Cave of Dogs

Last updated
Illustration of the cave from a 1865 science book. A guide shows a suffocated dog to a man and woman tourist. Mangin, Arthur 1865.png
Illustration of the cave from a 1865 science book. A guide shows a suffocated dog to a man and woman tourist.
Lake Agnano and the Cave of Dogs depicted in an etching by the Sieur de Rogissart, 1706. Lago di Agnano e Grotta del Cane - acquaforte aquerellata Sieur de Rogissart.jpg
Lake Agnano and the Cave of Dogs depicted in an etching by the Sieur de Rogissart, 1706.
The principle of the Cave of Dogs sketched by Alfred Swaine Taylor, 1832. The carbon dioxide (marked with a darker color) gathers in the lower part of the cave. From Taylor, 1832.png
The principle of the Cave of Dogs sketched by Alfred Swaine Taylor, 1832. The carbon dioxide (marked with a darker color) gathers in the lower part of the cave.

The Cave of Dogs (Italian: Grotta del Cane) is a cave near Naples, Italy. Volcanic gases seeping into the cave give the air inside a high concentration of carbon dioxide. Dogs held inside would faint; at one time this was a tourist attraction.

Contents

Description

The Cave of Dogs (Italian: Grotta del Cane, literally "Cave of the Dog") [1] [2] ) is a cave about ten metres deep on the eastern side of the Phlegraean Fields near Pozzuoli, Naples. [3] Inside the cave is a fumarole that releases carbon dioxide of volcanic origin.

The cave is thought to have been constructed in classical antiquity, possibly as a sudatorium; if so, the CO2 emissions must have been much lower at the time. [1] It may have been known to Pliny the Elder, who, in his Natural History Chapter 95 [4] (written 77-79 AD), mentions a location near Pozzuoli where animals die from poisonous fumes. However, the first unambiguous reports about the cave only appear in the 16th century. [1]

Later, it became a tourist attraction for travelers on the Grand Tour. The CO2 gas, being denser than air, tended to accumulate in the deeper parts of the cave. As a result, small animals such as dogs held inside the cave suffered carbon dioxide poisoning, while a standing human was not affected. [1] [5] Local guides, for a fee, would suspend small animals (usually dogs) inside it until they became unconscious. The dogs could be revived by submerging them in the cold waters of the nearby Lake Agnano, although in at least one case this led to the dog drowning instead. [6] Tourists who came to see this attraction included Sir Thomas Browne, [7] Richard Mead, [8] Goethe, John Evelyn, Montesquieu, [9] Alexandre Dumas père, and Mark Twain. [10]

Dutch traveller Cornelis de Bruijn also reported visiting the caves in the year 1677. He wrote:

Next, one comes close to the road by a small cave called Grotta del Cani, which is very venomous, to the extent that if a dog is kept inside, it dies very quickly. I had the curiosity to visit it with two different dogs and found that when the animal remains standing on its legs, it is not harmed by the poison. However, if one forcibly presses it down, it quickly loses its strength after great struggling and desperate resistance, and would undoubtedly die in an instant if not promptly picked up and thrown into a nearby water or lake, where it immediately recovers but with some dizziness, walking like a human who is completely drunk. This lake has the same nature as the cave and boils in several places due to the great heat of sulfur. Curiosity drove me to investigate how high the venom in the cave might be from the ground, so bowing my head downward, I found it to be only one foot high from the ground. [11]

Some tourists including Washington Irving (1804), [12] Percy Bysshe and Mary Shelley (1818) [13] and Ralph Waldo Emerson (1833), [14] objecting to the cruelty, refused to pay for the experiment to be performed on the dog. A Scottish scientist who examined the cave for several days (1877) reported:

On carrying a lighted torch into the cave, its smoke gradually falls, till it reaches the layer of gas, upon which it settles; and on looking in, the surface of the gaseous layer is seen, resembling that of water, and appears covered with beautiful undulations.

On holding the head below the level of the gas, holding the breath, and keeping the eyes open, an intolerable prickling sensation is produced upon the eyes by the carbonic acid.

