Air shower (physics)

Last updated
Cosmic ray air shower created by a 1TeV proton hitting the atmosphere 20 km above the Earth. The shower was simulated using the AIRES package. Animated 3d models of this and other showers can be found on COSMUS. Protonshower.jpg
Cosmic ray air shower created by a 1TeV proton hitting the atmosphere 20 km above the Earth. The shower was simulated using the AIRES package. Animated 3d models of this and other showers can be found on COSMUS.
Air shower detected in a cloud chamber. Air shower detected in a cloud chamber.jpg
Air shower detected in a cloud chamber.

Air showers are extensive cascades of subatomic particles and ionized nuclei, produced in the atmosphere when a primary cosmic ray enters the atmosphere. When a particle of the cosmic radiation, which could be a proton, a nucleus, an electron, a photon, or (rarely) a positron, interacts with the nucleus of a molecule in the atmosphere, it produces a vast number of secondary particles, which make up the shower. In the first interactions of the cascade especially hadrons (mostly light mesons like pions and kaons) are produced and decay rapidly in the air, producing other particles and electromagnetic radiation, which are part of the shower components. Depending on the energy of the cosmic ray, the detectable size of the shower can reach several kilometers in diameter.

Contents

The absorbed ionizing radiation from cosmic radiation is largely from muons, neutrons, and electrons, with a dose rate that varies in different parts of the world and is based largely on the geomagnetic field, altitude, and solar cycle. Airline crews are exposed to more radiation from cosmic rays if they routinely work flight routes that take them close to the North or South pole at high altitudes, where the shielding by the geomagnetic field is minimal.

The air shower phenomenon was unknowingly discovered by Bruno Rossi in 1933 in a laboratory experiment. In 1937 Pierre Auger, unaware of Rossi's earlier report, detected the same phenomenon and investigated it in some detail. He concluded that cosmic-ray particles are of extremely high energies and interact with nuclei high up in the atmosphere, initiating a cascade of secondary interactions that produce extensive showers of subatomic particles. [1] [2]

The most important experiments detecting extensive air showers today are the Telescope Array Project and the Pierre Auger Observatory. The latter is the largest observatory for cosmic rays ever built, operating with 4 fluorescence detector buildings and 1600 surface detector stations spanning an area of 3,000 km2 in the Argentinean desert.

History

In 1933, shortly after the discovery of cosmic radiation by Victor Hess, Bruno Rossi [3] conducted an experiment in the Institute of Physics in Florence, using shielded Geiger counters to confirm the penetrating character of the cosmic radiation. He used different arrangements of Geiger counters, including a setup of three counters, where two were placed next to each other and a third was centered underneath with additional shielding. From the detection of air-shower particles passing through the Geiger counters in coincidence, he assumed that secondary particles are being produced by cosmic rays in the first shielding layer as well as in the rooftop of the laboratory, unknowing that the particles he measured were muons, which are produced in air showers and which would only be discovered three years later. He also noted that the coincidence rate drops significantly for cosmic rays that are detected at a zenith angle below . A similar experiment was conducted in 1936 by Hilgert and Bothe in Heidelberg. [4]

In a publication in 1939, Pierre Auger, together with three colleagues, suggested that secondary particles are created by cosmic rays in the atmosphere, and conducted experiments using shielded scintillators and Wilson chambers on the Jungfraujoch at an altitude of above sea level, and on Pic du Midi at an altitude of above sea level, and at sea level. [5] They found that the rate of coincidences reduces with increasing distance of the detectors, but does not vanish, even at high altitudes. Thus confirming that cosmic rays produce air showers of secondary particles in the atmosphere. They estimated that the primary particles of this phenomenon must have energies of up to .

