| Year | Venue | Winner | Score | Runner-up |
|---|
| 2025 | Oak Hills Country Club (TX) | Mike McCoy | 3 & 2 | Greg Sanders |
| 2024 | Honors Course (TN) | Louis Brown | 4 & 3 | Dan Sullivan |
| 2023 | Martis Camp Club (CA) | Todd White | 4 & 3 | Jody Fanagan |
| 2022 | Kittansett Club (MA) | Rusty Strawn | 3 & 2 | Doug Hanzel |
| 2021 | Country Club of Detroit (MI) | Gene Elliott | 1 up | Jerry Gunthorpe |
| 2020 | Country Club of Detroit | Canceled due to the COVID-19 pandemic [3] |
| 2019 | Old Chatham Golf Club (NC) | Bob Royak | 1 up | Roger Newsom |
| 2018 | Eugene Country Club (OR) | Jeff Wilson | 2 & 1 | Sean Knapp |
| 2017 | The Minikahda Club (MN) | Sean Knapp | 2 & 1 | Paul Simson |
| 2016 | Old Warson Country Club (MO) | Dave Ryan | 5 & 3 | Matthew Sughrue |
| 2015 | Hidden Creek Golf Club (NJ) | Chip Lutz | 5 & 3 | Tom Brandes |
| 2014 | Big Canyon Country Club (CA) | Patrick Tallent | 2 & 1 | Bryan Norton |
| 2013 | Wade Hampton Golf Club (NC) | Doug Hanzel | 3 & 2 | Pat O'Donnell |
| 2012 | Mountain Ridge Country Club (NJ) | Paul Simson | 4 & 3 | Curtis Skinner |
| 2011 | Kinloch Golf Club (VA) | Louis Lee | 1 up | Philip Pleat |
| 2010 | Lake Nona Golf & Country Club (FL) | Paul Simson | 2 & 1 | Patrick Tallent |
| 2009 | Beverly Country Club (IL) | Vinny Giles | 1 up | John Grace |
| 2008 | Shady Oaks Country Club (TX) | Buddy Marucci | 2 up | George Zahringer |
| 2007 | Flint Hills National Golf Club (KS) | Stan Lee | 4 & 3 | Sam Farlow |
| 2006 | Victoria National Golf Club (IN) | Mike Bell | 1 up | Tom McGraw |
| 2005 | The Farm (GA) | Mike Rice | 1 up | Mark Bemowski |
| 2004 | Bel-Air Country Club (CA) | Mark Bemowski | 4 & 3 | Greg Reynolds |
| 2003 | The Virginian Golf Club (VA) | Kemp Richardson | 19th hole | Frank Abbott |
| 2002 | Timuquana Country Club (FL) | Greg Reynolds | 4 & 3 | Mark Bemowski |
| 2001 | Norwood Hills Country Club (MO) | Kemp Richardson | 2 & 1 | Bill Ploeger |
| 2000 | Charlotte Country Club (NC) | Bill Shean Jr. | 2 & 1 | Richard Van Leuvan |
| 1999 | Portland Golf Club (OR) | Bill Ploeger | 3 & 2 | Gary Menzel |
| 1998 | Skokie Country Club (IL) | Bill Shean Jr. | 5 & 3 | William King |
| 1997 | Atlantic Golf Club (NY) | Cliff Cunningham | 5 & 3 | Ed Bartlett |
| 1996 | Taconic Golf Club (MA) | O. Gordon Brewer Jr. | 2 up | Heyward Sullivan |
| 1995 | Prairie Dunes Country Club (KS) | James Stahl Jr. | 2 & 1 | Rennie Law |
| 1994 | Champions Golf Club (KY) | O. Gordon Brewer Jr. | 5 & 4 | Bob Hullender |
| 1993 | Farmington Country Club (VA) | Joe Ungvary | 7 & 6 | Jerry Nelson |
| 1992 | The Loxahatchee Club (FL) | Clarence Moore | 6 & 4 | Robert Harris |
| 1991 | Crystal Downs Country Club (MI) | Bill Bosshard | 5 & 4 | Morris Beecroft |
| 1990 | Desert Forest Golf Club (AZ) | Jackie Cummings | 3 & 2 | Bobby Clark |
