The Other Side of the Frontier

Last updated

The Other Side of the Frontier
The Other Side of the Frontier.jpg
First edition
Author Henry Reynolds
CountryAustralia
LanguageEnglish
Subject Australian history
Genre Non-fiction
Publisher James Cook University
Publication date
1981
Media typePrint (Hardcover)
Pages234 pp
ISBN 0-86840-892-1
OCLC 76032741
994.0049915 22
LC Class DU124.F57 R49 2006

The Other Side of the Frontier is a history book published in 1981 by Australian historian Henry Reynolds. It is a study of Aboriginal Australian resistance to the British settlement, or invasion, of Australia from 1788 onwards.

Contents

The book constituted the first comprehensive research on this topic, and had a profound impact on Australian historiography. The University of New South Wales Press, which later published the book in 2012, said it "profoundly changed the way in which we understand the history of relations between Indigenous Australians and European settlers. It has since become a classic of Australian history." [1] Robert Manne described it as "an important landmark", while Professor Cassandra Pybus of the University of Sydney [2] wrote of the book that "no one could doubt the magnitude of Henry Reynolds' achievement in profoundly changing the way we understand our past". [3] : dust jacket 

History and context

The Other Side of the Frontier is about the history of Indigenous Australian peoples, in particular Aboriginal Australians, after the commencement of a huge wave of immigration from 1788 onwards. Aboriginal people encountered cultures which were foreign to them. According to Reynolds, "over 750,000 Aboriginal people inhabited the island continent in 1788". [3] The arrival of settlers, who brought diseases, destroyed the immediate population of many Sydney tribes. For thousands of years before the European invasion, the land was populated by a number of Aboriginal tribes, although there was a widespread belief that the land was terra nullius , meaning "no one's land". Aboriginal people lived along the Sydney harbour foreshores [3] where they "fished and hunted the waters and hinterlands of the area, harvested good from the surrounding bush".[3] They were able to be independent and agreeable and did not need to travel away from their land, as their surroundings had everything they needed. They were able to trade between tribal groups and only moving across the land due to seasonal changes. Without any war between tribes, they were able to live happily, growing their customs, language and culture – "the heart of which was connection to the land". [3]

After James Cook arrived in 1770, the Aboriginal peoples' ancient way of life came to an end, as his job was to voyage to the Southern Continent and take possession of it - whether it was inhabited or not. He declared the land of New South Wales to be long to King George III of Great Britain and Ireland, disregarding the fact that the land was already inhabited by the Indigenous peoples. The subsequent wave of immigrants failed to understand the Aboriginal way of life, which was to live peacefully with the land and environment, utilising specially honed skills and knowledge which enabled them to use the land to extremely well. These Indigenous peoples had a proven sustainability over a long period of time for themselves. This was not understood by the British people, and food shortages soon became a problem. The large immigrant population depleted the fish by netting huge catches, reduced the kangaroo population with unsustainable hunting, cleared the land, and polluted the water. As a result, the Aboriginal people throughout the Sydney Basin were soon close to starvation.[ citation needed ]

Ben Kiernan, a director of the genocide studies program at Yale University, wrote that nineteenth-century Australia colonists mounted numerous disciplinary expeditions against the Aboriginal people in which they committed "hundreds of massacres". Kiernan claimed that in central Queensland 40% of the Indigenous population were killed, and that the Aboriginal people "were hunted like wild beasts, having lives for years in a state of absolute terror of white predators".[ citation needed ]

Overview

The most notable theme of the book is the analysis of Aboriginal resistance to the British at the time of the European settlement in Australia, which makes up about a third of The Other Side of the Frontier. [4] Reynolds gives a summary of Indigenous communities' first reactions to European settlers arriving in Australia. He examines the gradual transition of Indigenous communities' perception of European settlers, and the formation of areas of physical conflict. He analyses the transition from the initial curiosity Indigenous people had towards European settlers to warlike resistance. [5] According to historian Lyndall Ryan, the book is structured around three main themes: "a strong internationalism drawn from the United Nations Charter on Human Rights; that the ghost of racism underlies modern Australia; and Indigenous issues and justice should be at the center of public debate". [6]

The book recounts summaries of conditions in different areas of Indigenous life affected by colonial settlement. The first chapters include the most important accounts of Indigenous people’s reactions to European pastoral, urban, agricultural, and missionary activities. [7] [4] These significant activities make up the structure of Reynolds arguments regarding Aboriginal resistance to European settlement in Australia.