Based on the idea of quantum theory, theoretical work on air showers was carried between 1935 and 1940 out by many well-known physicists of the time (including Bhabha, Oppenheimer, Landau, Rossi and others), assuming that in the vicinity of nuclear fields high-energy gamma rays will undergo pair-production of electrons and positrons, and electrons and positrons will produce gamma rays by radiation. [6] [7] [8] [9] Work on extensive air showers continued mainly after the war, as many key figures were involved in the Manhattan project. In the 1950s, the lateral and angular structure of electromagnetic particles in air showers were calculated by Japanese scientists Koichi Kamata and Jun Nishimura. [10]

In 1955, the first surface detector array to detect air showers with sufficient precision to detect the arrival direction of the primary cosmic rays was built at the Agassiz station at MIT. [11] The Agassiz array consisted of 16 plastic scintillators arranged in a diameter circular array. The results of the experiment on the arrival directions of cosmic rays, however, where inconclusive.

The Volcano Ranch experiment, which was built in 1959 and operated by John Linsley, was the first surface detector array of sufficient size to detect ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays. [12] In 1962, the first cosmic ray with an energy of was reported. With a footprint of several kilometers, the shower size at the ground was twice as large as any event recorded before, approximately producing particles in the shower. Furthermore, it was confirmed that the lateral distribution of the particles detected at the ground matched Kenneth Greisen's approximation [13] of the structure functions derived by Kamata and Nishimura.

A novel detection technique for extensive air showers was proposed by Greisen in 1965. He suggested to directly observe Cherenkov radiation of the shower particles, and fluorescence light produced by excited nitrogen molecules in the atmosphere. In this way, one would be able to measure the longitudinal development of a shower in the atmosphere. This method was first applied successfully and reported in 1977 at Volcano Ranch, using 67 optical modules. [14] Volcano Ranch finished its operation shortly after due to lack of funding.

Many air-shower experiments followed in the decades after, including KASCADE, AGASA, and HIRES. In 1994, the latter reported the detection of an ultrahigh-energy cosmic ray with an energy beyond the theoretically expected spectral cutoff. [15] The air shower of the cosmic ray was detected by the Fly's Eye fluorescence detector system and was estimated to contain approximately 240 billion particles at its maximum. This corresponds to a primary energy for the cosmic ray of about . To this day, no single particle with a larger energy was recorded. It is therefore publicly referred to as the Oh-My-God particle.

Air shower formation

Air shower formation in the atmosphere. First proton collides with a particle in the air creating pions, protons and neutrons. AirShower.svg
Air shower formation in the atmosphere. First proton collides with a particle in the air creating pions, protons and neutrons.

The air shower is formed by interaction of the primary cosmic ray with the atmosphere, and then by subsequent interaction of the secondary particles, and so on. Depending on the type of the primary particle, the shower particles will be created mostly by hadronic or electromagnetic interactions.

Simplified shower model

Shortly after entering the atmosphere, the primary cosmic ray (which is assumed to be a proton or nucleus in the following) is scattered by a nucleus in the atmosphere and creates a shower core - a region of high-energy hadrons that develops along the extended trajectory of the primary cosmic ray, until it is fully absorbed by either the atmosphere or the ground. The interaction and decay of particles in the shower core feeds the main particle components of the shower, which are hadrons, muons, and purely electromagnetic particles. The hadronic part of the shower consists mostly of pions, and some heavier mesons, such as kaons and mesons. [16] [17]

Neutral pions, , decay by the electroweak interaction into pairs of oppositely spinning photons, which fuel the electromagnetic component of the shower. Charged pions, , preferentially decay into muons and (anti)neutrinos via the weak interaction. The same holds true for charged and neutral kaons. In addition, kaons also produce pions. [17] Neutrinos from pion and kaon decay are usually not accounted for as parts of the shower because of their very low cross-section, and are referred to as part of the invisible energy of the shower.

Sketch of the hadronic and electromagnetic sub-cascades in an air shower. Eas hm cascade.pdf
Sketch of the hadronic and electromagnetic sub-cascades in an air shower.

Qualitatively, the particle content of a shower can be described by a simplified model, in which all particles partaking in any interaction of the shower will equally share the available energy. [18] One can assume that in each hadronic interaction, charged pions and neutral pions are produced. The neutral pions will decay into photons, which fuel the electromagnetic part of the shower. The charged pions will then continue to interact hadronically. After interactions, the share of the primary energy deposited in the hadronic component is given by

,

and the electromagnetic part thus approximately carries

.

