Bank failure

Last updated

Depositors "run" on a failing New York City bank in an effort to recover their money, July 1914 Schwenk-bank-failure-1914.jpg
Depositors "run" on a failing New York City bank in an effort to recover their money, July 1914

A bank failure occurs when a bank is unable to meet its obligations to its depositors or other creditors because it has become insolvent or too illiquid to meet its liabilities. [1] Failing banks share commonalities: rising asset losses, deteriorating solvency, and an increasing reliance on expensive noncore funding. [2]

Contents

A bank typically fails economically when the market value of its assets falls below the market value of its liabilities. The insolvent bank either borrows from other solvent banks or sells its assets at a lower price than its market value to generate liquid money to pay its depositors on demand. The inability of the solvent banks to lend liquid money to the insolvent bank creates a bank panic among the depositors as more depositors try to take out cash deposits from the bank. As such, the bank is unable to fulfill the demands of all of its depositors on time. A bank may be taken over by the regulating government agency if its shareholders' equity are below the regulatory minimum.

The failure of a bank is generally considered to be of more importance than the failure of other types of business firms because of the interconnectedness and fragility of banking institutions. Research has shown that the market value of customers of the failed banks is adversely affected at the date of the failure announcements. [3] It is often feared that the spill over effects of a failure of one bank can quickly spread throughout the economy and possibly result in the failure of other banks, whether or not those banks were solvent at the time as the marginal depositors try to take out cash deposits from these banks to avoid from suffering losses. Thereby, the spill over effect of bank panic or systemic risk has a multiplier effect on all banks and financial institutions leading to a greater effect of bank failure in the economy. As a result, banking institutions are typically subjected to rigorous regulation, and bank failures are of major public policy concern in countries across the world. [4]

Notable acquisitions of failed banks

The following table lists significant acquisitions of failed banks, illustrating the scale and impact of major bank failures. It does not include partial purchases by governments to prevent bank or banking system failures, such as government intervention during the subprime mortgage crisis:

Announcement dateTargetAcquirerTransaction value
(US$ billion)
Type
1999-11-29 [5] Flag of the United Kingdom.svg National Westminster Bank Plc Flag of Scotland.svg Royal Bank of Scotland 42.5
2003-10-27 [6] Flag of the United States.svg FleetBoston Financial Flag of the United States.svg Bank of America 47
2004-01-15 [7] Flag of the United States.svg Bank One Corporation Flag of the United States.svg JPMorgan Chase 58
2006-01-01 [8] Flag of the United States.svg MBNA Flag of the United States.svg Bank of America34.2
2007-05-20 [9] Flag of Italy.svg Capitalia Flag of Italy.svg UniCredit 29.47
2007-09-28 [10] Flag of the United States.svg NetBank Flag of the Netherlands.svg ING Group 0.014
2008-02-22 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Northern Rock Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Government of the United Kingdom 41.213
2008-04-01 Flag of the United States.svg Bear Stearns Flag of the United States.svg JPMorgan2.2
2008-07-01 Flag of the United States.svg Countrywide Financial Flag of the United States.svg Bank of America4
2008-07-10 Flag of Denmark.svg Roskilde Bank Flag of Denmark.svg Nationalbanken (Centralbank of Denmark)15
2008-07-14 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Alliance & Leicester Flag of Spain.svg Santander1.93
2008-08-31 Flag of Germany.svg Dresdner Kleinwort Flag of Germany.svg Commerzbank 10.812
2008-09-07 Flag of the United States.svg Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Flag of the United States.svg Federal Housing Finance Agency 5,000[ dubious discuss ] Federal conservatorship with expected return to independent management
2008-09-14 Flag of the United States.svg Merrill Lynch Flag of the United States.svg Bank of America44
2008-09-17 Flag of the United States.svg Lehman Brothers Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Barclays 1.3
2008-09-18 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg HBOS Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Lloyds TSB 33.475
2008-09-26 Flag of the United States.svg Lehman Brothers Flag of Japan.svg Nomura Holdings 1.3
2008-09-26 Flag of the United States.svg Washington Mutual Flag of the United States.svg JPMorgan1.9
2008-09-28 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Bradford & Bingley Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Government of the United Kingdom Flag of Spain.svg Santander1.838
2008-09-28 Flag of Belgium (civil).svg Flag of Luxembourg.svg Flag of the Netherlands.svg Fortis Flag of France.svg BNP Paribas 12.356
2008-09-29 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Abbey National Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Government of the United Kingdom Flag of Spain.svg Santander2.298
2008-09-30 Flag of Belgium (civil).svg Dexia Flag of Belgium (civil).svg Flag of France.svg Flag of Luxembourg.svg The Governments of Belgium, France and Luxembourg7.06
2008-10-03 Flag of the United States.svg Wachovia Flag of the United States.svg Wells Fargo 15
2008-10-03 Flag of the Netherlands.svg ABN AMRO

