Brooklyn Thrill Killers

Last updated
Three of the boys standing before the district Attorney, who holds up the bullwhip used in one of the attacks. 3 Brooklyn Thrill Killers with Stenographers and DA.jpg
Three of the boys standing before the district Attorney, who holds up the bullwhip used in one of the attacks.
The boys, handcuffed, alongside the corpse of Willard Mentor. Brooklyn Thrill Killers with corpse of Willard Mellard.jpg
The boys, handcuffed, alongside the corpse of Willard Mentor.

The Brooklyn Thrill Killers were a group of teenage boys who were convicted of killing one man and accused of killed another (one by drowning, the other by beating) and committed acts of assault and torture against several other people in Brooklyn, a borough of New York City during the summer of 1954. [1] [2] The case attracted considerable media attention in the United States. It also fueled the controversy over comic books, which were accused at the time of causing sexual perversion and juvenile delinquency.

Contents

Members

The four members of the gang were teenagers who belonged to Brooklyn's Jewish community: [1]

Crimes

Jack Koslow, who was later identified by AP reports as the 'brains' of the group, admired the crackdown that commissioner Francis Adams was conducting at the time in Manhattan against "social undesirables", and thought similar actions were needed to "cleanse" the streets of Brooklyn. During the summer of 1954, the crackdown in Manhattan had intensified and many "undesirables" – among whom gay men, homeless people and alcoholics – had sought refuge in Brooklyn, which inspired Koslow and his friends to take action. [1]

The four boys roamed the streets of Brooklyn, assaulting girls and beating up vagrants. [3] Koslow, who read comic books, saw himself as a crime-fighting hero and believed that his actions would help the police to restore "law and order". [1] Mittman later commented that their goal had been to "clean the streets of bums". [1] The first man killed by the gang was a local homeless alcoholic named Reinhold Ulrickson, whom they kicked and punched to death. Their second victim was Willard Mentor, a 34-year old black man who worked at a local bag factory. Koslow and Mittman found Mentor as he was sleeping on a bench after a drinking binge. They beat him and threw him in the East River, where he drowned. The four gang members were arrested shortly after Mentor's murder. [3]

After their arrest, Mittman and Koslow were belligerent and bragged that murdering Mentor had been a "supreme adventure". Koslow stated that he considered vagrants to be social "parasites". [3] Trachtenberg and Lieberman, who had not participated in Mentor's murder, [1] appeared to be relieved by their arrest. [3]

The four boys admitted to a litany of offenses, which included pouring gasoline over a man and setting him alight, and horsewhipping two young women in a public park late at night. [1] The nickname "thrill killers" was given to them by the media after Kings County's District Attorney commented that the boys, who never robbed any of their victims, [4] "apparently had no reason except the thrill they got". [1]

The crimes generated a media frenzy at the time in the United States, where the four boys were presented as symbols of juvenile delinquency. [1] The New York Times wrote that the gang members were also homosexuals and neo-nazis, [1] Life called them "Those Terrible Youth", while Inside Detective magazine nicknamed Koslow – who wore a mustache – the “Boy Hitler of Flatbush Avenue.” [3] The notoriety of the case was such at the time that in 1955, columnist Hedda Hopper suggested that the Brooklyn killers had been inspirations for the character played by James Dean in Rebel Without a Cause . [1]

Trial and convictions

At the trial, Koslow's attorney was senator Fred G. Moritt, who tried to paint the boys' actions as simple mischief and implied that Mentor's death was not a loss for society. Trachtenberg turned State's evidence and was eventually sent to a reformatory. Lieberman had the charges against him dismissed for lack of evidence. Koslow and Mittman were found guilty of felony murder during the act of kidnapping, because Mentor had been dragged several blocks before being thrown in the river. [3] This allowed the jury to suggest life in prison rather than send two youths to the electric chair. Koslow and Mittman eventually won their appeal: at their retrial, they pleaded guilty of second degree murder and were sentenced to 10 to 20 years, receiving credit for the four years they had already served in jail. The sentence made them eligible for parole in 1961. [3]

