1996 Maryland train collision

Last updated

1996 Maryland train collision
Silver Spring collision aerial.png
Aerial photograph of the collision. The MARC commuter train is on the left, and the Capitol Limited is on the right.
Details
DateFebruary 16, 1996;28 years ago (1996-02-16)
5:39 pm
Location Silver Spring, Maryland, U.S.
Coordinates 39°00′03″N77°02′32″W / 39.0008°N 77.0423°W / 39.0008; -77.0423
CountryUnited States
Operator MARC
Amtrak
Incident typeCollision
Cause Signal passed at danger due to driver error of the MARC train, having forgotten to comply with the requirements of an approach signal.
Statistics
Trains2
Passengers184
Deaths11
Injured26

On February 16, 1996, a MARC commuter train collided with Amtrak's Capitol Limited passenger train in Silver Spring, Maryland, United States, killing three crew and eight passengers on the MARC train; a further eleven passengers on the same train and fifteen passengers and crew on the Capitol Limited were injured. Total damage was estimated at $7.5 million.

Contents

An investigation by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found that the crew of the MARC train had forgotten the indication of an approach signal which they had passed before a station stop, and as a consequence, could not slow down in time after encountering a stop signal.

The crash led to the creation of comprehensive federal rules for passenger car design, the first in the history of passenger service in the U.S., [1] as well as changes to operating rules.

Accident

The two-track railroad line between Brunswick, Maryland, and Union Station in Washington, D.C., is owned by CSX Transportation (save for approaches to Union Station) and is known as the Metropolitan Subdivision. MARC operates commuter services, known as the Brunswick Line, from Washington to Brunswick and points west. Amtrak operates the single daily Capitol Limited , a Washington–Chicago overnight train, over the route as well, though it makes fewer stops. [2] [3] :22

MARC No. 286 departed Brunswick at 4:30 p.m. Eastern time on February 16, 1996, traveling eastbound. No. 286 was a Brunswick–Washington, D.C., commuter train with a scheduled arrival at Union Station of 5:30 pm. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) described the conditions that day as a "blowing snowfall", with a 5-inch (130 mm) accumulation. At the time, CSX provided the operating crew for MARC commuter trains under contract to the Maryland Mass Transit Administration; aboard were an engineer, conductor, and assistant conductor. [3] :1 The train consisted of EMD GP39H-2 diesel locomotive number 73, two passenger coaches, and a control car. The train operated in push mode, meaning that the locomotive was on the rear of the train, and the locomotive engineer controlled operations from the control car in the front. [3] :6 MARC No. 286 had twenty passengers on board. [3] :1

Amtrak No. 29, the Capitol Limited, departed Union Station at 5:25 pm, traveling westbound towards Chicago. That day the Amtrak train consisted of two diesel locomotives, an EMD F40PHR, no. 255, leading and a GE P40DC, no. 811, trailing; six material handling cars; a baggage car; a Superliner transition sleeping car; two Superliner sleeping cars; a Superliner dining car; a Superliner Sightseer Lounge car; two Superliner coaches; and a Hi-Level dormitory-coach. The Capitol Limited had four crew, fourteen service personnel, and 164 passengers on board. [3] :1–6

Collision damage
Silver Spring collision cab car.png
MARC II cab control car #7752
Silver Spring collision amtrak locomotive.png
Amtrak EMD F40PHR No. 255

The two tracks of the Metropolitan Subdivision are numbered 1 and 2. MARC No. 286 was on track 2, having made a flag stop at Kensington to pick up two passengers. The Capitol Limited was also on track 2, having passed a stopped freight train on track 1. Both trains were approaching Georgetown Junction, where the Capitol Limited was to switch to track 1. The signal protecting Georgetown Junction indicated "stop" on track 2, which would have the effect of stopping MARC No. 286 and permitting the Capitol Limited to change tracks. Before reaching Kensington, MARC No. 286 passed an approach signal. The purpose of that signal was to warn the train's crew that the next signal would be a stop signal and that maximum speed was restricted to 30 miles per hour (48 km/h). For reasons unknown, the crew of MARC No. 286 did not obey this restriction, and, after departing Kensington, the train reached 66 miles per hour (106 km/h) before the crew applied the emergency brakes. The Capitol Limited had reached Georgetown Junction and begun crossing over to track 1. MARC No. 286 struck the Amtrak train at approximately 38 miles per hour (61 km/h) at 5:39 pm. [3] :1–6

