia's doctrine proved of little military use and costly in implementation with the realities of current technology under real-world combat conditions. [10] This especially applied with the aerial bombardment of Japan where previously unaccounted atmospheric conditions such as the jet stream seriously interfered with operations under Hansell's command. [11] The book examines Hansell's replacement by Major General Curtis LeMay, [12] who implemented a series of tactical changes such as ordering bombing at a dramatically lower altitude to avoid the jet stream, removal of most of the bombers' defensive weaponry to increase bomb payload and wholesale nighttime fire bombing with incendiaries like napalm to devastate many of the population centers of Japan. [13] The result furthered the Allies' military objectives leading to Japan's surrender, such as with the Operation Meetinghouse bombing of Tokyo on March 10, 1945. [14]

After the 1991 Gulf War, David L. Goldfein states that by then bombs could hit, with precision, a specific wing of a building. [15] At the time the book was released, a modern B-2 Stealth Bomber could approach a target without being detected on radar from 40,000 feet in altitude. The book concludes that "LeMay won the battle. [...] Hansell won the war". [16]

Reception

The book was met with mixed reviews upon release, with two rave reviews, one positive review, four mixed reviews, and three pan reviews as of November 14,2021 according to review aggregator Book Marks. [17] In The Wall Street Journal , Yale professor Paul Kennedy praised the audiobook version of The Bomber Mafia as "remarkable" and a "work of art"; similarly, in The Times , reviewer Gerard DeGroot said "The Bomber Mafia remind[ed] [him] of a really good podcast – a fascinating story is appealingly delivered", and historian Diana Preston of The Washington Post called the audiobook "innovative" for its inclusion of archival clips, music, and sound effects. [18] [19] [20] James McConnachie of The Times stated "for a book that is not a war story, this one is brilliantly, brilliantly told". [21] In The New York Times Book Review , Thomas E. Ricks called the book "a conversational work" which he enjoyed, but noted that "when Gladwell leaps to provide superlative assessments, or draws broad lessons of history from isolated incidents, he makes me wary". [22] Writing for the Los Angeles Review of Books , professors David Fedman and Cary Karacas state "[a]s a piece of writing, The Bomber Mafia is engaging. As a work of history, it borders on reckless". [23]

Several reviewers criticized the book for its accuracy, and for being light on details. Kennedy stated there were "gaps in [Gladwell's] account", and cites the RAF Bomber Command's attempt at careful bombing as an example. [18] In The Daily Telegraph , military historian Saul David called the book "error prone" and "bedevilled by the same oversimplification of the world into a single Big Idea that is characteristic of his other work", and gave the book two out of five stars. [24] DeGroot said "the subject demands more depth than this volume provides", and stated Gladwell boiled down the bombing strategy's evolution to personality clashes between Hansell and LeMay while ignoring other major factors, such as how the morality and acceptance of bombing evolved. [19] Publishers Weekly stated "this history feels more tossed off than fully fledged", though Gladwell "provide[d] plenty of colorful details and pose[d] intriguing questions about the morality of warfare". [25] Professors Fedman and Karacas stated that errors "pile up to the point where it becomes clear that a book that has received so much attention ought to have received more fact-checking". [23]

Writing for The Baffler , Noah Kulwin criticized the book as "an attempt to retcon the history of American aerial warfare by arguing that developing the capacity to explode anything, anywhere in the world has made America and, indeed, the rest of the globe, unequivocally safer" and stated "by taking up military history, Gladwell's half-witted didacticism threatens to convince millions of people that the only solution to American butchery is to continue shelling out for sharper and larger knives." [26] Fedman and Karacas state "[w]ittingly or not, [Gladwell] omits or downplays evidence that undermines the very premise of the book. Hansell was not the moral opposite of LeMay. To frame the book in this simplistic binary is to misconstrue the doctrines of both precision and area bombing". [23]