Public controversy

The case of the Brooklyn Thrill Killers is mostly remembered for its role in the controversy which surrounded at the time the comic book industry. The Court's appointed psychiatric expert was Dr Fredric Wertham, a leading critic of comic books, who had published Seduction of the Innocent earlier that year. Wertham cited the Thrill Killers as an example of the potential harm caused by comic books. [5] Specifically, a fetish pornographic comic book series named Nights of Horror was brought as evidence of Jack Koslow's "sexual perversions", and used to convict him and Mittman of their crimes. [5] When Wertham presented Koslow with copies of Nights of Horror, Koslow admitted that he read comics of that kind. Wertham concluded that the books were to blame for the crimes. However, Koslow never specifically stated that he had read Nights of Horror, and there was no evidence that any of the boys had purchased or read that particular comic book. [3]

As a result of its involvement in the trial, the Nights of Horror comic book series was seized and banned first by New York City, then by the State of New York. The case went to the Supreme Court of the United States, which upheld the ban in its Kingsley Books, Inc. v. Brown 1957 ruling.

The outrage surrounding this case fueled the public backlash against comic books, which resulted in the creation of the Comics Code Authority in October 1954. [3] Several decades later, it was revealed that the artist of Nights of Horror was Joe Shuster, the co-creator of Superman , a comic book also frequently denounced in Wertham's writings. [6]

Legacy

Derek Davidson and Paul Franco wrote and directed a 1999 short film about the events surrounding the incident and starring Chip Zien, Anne Meara, and Dan Fogler. [7]

According to historian Andrew Scott Cooper, Robert Rauschenberg placed a news clippings about this case in his combine painting Collection (1954/1955), which Cooper interprets as connecting the work to McCarthyism's hostility to homosexuality. After researching the painting, Cooper sought New York state and city records and interviewed Mittman in 2005. Cooper believes the accusations against the four were heavily exaggerated and sensationalized, as autopsy records do not support the police's claims, and the confessions given by the four were under extreme duress. [1]

Bibliography

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Saint Valentine's Day Massacre</span> 1929 gang shooting in Chicago

The Saint Valentine's Day Massacre was the murder of seven members and associates of Chicago's North Side Gang that occurred on Saint Valentine's Day 1929. The men were gathered at a Lincoln Park, Chicago garage on the morning of February 14, 1929. They were lined up against a wall and shot by four unknown assailants, two dressed as police officers.

Entertaining Comics, more commonly known as EC Comics, was an American publisher of comic books, which specialized in horror fiction, crime fiction, satire, military fiction, dark fantasy, and science fiction from the 1940s through the mid-1950s, notably the Tales from the Crypt series. Initially, EC was owned by Maxwell Gaines and specialized in educational and child-oriented stories. After Max Gaines' death in a boating accident in 1947, his son William Gaines took over the company and began to print more mature stories, delving into the genres of horror, war, fantasy, science-fiction, adventure, and others. Noted for their high quality and shock endings, these stories were also unique in their socially conscious, progressive themes that anticipated the Civil Rights Movement and the dawn of the 1960s counterculture. In 1954–55, censorship pressures prompted it to concentrate on the humor magazine Mad, leading to the company's greatest and most enduring success. Consequently, by 1956, the company ceased publishing all of its comic lines except Mad.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joe Shuster</span> Comic book artist, co-creator of Superman (1914–1992)

Joseph Shuster, was a Canadian American comic book artist best known for co-creating the DC Comics character Superman, with Jerry Siegel, in Action Comics #1.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Albert Fish</span> American serial killer, child rapist and cannibal (1870–1936)