| 1989 | Lochinvar Golf Club (TX) | R. S. Williams | 19th hole | Joe Simpson |
| 1988 | Milwaukee Country Club (WI) | Clarence Moore | 5 & 4 | Bud Stevens |
| 1987 | Saucon Valley Country Club (PA) | John Richardson | 5 & 4 | James Kite Jr. |
| 1986 | Interlachen Country Club (MN) | R. S. Williams | 3 & 2 | John Harbottle |
| 1985 | Wild Dunes Beach & Racquet Club (SC) | Lewis Oehmig | 20th hole | Ed Hopkins |
| 1984 | Birmingham Country Club (MI) | Robert Rawlins | 19th hole | Richard Runkle |
| 1983 | Crooked Stick Golf Club (IN) | Bill Hyndman | 1 up | Richard Runkle |
| 1982 | Tucson Country Club (AZ) | Alton Duhon | 2 up | Ed Updegraff |
| 1981 | Seattle Golf Club (WA) | Ed Updegraff | 2 & 1 | Dale Morey |
| 1980 | The Homestead (Cascades Course) (VA) | William C. Campbell | 3 & 2 | Keith K. Compton |
| 1979 | Chicago Golf Club (IL) | William C. Campbell | 2 & 1 | Lewis Oehmig |
| 1978 | Pine Tree Golf Club (FL) | Keith K. Compton | 1 up | John W. Kline |
| 1977 | Salem Country Club (MA) | Dale Morey | 4 & 3 | Lewis Oehmig |
| 1976 | Cherry Hills Country Club (CO) | Lewis Oehmig | 4 & 3 | John Richardson |
| 1975 | Carmel Valley Golf & Country Club (CA) | William F. Colm | 4 & 3 | Stephen Stimac |
| 1974 | Harbour Town Golf Links (SC) | Dale Morey | 4 & 2 | Lewis Oehmig |
| 1973 | Onwentsia Club (IL) | Bill Hyndman | 3 & 2 | Harry Welch |
| 1972 | Sharon Golf Club (OH) | Lewis Oehmig | 20th hole | Ernest Pieper Jr. |
| 1971 | Sunnybrook Golf Club (PA) | Tom Draper | 3 & 1 | Ernest Pieper Jr. |
| 1970 | California Golf Club of San Francisco (CA) | Gene Andrews | 1 up | James Ferrie |
| 1969 | Wichita Country Club (KS) | Curtis Person, Sr. | 1 up | David Goldman |
| 1968 | Atlanta Country Club (GA) | Curtis Person, Sr. | 2 & 1 | Ben Goodes |
| 1967 | Shinnecock Hills Golf Club (NY) | Ray Palmer | 3 & 2 | Walter D. Bronson |
| 1966 | Tucson National Golf Club (AZ) | Dexter H. Daniels | 1 up | George Beechler |
| 1965 | Fox Chapel Golf Club (PA) | Robert B. Kiersky | 19th hole | George Beechler |
| 1964 | Waverley Country Club (OR) | William D. Higgins | 2 & 1 | Edward Murphy |
| 1963 | Sea Island Golf Club (GA) | Merrill L. Carlsmith | 3 & 2 | William D. Higgins |
| 1962 | Evanston Golf Club (IL) | Merrill L. Carlsmith | 4 & 2 | Willis H. Blakely |
| 1961 | Southern Hills Country Club (OK) | Dexter H. Daniels | 2 & 1 | William K. Lanman |
| 1960 | Oyster Harbors Club (MA) | Michael Cestone | 20th hole | David Rose |
| 1959 | Memphis Country Club (TN) | J. Clark Espie | 3 & 1 | J. Wolcott Brown |
| 1958 | Monterey Peninsula Country Club (CA) | Thomas C. Robbins | 2 & 1 | Johnny Dawson |
| 1957 | Ridgewood Country Club (NJ) | J. Clark Espie | 2 & 1 | Fred Wright |
| 1956 | Somerset Country Club (MN) | Fred Wright | 4 & 3 | J. Clark Espie |
| 1955 | Belle Meade Country Club (TN) | J. Wood Platt | 5 & 4 | George Studinger |