A reviewer in Kirkus Reviews stated Gladwell "[delivered] a fairly flattering portrait of LeMay". [27] Ricks calls LeMay an "unexpected hero" of the story, [22] while McConnachie cites Hansell as Gladwell's hero. [21] The book debuted and peaked at number two on The New York Times Best Seller list for hardcover nonfiction on May 16, 2021. [28]

Notes

  1. Colville, Robert (December 17, 2008). "Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell – review" . The Daily Telegraph. Archived from the original on February 25, 2021.
  2. "Malcolm Gladwell (Journalist)". Faces of America. PBS. January 4, 2010. Archived from the original on January 24, 2021. Retrieved May 23, 2021.
  3. Zengerle, Jason (November 7, 2008). "Geek Pop Star". New York Magazine. Archived from the original on May 12, 2021.
  4. Hess, Amanda (December 15, 2017). "You Know Your History? These Podcasts Aren't So Sure" . The New York Times. Archived from the original on February 27, 2021.
  5. Gladwell 2021, p. 209
  6. "Presenting: The Bomber Mafia by Malcolm Gladwell". Revisionist History. April 27, 2021. Archived from the original on May 5, 2021. Those of you who are devoted Revisionist History listeners will remember that last season I did four episodes on the firebombing of Tokyo at the end of the Second World War... I've taken that little kernel from last season, and built an entirely new audiobook around it.
  7. Gladwell 2021, p. 37
  8. Gladwell 2021, p. 29
  9. Gladwell 2021, pp. 55–60
  10. Gladwell 2021, pp. 102–107
  11. Gladwell 2021, pp. 139–143
  12. Gladwell 2021, p. 167
  13. Gladwell 2021, pp. 170–173
  14. Gladwell 2021, pp. 180–184; 196–198
  15. Gladwell 2021, p. 204
  16. Gladwell 2021, p. 206
  17. "The Bomber Mafia: A Dream, a Temptation, and the Longest Night of the Second World War". Book Marks. Retrieved May 4, 2021.
  18. 1 2 Kennedy, Paul (April 30, 2021). "'The Bomber Mafia' Review: Architects of a Firestorm" . The Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original on May 21, 2021.
  19. 1 2 DeGroot, Gerard (April 22, 2021). "The Bomber Mafia by Malcolm Gladwell review – why 'precision bombing' is an utter delusion" . The Times. Archived from the original on May 17, 2021.
  20. Preston, Diana (April 23, 2021). "Wrestling with the strategy – and morality – of the firebombing of Japan". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on May 21, 2021.
  21. 1 2 McConnachie, James (April 18, 2021). "The Bomber Mafia by Malcolm Gladwell, review – the Outliers author on the morality of war" . The Times. Archived from the original on May 17, 2021.
  22. 1 2 Ricks, Thomas E. (April 25, 2021). "Malcolm Gladwell on the Hard Decisions of War" . The New York Times. Archived from the original on May 17, 2021.
  23. 1 2 3 Fedman, David; Karacas, Cary (June 12, 2021). "When Pop History Bombs: A Response to Malcolm Gladwell's Love Letter to American Air Power". Los Angeles Review of Books. Archived from the original on June 18, 2021.
  24. David, Saul (April 25, 2021). "Malcolm Gladwell's The Bomber Mafia is misleading history-lite" . The Daily Telegraph. Archived from the original on May 8, 2021.
  25. "The Bomber Mafia: A Dream, a Temptation, and the Longest Night of the Second World War". Publishers Weekly. Archived from the original on April 28, 2021.
  26. Kulwin, Noah (May 17, 2021). "Narrative Napalm". The Baffler. Archived from the original on May 21, 2021. Retrieved May 20, 2021.
  27. "The Bomber Mafia: A Dream, a Temptation, and the Longest Night of the Second World War". Kirkus Reviews. March 10, 2021. Archived from the original on May 6, 2021.
  28. "Hardcover Nonfiction – May 16, 2021". The New York Times. May 16, 2021. Archived from the original on May 21, 2021.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Strategic bombing</span> Systematic aerial attacks to destroy infrastructure and morale

