Chess rating system

Last updated

A chess rating system is a system used in chess to estimate the strength of a player, based on their performance versus other players. They are used by organizations such as FIDE, the US Chess Federation (USCF or US Chess), International Correspondence Chess Federation, and the English Chess Federation. Most of the systems are used to recalculate ratings after a tournament or match but some are used to recalculate ratings after individual games. Popular online chess sites such as chess.com, Lichess, and Internet Chess Club also implement rating systems. In almost all systems, a higher number indicates a stronger player. In general, players' ratings go up if they perform better than expected and down if they perform worse than expected. The magnitude of the change depends on the rating of their opponents. The Elo rating system is currently the most widely used (though it has many variations and improvements). The Elo-like ratings systems have been adopted in many other contexts, such as other games like Go, in online competitive gaming, and in dating apps. [1]

Contents

The first modern rating system was used by the Correspondence Chess League of America in 1939. Soviet player Andrey Khachaturov proposed a similar system in 1946. [2] The first one that made an impact on international chess was the Ingo system in 1948. The USCF adopted the Harkness system in 1950. Shortly after, the British Chess Federation started using a system devised by Richard W. B. Clarke. The USCF switched to the Elo rating system in 1960, which was adopted by FIDE in 1970. [3]

Ingo system

This was the system of the West German Chess Federation from 1948 until 1992, designed by Anton Hoesslinger and published in 1948. It was replaced by an Elo system, Deutsche Wertungszahl. It influenced some other rating systems.

New players receive a high, fixed starting score. Players' new ratings centre on the average rating of entrants to their competition: then if having achieved better than a net draw set of result, minus the number of percentage points it is over 50% (e.g. a 124 or 248 wins-to-losses result is, as ever, noted as a 75% tournament outcome) if having achieved worse than this then the number, again in percent, is added to the average of the tournament entrants' scores; thus in all cases recalibrating all players after each tournament completely. A consequence is at most 50 points gained or shed per tournament (namely by a totally winning or totally losing participant) away from the tournament average. Unlike other modern, nationally used chess systems, lower numbers indicate better performance. [4]

Harkness system

This system was noted in Chess Review by tournament organizer Kenneth Harkness, who expounded his invention of it in articles of 1956, 14 years later. It was used by the USCF from 1950 to 1960 and other leagues.

When players compete in a tournament, the average rating of their competition is calculated. If a player scores 50%, they receive the average competition rating as their performance rating. If they score more than 50%, their new rating is the competition average plus 10 points per percentage point exceeding 50. If they score less, their new rating is the competition average minus 10 points per percentage point shy of 50. [5]

Example

A player with a rating of 1600 plays in an eleven-round tournament and scores 2½–8½ (22.7%) against competition with an average rating of 1850. This is 27.3% below 50% (50–22.7%), so their new rating is 1850 (10 × 27.3) = 1577. [6]

English Chess Federation system

The ECF grading system was used by the English Chess Federation until 2020. It was published in 1958 by Richard W. B. Clarke. Each game has a large potential effect. Points (grades) are never immediately effective for every game won, lost or drawn, in a registered competition (including English congresses, local and county leagues, and registered, approved team events) but are averaged into personal grade (ECF Grade) over a cycle of at least 30 games.

A player's contributing score for such averaging is taken to be their opponent's grade (but the gap is deemed to be 40 points, if greater than such a grade gap). However this is adjusted by adding 50 points for a win, subtracting 50 points for a loss, and making no adjustment for a draw. Negative grades are deemed to be nil, so a personal score of 50 arose quickly in the lower leagues and experienced novices aspire to a 100 grading. The cyclical averaging and cycle-persistent Grades are its hallmarks. The maximum gain in a single cycle is 90 points, which would entail beating much higher-rated opponents at every match. The opposite applies to losses.

To convert between ECF and Elo grades, the formula ELO = (ECF * 7.50) + 700 was sometimes used. [7]

Elo rating system

The Elo system was invented by Arpad Elo and is the most common rating system. It is used by FIDE, other organizations and some Chess websites such as Internet Chess Club and chess24.com. Elo once stated that the process of rating players was in any case rather approximate; he compared it to "the measurement of the position of a cork bobbing up and down on the surface of agitated water with a yard stick tied to a rope and which is swaying in the wind". [8] Any attempt to consolidate all aspects of a player's strength into a single number inevitably misses some of the picture.

