Trial of Matthew McKnight

Last updated
R v. McKnight
Royal Cypher of Queen Elizabeth II.svg
Case number 161396254Q3
Court Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta in Edmonton, Alberta
Full case nameHer Majesty The Queen v. Matthew McKnight
DecidedJanuary 16, 2020 (2020-01-16)
VerdictGuilty on five counts
Court membership
Judge sittingHon. Doreen A. Sulyma, Q.C. sitting with a Jury
Case opinions
Decision byJury Verdict: Guilty on five counts

Her Majesty The Queen v. Matthew McKnight was a criminal prosecution of Matthew McKnight on thirteen charges of sexual assault between 2010 and 2016. [1]

Contents

On 10 August 2016, Matthew McKnight was charged with two counts of sexual assault, one count of sexual assault causing bodily harm, and one count of unlawful confinement. [2] Following a public statement from the Edmonton Police Service, more complainants emerged. On 16 January 2020, McKnight was found guilty on five of thirteen counts of sexual assault. The case drew considerable public attention in Canada due to the fact that McKnight was a prominent entrepreneur and promoter at several nightlife establishments in the City of Edmonton including Oil City Roadhouse and the Old Strathcona Rack. [3] The Globe and Mail referred to the trial as "the first major Canadian case of the #MeToo era." [4]

Prosecution attorneys

R v. Matthew McKnight was prosecuted by Mark Huyser-Wierenga and Katherine Fraser. [5] The Globe and Mail described Huyser-Wierenga as "one of the city’s most senior Crown prosecutors" and Fraser as "a young lawyer with an interest in sexual-assault prosecutions." [4] Mark Huyser-Wierenga was called to the Bar of Alberta in 1989 and has worked the majority of his career in the Family Protection Unit within the Edmonton Crown Prosecutors’ Office, primarily prosecuting cases involving adult victims of domestic violence and child victims of sexual abuse. [6] [7] The Globe and Mail stated that "although Huyser-Wierenga was an experienced lawyer, the McKnight trial would be one of the largest and most complex of his career." [4]

Defence attorneys

Lawyers Dino Bottos and Peter Sankoff defended the accused. The Globe and Mail referred to Bottos as "a prominent defence lawyer who’d been involved in a number of controversial and high-profile cases, including representing Bradley Barton in the death of Cindy Gladue in 2011." [4]

Judge

The Honourable Doreen A. Sulyma was selected as judge. Sulyma graduated from the University of Alberta Faculty of Law in 1975. [8]

Pre-trial

On 15 August 2016, McKnight was released from the Edmonton provincial law courts on $20,000 bail with conditions that he was to stay home from 21:00h each night until 7:00h the following morning. Additionally McKnight was prohibited from frequenting any businesses that serve alcohol and he was to regularly meet with an assigned police officer.

Initially there were 26 charges of sexual and physical assault from 21 different victims; however, some of the complainants decided they did not want to continue legal proceedings, and there were other charges on which the Crown decided not to proceed. Additionally, the Globe and Mail stated that "one woman couldn’t be located, and two cases would be heard separately." [4] Thus McKnight was only tried on 13 of the original 26 charges.

Jury selection

The trial of Matthew McKnight initially had a jury of 12 jurors; however, in the Globe and Mail, Jana G. Pruden wrote that "by the time closing arguments began in January, the McKnight trial had gone more than a month longer than planned, and the jury was down to 10. Losing another juror could put the case in serious jeopardy and even cause a mistrial." [4]

Prosecution's case

The prosecution questioned the accuracy of McKnight's memory; McKnight vividly described minute details of events that had taken place sometimes more than half a decade prior. Additionally, the Crown asked how McKnight could have "been struck by lightning 13 times," employing a metaphor for the 13 complainants. The Globe and Mail summarized that "the women didn’t know each other and had no connection to McKnight or any apparent reason to make up accusations about him. Many immediately told friends, family or boyfriends, and some searched for information about date-rape drugs, called the police or initiated sexual-assault examinations in the hours and days after leaving his apartment, even if they ultimately decided not to proceed." [4]