In following a loose chronological order, Reynolds revisits these key interactions between Indigenous people and European settlers, through which he provides evidence of Aboriginal resistance. [5] To document this, he draws upon archival information on the language developed by Indigenous people to address European settlers and their activities, highlighting the gradual transition from a use of Aboriginal words to newly invaded terms indicative of the fear and resistance. [4]

The book also covers new Aboriginal tools, strategies and resources that were part of Aboriginal reaction to European settlement. [5] Reynolds argues that there was not one homogeneous Aboriginal response to European settlement. The book covers Indigenous resistance in different parts of Australia and Tasmania highlighting the most significant differences and similarities amongst them. [5] [4]

Editions

The Other Side of the Frontier was first published by James Cook University in 1981 [7] This publication has been criticised for not having any illustrations and footnotes index, and there was criticism too for the failure of wide distribution of the book and making it readily available to the public, by failing to meet shipment the shipment criteria of public retailers. [4] In 1982, Penguin Books published the second edition of the book, with an edited introduction and different subheadings. [7]

Adaptations

Several documentaries and series have relied heavily on the book.

The ABC Television series Frontier, a three-part series on the development of European policy regarding Aboriginal people from mid 1780s to 1930s, draws heavily upon the historical facts Reynold’s present in his book. [8]

The 2012 docudrama film Mabo and a BBC documentary on the history of race also drew historical evidence and narrative from this book. [8]

The 2008 seven-part SBS Television historical series on Australian history through the eyes of First Nations people made by Rachel Perkins, First Australians , was also heavily based on the facts presented in Reynolds' book. [8]

Perkins' 2022 SBS Television series, The Australian Wars , also draws on Reynolds' work in this area. [9]

Reception

The Other side of the Frontier has been broadcast to the general public of Australia, since its first publication in 1981. [10] The book's accessible language and price makes it attainable to the general public. [8] It has also circulated in academic circles in seminars and talks given by Reynolds at universities [11] and his history lectures in Townsville University College until 1982. [6]

The book was ground-breaking in that it was the first major work by an historian to write Australian history from an Aboriginal perspective. [12] It has been recognised by leading Australian historians such as Lyndall Ryan, who said "In representing the Aborigines as displaced and dispossessed, he turned Australian history inside out rather than upside down". [6]

In addition, Reynolds has played a central role in the "history wars", [13] an ongoing debate amongst leading historians like Reynolds and Keith Windschuttle regarding the existence of a genocide during European settlement in Australia [13]

The Other side of the Frontier is also included in the History Extension curriculum of Australian high schools. [14]

In 1982, the book was awarded the Ernest Scott Historical Prize. [15]

Favourable

Reynolds is praised for discussing Aboriginal resistance and “shuttering the myth that Aboriginal people didn't fight for their land”. According to Australian historian and scholar McQueen,[ who? ] Reynolds' account of Aboriginal resistance to European settlement is a key counterpoint to the legal justification of Indigenous stolen land and rights. [4] Through the lens of European settlers, it is argued that the lack of Indigenous protection of their lands, furthers justifies European ownership.[ citation needed ]

The book has also been praised for Reynolds' historic methodology, with scholars like McQueen arguing that Reynolds achieved "the impossible" by documenting the response of pre-literate people. This was achieved mostly through a deep research of available historical archives as well as close contact with Indigenous communities and over ten years of research. [4] Reynolds' supporters, who generally share left-liberal views, considered Reynolds a pioneer of Australian revisionist history for having attempted to relate history from an Indigenous perspective. [16] Scholar Gray, states that this sets the Other Side of the Frontier apart from most historical books concerned with European settlement, which are in majority written from a colonial point of view. [5]

Barrier Dyster praises the book, stating that "No Australian course, no Australian student, no Australian home should be without a copy". [7]