A pion in the th generation thus carries an energy of . The reaction continues, until the pions reach a critical energy , at which they decay into muons. Thus, a total of

interactions are expected and a total of muons are produced, with . The electromagnetic part of the cascade develops in parallel by bremsstrahlung and pair production. For the sake of simplicity, photons, electrons, and positrons are often treated as equivalent particles in the shower. The electromagnetic cascade continues, until the particles reach a critical energy of , from which on they start losing most of their energy due to scattering with molecules in the atmosphere. Because , the electromagnetic particles dominate the number of particles in the shower by far. A good approximation for the number of (electromagnetic) particles produced in a shower is . Assuming each electromagnetic interaction occurs after the average radiation length , the shower will reach its maximum at a depth of approximately

,

where is assumed to be the depth of the first interaction of the cosmic ray in the atmosphere. This approximation is, however, not accurate for all types of primary particles. Especially showers from heavy nuclei will reach their maximum much earlier.

Longitudinal profile

The number of particles present in an air shower is approximately proportional to the calorimetric energy deposit of the shower. The energy deposit as a function of the surpassed atmospheric matter, as it can for example be seen by fluorescence detector telescopes, is known as the longitudinal profile of the shower. For the longitudinal profile of the shower, only the electromagnetic particles (electrons, positrons, and photons) are relevant, as they dominate the particle content and the contribution to the calorimetric energy deposit.

Number of particles for different primary energies as a function of the surpassed atmospheric depth. Eas greisen profile.pdf
Number of particles for different primary energies as a function of the surpassed atmospheric depth.

The shower profile is characterized by a fast rise in the number of particles, before the average energy of the particles falls below around the shower maximum, and a slow decay afterwards. Mathematically the profile can be well described by a slanted Gaussian, the Gaisser-Hillas function or the generalized Greisen function,

Here and using the electromagnetic radiation length in air, . marks the point of the first interaction, and is a dimensionless constant. The shower age parameter is introduced to compare showers with different starting depths and different primary energies to highlight their universal features, as for example at the shower maximum . For a shower with a first interaction at , the shower age is usually defined as

.

The image shows the ideal longitudinal profile of showers using different primary energies, as a function of the surpassed atmospheric depth or, equivalently, the number of radiation lengths .

The longitudinal profiles of showers are particularly interesting in the context of measuring the total calorimetric energy deposit and the depth of the shower maximum, , since the latter is an observable that is sensitive to type of the primary particle. The shower appears brightest in a fluorescence telescope at its maximum.

Lateral profile

For idealized electromagnetic showers, the angular and lateral distribution functions for electromagnetic particles have been derived by Japanese physicists Nishimura and Kamata. [19] For a shower of age , the density of electromagnetic particles as a function of the distance to the shower axis can be approximated by the NKG function [20]

using the number of particles , Molière radius and the common Gamma function. can be given for example by the longitudinal profile function. The lateral distribution of hadronic showers (i.e. initiated by a primary hadron, such as a proton), which contain a significantly increased amount of muons, can be well approximated by a superposition of NKG-like functions, in which different particle components are described using effective values for and .

Detection

The original particle arrives with high energy and hence a velocity near the speed of light, so the products of the collisions tend also to move generally in the same direction as the primary, while to some extent spreading sidewise. In addition, the secondary particles produce a widespread flash of light in forward direction due to the Cherenkov effect, as well as fluorescence light that is emitted isotropically from the excitation of nitrogen molecules. The particle cascade and the light produced in the atmosphere can be detected with surface detector arrays and optical telescopes. Surface detectors typically use Cherenkov detectors or scintillation counters to detect the charged secondary particles at ground level. The telescopes used to measure the fluorescence and Cherenkov light use large mirrors to focus the light on PMT clusters. Finally, air showers emit radio waves due to the deflection of electrons and positrons by the geomagnetic field. As advantage over the optical techniques, radio detection is possible around the clock and not only during dark and clear nights. Thus, several modern experiments, e.g., TAIGA, LOFAR, or the Pierre Auger Observatory use radio antennas in addition to particle detectors and optical techniques.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Electromagnetic radiation</span> Waves of the electromagnetic field

