Attack at Mocodome

Attack at Mocodome
Part of Father Le Loutre's War
John Connor, Old Burying Ground (Halifax, Nova Scotia)
Date February 21, 1753 Location Mocodome [1] (present-day Country Harbour), Nova Scotia Result Mi'kmaq victory
Belligerents
Mi'kmaq	British America
Commanders and leaders
Unknown	John Connor James Grace Michael Haggarthy  † John Power  †
Strength
Unknown
Casualties and losses
6 Mi'kmaq	2 killed, 2 prisoners

The attack at Mocodome was a battle which occurred during Father Le Loutre's War in present-day Country Harbour, Nova Scotia ^{[lower-alpha 1]} on February 21, 1753 which saw two British mariners and six Mi'kmaq killed. The battle ended any hope for the survival of the Treaty of 1752 signed by Governor Peregrine Hopson and Mi'kmaq chief Jean-Baptiste Cope.

Historical context

Main article: Military history of the Miꞌkmaq people

Despite the British Conquest of Acadia in 1710, Nova Scotia remained primarily occupied by Catholic Acadians and Mi'kmaq. By the time Cornwallis had arrived in Halifax, there was a long history of the Wabanaki Confederacy (which included the Mi'kmaq) attacking British colonists attempting to establish new settlements along the New England frontier in Maine (See the Northeast Coast Campaigns 1688, 1703, 1723, 1724, 1745, 1746, 1747). ^{[2] [3] [4]}

To prevent the establishment of a permanent British colonial presence in the region, Mi'kmaq raided the New England settlements of present-day Shelburne (1715) and Canso (1720). A generation later, Father Le Loutre's War began when Edward Cornwallis arrived to establish Halifax with 13 transports on June 21, 1749. ^[5] The British quickly began to establish other colonial settlements. To guard against Mi'kmaq, Acadian and French attacks on their new settlements, British fortifications were erected in Halifax (1749), Bedford (Fort Sackville) (1749), Dartmouth (1750), Lunenburg (1753) and Lawrencetown (1754). ^[6] There were numerous Mi'kmaq and Acadian raids on these villages such as the Raid on Dartmouth (1751). ^[7]

After the 1749 Raid on Dartmouth, Governor Edward Cornwallis offered a bounty on the head of every Mi'kmaq. Cornwallis paid the New England Rangers the same rate per scalp as the French paid the Mi'kmaq for British scalps. ^{[8] [lower-alpha 2]}

After eighteen months of inconclusive fighting, uncertainties and second thoughts began to disturb both the Mi'kmaq and the British leadership. By the summer of 1751, Governor Cornwallis began a more conciliatory policy. On 16 February 1752, hoping to lay the groundwork for a peace treaty, Cornwallis repealed his 1749 scalp proclamation against the Wabanaki Confederacy. ^[9] For more than a year, Cornwallis sought out Mi'kmaq leaders willing to negotiate a peace. He eventually gave up, resigned his commission and left the colony. ^[10]

With a new Governor in place, Governor Peregrine Thomas Hopson, the first willing Mi'kmaq negotiator was Cope. On 22 November 1752, Cope finished negotiating a peace for the Mi'kmaq at Shubenacadie. ^{[lower-alpha 3]} The basis of the treaty was the one signed in Boston which closed Dummer's War (1725). ^{[lower-alpha 4]} Cope tried to get other Mi'kmaq chiefs in Nova Scotia to agree to the treaty but was unsuccessful. The Governor became suspicious of Cope's actual leadership among the Mi'kmaq people. ^[11] Of course, Le Loutre and the French were outraged at Cope's decision to negotiate at all with the British.^{[ citation needed ]}

Battle

According to Charles Morris's account, John Connor and three other mariners onboard the British schooner Dunk from Canso, Nova Scotia, put into Jeddore and looted Mi'kmaq-owned stores, which consisted of 40 barrels of provisions given them by the Governor. At present-day Country harbour on 21 February 1753, nine Mi'kmaq from present-day Antigonish (also known as Nartigouneche) captured Connor and the three other crew members from the Dunk: James Grace, Michael Haggarthy and John Power. The Mi'kmaq fired on them and drove them toward the shore. Other natives joined in and boarded the schooner, forcing them to run their vessel into an inlet. The Mi'kmaq then captured, killed and scalped Haggarthy and Power. ^[12] The Mi'kmaq took Connor and Grace captive for seven weeks. After seven weeks in captivity, on April 8, the two captives killed six Mi'kmaq, including four men (and a woman and her child in retaliation for the Mi'kmaq murder of Conner's wife and son in 1751). Free of their captors, Connor and Grace effected their escape. ^{[13] [14]}