All three crew members aboard the MARC train were killed, along with eight passengers. Twenty-six people were injured. The collision destroyed both MARC passenger cars, the control car, and one of the two Amtrak locomotives, EMD F40PHR No. 255. The turnouts at Georgetown Junction were damaged and had to be replaced. The total property damage was estimated at $7.5 million. [3] :7–8

Investigation

Track diagram of the collision area 1996 Silver Spring, Maryland, train collision diagram.jpg
Track diagram of the collision area

It was clear from the outset that MARC No. 286 had not complied with the speed restrictions of the approach signal and consequently overran the stop signal, making the crash inevitable. [4] The deaths of all three MARC crew members in the collision meant that the reason for the failure would remain unknown; in its report, NTSB ascribed it to "the apparent failure of the engineer and the train crew because of multiple distractions to operate MARC train 286." [3] :vii The focus of the investigators and the public shifted to safety systems that could have prevented the crash and the design of the commuter rail cars themselves.

One of the crew members and seven of the eight MARC passengers who died were killed not by the collision itself but by a fire that started when the exposed diesel fuel tanks on the Amtrak locomotive ruptured. Emergency responders were unable to open the doors of the lead passenger car. Passengers in other cars reported trying to break the window glass but being unable to do so. [5] The NTSB found the existing emergency egress standards for passenger cars were inadequate and recommended multiple changes, including: [3] :74–75

Before the NTSB issued its report, MARC had taken steps in that direction, including installing more emergency windows, improving door release mechanisms, and improving emergency signage. [6]

Much criticism focused on the role of human error in the collision; once the engineer had forgotten (or missed) the approach signal, there was no automatic system to prevent the collision. [7] The NTSB noted that had a positive train control system been in place on the Metropolitan Subdivision, the collision would have been less likely: the system would have detected MARC #286's unauthorized speed and stopped the train. [3] :73 The NTSB also strongly criticized CSX and the Federal Transit Administration for the removal of a signal between Kensington and Georgetown Junction as part of capacity improvements on the Metropolitan Subdivision. The NTSB argued that having this signal after Kensington would have reduced the likelihood of the sort of human error that caused the crash, and in the NTSB's view, CSX and the FTA did not properly assess the effects of removing the signal. [3] :53–63

Aftermath

Crew fatalities Brunswick train crash memorial front.jpg
Crew fatalities
Passenger fatalities Brunswick train crash memorial back.jpg
Passenger fatalities

Following the accident, the engineer and conductor of the Capitol Limited filed lawsuits against Amtrak, CSX, and the state of Maryland for $103 million (1996 USD) alleging negligence[ needs update ], singling out the removal of the signal between Kensington and Georgetown Junction and the operator error by the MARC engineer. Both men claimed that the injuries they sustained in the crash "prevent[ed] them from returning to work". [8] In 1999, responding to the crash, the Federal Railroad Administration issued comprehensive rules for passenger car design, "the first ...in the 169-year history of rail passenger service". The new rules required new control cars and multiple units to be built to higher crashworthiness standards. [1]

Memorial at the Harpers Ferry Job Corps Center 1996 train collision memorial Job Corps WV1.jpg
Memorial at the Harpers Ferry Job Corps Center

Several memorials were erected to commemorate the dead. In Silver Spring, a plaque was placed on a bridge above the crash site. In Brunswick, a stone is engraved with the names and pictures of the three CSX crew members. Private donations paid for the stone. [9] The eight passengers who died were all students at the Harpers Ferry Job Corps Center. Students there erected a memorial flanked by weeping cherry trees. [10]

See also

Related Research Articles

<i>Capitol Limited</i> Amtrak service between Chicago, IL and Washington, D.C.

The Capitol Limited is a daily Amtrak train between Washington, D.C., and Chicago, running 764 miles (1,230 km) via Pittsburgh and Cleveland. Service began in 1981 and was named after the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad's Capitol Limited which ended in 1971 upon the formation of Amtrak. It carries the Amtrak train numbers 29 and 30, which were previously assigned to the discontinued National Limited.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">MARC Train</span> U.S. passenger rail system in Baltimore–Washington metropolitan area

MARC is a commuter rail system in the Washington–Baltimore area. MARC is administered by the Maryland Transit Administration (MTA) and operated under contract by Alstom and Amtrak on track owned by CSX Transportation (CSXT) and Amtrak. In 2022, the system had a ridership of 2,815,900, or about 12,100 per weekday as of the third quarter of 2023, less than pre-COVID-19 pandemic weekday ridership of 40,000.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rockville station</span> Washington Metro and MARC Train station

Rockville station is an intermodal train station located in downtown Rockville, Maryland, United States. It is served by the Washington Metro Red Line, MARC Brunswick Line commuter trains, and Amtrak Capitol Limited intercity trains.