In physics, electromagnetic radiation (EMR) consists of waves of the electromagnetic (EM) field, which propagate through space and carry momentum and electromagnetic radiant energy. Types of EMR include radio waves, microwaves, infrared, (visible) light, ultraviolet, X-rays, and gamma rays, all of which are part of the electromagnetic spectrum.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Muon</span> Subatomic particle

A muon is an elementary particle similar to the electron, with an electric charge of −1 e and a spin of 1/2, but with a much greater mass. It is classified as a lepton. As with other leptons, the muon is not thought to be composed of any simpler particles; that is, it is a fundamental particle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rayleigh scattering</span> Light scattering by small particles

Rayleigh scattering, named after the 19th-century British physicist Lord Rayleigh, is the predominantly elastic scattering of light, or other electromagnetic radiation, by particles with a size much smaller than the wavelength of the radiation. For light frequencies well below the resonance frequency of the scattering medium, the amount of scattering is inversely proportional to the fourth power of the wavelength, e.g., a blue color is scattered much more than a red color as light propagates through air.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cosmic ray</span> High-energy particle, mainly originating outside the Solar system

Cosmic rays or astroparticles are high-energy particles or clusters of particles that move through space at nearly the speed of light. They originate from the Sun, from outside of the Solar System in our own galaxy, and from distant galaxies. Upon impact with Earth's atmosphere, cosmic rays produce showers of secondary particles, some of which reach the surface, although the bulk are deflected off into space by the magnetosphere or the heliosphere.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Compton scattering</span> Scattering of photons off charged particles

Compton scattering is the quantum theory of high frequency photons scattering following an interaction with a charged particle, usually an electron. Specifically, when the photon hits electrons, it releases loosely bound electrons from the outer valence shells of atoms or molecules.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Synchrotron radiation</span> Electromagnetic radiation emitted by charged particles accelerated perpendicular to their velocity

Synchrotron radiation is the electromagnetic radiation emitted when relativistic charged particles are subject to an acceleration perpendicular to their velocity. It is produced artificially in some types of particle accelerators or naturally by fast electrons moving through magnetic fields. The radiation produced in this way has a characteristic polarization, and the frequencies generated can range over a large portion of the electromagnetic spectrum.

The Greisen–Zatsepin–Kuzmin limit (GZK limit or GZK cutoff) is a theoretical upper limit on the energy of cosmic ray protons traveling from other galaxies through the intergalactic medium to our galaxy. The limit is 5×1019 eV (50 EeV), or about 8 joules (the energy of a proton travelling at ≈ 99.99999999999999999998% the speed of light). The limit is set by the slowing effect of interactions of the protons with the microwave background radiation over long distances (≈ 160 million light-years). The limit is at the same order of magnitude as the upper limit for energy at which cosmic rays have experimentally been detected, although indeed some detections appear to have exceeded the limit, as noted below. For example, one extreme-energy cosmic ray, the Oh-My-God Particle, which has been found to possess a record-breaking 3.12×1020 eV (50 joules) of energy (about the same as the kinetic energy of a 95 km/h baseball).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Renormalization</span> Method in physics used to deal with infinities

Renormalization is a collection of techniques in quantum field theory, statistical field theory, and the theory of self-similar geometric structures, that are used to treat infinities arising in calculated quantities by altering values of these quantities to compensate for effects of their self-interactions. But even if no infinities arose in loop diagrams in quantum field theory, it could be shown that it would be necessary to renormalize the mass and fields appearing in the original Lagrangian.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomson scattering</span> Low energy photon scattering off charged particles

Thomson scattering is the elastic scattering of electromagnetic radiation by a free charged particle, as described by classical electromagnetism. It is the low-energy limit of Compton scattering: the particle's kinetic energy and photon frequency do not change as a result of the scattering. This limit is valid as long as the photon energy is much smaller than the mass energy of the particle: , or equivalently, if the wavelength of the light is much greater than the Compton wavelength of the particle.