A dog brought into the cave, as is the custom there, appears, as it were, to drink the gas, lapping with its tongue. Then its eyes begin to dilate to an unnatural size, and its lapping becomes more spasmodic; beyond this it does not seem to suffer. While in the cave, also, the dog was able to stand, but when carried and set on its feet outside in the fresh air, it fell, and lay struggling as if in paroxysms of suffocation, but recovered in two or three minutes. I was told, however, that the animal gets into such a nervous state with the prospects of its frequent ordeals, that it has to be killed in three months. [15]

The lake became polluted, was thought to be malarious, and was drained in 1870. At some point the spectacle fell into disuse, although Baedeker's guides in the 1880s were still advertising that to see the dog experiment would cost tourists 1 lire (≈ 20 U.S. cents). [16] . According to one source, it was banned before World War II for cruelty to animals. The cave entrance was blocked to prevent access by children. [17] [18] [5] [19] [20]

In 2001 the cave was investigated by Italian speleologists. Nine metres from its entrance the temperature was 52 °C (126 °F) and the CO2 concentration was 80%, with negligible oxygen. [1]

The cave was often described in nineteenth century science textbooks to illustrate the density and toxicity of carbon dioxide, [21] and its reputation gave rise to a scientific demonstration of the same name, in which stepped candles are successively extinguished by tipping carbon dioxide into a transparent container.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Blue Grotto (Capri)</span> Sea cave on the coast of Capri, Italy

The Blue Grotto is a sea cave on the coast of the island of Capri, southern Italy. Sunlight passing through an underwater cavity and shining through the seawater creates a blue reflection that illuminates the cavern. The cave extends some 50 metres into the cliff at the surface, and is about 150 metres (490 ft) deep, with a sandy bottom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grotto</span> Natural or artificial cave associated with use by humans

A grotto is a natural or artificial cave used by humans in both modern times and antiquity, and historically or prehistorically. Naturally occurring grottoes are often small caves near water that are usually flooded or often flooded at high tide. Sometimes, artificial grottoes are used as garden features. The Grotta Azzurra at Capri and the grotto at Tiberius' Villa Jovis in the Bay of Naples are examples of popular natural seashore grottoes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ponza</span> Italian island

Ponza is the largest island of the Italian Pontine Islands archipelago, located 33 km (21 mi) south of Cape Circeo in the Tyrrhenian Sea. It is also the name of the commune of the island, a part of the province of Latina in the Lazio region.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phlegraean Fields</span> A supervolcano located west of Naples, Italy

The Phlegraean Fields is a large region of supervolcanic calderas situated to the west of Naples, Italy. It was declared a regional park in 2003. The area of the caldera consists of 24 craters and volcanic edifices; most of them lie under water. Hydrothermal activity can be observed at Lucrino, Agnano and the town of Pozzuoli. There are also effusive gaseous manifestations in the Solfatara crater, the mythological home of the Roman god of fire, Vulcan. This area is monitored by the Vesuvius Observatory. It is considered a supervolcano.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cane Corso</span> Italian breed of mastiff

The Cane Corso is an Italian breed of mastiff. It is usually kept as a companion dog or guard dog; it may also be used to protect livestock. In the past it was used for hunting large game, and also to herd cattle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lake Avernus</span> Crater lake in Italy

Lake Avernus is a volcanic crater lake located in the Avernus crater in the Campania region of southern Italy, around 4 kilometres west of Pozzuoli. It is near the volcanic field known as the Phlegraean Fields and comprises part of the wider Campanian volcanic arc. The lake is roughly circular, measuring two kilometres in circumference and 60 metres deep.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lake Agnano</span> Volcanogenic lake , Former lake in Campania

Lago di Agnano or Lake Agnano was a circular lake, some 6½ km in circumference, which occupied the crater of the extinct volcano of Agnano 8 km west of Naples, Italy. It was apparently not formed until the Middle Ages, as it is not mentioned by ancient writers; it was drained in 1870.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Agnano</span> Crater and Suburb of Naples

Agnano is a suburb of Napoli, Italy, situated southwest of the city in the Campi Flegrei region. It was popular among both ancient Greeks and Romans and was famed for its hot sulphurous springs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sperlonga</span> Comune in Lazio, Italy

Sperlonga is a coastal town in the province of Latina, Italy, about halfway between Rome and Naples. It is best known for the ancient Roman sea grotto discovered in the grounds of the Villa of Tiberius containing the important and spectacular Sperlonga sculptures, which are displayed in a museum on the site.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bisceglie</span> Comune in Apulia, Italy