FIDE divides all its normal tournaments into categories by a narrower average rating of the players. Each category is 25 rating points wide. Category 1 is for an average rating of 2251 to 2275, category 2 is 2276 to 2300, etc. Women's tournaments currently commence 200 points lower, including its Category 1. [9]

Elo scales, 1978 [10]
Rating rangeCategory
2700+No formal title, but sometimes informally called "super grandmasters" [11]
2700–2500most Grandmasters (GM)
2499–2400most International Masters (IM) and some Grandmasters (GM)
2399–2300most FIDE Masters (FM) and some International Masters (IM)
2299–2200 FIDE Candidate Masters (CM), most national masters (NM)
2199–2000Candidate masters (CM)
1999–1800Class A, category 1
1799–1600Class B, category 2
1599–1400Class C, category 3
1399–1200Class D, category 4
1199–1000Class E, category 5
Below 1000Novices

The USCF uses the USCF system, a modification of the Elo system, in which the K factor varies and it gives bonus points for superior performance in a tournament. [12] USCF ratings are generally 50 to 100 points higher than the FIDE equivalents. [13]

USCF rating categories
CategoryRating range
Senior master2400 and up
National master2200–2399
Expert2000–2199
Class A1800–1999
Class B1600–1799
Class C1400–1599
Class D1200–1399
Class E1000–1199
Class F800–999
Class G600–799
Class H400–599
Class I200–399
Class J100–199

Example

Elo gives an example of amending the rating of Lajos Portisch, a 2635-rated player before his tournament, who scores 10½ points of a possible 16 winning points (as this is against 16 players). First, the difference in rating is recorded for each other player he faced. Then the expected score, against each, is determined from a table, which publishes this for every band of rating difference. For instance, one opponent was Vlastimil Hort, who was rated at 2600. The rating difference of 35 gave Portisch an expected score of "0.55". This is an impossible score as not 0, 12 or 1 but as this is higher than 0.5 even a draw will very slightly damage Portisch's rating; conversely a draw will very slightly improve Hort's rating.

Portisch's expected score is summed for each of his matches, which gave a total expected score of 9.66. Then the formula is:

new rating = old rating + (K × (WWe))

K is 10; W is the actual match/tournament score; We is the expected score.

Portisch's new rating [14] is 2635 + 10×(10.59.66) = 2643.4.

Linear approximation

Elo devised a linear approximation to his full system, negating the need for look-up tables of expected score. With that method, a player's new rating is

where Rnew and Rold are the player's new and old ratings respectively, Di is the opponent's rating minus the player's rating, W is the number of wins, L is the number of losses, C = 200 and K = 32. The term (W-L) / 2 is the score above or below 0. ΣD / 4C is the expected score according to: 4C rating points equals 100%. [15]

The USCF used a modification of this system to calculate ratings after individual games of correspondence chess, with a K = 32 and C = 200. [16]

Glicko rating system

The Glicko system is a more modern approach, which was invented by Mark Glickman as an improvement of the Elo system. It is used by Chess.com, Free Internet Chess Server and other online chess servers. The Glicko-2 system is a refinement of the original Glicko system and is used by Lichess, Australian Chess Federation and other online websites.

Turkey UKD system

TSF (Turkey Chess Federation) uses a combination of ELO and UKD system. [17]

USA ICCF system

The ICCF U.S.A. used its own system in the 1970s. It now uses the Elo system.

Deutsche Wertungszahl

The Deutsche Wertungszahl system replaced the Ingo system in Germany.

Chessmetrics

The Chessmetrics system was invented by Jeff Sonas. It is based on computer analysis of a large database of games and is intended to be more accurate than the Elo system.