Defence's case

The Globe and Mail wrote that defence lawyer Dino Bottos "went over and over how many drinks [the complainants] had, what they said or didn’t say in earlier statements, questioning every detail they recalled and didn’t. He asked them about their lives, their bodies, even whether it was possible they showed signs of arousal that McKnight could have construed as consent. He zeroed in on gaps in their memories and inconsistencies in their stories, pulling at each detail and thread, picking at small holes until they gaped and glared." [4]

Expert witness testimony

Expert witnesses were called by the Crown including RCMP toxicologist Gillian Sayer and multiple sexual-assault nurse examiners. Sayer testified about the effects of the date rape drug GHB, specifically discussing memory loss, blackouts, and physical impairment.

Closing arguments

In a longform piece in the Globe and Mail, Jana G. Pruden stated that the Crown's closing arguments "urged the jury to believe the women. Any inconsistencies or lapses in memory, they said, were entirely consistent with people who had experienced trauma and who were drinking and, in some cases, drugged. They argued the detailed and impeccable recollections of McKnight and his friends were not believable and were fabricated around the women’s testimony at the preliminary hearing." In contrast, the defence stated "went again through each allegation in minute detail. He argued a woman who had been telling people in the bar scene that McKnight drugged and raped women had become “patient zero” in a dangerous rumour, which exploded in the #MeToo environment, fuelled by gossip, social-media mobs and a shoddy police investigation. He said the announcement of the first three charges established McKnight as a threat and that the women who came forward after that were either lying or recasting their experiences, having 'buyer’s remorse' about an encounter with a man now publicly accused of being a predator."

Jury instructions

Jana G. Pruden reported that the jury was instructed on "myths and stereotypes around sexual assault," and told that "factors such as how someone was dressed and what they did or didn’t do after the assault are no longer acceptable ways to discredit someone. It is to be accepted that there’s no one way a 'real victim' would act." [4]

Jury verdict

The jury found Matthew McKnight guilty of five charges and not guilty of the other eight charges.

Sentencing

Matthew McKnight’s sentencing hearing began on 8 July 2020. The crown sought 22.5 years in jail. The defence presented their argument the week of 12 July 2020 arguing for five to nine years in jail. [9] On 31 July 2020 McKnight was sentenced to eight years in jail. [10] [11]

Public response

Edmonton Journal reporter Jonny Wakefield stated that "McKnight's case was Edmonton's highest-profile sexual assault trial of the Me Too era." [12] Following the announcement of the guilty verdict, communication scientist Kristen Hedley responded via Twitter, asking "Am I missing something? Why hasn't anyone in the #yegmedia asked Urban Sparq Hospitality to make a comment re: Matthew McKnight's guilty verdict? Don't tell me that a culture of complicity wasn't a factor in the number of women impacted by this case." [13]

In July 2020, the Globe and Mail's Jana G. Pruden called the trial of Matthew McKnight "the first major Canadian case of the #MeToo era" and John Doyle referred to Pruden's profile of the case as a "must read... superb." [4] [14]

See also

Related Research Articles

Gerald Augustine Paul Regan was a Canadian politician, who served as the 19th premier of Nova Scotia from 1970 to 1978.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jacob Hoggard</span> Canadian singer-songwriter (born 1984)

Jacob William Hoggard is a Canadian former musician who was the lead singer for the pop-rock band Hedley. Before Hedley was formed, Hoggard competed on the second season of Canadian Idol in 2004 when he placed third.

Timothy Gregg Bachman was a Canadian guitarist and vocalist best known for his work with rock bands Brave Belt and Bachman–Turner Overdrive (BTO). Bachman was one of the four founding members of BTO, a group that have sold nearly 30 million albums worldwide and also featured his brothers Randy (guitar/vocals) and Robbie (drums), as well as Fred Turner (bass/vocals).