Bisceglie is a city and municipality of 55,251 inhabitants in the province of Barletta-Andria-Trani, in the Apulia region, in southern Italy. The municipality has the fourth highest population in the province and fourteenth highest in the region.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aqua Augusta (Naples)</span> Aqueduct

The Aqua Augusta, or Serino Aqueduct, was one of the largest, most complex and costliest aqueduct systems in the Roman world; it supplied water to at least eight ancient cities in the Bay of Naples including Pompeii and Herculaneum. This aqueduct was unlike any other of its time, being a regional network rather than being focused on one urban centre.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Posillipo</span> Quarter of Naples, Italy

Posillipo is an affluent residential quarter of Naples, southern Italy, located along the northern coast of the Gulf of Naples.

In geology, a mazuku (Swahili for "evil wind") is a pocket of carbon dioxide-rich air that can be lethal to any human or animal life inside. Mazuku are created when carbon dioxide accumulates in pockets low to the ground. CO2 is denser than air, which causes it to flow downhill, hugging the ground like a low fog, and is also undetectable by human olfactory or visual senses in most conditions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Neptune's Grotto</span> Cave near Alghero on the island of Sardinia, Italy

Neptune's Grotto is a stalactite cave near the town of Alghero on the island of Sardinia, Italy. The cave was discovered by local fishermen in the 18th century and has since developed into a popular tourist attraction. The grotto gets its name from the Roman god of the sea, Neptune.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grotta dell'Addaura</span> Cave and archaeological site in Italy

The Addaura cave is a complex of three natural grottoes located on the northeast side of Mount Pellegrino in Palermo, Sicily, Southern Italy. The importance of the complex is due to the presence of cave-wall engravings dated to the late Epigravettian and the Mesolithic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ploutonion at Hierapolis</span> Ancient shrine to god Pluto in Turkey

The Ploutonion at Hierapolis or Pluto's Gate was a ploutonion in the ancient city of Hierapolis near Pamukkale in modern Turkey's Denizli Province. The site was discovered in 1965 by Italian archaeologists, who published reports on their excavations throughout the decade. Following the studies carried out on site in 1998, a geologist of the Italian National Research Council, Luigi Piccardi, recognized that the origin of both the Ploutonion and of the nearby Apollo's Oracle of Hierapolis was linked to the existence of the surface trace of a seismic fault, on which both sanctuaries were purposely built and which was revered as Gateway of Hades. In 2013, it was further explored by Italian archaeologists led by Francesco D'Andria, a professor of archaeology at the University of Salento. As part of a restoration project, a replica of the marble statue of Hades and Cerberus has been restored to its original place. The statue is known to have been there in ancient times.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tofana di Rozes</span> Mountain of the Dolomites in the Province of Belluno, Veneto, Italy

Tofana di Rozes is a mountain of the Dolomites in the Province of Belluno, Veneto, Italy. Located west of the resort of Cortina d'Ampezzo, the mountain's giant three-edged pyramid shape and its vertical south face, above the Falzarego Pass, makes it the most popular peak in the Tofane group, and one of the most popular in the Dolomites.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Deer Cave (Otranto)</span> Cave and archaeological site in southern Italy

The Deer Cave is a natural cave at the Salento coast near the town of Porto Badisco, around 8 km (5.0 mi) south of Otranto in Apulia, Italy. Unknown before 1970 it came to immediate international attention after the discovery of its impressive, innovative and enigmatic complex galleries of prehistoric parietal wall paintings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Grotta del Gelo</span>

