The Defence of Duffer's Drift

Last updated
The Defence of Duffer's Drift
The Defence of Duffer's Drift cover.jpg
Front cover, with the initials "B. F." [lower-alpha 1]
Author Ernest Dunlop Swinton, writing as "Backsight Forethought"
LanguageEnglish
GenreMilitary art and science
PublisherW. Clowes & Sons, London, reprinted from the United Service Magazine
Publication date
1904
Pages39
Map of Duffer's Drift, the Silliaasvogel River's only crossing. The defences are on the slopes of Waschout Hill to the south. Across the river to the north are Regret Table Mountain and the hillside farm of Incidentamba. Duffers Drift.JPG
Map of Duffer's Drift, the Silliaasvogel River's only crossing. The defences are on the slopes of Waschout Hill to the south. Across the river to the north are Regret Table Mountain and the hillside farm of Incidentamba.

The Defence of Duffer's Drift is a short 1904 book by the British Army officer Ernest Swinton. Lieutenant Backsight Forethought (BF) and his command of fifty men are given the task to defend Duffer's Drift, a natural ford to a river. A large force of Boers, unknown to BF, is moving toward his position. This scenario is played out six separate times, in six "dreams." In the early scenarios, BF and his British troops are ignominiously defeated. After each defeat, BF learns lessons and adapts his strategy for the later encounters. The later dreams end more inconclusively, and in the final dream, BF and his command successfully hold out long enough to be relieved. The book encourages critical thinking and careful use of position and terrain to mount a successful defence.

Contents

The book has been imitated many times, both for the British Army and for the US Army, and new adaptations continue to appear in the 21st century.

History

The Defence of Duffer's Drift was published in 1904 when Swinton was a field officer in the British Army. It appeared in the British United Service Magazine under the pseudonym, Lieutenant N. Backsight Forethought ("BF"), who is the narrator of the book. The book is an exploration of small unit tactics in a fictional encounter in the Second Boer War. Swinton was a captain of the Royal Engineers in South Africa during the Boer War, [2] [3] and the book "embodies some recollections of things actually done and undone in South Africa, 1899–1902." [4]

The Defence of Duffer's Drift was reprinted in the April 1905 edition of the Journal of the United States Infantry Association. The book, especially intended for young lieutenants, has become a military staple on small unit tactics, read far afield in places such as the United States, Russia, and Canada. [5] While some of the advice has become rather dated—notably, BF eventually decides to imprison all nearby locals, shoot any livestock that could be of aid to the enemy, and impress both Boer and black alike into building fortifications for his men, an "approach to the human terrain that would spell disaster" in modern times—the book is still considered relevant and interesting. [6]

Storyline

Lieutenant Backsight Forethought (BF to his friends) has been left in command of a 50-man reinforced platoon to hold Duffer's Drift, the only ford on the Silliassvogel River available to wheeled traffic. Here is his chance for fame and glory. He has passed his officer courses and special qualifications. "Now if they had given me a job, say like fighting the Battle of Waterloo, or Gettysburg, or Bull Run, I knew all about that, as I had crammed it up..." While BF's task appears simple enough the Boer enemy causes a multitude of problems, but the astute reader, with a sharp mind and quick intellect, will no doubt solve the problem before the first shot is fired. [7]

In his first two dreams, the British force is ambushed without much of a fight. Fortifications are not prepared and the sentries announce their locations, allowing the Boers to easily sneak up and defeat the sleepy British soldiers without resistance. In the third and fourth dreams, BF takes more proactive defensive preparations - digging trenches, arresting the local Boer civilians rather than attempting to trade or communicate with them, and impounding them and local black civilians for forced labour. While able to slow the Boers down some, poor placement of trenches, lack of supplies, obvious fortifications that the enemy can easily detect and plan around, and other problems hamper the British resistance. The fifth and sixth dreams are the most successful; in them, BF creates a spread-out and concealed force that greatly hampers and slows the enemy, even to the point of turning them back in the sixth dream, which allows for BF to obtain reinforcements.

