Borsuk's conjecture

Last updated
An example of a hexagon cut into three pieces of smaller diameter. Borsuk Hexagon.svg
An example of a hexagon cut into three pieces of smaller diameter.
Unsolved problem in mathematics:
Can every bounded subset E of the space be partitioned into (n + 1) sets, each of which has a smaller diameter than E?

The Borsuk problem in geometry, for historical reasons [note 1] incorrectly called Borsuk's conjecture , is a question in discrete geometry. It is named after Karol Borsuk.

Contents

Problem

In 1932, Karol Borsuk showed [2] that an ordinary 3-dimensional ball in Euclidean space can be easily dissected into 4 solids, each of which has a smaller diameter than the ball, and generally n-dimensional ball can be covered with n + 1 compact sets of diameters smaller than the ball. At the same time he proved that n subsets are not enough in general. The proof is based on the Borsuk–Ulam theorem. That led Borsuk to a general question: [2]

Die folgende Frage bleibt offen: Lässt sich jede beschränkte Teilmenge E des Raumes in (n + 1) Mengen zerlegen, von denen jede einen kleineren Durchmesser als E hat?

The following question remains open: Can every bounded subset E of the space be partitioned into (n + 1) sets, each of which has a smaller diameter than E?

Drei Sätze über die n-dimensionale euklidische Sphäre

The question was answered in the positive in the following cases:

The problem was finally solved in 1993 by Jeff Kahn and Gil Kalai, who showed that the general answer to Borsuk's question is no. [9] They claim that their construction shows that n + 1 pieces do not suffice for n = 1325 and for each n > 2014. However, as pointed out by Bernulf Weißbach, [10] the first part of this claim is in fact false. But after improving a suboptimal conclusion within the corresponding derivation, one can indeed verify one of the constructed point sets as a counterexample for n = 1325 (as well as all higher dimensions up to 1560). [11]

Their result was improved in 2003 by Hinrichs and Richter, who constructed finite sets for n ≥ 298, which cannot be partitioned into n + 11 parts of smaller diameter. [1]

In 2013, Andriy V. Bondarenko had shown that Borsuk's conjecture is false for all n ≥ 65. [12] Shortly after, Thomas Jenrich derived a 64-dimensional counterexample from Bondarenko's construction, giving the best bound up to now. [13] [14]

Apart from finding the minimum number n of dimensions such that the number of pieces α(n) > n + 1, mathematicians are interested in finding the general behavior of the function α(n). Kahn and Kalai show that in general (that is, for n sufficiently large), one needs many pieces. They also quote the upper bound by Oded Schramm, who showed that for every ε, if n is sufficiently large, . [15] The correct order of magnitude of α(n) is still unknown. [16] However, it is conjectured that there is a constant c > 1 such that α(n) > cn for all n ≥ 1.

Oded Schramm also worked in a related question, a body of constant width is said to have effective radius if , where is the unit ball in , he proved the lower bound , where is the smallest effective radius of a body of constant width 2 in and asked if there exists such that for all , [17] [18] that is if the gap between the volumes of the smallest and largest constant-width bodies grows exponentially. In 2024 a preprint by Arman, Bondarenko, Nazarov, Prymak, Radchenko reported to have answered this question in the affirmative giving a construction that satisfies . [19] [20] [21]

See also

Note

  1. As Hinrichs and Richter say in the introduction to their work, [1] the "Borsuk's conjecture [was] believed by many to be true for some decades" (hence commonly called a conjecture) so "it came as a surprise when Kahn and Kalai constructed finite sets showing the contrary". However, Karol Borsuk has formulated the problem just as a question, not suggesting the expected answer would be positive.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hodge conjecture</span> Unsolved problem in geometry

In mathematics, the Hodge conjecture is a major unsolved problem in algebraic geometry and complex geometry that relates the algebraic topology of a non-singular complex algebraic variety to its subvarieties.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Diophantine approximation</span> Rational-number approximation of a real number

In number theory, the study of Diophantine approximation deals with the approximation of real numbers by rational numbers. It is named after Diophantus of Alexandria.

In mathematical measure theory, for every positive integer n the ham sandwich theorem states that given n measurable "objects" in n-dimensional Euclidean space, it is possible to divide each one of them in half (with respect to their measure, e.g. volume) with a single (n − 1)-dimensional hyperplane. This is possible even if the objects overlap.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">3-manifold</span> Mathematical space

In mathematics, a 3-manifold is a topological space that locally looks like a three-dimensional Euclidean space. A 3-manifold can be thought of as a possible shape of the universe. Just as a sphere looks like a plane to a small and close enough observer, all 3-manifolds look like our universe does to a small enough observer. This is made more precise in the definition below.