Grotta del Gelo is a volcanic cave of Mount Etna which is known for the presence of a large amount of ice. The cave formed in 1614-1624 during a large eruption of the volcano, inside one of the lava flows produced during that eruption. Within the two subsequent decades, ice grew and accumulated in the cave. Today it is a tourist destination.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Halliday, William R.; Cigna, Arrigo A. (2007). "The Grotta Del Cane (Dog Cave), Naples, Italy" (PDF). Cave and Karst Science. British Cave Research Association. 33 (3): 131–136. ISSN   1356-191X.
  2. Urban, Sylvanus (1753). "The Gentleman's Magazine and Historical Chronicle, Volume XXIII. Page 16. "Grotto Del Cane described, with the cause of its effects"".
  3. "Grotta del Cane: Italy". Geographical Names. Retrieved 26 March 2015.
  4. "Pliny the Elder, The Natural History, BOOK II. AN ACCOUNT OF THE WORLD AND THE ELEMENTS., CHAP. 95. (93.)—OF VENTS1 IN THE EARTH. 1 "Spiracula."". www.perseus.tufts.edu. Retrieved 2023-07-20.
  5. 1 2 Kroonenberg, Salomon (2013). Why Hell Stinks of Sulfur: Mythology and Geology of the Underworld. London: Reaktion Books. pp. 41–45. ISBN   978-1-78023-045-0.
  6. Astarita, Tommaso (2005). Between Salt Water and Holy Water: A History of Southern Italy. New York: W. W. Norton & Company. p. 224. ISBN   0-393-05864-6.
  7. Wilkin, Simon, ed. (1845). The Works of Sir Thomas Browne. Vol. 1. London: Bohn. Retrieved 18 April 2021., p=78.
  8. Mead, Richard (1762). The Medical Works of Richard Mead. C. Hitch and L Hawes.
  9. Shackleton, Robert (1955). "The Evolution of Montesquieu's Theory of Climate". Revue Internationale de Philosophie. 9 (33/34): 317–329. JSTOR   23936721.
  10. Twain, Mark (1869). "Innocents Abroad". www.gutenberg.org. Archived from the original on 2005-08-13. Retrieved 2022-01-16. the Grotto of the Dog claimed our chief attention, because we had heard and read so much about it. Every body has written about the Grotto del Cane and its poisonous vapors, from Pliny down to Smith, and every tourist has held a dog over its floor by the legs to test the capabilities of the place. The dog dies in a minute and a half--a chicken instantly. As a general thing, strangers who crawl in there to sleep do not get up until they are called. And then they don't either. The stranger that ventures to sleep there takes a permanent contract. I longed to see this grotto. I resolved to take a dog and hold him myself; suffocate him a little, and time him; suffocate him some more and then finish him. We reached the grotto at about three in the afternoon, and proceeded at once to make the experiments. But now, an important difficulty presented itself. We had no dog.
  11. De Bruijn, Cornelis (1698). "3rd chapter; Travels from Rome to Napels [...]". Reizen van Cornelis de Bruyn door de vermaardste deelen van Klein Asia [...]. Amsterdam. Archived from the original on 2022-06-03.
  12. Irving, Washington (1921). Notes and Journal of Travel in Europe 1804-1805. Vol. III. New York: The Grolier Club. Retrieved 18 April 2022., p.16-8
  13. Chapin, Lisbeth Ann (2003). Shelley's Animals and the Landscape of Consciousness (PhD)., p.1.
  14. Emerson, Ralph Waldo (1910). Journals 1833-1835. Journal of Ralph Waldo Emerson. Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin. Retrieved 18 April 2022., p.67-8.
  15. Young, T. Graham (1878). "The Gas of the Grotta del Cane". Journal of the Chemical Society. XXXIII: 51–52. Retrieved 18 April 2022., p=52. (The author was the son of Paraffin Young.)
  16. Baedeker, Karl (1880). Italy. Handbook for Travellers. Third Part. Baedeker's handbooks for travellersseries 22-07. Leipzig and London: Baedeker. Retrieved 18 April 2022., p.95 and currency chart.
  17. Taylor, Alfred Swaine, An Account of the Grotta del Cane; With Remarks Upon Suffocation by Carbonic Acid, The London Medical and Physical Journal, 1832, 278-285.
  18. Fleming & Johnson, Toxic Airs: Body, Place, Planet in Historical Perspective, Pittsburgh, 255-256.
  19. Jeff Matthews, Naples: Life, Death & Miracles: Agnano & the Grotto of the Dog. Archived 2016-12-20 at the Wayback Machine , visited 26.3.2015. "The area degraded terribly after WWII and became an eyesore from shoddy overbuilding and illegal waste dumping. I drove by the baths hundreds of times over the years and never knew about the lake, never knew that I was 100 yards from the Grotto of the Dog ...".
  20. Grotta del Cane visited 26.3.2015.
  21. The above image is from L'air et le monde aèrien, an 1865 textbook by Arthur Mangin, p.162

40°50′00″N14°10′00″E / 40.833333°N 14.166667°E / 40.833333; 14.166667