Lessons learned

Title page, with pseudonymous byline "Backsight Forethought" Defence of Duffer's Drift by Backsight Forethought Title Page.jpg
Title page, with pseudonymous byline "Backsight Forethought"

The following are the lessons learned discussed in this book. [7]

  1. Do not put off taking measures of defence till the morrow, as these are more important than the comfort of the soldiers or the shipshape arrangement of the camp. Choose the position of the camp mainly with reference to defence.
  2. Do not in war-time show stray men of the enemy's breed all over the camp, be they never so kind and full of butter, and do not be hypnotised, by numerous "passes," at once to confide in them.
  3. Do not let sentries advertise their position to the whole world, including the enemy, by standing in the full glare of a fire, and making much noise every half-hour.
  4. Do not, if avoidable, be in tents when bullets are ripping through them; at such times a hole in the ground is worth many tents.
  5. With modern rifles, to guard a drift or locality does not necessitate sitting on top of it (as if it could be picked up and carried away), unless the locality is suitable to hold for other and defensive reasons. It may even be much better to take up defensive position some way from the spot, and so away from concealed ground, which enables the enemy to crawl up to very close range, concealed and unperceived, and to fire from cover which hides them even when shooting. It would be better, if possible, to have the enemy in the open, or to have what is called a clear "field of fire." A non-bullet-proof parapet or shelter which is visible serves merely to attract bullets instead of keeping them out—the proof of thickness can be easily and practically tested. When fired at by an enemy at close range from nearly all round, a low parapet and shallow trench are not of much use, as what bullets do not hit the defenders on one side hit those on another.
  6. It is not enough to keep strange men of the enemy's breed away from the actual defences, letting them go free to warn the enemy of their existence and whereabouts—even though they should not be under temptation to impart any knowledge they may have obtained. "Another way," as the cookery book says, more economical in lives, would be as follows: Gather and warmly greet a sufficiency of strangers. Stuff well with chestnuts as to the large force about to join you in a few hours; garnish with corroborative detail, and season according to taste with whiskey or tobacco. This will very likely be sufficient for the nearest commando. Probable cost—some heavy and glib lying, but no lives will be expended.
  7. It is not business to allow lazy black men (even though they be brothers and neutrals) to sit and pick their teeth outside their kraals whilst tired white men are breaking their hearts trying to do heavy labour in short time. It is more the duty of a Christian soldier to teach the dusky neutral the dignity of labour, and to keep him under guard, to prevent his going away to talk about it. [8] (This lesson has often been edited in later revisions to be merely "lazy men" rather than "lazy black men" or "dusky neutral", and "soldiers" rather than "white men.")
  8. When collecting the friendly stranger and his sons in order to prevent their taking information to the enemy, if you are wishful for a "surprise packet," do not forget also to gather his wife and his daughter, his manservant and his maidservant (who also have tongues), and his ox and his ass (which may possibly serve the enemy). Of course, if they are very numerous or very far off, this is impossible; only do not then hope to surprise the enemy.
  9. Do not forget that, if guns are going to be used against you, a shallow trench with a low parapet some way from it is worse than useless, even though the parapet be bulletproof ten times over. The trench gives the gunners an object to lay on, and gives no protection from shrapnel. Against well-aimed long-range artillery fire it would be better to scatter the defenders in the open hidden in grass and bushes, or behind stones or ant hills, than to keep them huddled in such a trench. With the defending soldiers scattered around, you can safely let the enemy fill the visible trench to the brim with shrapnel bullets.
  10. Though to stop a shrapnel bullet much less actual thickness of earth is necessary than to stop a rifle bullet, yet this earth must be in the right place. For protection you must be able to get right close under the cover. As narrow a trench as possible, with the sides and inside of the parapet as steep as they will stand, will give you the best chance. To hollow out the bottom of the trench sides to give extra room be even better, because the open top of the trench can be kept the less wide. The more like a mere slit the open top of the trench is, the fewer shrapnel bullets will get in.
  11. For a small isolated post and an active enemy, there are no flanks, no rear, or, to put it otherwise, it is front all round.
  12. Beware of being taken in reverse; take care, when placing and making defences, that when you are engaged in shooting the enemy to the front of the trench, his pal cannot sneak up and shoot you in the back.
  13. Beware of being enfiladed. It is nasty from one flank—far worse from both flanks.
  14. Do not position the trench near rising ground over which you cannot see, and which you cannot hold.
  15. Do not huddle all the defending soldiers together in a small trench like sheep in a pen. Give them air.
  16. As once before—cover from sight is of often worth more than cover from bullets. For close shooting from a non-concealed trench, head cover with loopholes is an advantage. This should be bulletproof and not be conspicuously on the top of the parapet, so as to draw fire, or it will be far more dangerous than having none.
  17. To surprise the enemy is a great advantage.
  18. If you wish to obtain this advantage, conceal the position. Though for promotion it may be sound to advertise the position, for defence it is not.
  19. To test the concealment or otherwise of a position, look at it from the enemy's point of view.
  20. Beware of convex hills and dead ground. Especially take care to have some place where the enemy must come under defensive fire. Choose the exact position of the firing trenches, with an eye at the level of the men who will eventually use them.
  21. A hill may not, after all, though it has "command," necessarily be the best place to hold.
  22. A conspicuous "bluff" trench may cause the enemy to waste much ammunition, and draw fire away from the actual defences.