Universal Rating System

The Universal Rating System was developed by Mark Glickman, Jeff Sonas, J. Isaac Miller and Maxime Rischard, with the support of the Grand Chess Tour, the Kasparov Chess Foundation, and the Chess Club and Scholastic Center of Saint Louis. [18]

Rating systems using computers as a reference

Many rating systems give a rating to players at a given time, but cannot compare players from different eras. In 2006, Matej Guid and Ivan Bratko pioneered a new way of rating players, by comparing their moves against the recommended moves of a chess engine. The authors used the program Crafty and argued that even a lower-ranked program (Elo around 2700) could identify good players. [19] In their follow-up study, they used Rybka 3 to estimate chess player ratings. [20]

In 2017, Jean-Marc Alliot compared players using Stockfish 6 with an ELO rating around 3300, well above top human players. [21]

Chronology

See also

Notes

  1. "Tinder matchmaking is more like Warcraft than you might think - Kill Screen". 2017-08-19. Archived from the original on 2017-08-19. Retrieved 2024-02-04. According to Tinder CEO Jonathan Badeen, Tinder uses a variation of ELO scoring to determine how you rank among the site's userbase, and therefore, which profiles to suggest to you and whose queues your profile shows up in.
  2. ( Hooper & Whyld 1992 :332)
  3. ( Hooper & Whyld 1992 :332)
  4. ( Harkness 1967 :205–6).
  5. ( Harkness 1967 :185–88)
  6. ( Harkness 1967 :187)
  7. "The calculation of ECF Grades on a monthly basis". English Chess Federation. Retrieved 2022-07-08.
  8. Chess Life, 1962.
  9. FIDE Handbook, Section B.0.0, FIDE web site
  10. Elo, 1978, p. 18
  11. "How to face a Super Grandmaster?". Saint Louis Chess Club. January 25, 2019.
  12. ( Just & Burg 2003 :259–73)
  13. ( Just & Burg 2003 :112)
  14. ( Elo 1978 :37)
  15. ( Elo 1978 :28–29)
  16. "The United States Chess Federation - CC Ratings Explanation". www.uschess.org.
  17. "TSF UKD Bilgi Sistemi". ukd.tsf.org.tr.
  18. "Universal Rating System". 2017-01-03.
  19. Riis, Søren (2 November 2006). "Review of "Computer Analysis of World Chess Champions"". Chessbase.
  20. Riis, Søren (11 November 2011). "Review of "Using Chess Engines to Estimate Human Skill"". Chessbase.
  21. 1 2 Alliot, Jean-Marc (2017). "Who is the Master?". ICGA Journal. 39: 3–43. doi: 10.3233/ICG-160012 .
  22. ( Harkness 1967 :184)
  23. ( Lawrence 2009 )
  24. ( Harkness 1967 :184)
  25. ( Elo 1978 :197)
  26. ( Elo 1978 :68, 89)
  27. "Glickman website". Archived from the original on June 11, 2010.
  28. "Welcome to the Chessmetrics site". chessmetrics.com. Archived from the original on November 15, 2011.
  29. Guid, Matej; Bratko, Ivan. "Computer analysis of world chess champions". International Computer Games Association Journal. 29 (2): 3–14.

Related Research Articles

Grandmaster (GM) is a title awarded to chess players by the world chess organization FIDE. Apart from World Champion, Grandmaster is the highest title a chess player can attain. Once achieved, the title is held for life, though exceptionally the title can be revoked for cheating.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Elo rating system</span> Method for calculating relative skill levels of players

The Elo rating system is a method for calculating the relative skill levels of players in zero-sum games such as chess. It is named after its creator Arpad Elo, a Hungarian-American physics professor.

The game of chess, or rather its immediate precursor, known as shatranj, was introduced to Europe from the Islamic sphere, most likely via Iberia, in the 9th or 10th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States Chess Federation</span> US governing body for chess competition

The United States Chess Federation is the governing body for chess competition in the United States and represents the U.S. in FIDE, the World Chess Federation. US Chess administers the official national rating system, awards national titles, sanctions over twenty national championships annually, and publishes two magazines: Chess Life and Chess Life for Kids. The USCF was founded and incorporated in Illinois in 1939, from the merger of two older chess organizations. It is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization headquartered in St. Louis, Missouri. Its membership as of 2020 as COVID hit was 97,000; as of 2024 the membership was 112,000.

In chess, there are a number of ways that a game can end in a draw, neither player winning. Draws are codified by various rules of chess including stalemate, threefold repetition, and the fifty-move rule. Under the standard FIDE rules, a draw also occurs in a dead position, most commonly when neither player has sufficient material to checkmate the opponent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arnold Denker</span> American chess player

Arnold Sheldon Denker was an American chess player and author. He was U.S. champion in 1944 and 1946. In later years he served in various chess organizations, receiving recognition from the United States Chess Federation, including in 2004 the highest honor, "Dean of American Chess".