Strategic bombing is a systematically organized and executed attack from the air which can utilize strategic bombers, long- or medium-range missiles, or nuclear-armed fighter-bomber aircraft to attack targets deemed vital to the enemy's war-making capability. It is a military strategy used in total war with the goal of defeating the enemy by destroying its morale, its economic ability to produce and transport materiel to the theatres of military operations, or both. The term terror bombing is used to describe the strategic bombing of civilian targets without military value, in the hope of damaging an enemy's morale.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Firebombing</span> Bombing technique

Firebombing is a bombing technique designed to damage a target, generally an urban area, through the use of fire, caused by incendiary devices, rather than from the blast effect of large bombs. In popular usage, any act in which an incendiary device is used to initiate a fire is often described as a "firebombing".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Malcolm Gladwell</span> Canadian journalist and science writer (born 1963)

Malcolm Timothy Gladwell is a Canadian journalist, author, and public speaker. He has been a staff writer for The New Yorker since 1996. He has published eight books. He is also the host of the podcast Revisionist History and co-founder of the podcast company Pushkin Industries.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jacob Weisberg</span> American political journalist (born 1964)

Jacob Weisberg is an American political journalist, who served as editor-in-chief of The Slate Group, a division of Graham Holdings Company. In September 2018, he left Slate to co-found Pushkin Industries, an audio content company, with Malcolm Gladwell. Weisberg was also a Newsweek columnist. He served as the editor of Slate magazine for six years before stepping down in June 2008. He is the son of Lois Weisberg, a Chicago social activist and municipal commissioner.

Precision bombing is the attempted aerial bombing of a target with some degree of accuracy, with the aim of maximising target damage or limiting collateral damage. Its strategic counterpart is carpet bombing. An example would be destroying a single building in a built up area causing minimal damage to the surroundings. Precision bombing was initially tried by both the Allied and Central Powers during World War I, however it was found to be ineffective because the technology did not allow for sufficient accuracy. Therefore, the air forces turned to area bombardment, which killed civilians. Since the War, the development and adoption of guided munitions has greatly increased the accuracy of aerial bombing. Because the accuracy achieved in bombing is dependent on the available technology, the "precision" of precision bombing is relative to the time period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carl Norden</span> Dutch-American engineer (1880–1965)

Carl Lucas Norden, born Carel Lucas van Norden, was a Dutch-American engineer who invented the Norden bombsight.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bombing of Nagoya</span> Air raids on Nagoya, Japan (1942–45)

The bombing of Nagoya by the United States Army Air Forces took place as part of the air raids on Japan during the closing months of the Pacific War in 1945.

The Air Corps Tactical School, also known as ACTS and "the Tactical School", was a military professional development school for officers of the United States Army Air Service and United States Army Air Corps, the first such school in the world. Created in 1920 at Langley Field, Virginia, it relocated to Maxwell Field, Alabama, in July 1931. Instruction at the school was suspended in 1940, anticipating the entry of the United States into World War II, and the school was dissolved shortly after. ACTS was replaced in November 1942 by the Army Air Force School of Applied Tactics.

Dan Carlin is an American podcaster and political commentator. Previously a professional radio host, Carlin hosts three popular independent podcasts: Hardcore History, Hardcore History: Addendum, and Common Sense, for which he received recognitions and awards, including best educational and history podcasts, and ranking among the best podcasts of all time. His first book was published in 2019, and he has been involved in a range of other media appearances and collaborations.

<i>The Tipping Point</i> 2000 book by Malcolm Gladwell

The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference is the debut book by Malcolm Gladwell, first published by Little, Brown in 2000. Gladwell defines a tipping point as "the moment of critical mass, the threshold, the boiling point." The book seeks to explain and describe the "mysterious" sociological changes that mark everyday life. As Gladwell states: "Ideas and products and messages and behaviors spread like viruses do." The examples of such changes in his book include the rise in popularity and sales of Hush Puppies shoes in the mid-1990s and the steep drop in New York City's crime rate after 1990.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Haywood S. Hansell</span> US Air Force major general, born 1903