The Howard Street Tunnel fire was a 60-car CSX Transportation freight train derailment that occurred in the Howard Street Tunnel, a freight through-route tunnel under Howard Street in Baltimore, Maryland, on July 18, 2001. The derailment sparked a chemical fire that raged for five or six days and virtually shut down the downtown area. In the evening of the first day, a water main ruptured causing significant flooding in the streets above. The accident disrupted Northeast Corridor rail service. It also slowed Internet service in the US for several hours due to the destruction of a cable passing through the tunnel.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Big Bayou Canot rail accident</span> 1993 train wreck in Alabama, U.S.

On September 22, 1993, an Amtrak Sunset Limited passenger train derailed on the CSX Transportation Big Bayou Canot Bridge near Mobile, Alabama, United States. It was caused by displacement of a span and deformation of the rails when a tow of heavy barges collided with the rail bridge eight minutes earlier. Forty-seven people were killed and 103 more were injured. To date, it is the deadliest train wreck in both Amtrak's history and Alabama's railway history. It is also the worst rail disaster in the United States since the 1958 Newark Bay rail accident, in which 48 people died.

On 8 February 1986, twenty-three people were killed in a collision between a Canadian National Railway freight train and a Via Rail passenger train called the Super Continental, including the engine crews of both trains. It was the deadliest rail disaster in Canada since the Dugald accident of 1947, which had thirty-one fatalities, and was not surpassed until the Lac-Mégantic rail disaster in 2013, which resulted in 47 deaths.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1987 Maryland train collision</span> 1987 rail transit disaster in Chase, Maryland, USA

On January 4, 1987, two trains collided on Amtrak's Northeast Corridor main line near Chase, Maryland, United States, at Gunpow Interlocking. Amtrak train 94, the Colonial, traveling north from Washington, D.C., to Boston, crashed at over 100 miles per hour (160 km/h) into a set of Conrail locomotives running light which had fouled the mainline. Fourteen passengers on the Amtrak train died, as well as the Amtrak engineer and lounge car attendant.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Metropolitan Subdivision</span> Railroad line in Washington, D.C. and Maryland, United States

The Metropolitan Subdivision is a railroad line owned and operated by CSX Transportation in the District of Columbia and the U.S. state of Maryland. The 53-mile line runs from Washington, D.C., northwest to Weverton, Maryland, along the former Metropolitan Branch of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brunswick Line</span> MARC commuter rail line in Maryland, West Virginia and Washington, D.C.

The Brunswick Line is a MARC commuter rail line between Washington, D.C., and Martinsburg, West Virginia, with a branch to Frederick, Maryland. It primarily serves the northern and western suburbs of Washington. The line, MARC's second longest at 74 miles, is operated under contract to MARC by Alstom and runs on CSX-owned track, including the Metropolitan, Old Main Line, and Cumberland subdivisions. It is the successor to commuter services provided by the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad (B&O), which date to the mid-19th century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Positive train control</span> Type of train protection system

Positive train control (PTC) is a family of automatic train protection systems deployed in the United States. Most of the United States' national rail network mileage has a form of PTC. These systems are generally designed to check that trains are moving safely and to stop them when they are not.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2008 Chatsworth train collision</span> Head-on collision in Los Angeles, California

The 2008 Chatsworth train collision occurred at 4:22:23 p.m. PDT on September 12, 2008, when a Union Pacific Railroad freight train and a Metrolink commuter rail train collided head-on in the Chatsworth neighborhood of Los Angeles, California, United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1990 Back Bay, Massachusetts, train collision</span> Train wreck in 1990

The 1990 Back Bay, Massachusetts train collision was a collision between an Amtrak passenger train, the Night Owl, and a Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) Stoughton Line commuter train just outside Back Bay station in Boston, Massachusetts, United States. An investigation by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) found that the Amtrak train entered a speed-restricted curve at excessive speed, causing the train to derail and crash into the MBTA commuter train on an adjacent track. Although no one was killed in the accident, 453 people were injured and Back Bay station was closed for six days. Total damage was estimated at $14 million. The accident led to new speed restrictions and safety improvements in the vicinity of Back Bay and a revamp of Amtrak's locomotive engineer training program.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2018 Crozet, Virginia, train crash</span> Level crossing accident in Virginia, United States