In geometric topology, the Property P conjecture is a statement about 3-manifolds obtained by Dehn surgery on a knot in the 3-sphere. A knot in the 3-sphere is said to have Property P if every 3-manifold obtained by performing (non-trivial) Dehn surgery on the knot is not simply-connected. The conjecture states that all knots, except the unknot, have Property P.

The Fulkerson Prize for outstanding papers in the area of discrete mathematics is sponsored jointly by the Mathematical Optimization Society (MOS) and the American Mathematical Society (AMS). Up to three awards of $1,500 each are presented at each (triennial) International Symposium of the MOS. Originally, the prizes were paid out of a memorial fund administered by the AMS that was established by friends of the late Delbert Ray Fulkerson to encourage mathematical excellence in the fields of research exemplified by his work. The prizes are now funded by an endowment administered by MPS.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hadwiger conjecture (graph theory)</span> Unproven generalization of the four-color theorem

In graph theory, the Hadwiger conjecture states that if is loopless and has no minor then its chromatic number satisfies . It is known to be true for . The conjecture is a generalization of the four-color theorem and is considered to be one of the most important and challenging open problems in the field.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Schanuel's conjecture</span> Major unsolved problem in transcendental number theory

In mathematics, specifically transcendental number theory, Schanuel's conjecture is a conjecture about the transcendence degree of certain field extensions of the rational numbers , which would establish the transcendence of a large class of numbers, for which this is currently unknown. It is due to Stephen Schanuel and was published by Serge Lang in 1966.

In additive combinatorics, a discipline within mathematics, Freiman's theorem is a central result which indicates the approximate structure of sets whose sumset is small. It roughly states that if is small, then can be contained in a small generalized arithmetic progression.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hirsch conjecture</span> On lengths of shortest paths in convex polytopes

In mathematical programming and polyhedral combinatorics, the Hirsch conjecture is the statement that the edge-vertex graph of an n-facet polytope in d-dimensional Euclidean space has diameter no more than n − d. That is, any two vertices of the polytope must be connected to each other by a path of length at most n − d. The conjecture was first put forth in a letter by Warren M. Hirsch to George B. Dantzig in 1957 and was motivated by the analysis of the simplex method in linear programming, as the diameter of a polytope provides a lower bound on the number of steps needed by the simplex method. The conjecture is now known to be false in general.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gil Kalai</span> Israeli mathematician and computer scientist

Gil Kalai is an Israeli mathematician and computer scientist. He is the Henry and Manya Noskwith Professor Emeritus of Mathematics at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel, Professor of Computer Science at the Interdisciplinary Center, Herzliya, and adjunct Professor of mathematics and of computer science at Yale University, United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hadwiger conjecture (combinatorial geometry)</span>

In combinatorial geometry, the Hadwiger conjecture states that any convex body in n-dimensional Euclidean space can be covered by 2n or fewer smaller bodies homothetic with the original body, and that furthermore, the upper bound of 2n is necessary if and only if the body is a parallelepiped. There also exists an equivalent formulation in terms of the number of floodlights needed to illuminate the body.

The Koukoulopoulos–Maynard theorem, also known as the Duffin-Schaeffer conjecture, is a theorem in mathematics, specifically, the Diophantine approximation proposed as a conjecture by R. J. Duffin and A. C. Schaeffer in 1941 and proven in 2019 by Dimitris Koukoulopoulos and James Maynard. It states that if is a real-valued function taking on positive values, then for almost all , the inequality

In geometry, more specifically in polytope theory, Kalai's 3d conjecture is a conjecture on the polyhedral combinatorics of centrally symmetric polytopes, made by Gil Kalai in 1989. It states that every d-dimensional centrally symmetric polytope has at least 3d nonempty faces.

In geometry, it is an unsolved conjecture of Hugo Hadwiger that every simplex can be dissected into orthoschemes, using a number of orthoschemes bounded by a function of the dimension of the simplex. If true, then more generally every convex polytope could be dissected into orthoschemes.

In mathematics, the Bing–Borsuk conjecture states that every -dimensional homogeneous absolute neighborhood retract space is a topological manifold. The conjecture has been proved for dimensions 1 and 2, and it is known that the 3-dimensional version of the conjecture implies the Poincaré conjecture.

Chern's conjecture for hypersurfaces in spheres, unsolved as of 2018, is a conjecture proposed by Chern in the field of differential geometry. It originates from the Chern's unanswered question:

Consider closed minimal submanifolds immersed in the unit sphere with second fundamental form of constant length whose square is denoted by . Is the set of values for discrete? What is the infimum of these values of ?

The Kahn–Kalai conjecture, also known as the expectation threshold conjecture or more recently the Park-Pham Theorem, was a conjecture in the field of graph theory and statistical mechanics, proposed by Jeff Kahn and Gil Kalai in 2006. It was proven in a paper published in 2024.