Reviewing it for the Aboriginal Law Bulletin , John Terry wrote:

Reynolds' book presents important concepts in Australian history. It is an appreciation that the convicts, squatters, explorers, diggers, ticket-of-leave men and the like did not step onto a continent that was barren and uninhabited, but into a rich and complex world of another people who resisted the invasion, fought for their land, struggled to survive - and who continue to struggle for due recognition. These ideas have been familiar for some time of course, and attempts have been made to document them, but this is the first serious production by a competent historian. [17]

Negative

The Other Side of the Frontier has also received strong criticism about the historical alternative it offers. In particular Keith Windschuttle, the other main historian at the centre of the History Wars, disagrees that there ever was an Aboriginal frontier war, arguing that Reynolds had fabricated the evidences that he uses in his book. [14] [18] Other historical and political figures, like R. Firth and J. Howard, share a similar view. [8] This criticism is based mostly on different historical methodologies that are used to collect data supporting or disproving of the existence of the Australian frontier wars, mostly in regard to which sources are deemed reliable in their records of Indigenous people death toll.[ citation needed ]

Windschuttle has extensively spoken and written in response to The Other side of the Frontier, rejecting Reynolds' arguments and questioning his methodology. [16] He has argued that Reynolds has misinterpreted or misunderstood the original sources in his book, resulting in inaccurate claims. Windschuttle notes that the original sources Reynolds has used (which he does not reveal), have admitted guessing the death toll of Indigenous people with no clear knowledge of the actual numbers. [19]

In addition, Windschuttle also argues that Reynolds exaggerates the death toll of Indigenous people in his book, in order to support his claims about European settlement in Australia.Reynolds, as Windschuttle argues, achieves this by deliberately taking out of context historical sources, like British settlers' ones, to support his claims on Australian history. With regard to Reynolds' methodology of recording Indigenous people's death toll during European settlement, Windschuttle notes: [19]

The Other Side of the Frontier has also been criticised for the socio-political aftermath of the book. Nick Minchin, former Australian federal senator, argued that the book makes reconciliation in Australia "even harder to achieve", by discussing the genocide and hardship Indigenous communities' experiences during European settlement, which stands responsible for Indigenous peoples' generational trauma today. [8]

This fits into a wider narrative of criticism against Reynolds and his work, targeting his particularly dark and bloody presentation of Australian history. [16] It is for these reasons that the book has been characterised as unpatriotic by Windschuttle and other conservatives. [16]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aboriginal Tasmanians</span> Indigenous people of the Australian island state of Tasmania

The Aboriginal Tasmanians are the Aboriginal people of the Australian island of Tasmania, located south of the mainland. For much of the 20th century, the Tasmanian Aboriginal people were widely, and erroneously, thought of as being an extinct cultural and ethnic group that had been intentionally exterminated by white settlers. Contemporary figures (2016) for the number of people of Tasmanian Aboriginal descent vary according to the criteria used to determine this identity, ranging from 6,000 to over 23,000.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Black War</span> Period of violent conflict between British colonists and Aboriginal Australians in Tasmania

The Black War was a period of violent conflict between British colonists and Aboriginal Tasmanians in Tasmania from the mid-1820s to 1832. The conflict, fought largely as a guerrilla war by both sides, claimed the lives of 600 to 900 Aboriginal people and more than 200 British colonists. The near-destruction of the Aboriginal Tasmanians and the frequent incidence of mass killings have sparked debate among historians over whether the Black War should be defined as an act of genocide.

Keith Windschuttle is an Australian historian. He was appointed to the board of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation in 2006. He was editor of Quadrant from 2007 to 2015 when he became chair of the board and editor-in-chief. He was the publisher of Macleay Press, which operated from 1994 to 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Manne</span> Australian political scientist

Robert Michael Manne is an Emeritus Professor of politics and Vice-Chancellor's Fellow at La Trobe University, Melbourne, Australia. He is a leading Australian public intellectual.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pemulwuy</span> Aboriginal Australian political leader (born 1750)

Pemulwuy, was a Bidjigal warrior of the Dharug nation, born around 1750 in the area of Botany Bay in New South Wales, Australia. One of the most famous Aboriginal resistance fighters in the colonial era, he is noted for his resistance to European colonisation which began with the arrival of the First Fleet in January 1788.