Flag of the Netherlands.svg Fortis

Flag of the Netherlands.svg NL Financial Investments  [ nl ](Ministry of Finance )23.3 [11] Breakup, nationalization of some components with return to publicly traded company [12]
2008-10-07 Flag of Iceland.svg Landsbanki Flag of Iceland.svg Icelandic Financial Supervisory Authority 4.192UK assets seized by UK government; bad assets nationalized by Iceland and retail operations reorganized as Landsbankinn
2008-10-08 Flag of Iceland.svg Glitnir Flag of Iceland.svg Icelandic Financial Supervisory Authority3.254
2008-10-09 Flag of Iceland.svg Kaupthing Bank Flag of Iceland.svg Icelandic Financial Supervisory Authority1.257
2008-10-13 Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Lloyds Banking Group Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Government of the United Kingdom26.045
2008-10-13 Flag of Scotland.svg Royal Bank of Scotland Group Flag of the United Kingdom.svg Government of the United Kingdom30.641
2008-10-14 Flag of the United States.svg Bank of America Flag of the United States.svg United States Federal Government 45
2008-10-14 Flag of the United States.svg Bank of New York Mellon Flag of the United States.svg United States Federal Government3
2008-10-14 Flag of the United States.svg Goldman Sachs Flag of the United States.svg United States Federal Government10
2008-10-14 Flag of the United States.svg JP Morgan Flag of the United States.svg United States Federal Government25
2008-10-14 Flag of the United States.svg Morgan Stanley Flag of the United States.svg United States Federal Government10
2008-10-14 Flag of the United States.svg State Street Flag of the United States.svg United States Federal Government2
2008-10-14 Flag of the United States.svg Wells Fargo Flag of the United States.svg United States Federal Government25
2009-02-11 Flag of Ireland.svg Allied Irish Bank Flag of Ireland.svg Government of the Republic of Ireland 3.861
2009-02-11 Flag of Ireland.svg Anglo Irish Bank Flag of Ireland.svg Government of the Republic of Ireland13.57
2009-02-11 Flag of Ireland.svg Bank of Ireland Flag of Ireland.svg Government of the Republic of Ireland3.861
2009-03-19 [13] Flag of the United States.svg IndyMac Flag of the United States.svg OneWest Bank unknown
2012-03-13 Flag of Greece.svg Alpha Bank Flag of Greece.svg Government of Greece 2.096
2012-03-13 Flag of Greece.svg Eurobank Flag of Greece.svg Government of Greece4.633
2012-03-13 Flag of Greece.svg National Bank of Greece Flag of Greece.svg Government of Greece7.612
2012-03-13 Flag of Greece.svg Piraeus Bank Flag of Greece.svg Government of Greece5.516
2012-03-25 Flag of Cyprus.svg Laiki Bank Flag of Cyprus.svg Bank of Cyprus 10.812
2012-05-25 Flag of Spain.svg Bankia Flag of Spain.svg Government of Spain 20.962
2012-06-07 Flag of Portugal (official).svg Caixa Geral de Depositos Flag of Portugal (official).svg Government of Portugal 1.78
2012-06-07 Flag of Portugal (official).svg Millennium BCP Flag of Portugal (official).svg Government of Portugal3.3

Bank failures in the U.S.