Influence

Start of the prologue. The Defence of Duffer's Drift prologue. The book is attributed to a Lieutenant N. Backsight Forethought, otherwise known as Major General Sir Ernest Dunlop Swinton..jpg
Start of the prologue.

The Defence of Duffer's Drift's style of literary fiction has been copied by several authors, making this author an influence upon the writings of others. Some examples are provided below, including: a primer on World War I battalion level combined arms tactics incorporating new types of warfare (tanks, machine guns, and aviation), [9] a mechanized battalion level primer, a military combat service support example, one that is non-military related, and one adopting the parable to operations in Iraq. [10] [11] [12] [13]

The first example is Battle of Booby's Bluffs, originally published in 1921 by an Army officer under the pseudonym Major Single List. It is important for its "lessons-learned" examination of the new weapons introduced in the Great War (most notably tanks, machine guns and aeroplanes) and how these innovations required learning new combined arms tactics. In the style of Duffer's Drift, a hapless battalion commander faces a battle scenario in a series of six dreams. In the first dream, he makes so many mistakes as to prove catastrophic for him and his men. But he learns a few more things about tactics and leadership through each dream, until at last he leads his men to victory through the treacherous terrain of Booby's Bluffs. Included with the dreams are notations to real life mistakes made by American commanders during the War. [9]

Defense of Hill 781, written by James R. McDonough in 1988, deals with a somewhat larger combat element than Duffer's Drift, and having a slightly different reason for the "dreams". [10]

The Defense of Duffer's Drift Brigade Support Area was written by Staff Sergeants Reginald Scott and Steve Newman, along with Sergeants William Baucom, Rodney Weathers, and Louise Chee in the September 2001 edition of NCO Notes, number 01-2, from the Association of the United States Army (AUSA) Institute of Land Warfare. Instead of trying to teach infantry tactics, the authors of this story focused upon a supply company of a forward support battalion in an effort to teach units inside of a Brigade Support Area to become more effective in defensive operations during combat. [13]

The winter 2005 edition of the Canadian Army Journal contained the following praise:

The South African War (1899–1902) provided the next opportunity for literary fiction to play a role in future army concepts. The publication of The Defence of Duffer's Drift by Captain (later Major-General Sir) Ernest Swinton, KBE, CB, DSO, in 1905, was extremely well received and became required reading for many subsequent generations of young officers. Set at a river choke point on some generic veldt anywhere in the Transvaal, the story's main character, a young and energetic Lieutenant Backsight Forethought, has a series of nightmares in which he loses battle after battle against his Boer adversaries. After each dream, however, a series of lessons are highlighted, and each of these was incorporated into the next battle, which eventually leads Lieutenant Forethought to victory and relief in the final dream. Although written as a fictional tale, Swinton's aim was to teach tactical lessons as well as generate discussion and debate on the planning and execution of operations.