References

  1. 1 2 Hinrichs, Aicke; Richter, Christian (28 August 2003). "New sets with large Borsuk numbers". Discrete Mathematics . 270 (1–3). Elsevier: 137–147. doi: 10.1016/S0012-365X(02)00833-6 .
  2. 1 2 Borsuk, Karol (1933), "Drei Sätze über die n-dimensionale euklidische Sphäre" [Three theorems about the n-dimensional Euclidean sphere](PDF), Fundamenta Mathematicae (in German), 20: 177–190, doi: 10.4064/fm-20-1-177-190
  3. Perkal, Julian (1947), "Sur la subdivision des ensembles en parties de diamètre inférieur", Colloquium Mathematicum (in French), 2: 45
  4. Eggleston, H. G. (1955), "Covering a three-dimensional set with sets of smaller diameter", Journal of the London Mathematical Society , 30: 11–24, doi:10.1112/jlms/s1-30.1.11, MR   0067473
  5. Hadwiger, Hugo (1945), "Überdeckung einer Menge durch Mengen kleineren Durchmessers", Commentarii Mathematici Helvetici (in German), 18 (1): 73–75, doi:10.1007/BF02568103, MR   0013901, S2CID   122199549
  6. Hadwiger, Hugo (1946), "Mitteilung betreffend meine Note: Überdeckung einer Menge durch Mengen kleineren Durchmessers", Commentarii Mathematici Helvetici (in German), 19 (1): 72–73, doi:10.1007/BF02565947, MR   0017515, S2CID   121053805
  7. Riesling, A. S. (1971), "Проблема Борсука в трехмерных пространствах постоянной кривизны" [Borsuk's problem in three-dimensional spaces of constant curvature](PDF), Ukr. Geom. Sbornik (in Russian), 11, Kharkov State University (now National University of Kharkiv): 78–83
  8. Dekster, Boris (1995), "The Borsuk conjecture holds for fields of revolution", Journal of Geometry, 52 (1–2): 64–73, doi:10.1007/BF01406827, MR   1317256, S2CID   121586146
  9. Kahn, Jeff; Kalai, Gil (1993), "A counterexample to Borsuk's conjecture", Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society , 29 (1): 60–62, arXiv: math/9307229 , doi:10.1090/S0273-0979-1993-00398-7, MR   1193538, S2CID   119647518
  10. Weißbach, Bernulf (2000), "Sets with Large Borsuk Number" (PDF), Beiträge zur Algebra und Geometrie (in German), 41 (2): 417–423
  11. Jenrich, Thomas (2018), On the counterexamples to Borsuk's conjecture by Kahn and Kalai, arXiv: 1809.09612v4
  12. Bondarenko, Andriy (2014) [2013], "On Borsuk's Conjecture for Two-Distance Sets", Discrete & Computational Geometry , 51 (3): 509–515, arXiv: 1305.2584 , doi: 10.1007/s00454-014-9579-4 , MR   3201240
  13. Jenrich, Thomas (2013), A 64-dimensional two-distance counterexample to Borsuk's conjecture, arXiv: 1308.0206 , Bibcode:2013arXiv1308.0206J
  14. Jenrich, Thomas; Brouwer, Andries E. (2014), "A 64-Dimensional Counterexample to Borsuk's Conjecture", Electronic Journal of Combinatorics , 21 (4): #P4.29, doi: 10.37236/4069 , MR   3292266
  15. Schramm, Oded (1988), "Illuminating sets of constant width", Mathematika , 35 (2): 180–189, doi:10.1112/S0025579300015175, MR   0986627
  16. Alon, Noga (2002), "Discrete mathematics: methods and challenges", Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians, Beijing, 1: 119–135, arXiv: math/0212390 , Bibcode:2002math.....12390A
  17. Schramm, Oded (June 1988). "On the volume of sets having constant width". Israel Journal of Mathematics. 63 (2): 178–182. doi:10.1007/BF02765037. ISSN   0021-2172.
  18. Kalai, Gil (2015-05-19). "Some old and new problems in combinatorial geometry I: Around Borsuk's problem". arXiv: 1505.04952 [math.CO].
  19. Arman, Andrii; Bondarenko, Andriy; Nazarov, Fedor; Prymak, Andriy; Radchenko, Danylo (2024-05-28). "Small volume bodies of constant width". arXiv: 2405.18501 [math.MG].
  20. Kalai, Gil (2024-05-31). "Andrii Arman, Andriy Bondarenko, Fedor Nazarov, Andriy Prymak, and Danylo Radchenko Constructed Small Volume Bodies of Constant Width". Combinatorics and more. Retrieved 2024-09-28.
  21. Barber, Gregory (2024-09-20). "Mathematicians Discover New Shapes to Solve Decades-Old Geometry Problem". Quanta Magazine. Retrieved 2024-09-28.

Further reading