Henry Reynolds is an Australian historian whose primary work has focused on the frontier conflict between European settlers in Australia and Indigenous Australians. He was the first academic historian to advocate for Indigenous land rights, becoming known with his first major work, The Other Side of the Frontier (1981).

The history of Australia from 1788 to 1850 covers the early British colonial period of Australia's history. This started with the arrival in 1788 of the First Fleet of British ships at Port Jackson on the lands of the Eora, and the establishment of the penal colony of New South Wales as part of the British Empire. It further covers the European scientific exploration of the continent and the establishment of the other Australian colonies that make up the modern states of Australia.

The history wars is a term used in Australia to describe the public debate about the interpretation of the history of the European colonisation of Australia and the development of contemporary Australian society, particularly with regard to their impact on Aboriginal Australian and Torres Strait Islander peoples. The term "history wars" emerged in the late 1990s during the term of the Howard government, and despite efforts by some of Howard's successors, the debate is ongoing, notably reignited in 2016 and 2020.

The Kalkadoon are descendants of an Indigenous Australian tribe living in the Mount Isa region of Queensland. Their ancestral tribe has been called "the elite of the Aboriginal warriors of Queensland". In 1884 they were massacred at "Battle Mountain" by settlers and police.

Lyndall Ryan, is an Australian academic and historian. She has held positions in Australian studies and women's studies at Griffith University and Flinders University and was the foundation professor of Australian studies and head of the School of Humanities at the University of Newcastle from 1998 to 2005. She is currently a conjoint professor in the Centre for the History of Violence at the University of Newcastle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Musquito</span> Indigenous Australian bushranger and resistance leader

Musquito was an Indigenous Australian resistance leader, convict hunter and outlaw based firstly in the Sydney region of the British colony of New South Wales and later in Van Diemen's Land.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Indigenous Australians</span>

The history of Indigenous Australians began at least 65,000 years ago when humans first populated the Australian continental landmasses. This article covers the history of Aboriginal Australian and Torres Strait Islander peoples, two broadly defined groups which each include other sub-groups defined by language and culture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Australian frontier wars</span> 1788–1934 conflicts between settlers and Indigenous Australians

The Australian frontier wars were the violent conflicts between Indigenous Australians and primarily British settlers during the colonial period of Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tunnerminnerwait</span> Aboriginal Australian leader and resistance fighter in Tasmania (c.1812–1842)

Tunnerminnerwait (c.1812–1842) was an Australian Aboriginal resistance fighter and Parperloihener clansman from Tasmania. He was also known by several other names including Pevay, Jack of Cape Grim, Tunninerpareway and renamed Jack Napoleon Tarraparrura by George Robinson.

Margaret Susan "Peggy" Brock was an Australian historian and writer. Her major areas of interest were colonial and Indigenous history in Australia, the Pacific and parts of Canada and Africa, with particular interest in Australian Aboriginal women. Her work continues to be cited in national and international debates over Indigenous policy. Born in Adelaide, she took up academic positions and was at the end of her career emeritus professor at Edith Cowan University in Perth, Western Australia.

<i>Forgotten War</i> (book) 2013 book by Henry Reynolds concerning the Australian frontier wars

Forgotten War is a 2013 book by Australian historian Henry Reynolds concerning the Australian frontier wars, a conflict between the British Empire and settlers on one side and Indigenous Australians on the other.

<i>Dark Emu</i> Australian non-fiction book about Indigenous Australian history

Dark Emu: Black Seeds: Agriculture or Accident? is a 2014 non-fiction book by Bruce Pascoe. It re-examines colonial accounts of Aboriginal people in Australia, and cites evidence of pre-colonial agriculture, engineering and building construction by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. A second edition, published under the title Dark Emu: Aboriginal Australia and the Birth of Agriculture was published in mid-2018, and a version of the book for younger readers, entitled Young Dark Emu: A Truer History, was published in 2019.