In physics, the Saha ionization equation is an expression that relates the ionization state of a gas in thermal equilibrium to the temperature and pressure. The equation is a result of combining ideas of quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics and is used to explain the spectral classification of stars. The expression was developed by physicist Meghnad Saha in 1920.

In particle physics, a shower is a cascade of secondary particles produced as the result of a high-energy particle interacting with dense matter. The incoming particle interacts, producing multiple new particles with lesser energy; each of these then interacts, in the same way, a process that continues until many thousands, millions, or even billions of low-energy particles are produced. These are then stopped in the matter and absorbed.

Intrabeam scattering (IBS) is an effect in accelerator physics where collisions between particles couple the beam emittance in all three dimensions. This generally causes the beam size to grow. In proton accelerators, intrabeam scattering causes the beam to grow slowly over a period of several hours. This limits the luminosity lifetime. In circular lepton accelerators, intrabeam scattering is counteracted by radiation damping, resulting in a new equilibrium beam emittance with a relaxation time on the order of milliseconds. Intrabeam scattering creates an inverse relationship between the smallness of the beam and the number of particles it contains, therefore limiting luminosity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gamma ray</span> Energetic electromagnetic radiation arising from radioactive decay of atomic nuclei

A gamma ray, also known as gamma radiation (symbol
γ
), is a penetrating form of electromagnetic radiation arising from the radioactive decay of atomic nuclei. It consists of the shortest wavelength electromagnetic waves, typically shorter than those of X-rays. With frequencies above 30 exahertz (3×1019 Hz), each gamma ray imparts the highest photon energy of any form of electromagnetic radiation. Paul Villard, a French chemist and physicist, discovered gamma radiation in 1900 while studying radiation emitted by radium. In 1903, Ernest Rutherford named this radiation gamma rays based on their relatively strong penetration of matter; in 1900 he had already named two less penetrating types of decay radiation (discovered by Henri Becquerel) alpha rays and beta rays in ascending order of penetrating power.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cosmic-ray observatory</span> Installation built to detect high-energy-particles coming from space

A cosmic-ray observatory is a scientific installation built to detect high-energy-particles coming from space called cosmic rays. This typically includes photons, electrons, protons, and some heavier nuclei, as well as antimatter particles. About 90% of cosmic rays are protons, 9% are alpha particles, and the remaining ~1% are other particles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cherenkov radiation</span> Electromagnetic radiation from a charged particle in a medium

Cherenkov radiation is electromagnetic radiation emitted when a charged particle passes through a dielectric medium at a speed greater than the phase velocity of light in that medium. A classic example of Cherenkov radiation is the characteristic blue glow of an underwater nuclear reactor. Its cause is similar to the cause of a sonic boom, the sharp sound heard when faster-than-sound movement occurs. The phenomenon is named after Soviet physicist Pavel Cherenkov.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Very-high-energy gamma ray</span> Gamma radiation with photon energies between 100GeV and 100TeV

Very-high-energy gamma ray (VHEGR) denotes gamma radiation with photon energies of 100 GeV (gigaelectronvolt) to 100 TeV (teraelectronvolt), i.e., 1011 to 1014 electronvolts. This is approximately equal to wavelengths between 10−17 and 10−20 meters, or frequencies of 2 × 1025 to 2 × 1028 Hz. Such energy levels have been detected from emissions from astronomical sources such as some binary star systems containing a compact object. For example, radiation emitted from Cygnus X-3 has been measured at ranges from GeV to exaelectronvolt-levels. Other astronomical sources include BL Lacertae, 3C 66A Markarian 421 and Markarian 501. Various other sources exist that are not associated with known bodies. For example, the H.E.S.S. catalog contained 64 sources in November 2011.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">High Altitude Water Cherenkov Experiment</span>