— Godefroy, Andrew B., Canadian Army Journal [14]

The Defense of Jisr Al Doreaa is a 2009 novella by two US Army captains, based on The Defence of Duffer's Drift, and meant to teach junior officers how to apply the basic principles of counter-insurgency. [11]

The Defense of Battle Position Duffer is a publication created by the Asymmetric Warfare Group and Johns Hopkins University in 2016 that covers how commanders may integrate the cyber domain with tactical operations at the brigade combat team level. It follows Colonel Backsight Forethought V, a student of the Army War College, in a similar series of dreams where his mission as a brigade commander in varying scenarios are hampered by more cyber-proficient enemy commanders. Eventually, after integrating a litany of lessons learned throughout previous dreams, he is able to finally defeat a determined enemy with minimal losses. [12]

Dominating Duffer's Domain is a 2017 report in the Duffer's Drift idiom meant to instruct U.S. Army information operations practitioners. [3]

Notes

  1. ↑ The box wrapped around the officer's legs is marked with the initials "BF", which could stand for the author's pseudonym "Backsight Forethought" as on the title page, but the label "BF First Class" could also be read as "Bloody Fool, First Class". [1]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sniper</span> Highly trained marksman

A sniper is a military/paramilitary marksman who engages targets from positions of concealment or at distances exceeding the target's detection capabilities. Snipers generally have specialized training and are equipped with high-precision rifles and high-magnification optics, and often also serve as scouts/observers feeding tactical information back to their units or command headquarters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Trench warfare</span> Land warfare involving static fortification of lines

Trench warfare is a type of land warfare using occupied lines largely comprising military trenches, in which combatants are well-protected from the enemy's small arms fire and are substantially sheltered from artillery. It became archetypically associated with World War I (1914–1918), when the Race to the Sea rapidly expanded trench use on the Western Front starting in September 1914.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of Port Hudson</span> Battle of the American Civil War

The siege of Port Hudson was the final engagement in the Union campaign to recapture the Mississippi River in the American Civil War. While Union General Ulysses Grant was besieging Vicksburg upriver, General Nathaniel Banks was ordered to capture the lower Mississippi Confederate stronghold of Port Hudson, Louisiana, to go to Grant's aid. When his assault failed, Banks settled into a 48-day siege, the longest in US military history up to that point. A second attack also failed, and it was only after the fall of Vicksburg that the Confederate commander, General Franklin Gardner, surrendered the port. The Union gained control of the river and navigation from the Gulf of Mexico through the Deep South and to the river's upper reaches.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Technology during World War I</span> Technology available in World War I

Technology during World War I (1914–1918) reflected a trend toward industrialism and the application of mass-production methods to weapons and to the technology of warfare in general. This trend began at least fifty years prior to World War I during the American Civil War of 1861–1865, and continued through many smaller conflicts in which soldiers and strategists tested new weapons.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Suppressive fire</span> Weapons fire that degrades the performance of an enemy force

In military science, suppressive fire is "fire that degrades the performance of an enemy force below the level needed to fulfill its mission". When used to protect exposed friendly troops advancing on the battlefield, it is commonly called covering fire. Suppression is usually only effective for the duration of the fire. It is one of three types of fire support, which is defined by NATO as "the application of fire, coordinated with the maneuver of forces, to destroy, neutralise or suppress the enemy".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Infiltration tactics</span> Infantry bypassing strongpoints

In warfare, infiltration tactics involve small independent light infantry forces advancing into enemy rear areas, bypassing enemy frontline strongpoints, possibly isolating them for attack by follow-up troops with heavier weapons. Soldiers take the initiative to identify enemy weak points and choose their own routes, targets, moments and methods of attack; this requires a high degree of skill and training, and can be supplemented by special equipment and weaponry to give them more local combat options.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Spion Kop</span> 1900 battle of the Second Boer War

The Battle of Spioen Kop was a military engagement between British forces and two Boer Republics, the South African Republic and the Orange Free State, during the campaign by the British to relieve the besieged city Ladysmith during the initial months of the Second Boer War. The battle was fought 23–24 January 1900 on the hilltop of Spioen Kop(1), about 38 km (24 mi) west-southwest of Ladysmith and resulted in a Boer victory.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stormtroopers (Imperial Germany)</span> German WWI shock troops