The Crozet, Virginia train crash was a railway accident that occurred on January 31, 2018. A chartered Amtrak train named Congressional Special Train 923, following the route normally used by the Amtrak Cardinal and carrying a group of politicians and lawmakers from the Republican Party, collided with a garbage truck at a level crossing at Lanetown Road in Crozet, Virginia, 12 miles (19 km) west of Charlottesville, Virginia. The train was chartered by Republican lawmakers for transportation from Washington Union Station to an annual retreat at The Greenbrier in White Sulphur Springs, West Virginia. Several politicians brought their spouses and children with them for the trip; no members of the general public were passengers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cayce, South Carolina, train collision</span> 2018 railroad accident in South Carolina, US

On February 4, 2018, the southbound Amtrak Silver Star No. 91 passenger train from New York City to Miami collided with a stationary CSX Transportation freight train in Cayce, South Carolina, just south of the state's capital of Columbia on CSX's Columbia Subdivision. Two Amtrak crew members were killed and 116 other crew and passengers were injured.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Harvey, Illinois, train collision</span> 1979 crash with two fatalities

The Harvey train collision took place on October 12, 1979, when the Shawnee train operated by Amtrak between Carbondale and Chicago Union Station crashed into a parked Illinois Central Gulf freight train, leading to the death of two crew members.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2022 Missouri train derailment</span> 2022 railroad accident in Missouri

On June 27, 2022, the Southwest Chief, a passenger train operated by Amtrak, derailed near the small town of Mendon, Missouri. The derailment was caused by the train striking a dump truck that was obstructing the crossing of County Road 113, about three miles (4.8 km) southwest of Mendon. Four people were killed in the wreck: three passengers on board the train and the truck driver, with up to 150 people injured.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2002 Placentia train collision</span>

The 2002 Placentia train collision occurred at around 8:10 am. PDT on April 23, 2002, when a BNSF Railway freight train and a Metrolink commuter train collided head-on at Control Point Atwood in Placentia, California, United States.

References

  1. 1 2 Phillips, Don; Sipress, Alan (May 11, 1999). "New Rules Set for Passenger Trains; U.S. Agency Aims to Reduce Damage in Accidents Like the Fiery 1996 MARC Crash". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on July 14, 2014. Retrieved July 13, 2014.
  2. "Northern Region: Baltimore Division Timetable No. 4" (PDF). CSX Transportation. January 1, 2005.[ dead link ]
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 "Collision and Derailment of Maryland Rail Commuter MARC Train 286 and National Railroad Passenger Corporation Amtrak Train 29 Near Silver Spring, Maryland on February 16, 1996" (PDF). Railroad Accident Report. National Transportation Safety Board. July 3, 1997. Archived (PDF) from the original on July 14, 2014.
  4. Phillips, Don (February 17, 1996). "Simple Switching Maneuver Somehow Went Badly Awry; Location of Crash Suggests MARC Train Ran Signal, but Question Is Why". The Washington Post . Archived from the original on November 3, 2014. Retrieved July 13, 2014.
  5. Montgomery, David; Reid, Alice (February 20, 1996). "Eight of 11 Train Crash Victims Died of Fire, Not Crash Injuries". The Tech . Archived from the original on August 8, 2012.
  6. "MARC Agency Promises Improved Safety by July". The Washington Post. May 23, 1996. Archived from the original on July 14, 2014. Retrieved July 13, 2014.
  7. Phillips, Don (February 20, 1996). "Crash Sharpens Focus on Train Control, Safety". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on July 14, 2014. Retrieved July 13, 2014.
  8. Sarris, Marina (April 1, 1997). "Engineer, conductor file suits for $103 million in train crash". The Baltimore Sun . Archived from the original on July 14, 2014.
  9. Gillis, Justin (September 22, 1996). "A Railroad Town Remembers and Mourns; Memorial to Victims of MARC Crash Dedicated in Brunswick, Md". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on July 14, 2014. Retrieved July 13, 2014.
  10. "Harpers Ferry Jobs Corps remembers '96 train wreck". The Charleston Gazette. February 17, 2006. Archived from the original on September 24, 2015. Retrieved July 13, 2014.