Haywood Shepherd Hansell Jr. was an American general officer in the United States Army Air Forces (USAAF) during World War II, and later the United States Air Force. He became an advocate of the doctrine of strategic bombardment, and was one of the chief architects of the concept of daylight precision bombing that governed the use of airpower by the USAAF in the war.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bomber Mafia</span> Group of soldiers arguing that long-range bombers could win wars

The Bomber Mafia were a close-knit group of American military men who believed that long-range heavy bomber aircraft in large numbers were able to win a war. The derogatory term "Bomber Mafia" was used before and after World War II by those in the military who did not share their belief, and who were frustrated by the insistence of the men that the heavy bomber should take a primary position in planning and funding.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harold L. George</span> United States Air Force general, born 1893

Harold Lee George was an American aviation pioneer who helped shape and promote the concept of daylight precision bombing. An outspoken proponent of the industrial web theory, George taught at the Air Corps Tactical School and influenced a significant group of airmen passing through the school, ones who had powerful influence during and after World War II. He has been described as the leader of the Bomber Mafia, the men who advocated for an independent military arm composed of heavy bombers. George helped shape America's bomber strategy for the war by assisting Air War Plans Division with the development of a complete aircraft production and bombing strategy.

Industrial web theory is the military concept that an enemy's industrial power can be attacked at nodes of vulnerability, and thus the enemy's ability to wage a lengthy war can be severely limited, as well as his morale—his will to resist. The theory was formulated by American airmen at the Air Corps Tactical School (ACTS) in the 1930s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air War Plans Division</span> American military organization

The Air War Plans Division (AWPD) was an American military organization established to make long-term plans for war. Headed by Harold L. George, the unit was tasked in July 1941 to provide President Franklin D. Roosevelt with "overall production requirements required to defeat our potential enemies." The plans that were made at the AWPD eventually proved significant in the defeat of Nazi Germany.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1 November 1944 reconnaissance sortie over Japan</span> Sortie by US F-13 Superfortress aircraft

On 1 November 1944, a United States Army Air Forces (USAAF) F-13 Superfortress conducted the first flight by an Allied aircraft over the Tokyo region of Japan since the Doolittle Raid in April 1942. This photo reconnaissance sortie returned with 7000 photographs which helped with planning air raids on Japan during the last months of World War II. Attempts by Japanese air units and anti-aircraft gun batteries to shoot down the F-13 failed, as the available fighter aircraft and guns could not reach the high altitude at which it operated.

<i>Revisionist History</i> (podcast) Podcast by Malcolm Gladwell

Revisionist History is a podcast by Malcolm Gladwell produced by Gladwell's company Pushkin Industries. It began in 2016 and, as of 2024, has aired nine seasons.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bombing of Tokyo (10 March 1945)</span> Firebombing raid on Tokyo in the Pacific War

On the night of 9/10 March 1945, the United States Army Air Forces (USAAF) conducted a devastating firebombing raid on Tokyo, the Japanese capital city. This attack was code-named Operation Meetinghouse by the USAAF and is known as the Tokyo Great Air Raid in Japan. Bombs dropped from 279 Boeing B-29 Superfortress heavy bombers burned out much of eastern Tokyo. More than 90,000 and possibly over 100,000 Japanese people were killed, mostly civilians, and one million were left homeless, making it the most destructive single air attack in human history. The Japanese air and civil defenses proved largely inadequate; 14 American aircraft and 96 airmen were lost.

<i>Talking to Strangers</i> Non-fiction book by Malcolm Gladwell

Talking to Strangers: What We Should Know about the People We Don't Know is a nonfiction book written by Malcolm Gladwell and published by Little, Brown and Company on September 10, 2019. The audiobook version of the book follows Gladwell's Revisionist History podcast-style structure, using Gladwell's narration, interviews, sound bites, and the theme song "Hell You Talmbout".

Pushkin Industries is an American publisher of podcasts and audiobooks. It was co-founded in 2018 by Malcolm Gladwell and Jacob Weisberg. As of 2021, it hosts over 25 podcasts.

References