The High Altitude Water Cherenkov Experiment or High Altitude Water Cherenkov Observatory is a gamma-ray and cosmic ray observatory located on the flanks of the Sierra Negra volcano in the Mexican state of Puebla at an altitude of 4100 meters, at 18°59′41″N97°18′30.6″W. HAWC is the successor to the Milagro gamma-ray observatory in New Mexico, which was also a gamma-ray observatory based around the principle of detecting gamma-rays indirectly using the water Cherenkov method.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ter-Antonyan function</span>

The Ter-Antonyan function parameterizes the energy spectra of primary cosmic rays in the "knee" region by the continuously differentiable function of energy taking into account the rate of change of spectral slope. The function is expressed as:

The Waxman-Bahcall bound is a computed upper limit on the observed flux of high energy neutrinos based on the observed flux of high energy cosmic rays. Since the highest energy neutrinos are produced from interactions of utlra-high-energy cosmic rays, the observed rate of production of the latter places a limit on the former. It is named for John Bahcall and Eli Waxman.

In particle physics, the coincidence method is an experimental design through which particle detectors register two or more simultaneous measurements of a particular event through different interaction channels. Detection can be made by sensing the primary particle and/or through the detection of secondary reaction products. Such a method is used to increase the sensitivity of an experiment to a specific particle interaction, reducing conflation with background interactions by creating more degrees of freedom by which the particle in question may interact. The first notable use of the coincidence method was conducted in 1924 by the Bothe–Geiger coincidence experiment.