Johnson Aziga is a Ugandan-born Canadian man formerly residing in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, notable as the first person to be charged and convicted of first-degree murder in Canada for spreading HIV, after two women whom he had infected without their knowledge died.

A rape shield law is a law that limits the ability to introduce evidence about the past sexual activity of a complainant in a sexual assault trial, or that limits cross-examination of complainants about their past sexual behaviour in sexual assault cases. The term also refers to a law that prohibits the publication of the identity of a complainant in a sexual assault case.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Pickton</span> Canadian serial killer

Robert William Pickton, also known as the Pig Farmer Killer or the Butcher, is a Canadian serial killer, serial rapist, former pig farmer and possible cannibal who is suspected of being one of the most prolific serial killers in Canadian history. After dropping out of school, Pickton left a butcher's apprenticeship to begin working full-time at his family's pig farm. He is believed to have begun his murders in the early 1990s after inheriting the farm. Arrested in 2002, he was convicted in 2007 of the second-degree murders of six women and was also the subject of a lengthy investigation that yielded evidence of numerous other murders.

Carl Desmond Leone is a Canadian businessman from Windsor, Ontario. Leone was jailed after pleading guilty in a Windsor court to 15 counts of aggravated sexual assault for not informing his sexual partners of his positive HIV status. It is believed he has been charged with exposing more women to the AIDS-causing virus than anyone in Canadian history. Two of his victims have attempted suicide.

Arthur Allan Thomas is a New Zealand man who was granted a Royal Pardon and compensation after being wrongfully convicted of the murders of Harvey and Jeannette Crewe in June 1970. Thomas was married and farming a property in the Pukekawa district, south of Auckland before the case. Following the revelation that the crucial evidence against him had been faked, Thomas was pardoned in 1979 and awarded NZ$950,000 in compensation for his 9 years in prison and loss of earnings.

Catholic Church sexual abuse cases in Canada are well documented dating back to the 1960s. The preponderance of criminal cases with Canadian Catholic dioceses named as defendants that have surfaced since the 1980s strongly indicate that these cases were far more widespread than previously believed. While recent media reports have centred on Newfoundland dioceses, there have been reported cases—tested in court with criminal convictions—in almost all Canadian provinces. Sexual assault is the act of an individual touching another individual sexually and/or committing sexual activities forcefully and/or without the other person's consent. The phrase Catholic sexual abuse cases refers to acts of sexual abuse, typically child sexual abuse, by members of authority in the Catholic church, such as priests. Such cases have been occurring sporadically since the 11th century in Catholic churches around the world. This article summarizes some of the most notable Catholic sexual abuse cases in Canadian provinces.

Kathryn Borel is a Canadian writer, editor and radio producer. She was a founding producer of the CBC Radio One show Q. Borel is the author of Corked: A Memoir (2009).

Aubrey Levin is a South African-born Canadian psychiatrist and former Colonel in the South African Defence Force who used abusive procedures on homosexual army conscripts and conscientious objectors in an attempt to cure them of suspected same-sex attraction in apartheid era South Africa.

<i>R v Evans and McDonald</i>

R v Evans and McDonald was the prosecution of two footballers, Ched Evans and Clayton McDonald, who were accused of the rape of a woman. On 20 April 2012, Evans was convicted and sentenced to five years imprisonment. McDonald was acquitted. Several people were later fined after naming the woman on Twitter and other social media websites.

Massimo 'Max' Sica is a convicted triple murderer, having been found guilty of killing his former girlfriend Neelma Singh, and her siblings Kunal and Sidhi in April 2003. Sica is from an Italian family. Prior to the murders, he had numerous criminal convictions, including unlawful possession of a firearm and arson.

Marie Therese Henein, KC is a Canadian criminal defence lawyer. She is a partner of Henein Hutchison Robitaille LLP, a law firm in Toronto.