Stormtroopers were specialist infantry soldiers of the German Army. In the last years of World War I, Stoßtruppen were trained to use infiltration tactics – part of the Germans' improved method of attack on enemy trenches. The German Empire entered the war certain that the conflict would be won in the course of great military campaigns, thus relegating results obtained during individual clashes to the background; consequently the best officers, concentrated in the German General Staff, placed their attention on maneuver warfare and the rational exploitation of railways, rather than concentrating on the conduct of battles: this attitude gave a direct contribution to operational victories of Germany in Russia, Romania, Serbia and Italy, but it resulted in failure in the West. Thus the German officers on the Western Front found themselves in need of resolving the static situation caused by trench warfare on the battlefield.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James Henry Reynolds</span> Recipient of the Victoria Cross

Lieutenant-Colonel James Henry Reynolds VC, born Kingstown, County Dublin, Ireland was an Irish recipient of the Victoria Cross for his actions at the Battle of Rorke's Drift, the highest and most prestigious award for gallantry in the face of the enemy that can be awarded to British and Commonwealth forces. He was educated at Castleknock College and Trinity College, Dublin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stewart Loudoun-Shand</span> Recipient of the Victoria Cross

Major Stewart Walter Loudoun-Shand VC was a British recipient of the Victoria Cross (VC), the highest and most prestigious award for gallantry in the face of the enemy that can be awarded to British and Commonwealth forces. He was posthumously awarded the VC for his actions during an attack near the French village of Fricourt on the opening day of the Battle of the Somme.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Modder River</span> 1899 battle of the Second Boer War

The Battle of Modder River was an engagement in the Boer War, fought at Modder River, on 28 November 1899. A British column under Lord Methuen, that was attempting to relieve the besieged town of Kimberley, forced Boers under General Piet Cronjé to retreat to Magersfontein, but suffered heavy casualties altogether.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Infantry tactics</span> Foot-soldier combat methods

Infantry tactics are the combination of military concepts and methods used by infantry to achieve tactical objectives during combat. The role of the infantry on the battlefield is, typically, to close with and engage the enemy, and hold territorial objectives; infantry tactics are the means by which this is achieved. Infantry commonly makes up the largest proportion of an army's fighting strength, and consequently often suffers the heaviest casualties. Throughout history, infantrymen have sought to minimise their losses in both attack and defence through effective tactics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Battle of Magersfontein</span> 1899 battle of the Second Boer War

The Battle of Magersfontein was fought on 11 December 1899, at Magersfontein, near Kimberley, South Africa, on the borders of the Cape Colony and the independent republic of the Orange Free State. British forces under Lieutenant General Lord Methuen were advancing north along the railway line from the Cape to relieve the siege of Kimberley, but their path was blocked at Magersfontein by a Boer force that was entrenched in the surrounding hills. The British had already fought a series of battles with the Boers, most recently at Modder River, where the advance was temporarily halted.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ernest Swinton</span> British Army general, author (1868–1951)

Major-General Sir Ernest Dunlop Swinton, was a British Army officer who played a part in the development and adoption of the tank during the First World War. He was also a war correspondent and author of several short stories on military themes. He is credited, along with fellow officer Lieutenant-Colonel Walter Dally Jones, with having initiated the use of the word "tank" as a code-name for the first tracked, armoured fighting vehicles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Webster Anderson</span> United States Army Medal of Honor recipient

Webster Anderson was a United States Army soldier and a recipient of America's highest military decoration—the Medal of Honor—for his actions in the Vietnam War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barrage (artillery)</span> Artillery tactic

In military usage, a barrage is massed sustained artillery fire (shelling) aimed at a series of points along a line. In addition to attacking any enemy in the kill zone, a barrage intends to suppress enemy movements and deny access across that line of barrage. The impact points along the line may be 20–30 yards/meters apart, with the total line length of the barrage zone anything from a few hundred to several thousand yards/meters long. Barrages can consist of multiple such lines, usually about 100 yards/meters apart, with the barrage shifting from one line to the next over time, or several lines may be targeted simultaneously.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British Army during the First World War</span> History of the British Army during World War I

The British Army during the First World War fought the largest and most costly war in its long history. Unlike the French and German Armies, the British Army was made up exclusively of volunteers—as opposed to conscripts—at the beginning of the conflict. Furthermore, the British Army was considerably smaller than its French and German counterparts.