Peter John Read is an Australian historian specialising in the history of Indigenous Australians. Read worked as a teacher and civil servant before co-founding Link-Up. Link-Up was an organisation that reunited aboriginal families who had undergone forcible separation of children from their families through government intervention. Read coined the term "Stolen Generations" to refer to the children subject to these interventions in a 1981 study. After graduating with a doctorate, Read worked as an academic for the rest of his career primarily working on Australian Indigenous history. He has also published work on the relationship between non-indigenous Australians and the land. In 2019, Read was made a Member of the Order of Australia for his work on Indigenous history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Genocide of Indigenous Australians</span>

The genocide of Indigenous Australians refers to the systematic and deliberate actions taken primarily by European settlers, particularly during the 18th to the 20th centuries, aimed at eradicating Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures, languages, and people. Motivations for the genocide varied, and included motivations aimed at preserving a 'white Australia', or assimilating Indigenous populations 'for their own good'.

References

  1. ↑ UNSW Press website
  2. ↑ Professor Cassandra Pybus, University of Sydney, Department of History]
  3. 1 2 3 4 Reynolds, Henry; James Cook University of North Queensland (1981), The Other Side of the Frontier, James Cook University, ISBN   978-0-86443-024-3
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 McQueen, Humphrey (2014). "Review Other side of the Frontier". Honest History.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 Gray, L (2008). "The Other Side of the Frontier: Aboriginal Resistance to the European Invasion of Australia [Book Review]". Colloquy: 283–286.
  6. 1 2 3 Ryan, Lyndall (2008). "Race, Nation, History: A Conference in Honour of Henry Reynolds, Canberra, 29-30 August 2008". Labour History (95): 247–249. doi:10.2307/27516321. ISSN   0023-6942. JSTOR   27516321.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Dyster, Barrie (1 January 1985). "Henry Reynolds, The Other Side of the Frontier: Aboriginal resistance to the European invasion of Australia (Ringwood, Penguin, 1982), pp. xii + 255: $6.95". Australian Economic History Review. 25 (2): 163–164. doi:10.1111/aehr.252br5. ISSN   0004-8992.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 McKenna, M (2009). "Silence shatter with a whispear". The Australian Literary Review.
  9. ↑ IN FULL: Rachel Perkins & Professor Henry Reynolds' Address to the National Press Club of Australia on YouTube (Address 23 November 2022; published on YouTube 15 September 2023.
  10. ↑ Backett, L (2016). "The Function of 'the tragic' in Henry Reynolds' Narratives of Contact History". Queensland Review. 3: 62–72. doi:10.1017/S1321816600000684.
  11. ↑ "HPRC School: Special History Seminar by Professor Henry Reynolds and Professor Marilyn Lake on 'Locating Australia in the World' - UQ Events, The University of Queensland". www.uq.edu.au. Retrieved 2 June 2021.
  12. ↑ "In Conversation with Henry Reynolds". Events - University of Tasmania, Australia. 2021. Retrieved 28 November 2023.
  13. 1 2 Hirst, J (2006). "In the Middle of the History Wars". The Sydney Papers. 18: 50–58.
  14. 1 2 Steward, R (2019). "History extension: Resources for teaching the frontier in Australia case study; the responses of Aboriginal people(s) on the frontier in Australia". Teaching History. 53: 16–18.
  15. ↑ "Papers of Henry Reynolds", National Library of Australia
  16. 1 2 3 4 David, R (2007). "Myths, Truths and Arguments: Some Recent Writings on Aboriginal History". Australian Journal of Politics & History. 53: 138–148. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8497.2007.00447.x.
  17. ↑ John Terry, "Book Review - The Other Side of the Frontier: An Interpretation of the Aboriginal Response to the Invasion and Settlement of Australia", Aboriginal Law Bulletin
  18. ↑ Windschuttle, K. (2003). The Fabrication of Aboriginal History: Van Diemen's Land, 1803-1847. Macleay Press. ISBN   978-1-876492-05-2 . Retrieved 28 November 2023.
  19. 1 2 Windschuttle, K (2000). "The Myths of Frontier Massacres in Australia History". Quaadrat, Gale Academic OneFIle. 44: 17–23.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.