Hamilton Howard "Albert" Fish was an American serial killer, rapist, child molester, and cannibal who committed at least three child murders from July 1924 to June 1928. He was also known as the Gray Man, the Werewolf of Wysteria, the Brooklyn Vampire, the Moon Maniac, and The Boogey Man. Fish was a suspect in at least ten murders during his lifetime although he only confessed to three murders that police were able to trace to a known homicide. He also confessed to stabbing at least two other people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fredric Wertham</span> German-American psychiatrist (1895–1981)

Fredric Wertham was a German-American psychiatrist and author. Wertham had an early reputation as a progressive psychiatrist who treated poor black patients at his Lafargue Clinic at a time of heightened discrimination in urban mental health practice. Wertham also authored a definitive textbook on the brain, and his institutional stressor findings were cited when courts overturned multiple segregation statutes, most notably in Brown v. Board of Education.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frankie Yale</span> Italian American mob boss (1893–1928)

Francesco Ioele, known as Frankie Yale or Frankie Uale, was an American gangster based in Brooklyn and the second employer of Al Capone.

<i>Seduction of the Innocent</i> 1954 book by psychiatrist Fredric Wertham

Seduction of the Innocent is a book by German-born American psychiatrist Fredric Wertham, published in 1954, that warned that comic books were a negative form of popular literature and a serious cause of juvenile delinquency. The book was taken seriously at the time in the United States, and was a minor bestseller that created alarm in American parents and galvanized them to campaign for censorship. At the same time, a U.S. Congressional inquiry was launched into the comic book industry. Subsequent to the publication of Seduction of the Innocent, the Comics Code Authority was voluntarily established by publishers to self-censor their titles. In the decades since the book's publication, Wertham's research has been disputed by scholars.

Mainline Publications, also called Mainline Comics, was a short-lived, 1950s American comic book publisher established and owned by Jack Kirby and Joe Simon.

<i>The Haunt of Fear</i> American bi-monthly horror comic

The Haunt of Fear was an American bi-monthly horror comic anthology series published by EC Comics, starting in 1950. Along with Tales from the Crypt and The Vault of Horror, it formed a trifecta of popular EC horror anthologies. The Haunt of Fear was sold at newsstands beginning with its May/June 1950 issue.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">I. W. Publications</span> Defunct American comic book publishing company

I.W. Publications was a short-lived comic book publisher in the late 1950s and early 1960s. The company was part of I.W. Enterprises, and named for the company's owner, Israel Waldman. I.W. Publications was notable for publishing unauthorized reprints of other publishers' properties. Usually these companies were already out of business — but not always.

The United States Senate Subcommittee on Juvenile Delinquency was established by the United States Senate in 1953 to investigate the problem of juvenile delinquency.

The Association of Comics Magazine Publishers (ACMP) was an American industry trade group formed in the late 1940s to regulate the content of comic books in the face of public criticism during that time. It was a precursor to the Comics Magazine Association of America, and the ACMP Publishers Code served as the template for a more detailed set of rules enforced by the CMAA's Comics Code Authority.

Bernard O'Mahoney is an English author, security detail, and former soldier. After taking control of security at a nightclub he became associated with Tony Tucker, a drug dealer who was shot along with two others in what is known as the Rettendon murders.

<i>Crime Does Not Pay</i> (comics) Comic book published by Lev Gleason Publications

Crime Does Not Pay is an American comic book series published between 1942 and 1955 by Lev Gleason Publications. Edited and chiefly written by Charles Biro, the title launched the crime comics genre and was the first "true crime" comic book series. At the height of its popularity, Crime Does Not Pay would claim a readership of six million on its covers. The series' sensationalized recountings of the deeds of gangsters such as Baby Face Nelson and Machine Gun Kelly were illustrated by artists Bob Wood, George Tuska, and others. Stories were often introduced and commented upon by "Mr. Crime", a ghoulish figure in a top hat, and the precursor of horror hosts such as EC Comics's The Crypt Keeper. According to Gerard Jones, Crime Does Not Pay was "the first nonhumor comic to rival the superheroes in sales, the first to open the comic book market to large numbers of late adolescent and young males."