In the U.S., deposits in savings and checking accounts are backed by the FDIC. As of 1933, each account owner is insured up to $250,000 in the event of a bank failure. [14] When a bank fails, in addition to insuring the deposits, the FDIC acts as the receiver of the failed bank, taking control of the bank's assets and deciding how to settle its debts. The number of bank failures has been tracked and published by the FDIC since 1934, and has decreased after a peak in 2010 due to the 2008 financial crisis. [15]

Since the year 2000, over 500 banks have failed. The 2010s saw the most bank failures in recent memory, with 367 banks collapsing over that decade. However, while the 2010s saw the most banks fail, it wasn't the worst decade in terms of the value of the banks going under. The 2000s saw 192 banks go under with $533 billion in assets ($749 billion in 2023 dollars) compared to the $273 billion ($354 billion) lost in the 2010s. [16]

No advance notice is given to the public when a bank fails. [1] Under ideal circumstances, a bank failure can occur without customers losing access to their funds at any point. For example, in the 2008 failure of Washington Mutual the FDIC was able to broker a deal in which JP Morgan Chase bought the assets of Washington Mutual for $1.9 billion. [17] Existing customers were immediately turned into JP Morgan Chase customers, without disruption in their ability to use their ATM cards or do banking at branches. [18] Such policies are designed to discourage bank runs that might cause economic damage on a wider scale.[ citation needed ]

Global failure

The failure of a bank is relevant not only to the country in which it is headquartered, but for all other nations with which it conducts business. This dynamic was highlighted during the 2008 financial crisis, when the failures of major bulge bracket investment banks affected local economies globally. This interconnectedness was manifested not on a high level, with respect to deals negotiated between major companies from different parts of the world, but also to the global nature of any one company's makeup. Outsourcing is a key example of this makeup; as major banks such as Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns failed, the employees from countries other than the United States suffered in turn. A 2015 analysis by the Bank of England found greater interconnectedness between banks has led to a greater transmission of stresses during a time of recession. [19]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 "When a Bank Fails – Facts for Depositors, Creditors, and Borrowers". Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.
  2. Correia, Sergio; Luck, Stephan; Verner, Emil (2025). "Failing Banks". The Quarterly Journal of Economics. doi:10.1093/qje/qjaf044. ISSN   0033-5533.
  3. Brewer III, Elijah; Genay, Hesna; Hunter, William Curt; Kaufman, George G. (August 26, 2002). "The Value of Banking Relationships During a Financial Crisis: Evidence from Failures of Japanese Banks" (PDF). Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago . Archived (PDF) from the original on December 25, 2016. Retrieved May 14, 2021.
  4. "Bank Failures, Systemic Risk, and Bank Regulation" (PDF). The Cato Institute. Spring 1996. Archived from the original on December 8, 2008.
  5. "RBS launches $43B bid for NatWest – Nov. 29, 1999". money.cnn.com. Retrieved May 14, 2021.
  6. "Bank of America to acquire FleetBoston for $47B – Oct. 27, 2003". CNN . October 27, 2003.
  7. "J.P. Morgan to buy Bank One for $58 billion – Jan. 15, 2004". CNN . January 15, 2004.
  8. "Bank Of America Acquires MBNA". CBS News . Associated Press. January 1, 2006.
  9. Biondi, Paolo; Sisto, Alberto (May 20, 2007). "UniCredit agrees to buy Capitalia in $29 bln deal". Reuters. Retrieved May 14, 2021.
  10. Wilchins, Dan (September 28, 2007). "ING Bank to acquire NetBank deposits". Reuters. Retrieved May 14, 2021.
  11. Schwartz, Nelson D. (October 3, 2008). "Dutch government nationalizes Fortis' operations in the Netherlands". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved July 23, 2025.
  12. "Het einde voor ABN Amro als staatsbank is in zicht". RTL.nl (in Dutch). May 22, 2015. Retrieved July 23, 2025.
  13. "OneWest completes acquisition of Indymac Assets". Reuters. March 20, 2009. Retrieved May 14, 2021.
  14. "Deposit Insurance FAQs". Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.
  15. "FDIC | Failed Bank List". Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.
  16. Laycock, Richard (May 11, 2023). "List of bank failures: 2000 to 2023 | Finder". finder.com. Retrieved May 12, 2023.
  17. Ellis, David; Sahadi, Jeanne (September 26, 2008). "JPMorgan buys WaMu". CNN .
  18. "OTS 08-046 – Washington Mutual Acquired by JPMorgan Chase". Office of Thrift Supervision. September 25, 2008. Archived from the original on January 15, 2009.
  19. Zijun, Liu; Quiet, Stephanie; Roth, Benedict (2015). "Banking sector interconnectedness: what is it, how can we measure it and why does it matter?" (PDF). Bank of England . Archived (PDF) from the original on October 5, 2021.

Further reading