<i>Basic Battle Skills</i> British Army field training manual

Basic Battle Skills is a field training manual formerly issued to individual soldiers in the British Army.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Brenton Laurie</span>

George Brenton Laurie was a Nova Scotian army officer and author who distinguished himself in both the Boer War and the First World War. In the latter war, he was killed in the Battle of Neuve Chapelle. General Sir John Keir, K.C.B, said of him "I learnt to appreciate his value as a soldier and his many other sterling qualities. … His name remains one held in honour for all time."

References

  1. ↑ Hughes, Geoffrey (2015). An Encyclopedia of Swearing: The Social History of Oaths, Profanity, Foul Language, and Ethnic Slurs in the English-speaking World. Routledge. p. 3. ISBN   978-1-317-47678-8.
  2. ↑ "No. 27353". The London Gazette . 10 September 1901. p. 5935.
  3. 1 2 Paul, Christopher; Marcellino, William. "Dominating Duffer's Domain: Lessons for the U.S. Army Information Operations Practitioner" (PDF). RAND Corporation. Retrieved 24 September 2021.
  4. ↑ Swinton 1904, Preface (page 1).
  5. ↑ Godefroy, Andrew B. (Winter 2005). "Fictional Writing and the Canadian Army of the Future" (PDF). Canadian Army Journal. 8 (1). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2011-06-10. Retrieved 2008-08-17. The Defence of Duffer's Drift, archived from the original on 2008-08-14, retrieved 2008-08-17– via CGSC/CSI
  6. ↑ Fishel, John T. (15 March 2009), Review of The Defense of Jisr al-Doreaa, a book inspired by The Defence of Duffer's Drift quoted by publisher, University of Chicago Press, ISBN   978-0226080932, B.F.'s approach to his human terrain would have spelled disaster [in the Iraq War]
  7. 1 2 Combined Arms Research Library, book republication and brief review of Defense of Duffer's Drift, United States Command and General Staff College, U.S. Government Printing Office: 1991 - 554-001/42036.
  8. ↑ The Defence of Duffer's Drift pg. 21, for the original version.
  9. 1 2 List, Major Single (2016) [1921]. Battle of Booby's Bluffs. Silver Spring, Maryland: Dale Street Books. pp. 1–102. ISBN   978-1941656341.
  10. 1 2 McDonough, James (1993). The defense of Hill 781 : an allegory of modern mechanized combat. Novato, CA: Presidio. ISBN   978-0-89141-475-9. OCLC   40253813.
  11. 1 2 Burgoyne, Michael L.; Marckwardt, Albert J. (2009). "The Defense of Jisr Al Doreaa" (PDF). Small Wars Journal. University of Chicago Press. Retrieved 24 September 2021. See also publisher's page and book's page for multiple reviews.
  12. 1 2 Leonhard, Robert R. (2016). The Defense of Battle Position Duffer – Cyber-Enabled Maneuver in Multi-Domain Battle. The Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory and the Asymmetric Warfare Group, a National Training Center narrative.
  13. 1 2 Scott, Reginald (S/Sgt); Newman, Steve (S/Sgt); Baucom, William (Sgt); Weathers, Rodney (Sgt); Chee, Louise (Sgt (Promotable)) (September 2001). Lewis, Steve (Capt) (ed.). "The Defense of Duffer's Drift Brigade Support Area" (PDF). NCO Notes. AUSA's Institute of Land Warfare (1–2): 1–7. Retrieved 24 September 2021.
  14. ↑ "Fictional Writing and the Canadian Army of the Future". Canadian Army Journal. 8 (1): 93–94. Winter 2005.

Bibliography

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.