In contrast, according to Anthony Casteel, after looting provisions from the Mi'kmaq at Jeddore, the Dunk accidentally was shipwrecked and two of the four crew members drowned. ^[15] The two survivors, despite the Mi'kmaw showing hospitality towards them, killed seven Mi'kmaq: two men, three women, and two children before escaping. In response, the Mi'kmaq were reported to have gone to Halifax to complain about their provisions were being looted during the fishing season. ^[16]

A French officer at Louisbourg criticized Casteel's account of events as being unsubstianted. ^{[17] [lower-alpha 5]} If Connor and Grace were only motivated by scalp money as Casteel asserted, it is unclear who would have paid them for Mi'kmaw scalps given Governor Cornwallis ended the bounty for Mi'kmaw prisoners and scalps the previous year.^{[ citation needed ]}

Aftermath

In response, on the night of April 21, under the leadership of Jean-Baptiste Cope, the Mi'kmaq attacked a British schooner at Jeddore. There were nine British sailors and one Acadian, Anthony Casteel, who was serving as an interpreter. The Mi'kmaq killed the sailors and let Casteel go at Port Toulouse, where the Mi'kmaq sank the schooner after looting it. ^[18] Cope's peace treaty was ultimately rejected by most of the other Mi'kmaq leaders. Cope burned the treaty six months after he signed it. ^[19] Despite the collapse of peace on the eastern shore, the British did not formally renounce the Treaty of 1752 until 1756. ^[20]

See also

• List of massacres in Canada

Notes

1. Stephen Patterson (1998), p. 97, reports the attack happened on the coast between Country Harbour and Tor Bay. Ruth Whitehead (1991), p. 137, reports the location was a little harbour to the westward of Torbay, "Martingo", "port of Mocodome". Beamish Murdoch (1865), p. 410, identifies Mocodome as present-day "Country Harbour".
2. Cornwallis's proclamation was part a tradition of European colonial authorities in the Americas issuing scalp bounties against their enemies. These were typically collected by frontiersmen and irregular forces, as European militaries were unsuited at frontier warfare against Native Americans. However, Cornwallis and his fellow officers occasionally expressed dismay over the tactics employed by colonial forces and Native Americans (See Grenier, p.152, Faragher, p. 405;, Hand, p.99).
3. Historian William Wicken (2002), p. 184, notes that there is controversy about this assertion. While there are claims that Cope made the treaty on behalf of all the Mi'kmaq, there is no written documentation to support this assertion.
4. For a detailed discussion of the treaty see Wicken (2002), pp. 183–189
5. The Mi'kmaq account of the crew of the Dunk killing infants or babies in the womb echoes the same accusations against John Gorham in his attack on Mi'kmaq near Annapolis in 1744 (See Malliard's journal). The assertion against Gorham is not supported by the evidence. In both accounts, the influence of French Catholic priests on the embellishment of these incidents is apparent. Accusing the enemy of killing babies and babies in the womb has a long history in war propaganda to objectify the enemy.