<i>This Magazine Is Haunted</i> Horror comic book

This Magazine is Haunted was a horror comic originally published by Fawcett between 1951 and 1953. Running 14 issues, it was the first of Fawcett's supernatural line; a string of titles which included Beware! Terror Tales, Worlds of Fear, Strange Suspense Stories, and Unknown Worlds.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Horror comics</span> Horror comics book

Horror comics are comic books, graphic novels, black-and-white comics magazines, and manga focusing on horror fiction. In the US market, horror comic books reached a peak in the late 1940s through the mid-1950s, when concern over content and the imposition of the self-censorship Comics Code Authority contributed to the demise of many titles and the toning down of others. Black-and-white horror-comics magazines, which did not fall under the Code, flourished from the mid-1960s through the early 1980s from a variety of publishers. Mainstream American color comic books experienced a horror resurgence in the 1970s, following a loosening of the Code. While the genre has had greater and lesser periods of popularity, it occupies a firm niche in comics as of the 2010s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Star Publications</span> Defunct American comic book publisher

Star Publications, Inc. was a Golden Age American comic book publisher, operating during the years 1949–1954. Founded by artist/editor L. B. Cole and lawyer Gerhard Kramer, Star specialized in horror comics, crime, and romance comics — but also published talking animal stories. Star was originally based in New York City before relocating to Buffalo, New York.

Farrell Publications is the name of a series of American comic book publishing companies founded and operated by Robert W. Farrell in the 1940s and 1950s, including Elliot Publishing Company, Farrell Comic Group, and Excellent Publications. Farrell is particularly known for its pre-Comics Code horror comics, mostly produced by the S. M. Iger Studio. Farrell also published romance, Western, adventure, superhero, and talking animal comics. Farrell acted as editor throughout. In addition to packaging art for Farrell from the beginning, Jerry Iger was the company's art director from 1955–1957.

<i>Nights of Horror</i> Fetish comic book series by Joe Shuster

Nights of Horror is an American series of fetish comic books, created in 1954 by publisher Malcla, drawn by comic artist Joe Shuster, who is also one of the original creators of Superman. The comic stories were written by an author under the pseudonym Clancy, who also used other pseudonyms for different issues of the books. The stories are based on situations of BDSM, bondage, torture, and sexual slavery, featuring both men and women as the tormentors and victims. The series was important in the conviction of Jack Koslow in 1954, during the trial of the Brooklyn Thrill Killers. The books themselves were seized and banned first by New York City, then by the State of New York for violating obscenity laws, and the case went to the Supreme Court of the United States. The Court determined that the ban was not in violation of First Amendment rights, and upheld New York's request for destroying copies of Nights of Horror. Shuster was never named as the illustrator until Gerard Jones published the information in 2004.

Kingsley Books, Inc. v. Brown, 354 U.S. 436 (1957), was a Supreme Court case that addressed issues of obscenity, free speech, and due process. The case stemmed from the confiscation and destruction of books from a New York City bookstore. The court's determination was that:

A state injunction against distribution of material designated as "obscene" does not violate freedom of speech and press protected by the First Amendment and the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Did an Artwork Solve a Decades-Old NYC Crime?, The Observer, August 19, 2014
  2. "Thrill Killers", Time, 27 December 1954.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 The Incredible True Story of Joe Shuster’s NIGHTS OF HORROR, Comic book legal defense, October 3, 2012
  4. "Thrill Killers". Time. 27 December 1954.
  5. 1 2 Secret Identity Archived 2016-03-31 at the Wayback Machine by Craig Yoe, published April 2009
  6. Jones, Gerard (2004). Men of Tomorrow: Geeks, Gangsters, and the Birth of the Comic Book . Basic Books. pp.  269–270. ISBN   0465036570 . Retrieved 9 February 2017.
  7. "MMAVERICK MOGUL INSPIRES FILM FEST" . The Charlotte Observer . July 15, 2000.