Several methods have been suggested for comparing the greatest chess players in history. There is agreement on a statistical system to rate the strengths of current players, called the Elo system, but disagreement about methods used to compare players from different generations who never competed against each other.

Kenneth Harkness was a chess organizer. He is the creator of the Harkness rating system.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arpad Elo</span> American-Hungarian physicist (1903–1992)

Arpad Emmerich Elo was an American-Hungarian physics professor who created the Elo rating system for two-player games such as chess.

Chessmetrics is a system for rating chess players devised by Jeff Sonas. It is intended as an improvement over the Elo and Edo rating systems.

The Glicko rating system and Glicko-2 rating system are methods of assessing a player's strength in zero-sum two-player games. The Glicko rating system was invented by Mark Glickman in 1995 as an improvement on the Elo rating system and initially intended for the primary use as a chess rating system. Glickman's principal contribution to measurement is "ratings reliability", called RD, for ratings deviation.

The ECF grading system was the rating system formerly used by the English Chess Federation. A rating produced by the system was known as an ECF grading.

Swiss system tournaments, a type of group tournament common in chess and other board games, use various criteria to break ties between players who have the same total number of points after the last round. This is needed when prizes are indivisible, such as titles, trophies, or qualification for another tournament. Otherwise players often share the tied spots, with cash prizes being divided equally among the tied players.

Lone Pine International was a series of chess tournaments held annually in March or April from 1971 through 1981 in Lone Pine, California. The tournaments were formally known as the Louis D. Statham Masters, named after sponsor Louis D. Statham (1907–1983), an engineer and millionaire inventor of medical instruments who was also a Los Angeles based chess aficionado. The events were seven- to ten-round Swiss system tournaments, with entrance requirements that made them the strongest recurring Swiss tournaments in the U.S. in the 1980s. Grandmaster Isaac Kashdan served as the tournament director.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chess title</span> Title bestowed on a chessplayer

A chess title is a title regulated by a chess governing body and bestowed upon players based on their performance and rank. Such titles are usually granted for life. The international chess governing body FIDE grants several titles, the most prestigious of which is Grandmaster; many national chess federations also grant titles such as "National Master". More broadly, the term "master" can refer to any highly skilled chess player.

Jeff Sonas is a statistical chess analyst who invented the Chessmetrics system for rating chess players, which is intended as an improvement on the Elo rating system. He is the founder and proprietor of the Chessmetrics.com website, which gives Sonas' calculations of the ratings of current players and historical ratings going back as far as January 1843. Sonas has written dozens of articles since 1999 for ChessBase.com and other chess websites. He was a participant in the FIDE ratings committee meeting in Athens, Greece in June 2010.

The Deutsche Wertungszahl is a chess rating system used in Germany. A higher rating number corresponds to a stronger player. A beginner is rated around 500 and a world champion about 2800.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">FIDE titles</span> Title for chess players awarded by FIDE

FIDE titles are awarded by the international chess governing body FIDE for outstanding performance. The highest such title is Grandmaster (GM). Titles generally require a combination of Elo rating and norms. Once awarded, titles are held for life except in cases of fraud or cheating. Open titles may be earned by all players, while women's titles are restricted to female players. Many strong female players hold both open and women's titles. FIDE also awards titles for arbiters, organizers and trainers. Titles for correspondence chess, chess problem composition and chess problem solving are no longer administered by FIDE.


The Universal Rating System (URS) is a system for rating chess players devised by Jeff Sonas, Mark Glickman, J. Isaac Miller and Maxime Rischard. It was introduced to determine seedings and qualification for the 2017 Grand Chess Tour.

Enrico Sevillano is a Filipino and American chess player who received the FIDE title of Grandmaster (GM) in September 2012. He plays for the United States Chess Federation (USCF) where he has a Regular Rating of 2542, Quick Rating of 2488 and Blitz Rating of 2572. He is ranked #112 among all players in the US, #72 among all active players, #235 in the American Continent and #1796 among all players in the world. Per FIDE, he reached a peak rating of 2537 and currently has an ELO standard rating of 2447 and blitz rating of 2515.

References