Ivan William Mervin Henry is a Canadian man who was wrongly convicted on ten counts of sexual assault. He was sentenced to an indeterminate period in prison and ultimately spent 27 years in jail before his conviction was quashed.

In late 2014, Canadian radio host Jian Ghomeshi was arrested and charged with four counts of sexual assault, and one count of overcoming resistance by choking, in relation to three complainants. He was charged with three additional counts related to three more women on January 8, 2015. On October 1, 2015, Ghomeshi pleaded not guilty to one count of choking and four counts of sexual assault. The trial began on February 1, 2016. He was acquitted of all five charges on March 24, 2016.

A child sexual abuse scandal involving the abuse of young players at football clubs in the United Kingdom began in mid-November 2016. The revelations began when former professional footballers waived their rights to anonymity and talked publicly about being abused by former coaches and scouts in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s. This led to a surge of further allegations, as well as allegations that some clubs had covered them up.

<i>HM Advocate v Salmond</i> Criminal prosecution of Alex Salmond, former First Minister of Scotland

Her Majesty's Advocate v Alexander Elliot Anderson Salmond was the 2020 criminal prosecution of Alex Salmond, the former First Minister of Scotland. Salmond faced 14 charges, mostly of sexual assault. The trial began on 9 March 2020 at the High Court in Edinburgh and concluded on 23 March 2020 with the jury acquitting him of all charges.

Mark Huyser-Wierenga is a Canadian lawyer, currently a Crown Prosecutor for the Province of Alberta.

The Royal Newfoundland Constabulary sexual abuse scandal occurred in 2014 and concerned allegations of assault by Constable Doug Snelgrove.

References

  1. ↑ "Matthew McKnight: Jury finds former nightclub worker guilty on multiple counts of sexual assault". Edmonton Journal. Retrieved 2020-06-12.
  2. ↑ "More sexual assault charges laid against Edmonton man". Edmonton. 2016-09-28. Retrieved 2020-07-05.
  3. ↑ "Edmonton night club promoter guilty on five counts of sexual assault, acquitted on eight others" . Retrieved 2020-06-12.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 "He said, they said: inside the trial of Matthew McKnight". The Globe and Mail. 4 July 2020. Retrieved 2020-07-05.
  5. ↑ Huncar, Andrea (October 2, 2019). "Edmonton bar promoter pleads not guilty to multiple sex assaults". CBC News.
  6. ↑ "Mark A. Huyser-Wierenga - Canadian Law List - Listing Detail". www.canadianlawlist.com. Retrieved 2020-06-15.
  7. ↑ The Federal/Provincial/Territorial Elder Abuse Working Forum (PDF). Vancouver, British Columbia: The Safety and Security for Seniors Working Group. 2007. p. 38.
  8. ↑ Francis, Lesley (May 29, 1975). "Women Take Spot In The Legal Field". The Edmonton Journal. p. 66.
  9. ↑ "McKnight's defence argues for 5 to 9 year sentence for sex assault convictions". Edmonton. 2020-07-17. Retrieved 2020-07-20.
  10. ↑ "Former Edmonton nightclub consultant Matthew McKnight sentenced to 8 years for sexual assaults". Global News. Retrieved 2020-08-01.
  11. ↑ "Former Edmonton nightclub employee sentenced to eight years for sex assaults". thestar.com. 2020-07-31. Retrieved 2020-08-01.
  12. ↑ Wakefield, Jonny (January 17, 2020). "McKnight Guilty on Five Charges". The Edmonton Journal. p. A1.
  13. ↑ Hedley, Kristen (January 17, 2020). "Kristen Hedley [@YEG_SLP]". Twitter. Archived from the original on January 19, 2020. Retrieved June 30, 2020.
  14. ↑ Doyle, John (July 4, 2020). "John Doyle [@MisterJohnDoyle]". Twitter.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.