Citations

1. 1751 French Map with I. Mocodome marked
2. Scott, Tod (2016). "Mi'kmaw Armed Resistance to British Expansion in Northern New England (1676–1761)". Royal Nova Scotia Historical Society . 19: 1–18.
3. Reid, John G.; Baker, Emerson W. (2008). "Amerindian Power in the Early Modern Northeast: A Reappraisal". Essays on Northeastern North America, Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries. University of Toronto Press. pp. 129–152. doi:10.3138/9781442688032. ISBN   978-0-8020-9137-6. JSTOR   10.3138/9781442688032.12.
4. Grenier, John. The Far Reaches of Empire. War in Nova Scotia, 1710-1760. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, 2008.
5. Grenier, John. The Far Reaches of Empire. War in Nova Scotia, 1710-1760. Norman: U of Oklahoma P, 2008; Thomas Beamish Akins. History of Halifax, Brookhouse Press. 1895. (2002 edition). p 7
6. John Grenier. The Far Reaches of Empire: War in Nova Scotia, 1710-1760. Oklahoma University Press.
7. Grenier pp. 154–155. For the Raids on Dartmouth see the Diary of John Salusbury (diarist): Expeditions of Honour: The Journal of John Salusbury in Halifax; also see A genuine narrative of the transactions in Nova Scotia since the settlement, June 1749, till August the 5th, 1751 [microform] : in which the nature, soil, and produce of the country are related, with the particular attempts of the Indians to disturb the colony / by John Wilson. Also see http://www.blupete.com/Hist/NovaScotiaBk1/Part5/Ch07.htm
8. Thomas Akins. History of Halifax, Brookhouse Press. 1895. (2002 edition). p 19
9. Patterson, p. 134
10. Plank, 1996, p.34
11. Plank, 2001, p.135
12. Halifax Gazette 28 April 1753
13. Diary of Anthony Casteel; Atkins. Public Documents, pp. 694–695
14. Diary of Anthony Casteel
15. Diary of Anthony Casteel, p. 118
16. Account by Joseph Morrice in the Diary of Anthony Casteel, p. 118
17. Whitehead (1991) , p. 137; Patterson (1998) , p. 99
18. Whitehead (1991) , p. 137; Patterson (1994) , p. 135
19. Plank (1996), pp. 33–34.
20. Patterson (1994), p. 138.

References

Primary sources

• Diary of Anthony Casteel
• Atkins. Selections from the Public Documents of the province of Nova Scotia, Connor and Grace account pp. 694-695
• The London magazine, or, Gentleman's monthly intelligencer ... v.22 1753, p. 242
• Halifax Gazette. 24 April 1753
• April 28, 1753, Halifax Gazette
• newspaper

Secondary sources

• Faragher, John. Great and Noble Scheme. New York: Norton, 2005.
• Grenier, John. The Far Reaches of Empire. War in Nova Scotia, 1710-1760. Norman: U of Oklahoma P, 2008. pp. 154–155
• Griffiths, N.E.S. (2005). From Migrant to Acadian: A North American Border People, 1604-1755. McGill-Queen's University Press. ISBN   978-0-7735-2699-0.
• Landry, Peter. The Lion & The Lily. Vol. 1. Victoria: Trafford, 2007.
• Murdoch, Beamish (1865). A History of Nova-Scotia, Or Acadie. Vol. I. Halifax: J. Barnes.
• Murdoch, Beamish (1866). A History of Nova-Scotia, Or Acadie. Vol. II. Halifax: J. Barnes.
• Patterson, Stephen E. (1994). "1744–1763: Colonial Wars and Aboriginal Peoples". In Phillip Buckner; John G. Reid (eds.). The Atlantic Region to Confederation: A History. University of Toronto Press. pp. 125–155. ISBN   978-1-4875-1676-5. JSTOR   10.3138/j.ctt15jjfrm.
• Patterson, Stephen E. (1998). "Indian-White Relations in Nova Scotia, 1749-61: A Study in Political Interaction". In P.A. Buckner; Gail G. Campbell; David Frank (eds.). The Acadiensis Reader: Atlantic Canada Before Confederation (3rd ed.). Acadiensis Press. pp.  105-106. ISBN   978-0-919107-44-1.
• Plank, Geoffrey (Spring 1996). "The Two Majors Cope: the boundaries of Nationality in Mid-18th Century Nova Scotia". Acadiensis . 25 (2): 18–40. JSTOR   30302888.
• Rompkey, Ronald, ed. Expeditions of Honour: The Journal of John Salusbury in Halifax, Nova Scotia, 1749-53. Newark: U of Delaware P, Newark, 1982.
• John Clarence Webster. The career of the Abbé Le Loutre in Nova Scotia (Shediac, N.B., 1933),
• Wicken, William C. (2002). Mi'kmaq Treaties on Trial: History, Land and Donald Marshall Junior. University of Toronto Press. ISBN   978-0-8020-7665-6.
• Whitehead, Ruth Holmes (1991). The Old Man Told Us: Excerpts from Micmac History, 1500-1950. Nimbus. ISBN   978-0-921054-83-2.

45°18′22″N61°37′25″W / 45.30611°N 61.62361°W / 45.30611; -61.62361