References

  1. Auger, P.; et al. (July 1939), "Extensive Cosmic-Ray Showers", Reviews of Modern Physics, 11 (3–4): 288–291, Bibcode:1939RvMP...11..288A, doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.11.288.
  2. Rossi, Bruno (August 1930). "On the Magnetic Deflection of Cosmic Rays". Physical Review. 36 (3): 606. Bibcode:1930PhRv...36..606R. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.36.606.
  3. Rossi, Bruno (1933). "Über die Eigenschaften der durchdringenden Korpuskularstrahlung im Meeresniveau". Zeitschrift für Physik (in German). Springer Science and Business Media LLC. 82 (3–4): 151–178. Bibcode:1933ZPhy...82..151R. doi:10.1007/bf01341486. ISSN   1434-6001. S2CID   121427439.
  4. Hilgert, R.; Bothe, W. (1936). "Zur Struktur der kosmischen Ultrastrahlung". Zeitschrift für Physik (in German). Springer Science and Business Media LLC. 99 (5–6): 353–362. Bibcode:1936ZPhy...99..353H. doi:10.1007/bf01330786. ISSN   1434-6001. S2CID   119935508.
  5. Auger, Pierre; Ehrenfest, P.; Maze, R.; Daudin, J.; Fréon, Robley A. (1939-07-01). "Extensive Cosmic-Ray Showers". Reviews of Modern Physics. American Physical Society (APS). 11 (3–4): 288–291. Bibcode:1939RvMP...11..288A. doi:10.1103/revmodphys.11.288. ISSN   0034-6861.
  6. Bhabha; Heitler (1937). "The passage of fast electrons and the theory of cosmic showers". Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A - Mathematical and Physical Sciences. The Royal Society. 159 (898): 432–458. Bibcode:1937RSPSA.159..432B. doi: 10.1098/rspa.1937.0082 . ISSN   0080-4630.
  7. Carlson, J. F.; Oppenheimer, J. R. (1937-02-15). "On Multiplicative Showers". Physical Review. American Physical Society (APS). 51 (4): 220–231. Bibcode:1937PhRv...51..220C. doi:10.1103/physrev.51.220. ISSN   0031-899X.
  8. Landau, L.; Rumer, G. (1938-05-19). "The cascade theory of electronic showers". Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences. The Royal Society. 166 (925): 213–228. Bibcode:1938RSPSA.166..213L. doi: 10.1098/rspa.1938.0088 . ISSN   0080-4630.
  9. Rossi, Bruno; Greisen, Kenneth (1941-10-01). "Cosmic-Ray Theory". Reviews of Modern Physics. American Physical Society (APS). 13 (4): 240–309. Bibcode:1941RvMP...13..240R. doi:10.1103/revmodphys.13.240. ISSN   0034-6861.
  10. Kamata, Koichi; Nishimura, Jun (1958). "The Lateral and the Angular Structure Functions of Electron Showers". Progress of Theoretical Physics Supplement. Oxford University Press (OUP). 6: 93–155. Bibcode:1958PThPS...6...93K. doi: 10.1143/ptps.6.93 . ISSN   0375-9687.
  11. CLARK, G.; EARL, J.; KRAUSHAAR, W.; LINSLEY, J.; ROSSI, B.; SCHERB, F. (1957). "An Experiment on Air Showers Produced by High-Energy Cosmic Rays". Nature. Springer Science and Business Media LLC. 180 (4582): 353–356. Bibcode:1957Natur.180..353C. doi:10.1038/180353a0. ISSN   0028-0836. S2CID   4173505.
  12. Linsley, John (1963-02-15). "Evidence for a Primary Cosmic-Ray Particle with Energy 10^20eV". Physical Review Letters. American Physical Society (APS). 10 (4): 146–148. doi:10.1103/physrevlett.10.146. ISSN   0031-9007.
  13. Greisen, Kenneth (1960). "Cosmic Ray Showers". Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science. 10: 63–108. Bibcode:1960ARNPS..10...63G. doi:10.1146/annurev.ns.10.120160.000431.
  14. Bergeson, H. E.; Cassiday, G. L.; Chiu, T. -W.; Cooper, D. A.; Elbert, J. W.; Loh, E. C.; Steck, D.; West, W. J.; Linsley, J.; Mason, G. W. (1977-09-26). "Measurement of Light Emission from Remote Cosmic-Ray Air Showers". Physical Review Letters. American Physical Society (APS). 39 (13): 847–849. Bibcode:1977PhRvL..39..847B. doi:10.1103/physrevlett.39.847. ISSN   0031-9007.
  15. Bird, D. J.; Corbato, S. C.; Dai, H. Y.; Elbert, J. W.; Green, K. D.; Huang, M. A.; Kieda, D. B.; Ko, S.; Larsen, C. G.; Loh, E. C.; Luo, M. Z.; Salamon, M. H.; Smith, J. D.; Sokolsky, P.; Sommers, P.; Tang, J. K. K.; Thomas, S. B. (1995). "Detection of a cosmic ray with measured energy well beyond the expected spectral cutoff due to cosmic microwave radiation". The Astrophysical Journal. American Astronomical Society. 441: 144. arXiv: astro-ph/9410067 . Bibcode:1995ApJ...441..144B. doi: 10.1086/175344 . ISSN   0004-637X.
  16. Gaisser, T. K., Engel, R., & Resconi, E. (2016). Cosmic Rays and Particle Physics: 2nd Edition. Cambridge University Press.
  17. 1 2 Rao, M. (1998). Extensive Air Showers. World Scientific. p. 10. ISBN   9789810228880.
  18. Matthews, J. (2005). "A Heitler model of extensive air showers". Astroparticle Physics. Elsevier BV. 22 (5–6): 387–397. Bibcode:2005APh....22..387M. doi:10.1016/j.astropartphys.2004.09.003. ISSN   0927-6505.
  19. Kamata, Koichi; Nishimura, Jun (1958). "The Lateral and the Angular Structure Functions of Electron Showers". Progress of Theoretical Physics Supplement. Oxford University Press (OUP). 6: 93–155. Bibcode:1958PThPS...6...93K. doi: 10.1143/ptps.6.93 . ISSN   0375-9687.
  20. Greisen, Kennet (1960). "Cosmic Ray Showers". Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science. 10: 63–108. Bibcode:1960ARNPS..10...63G. doi:10.1146/annurev.ns.10.120160.000431.